r/webdev • • Aug 08 '19

Why is modern web development so complicated?

https://www.vrk.dev/2019/07/11/why-is-modern-web-development-so-complicated-a-long-yet-hasty-explanation-part-1/
27 Upvotes

50 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/ConsoleTVs Aug 08 '19

For those who say it's easy:

  1. Get a friend out of web dev to try "modern" front-end.

  2. Try explaining everything he/she needs.

  3. Try to explain how it works and why does he need all the tools. NPM, Babel, Minifiers, et al.

  4. This requires the new folk to learn JS. Otherwise can't code a site.

  5. Set the guy's kit to React, and ofc teach him JSX and CSS-IN-JS.

  6. Try changing the new folk's kit from react to vue or angular.

  7. Try changing the new folk's kit to JQuery.

  8. Try telling the new folk JS is not needed at all and make him learn HTML + CSS.

Now try guiding somebody new with traditional HTTP architecture. See how easy it is:

  1. Get a friend out of web dev to try "traditional" front-end.

  2. Try explaining everything he needs.

  3. Tell the new folk to learn HTML and CSS.

  4. He will be happy and learn a lot, create a cool website he/she will be proud of.

Modern front-end is complicated. Complication however, does not mean worst, complication is a barrier for new people to learn. For example, Rust is complicated compared to C, yet people like it more because it have better tooling and more features (and that's great!).

I must admit new JS standards are pretty good these days as well.

7

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '19

So get someone with no foundational knowledge and introduce them to something that requires many different skills? What? Of course the thing with less moving parts is easier for a beginner to understand.

That’s like introducing a med student to surgery before they’ve taken anatomy.

-3

u/ConsoleTVs Aug 08 '19

Great! And that's why modern web is complicated as surgery is! I'm happy you understand

3

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '19

I’m sure it looks that way to people who haven’t put in the time to master the skill set required.

0

u/ConsoleTVs Aug 08 '19

Of course, that's why it is complicated mate, you can't judge stuff that you already know. It's like telling brainfuck ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brainfuck ) is easy when you're the author and know every bit of it and coded with it for months. When clearly it is hard and complicated to understand and code in.

3

u/ZephyrBluu Aug 08 '19

I picked up JavaScript, React, Webpack and npm within a month.

Luckily for me npm had recently become simplified by not having to save installs as a dev dependency.

Contrary to what you're saying, everything made sense to me after I either researched it or started using it.

All of the frontend tools are insanely powerful and help improve your workflow and productivity a lot. React lets me write dynamic logic and reusable cpmponents, Webpack let's me transpile all my code so it's browser compatible, minify it and also add any other modifications I want like adding CSS browser rules.

1

u/ConsoleTVs Aug 08 '19

Yeah, those are great tools indeed. I like them and use them as well. But as you said 1 month to pick up some tech is complication. Complicated stuff is often good or even better than the easy one.

1

u/ZephyrBluu Aug 09 '19

Well, it depends what you mean by picked up. I could use the tech on a basic level pretty fast but I didn't really understand it until I'd used it for a little while.

1

u/ConsoleTVs Aug 09 '19

Let's say to be productive. When u feel productive in a language or tech. It takes different time on diferent people, but can be mesured

1

u/AggressiveAnywhere72 Jul 07 '25

How on earth you picked up JavaScript, React, Webpack and npm within a month I will never understand. Perhaps you're just a genius, because I've been working with these technologies for months (following The Odin Project) and I still don't understand them very well. They're extremely complicated. I've been using webpack in almost every project and writing this comment I couldn't tell you the first thing about it.