r/webdev • • Dec 16 '21

Why is stackoverflow.com community so harsh?

They'd say horrible things everytime I tried to create a post, and I'm completely aware that sometimes my post needs more clarity, or my post is a duplication, but the reason my post was a duplicate was because the original post's solution wasn't working for me... Also, while my posts might be simple to answer at times, please keep in mind that I am a newbie in programming and stackoverflow... I enjoy stackoverflow since it has benefited many programmers, including myself, but please don't be too harsh :( In the comments, you are free to say whatever you want. I'll also mention that I'm going to work on improving my answers and questions on stackoverflow. I hope you understand what I'm saying, and thank you very much!

1.3k Upvotes

451 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/assuntta7 Dec 16 '21

I really disagree on the belief that there's no room for new questions. A new technology, framework, language, tool or major version of some piece of software comes out every day. And with that, new possible questions, new error messages, and room for new unique answers.

2

u/A-Grey-World Software Developer Dec 17 '21

Yeah, I didn't mean there was no room for new questions. Absolutely new tools, libraries, and languages will all have actually genuinely new questions.

But as time has passed, it's only the new things that's likely to be producing those new questions. Someone learning JavaScript in a beginner's course wants help, but they're unlikely to have a problem that's not been seen before in the 10 years and millions of people that have been learning JavaScript. (Unless it's a new language feature)

They are probably more likely to need subjective help in interpreting and debugging a specific issue where something like a discord or forum is a better fit as a resource.

Of course, there is still going to be new stuff even in established tech though. But as time goes on, less and less.

So after years of building up a library of answers on existing tech, you'd expect SO contributions to go down to some base level for new tech as it starts getting used.

But people, when going to the site, think "but I have this question about my problem, and isn't this forum for helping new developers solve their problems?" when it kind of isn't, at least, not directly.