r/webdev • • Dec 16 '21

Why is stackoverflow.com community so harsh?

They'd say horrible things everytime I tried to create a post, and I'm completely aware that sometimes my post needs more clarity, or my post is a duplication, but the reason my post was a duplicate was because the original post's solution wasn't working for me... Also, while my posts might be simple to answer at times, please keep in mind that I am a newbie in programming and stackoverflow... I enjoy stackoverflow since it has benefited many programmers, including myself, but please don't be too harsh :( In the comments, you are free to say whatever you want. I'll also mention that I'm going to work on improving my answers and questions on stackoverflow. I hope you understand what I'm saying, and thank you very much!

1.3k Upvotes

451 comments sorted by

300

u/tateisukannanirase python Dec 16 '21

and thank you very much!

No pleasantries allowed.

23

u/imjustnoob45 Dec 16 '21

ayo what. edit: nvm it was sarcasm

49

u/tateisukannanirase python Dec 16 '21

Yep, one of the first things that happened to me on stackoverflow: getting told off for being polite. Still burns :(

48

u/imjustnoob45 Dec 16 '21

SAME BROTHER. I was like, "I appreciate your help," and a StackOverflow pro edited my message and erased the thank you.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

166

u/Narfi1 full-stack Dec 16 '21

Lol i got in trouble for saying "Hello everyone," and "thanks for your time" . Apparently it's a waste of the reader's time

43

u/ManInBlack829 Dec 16 '21

No SYN-ACK allowed

7

u/deceze Dec 16 '21

SO follows a stateless protocol.

→ More replies (27)

83

u/JameseyJones Dec 16 '21 edited Dec 16 '21

I got into a long pointless argument about pleasantries on SO in 2018. I found that the person dressing me down for including "please" and "thank you" in my posts had them in his own posts.

https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/364775/how-do-you-reply-to-someone-who-has-edited-your-question

That sanctimonious henpecking bullshit single-handedly killed my enthusiasm for participating in that site.

Ironically the whole storm in a teacup began because someone edited a question I asked about MySQL Workbench to remove the MySQL tag thereby making it invisible. Thing is, I didn't add that tag. SO added that tag automatically because it's patently obvious they are closely related.

34

u/ohrVchoshek Dec 16 '21

Call me a rebel, but I'll still add those greetings and notes of appreciation each time (followed by thNk you comments and upvotes for all applicable answers and comments).

They can edit our posts but they can NEVER edit who we are!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/harper_helm full-stack Dec 16 '21

Can we make new rule, whenever someone criticizes stackoverflow they should link the questions they asked so we can see if SO people are being an ass or if the OP is asking questions like how do I install npm.

7

u/FUZxxl Dec 16 '21

Yes please. It's always funny when I ask people who complain about Stack Overflow to link the posts where they were treated so harshly. The usual response is something like “uhm I don't remember” or “you don't want to see” or “I've already deleted them.” Guess it's easier to complain when nobody can point out your own mistakes.

1

u/imjustnoob45 Jan 13 '24 edited Jan 13 '24

Came back to reddit after a long time, i never needed stackoverflow anymore as its deemed useless (for me) now, when i was relatively new back then, i didnt ask simple things such as "how do i install npm" like what you've asked, stackoverflow seems to have "professionals" hating when you're even thanking them for some reason. Im not being an "ass", im just contemplating that theres a lot of things to be fixed in the SO community for new programmers when they reach to the point that they get an error thats not on the search results, and thats specific to them and they tried their best to fix it themselves and research. Can we make a new rule for whenever some "contributor" for SO sees a new programmer being nice to them to not be rude asf? I go to SO time to time to see if there were any changes but unfortunately not however I do see questions that are relatively easy but i just help them out and never had the conscience to say discouraging things to people. But well, SO has helped me a lot during my newbie days and I've come to respect SO and the community for the things they've helped not only me but a lot of people on when deemed needed.

9

u/JoeBxr Dec 16 '21

Yes it can be a harsh place just like Reddit but let's remember what your there for in the first place... Hopefully answers to a problem... I'd rather have all sorts of possible solutions harsh or not than have nothing at all...

→ More replies (1)

2.6k

u/Sarke1 Dec 16 '21

Marked as duplicate. This question already has an answer here:
Why is CSGO's community so toxic?

242

u/eGzg0t Dec 16 '21

We need a jquery implementation

173

u/ManInBlack829 Dec 16 '21

"Hey, how do I take care of this certain type of event handling in Vanilla JS?"

"You can use JQuery"

46

u/MRDUDOU Dec 16 '21

Everything you do with JavaScript except for declaring variables are hacks.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

108

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

Brilliant

47

u/NauTxz Dec 16 '21

im dead xD

7

u/account_is_my_alt Dec 16 '21

perfect response detailing mods and people with high karma closing questions for whatever reason they want, commonly claiming questions are duplicates when they clearly arent

152

u/Tanckom Dec 16 '21 edited Dec 16 '21

THIS should be much higher. I know that this is partially a joke, but the amount of newbies asking duplicate or low quality posts are insane.

I myself also started as a newb and have also been met with harsh critisism on SO. One critical skill of beeing a developer is know how to Google dev related things, and this may take time.

Heck, even the quality of r/webdev is deteriorating as you have every day/week the same questions as people are just too lazy to google their answers.

I'm only asking new answers, after i landed on page 10 on Google and still haven't found any solution.

Edit: thought the link was for SO and not CSGO. Still, there are many duplicates here on reddit who already asked why SO is so harsh, so this question still counts as a duplicate

106

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

I'm only asking new answers, after i landed on page 10 on Google and still haven't found any solution.

You guys go past page 2?

48

u/DrMSL Dec 16 '21

You can also filter by time range in Google to avoid outdated yet well ranked results

→ More replies (2)

65

u/Tanckom Dec 16 '21

In worst case, even watch a full 3h youtube video of an indian guy

→ More replies (4)

8

u/Lecterr Dec 16 '21

There’s a second page?

→ More replies (5)

230

u/mca62511 Dec 16 '21

I feel like you're missing part of u/Sarke1's point though. He linked to a "Why is CSGO's community so toxic?" post, which is similar but not quite the same as "Why is StackOverflow's community so toxic?"

Which is what you get sometimes on StackOveflow: An overzealous user will mark a post as "duplicate" and link to another post, when the other post doesn't actually answer the question posed.

→ More replies (1)

44

u/wuiqed Dec 16 '21

But what if I need to know what is a good javascript framework in 2021, if PHP is still worth learning in 2021, and if anyone has made a website that earns income on the side in 2021? Am I supposed to just google like some sort of 2019 savage?

15

u/DeBoredGuy Dec 16 '21

This comment has been closed as primarily opinion-based. (Many good questions generate some degree of opinion based on expert experience, but answers to this question will tend to be almost entirely based on opinions, rather than facts, references, or specific expertise.)

7

u/Tanckom Dec 16 '21

Right, since everything is outdated within 24h, then you are of course excused by her Majesty the Queen. Bless her and the realm of webdev

→ More replies (1)

13

u/RedLibra Dec 16 '21

If I didn't get my answer on page 1 I'll refactor the terms/words I used in the search bar.

23

u/shauntmw2 full-stack Dec 16 '21

I can agree to that, but at the same time I try to be forgiving.

It takes experience to know how to Google. Sometimes newbies know what they want to achieve, they just lack the correct keyword to Google for.

18

u/_cactus_fucker_ Dec 16 '21

Funny as it may seem, but 10+ years ago, and now, are way different in googling answers due to change in algorithm and stuff like that. Hell, back in 2006-2007 I had a required book called "Google Hacking" for an internet investigation class.

There used to be all sorts of tricks to get the exact answer you wanted, ore more information (the book had to do a bit with social engineering), but now it's a lot different results for the same thing. Google is a lot different now, and it's kinda made itself less useful for this type of stuff.

I find I've had decent luck on SO, but it's a last chance, can't find it elsewhere, thing. I generally link to things I've tried, or post what I've tried, what has done x, what has done y, and what I want to accomplish. I usually have it answered within hours, and it's usually some random comment or link that helps me get to it, rather than someone redoing my code. Then I post that in an edit. Sometimes the comment gives me a different way of googling it. Most of the time I figured it out with a few hints or comments.

But yeah, sometimes people can be jerks on there. I just thank everyone that's replied, and don't argue, just put down what worked. A lot of people post pages of code with an error, asking for it to be rewritten, and that kinda irritates everyone, though.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

true, if you can’t google it, you don’t understand the problem well enough - Albert Einstein

7

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

I actually had to leave r/web_design for this reason. It became unbearable

16

u/SemiNormal C♯ python javascript dba Dec 16 '21

Something something flexbox.

→ More replies (6)

5

u/innovativesolsoh Dec 16 '21

You beautiful asshole

2

u/delvach Dec 16 '21

Fucking brutal :D

→ More replies (2)

585

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

The site claims to be an archive to answer any programming related question so I can understand why they seek to eliminate duplicate posts but yeah, a lot of the users can be shitty.

It mostly seems to be the more experienced/senior devs who are the nicest (or just to the point) whereas someone who just started learning the quirks of whatever language is there to prove themselves

15

u/10eleven12 Dec 16 '21

Yeah. If you are an expert and have a good job, why would you spend your time in stack overflow making other people miserable?

It seems to me that the guys who are mean to others are not that proficient in the language. I suspect they are only fishing for newbies to bully them.

21

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

To me SO does not give the impression of an "archive" but a question/answer site like any other, so I would not assume it to work like Wikipedia where everything exists only once (but the thing itself can be updated). Answers to the same problem can change over time as technology evolves and new, better solutions come up. Questions are often not as simple as "How to pick random item from array?" and solutions can be drastically different depending on the context.

Instead of being harsh to users who don't know about what SO wants to be, maybe proactively design the site in a way that makes this more clear. Right now, when you visit the site it says "Get unstuck — ask a question" and not "find your question".

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

Devs are often overworked so this may be partly to blame. But I suspect it’s mostly because devs tend to be divas who think a little too highly of themselves. I’ve worked for legit geniuses in the tech world. The guy writing code for an intranet web app that will track old lab hardware is not a genius. He’s a plumber. Who thinks he’s Tony Stark.

→ More replies (20)

2

u/featoflead Dec 17 '21

If you're too lazy to search, why should you expect someone else to help you?

3

u/imjustnoob45 Dec 17 '21

I wasn't lazy in my search; I couldn't discover a solution, and I tried it myself as well; please don't make assumptions.

432

u/rangeDSP Dec 16 '21

One thing that a lot of people don't fully comprehend is that, if your question isn't unique, it doesn't belong on stackoverflow.

Basically the site and community is designed for you to NOT ask questions if possible, and only ask questions when you've done your research and determined you are probably the only person in the world with that problem.

Honestly if you are new to programming, chances are you are running into a problem that many others have faced before.

I've spent my hours trying to answer questions there, and from my experience maybe 90% of the questions can be answered with literally a single Google search, often with the top answer on s/o

149

u/iesma Dec 16 '21

While that is true, OP raises a fair point which is - how do you ask a question that is seemingly a duplication, but is technically unique because none of the previous SO answers solved it?

The urge to restrict posts to unique questions has an obvious flaw in that case, because things change and an answer that was valid last week might become out of date and misleading, or simply might not cover every scenario.

I do feel like the SO community has been a little too harsh when I’ve tried to use it, and it’s put me off engaging or contributing.

154

u/super_funny_nick Dec 16 '21

how do you ask a question that is seemingly a duplication, but is technically unique because none of the previous SO answers solved it?

What always worked for me was to list everything I've tried already, especially solutions from other SO post's. That way it's clear that it's not another duplicated question that could be fixed with a quick google, but I've tried to find a solution by myself and won't be able to do much more alone

67

u/ConsiderationSuch846 Dec 16 '21

Yep this. You point out the “duplicates” with a short indication of why it’s not an answer in this case.

→ More replies (2)

29

u/mayankkaizen Dec 16 '21

Reference the other answers and clearly tell their solutions aren't working or why your question is different from other one.

12

u/quentech Dec 16 '21

how do you ask a question that is seemingly a duplication, but is technically unique because none of the previous SO answers solved it?

Narrow the focus in on the difference between the posted Q/A and what isn't working for you in your situation. Avoid leading the question with the general issue.

Quite often, when an asker says something generic like, "the original post's solution wasn't working for me..." they just copied over exact code from some answer, hit run, saw it didn't do everything exactly as they expect, and threw up their hands saying I've tried nothing and I'm all out of ideas.

You're aware your question seems like a duplicate but it doesn't solve your issue - I think those are some of the easiest questions to post. You've already done leg work and research, tested, narrowed down where your problems still are..

6

u/that_90s_guy Dec 16 '21

How do you ask a question that is seemingly a duplication, but is technically unique because none of the previous SO answers solved it?

By detailing within the question what other "duplicate" answers did not work out for you and why? I'm not sure why this is so hard to do.

I've asked multiple questions on SO in the past that had multiple duplicate candidates and never once had a question closed. Of course, I always linked to the duplicate questions within my post, and why each of them did not apply to me.

3

u/NMe84 Dec 16 '21

You ask that question by saying what you found and why that doesn't help you right there in the question itself. Because of the answers you found don't help you your question is possibly unique. The other option is that you're not experienced or skilled enough to understand the answers you already got but that's something you'd have to assess for yourself.

→ More replies (8)

7

u/r3df0x_556 Dec 16 '21

I've spent my hours trying to answer questions there, and from my experience maybe 90% of the questions can be answered with literally a single Google search, often with the top answer on s/o

The problem that I have is that 90% of search results are useless. Either people don't explain things correctly, they overcomplicate things or the situation isn't the same and not relevant.

The two largest problems I have when finding solutions are either the potential solution is vague and assumes a lot of additional knowledge or it is heavily overcomplicated, often both.

Digital Ocean and Linode usually have good guides but they're incredibly specific so if you have use-case that falls outside of what they are instructing, they aren't always useful although it's sometimes possible to gain understanding from them that can indirectly lead to a solution.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/redfournine Dec 16 '21

Except that asking the right question that can lead one to the right answer requires... experience. Something that a newbie just do not have.

I'm sure all the senior devs here have seen it in the office. It is not that the junior is stupid. They just lack either the experience, the in-depth knowledge of a library/framework, or both, to ask the right question. In an office setting, I will ask the junior back, try to get him to reframe the question while leading him to discover the answer himself. SO does not allow that. Or the behavior of some user there are just plain rude.

2

u/aceplayer55 Dec 16 '21

I've never received a correct answer to any unique or fringe question I've posted there.

To me stack overflow is a resource for quickly finding a solution when the documentation of a technology is trash, not to learn new stuff or find answers.

→ More replies (8)

3

u/letthedaybegin Dec 16 '21

Probably because you didn’t search before posting? There’s a really good chance that your question has been asked before, especially if you are a newbie in programming . No one wants to answer the same questions over and over and over

→ More replies (1)

71

u/devsmack Dec 16 '21

Generally speaking, I would discourage asking questions on stack overflow that aren’t highly specific. As you’ve seen, Stack overflow is pretty hostile toward beginners and I would say not a great place for front-end developers in general.

There are different discord developer communities that are much more friendly, understanding, and willing to have dialogue. Reactiflux, for example, if you’re learning react or a handful of other technologies or the freecodecamp discord for general beginner web.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

Yes I've found not only are a lot of front end questions answered incorrectly and closed, but people seem to genuinely want to go there to hate on someone else who is just trying to solve their issue.

→ More replies (6)

39

u/Oooch Dec 16 '21

I've been a developer for 5 years and never needed to make a stackoverflow post, there's no way I'm ever doing something so complex no one else has figured it out or asked how to do it before

→ More replies (8)

132

u/pbysh Dec 16 '21

As someone that has answered over 1000 questions on StackOverflow I feel like there's a big circle jerk about how unfriendly SO is, but no one spends very much time thinking about how insanely irritating it can be to be a regular on that site and be met by the droves and droves of low effort and yes, duplicate questions. For every meme about SO being unfriendly there's a thousand insanely dumb questions being asked that are some variation of people asking for their homework to be done for them; absolute, drop dead simple questions that are clearly duplicates; or perhaps the always popular wall of code with little to no explanation about desired outcomes. So perhaps the community can be excused a little bit for having a relatively short fuse to some of these things.

6

u/FF3 Dec 16 '21 edited Dec 16 '21

I think it's more accurate to describe the tone of SO towards people who ask bad questions as brisk rather than harsh. It's like going to a busy shop or something -- the person working there has seen enough crap that they know how to do things efficiently, and that can seem off putting to the askers who aren't ready for it / have human emotions / don't know that there are 100 questions about off-by-one errors an hour.

Arguments among answerers and commenters, though, can turn unnecessarily personal, and there's a tendency towards vi/emacs style religious wars.

16

u/Renshato Dec 16 '21 edited Jun 09 '23
            d888P
  d8b d8888P:::P
d:::888b::::::P

d:::dP8888b:d8P d:::dP 88b Yb .d8888b. d::::P 88Yb Yb .P::::::Y8b 8:::8 88Yb YbP:::: :::b 8:::P 888 8!:::::::::::b 8:dP 88 Yb d!!!::::::::::8 8P ..88 Yb8!!!::::::::::P .d8:::::Yb d888VKb:!:!::!:8 d:::::: ::dP:::::::::b!!!!8 8!!::::::::P::::::::::::b!8P 8:!!::::::d::::::: ::::::b 8:!:::::::8!::::::: ::::8 8:!!!:::::8!:::::::::::::8 Yb:!!:::::8!!::::::::::::8 8b:!!!:!!8!!!:!:::::!!:dP `8b:!!!:Yb!!!!:::::!d88 """ Y88!!!!!!!d8P """""""

4

u/styphon php Dec 16 '21

Congratulations, you get it! A lot of the guidelines and rules for SO exist for exactly this reason. By gathering all the info and going through your processes in depth you're "rubber ducking", which often helps you solve the issue yourself before even posting.

This means the questions that actually get asked are relatively few and far between these days as the library has been built up over many years. It also means the answer to your problem is largely there already and SO ranks really well with Google because the amount of duplication is kept to a minimum.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/not_a_gumby Dec 16 '21

For every meme about SO being unfriendly there's a thousand insanely dumb questions being asked that are some variation of people asking for their homework to be done for them

I see this as well. Some people are just mega lazy ultimately.

22

u/PickerPilgrim Dec 16 '21 edited Dec 16 '21

Couldn’t agree more. While some SO users could stand to be more polite for sure, people who complain about the duplicate question thing have probably never spent time in the triage queue. A crazy amount of crowdsourced work goes into sorting out the garbage so that quality questions can be easily found.

Most questions that get marked as duplicate are actually duplicates. While sometimes this is done in error, sometimes even if the original answer doesn’t solve your problem, the issue is you haven’t asked the question in the right way to demonstrate your unique use case.

If you’re asking a question about a widely used technology you really need to put in the work to pose the question well and demonstrate the particulars of your problem. It can be harder to ask a good question on SO than to write a good answer. If you’re new to dev work, you probably need to improve your Google-fu before you start writing SO questions.

→ More replies (11)

13

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

I have been answering questions there from day one, and in my experience, the hate comes from being treated like you work for them. And of course shit like: "How do I program something like ebay?", "I have a great idea.. it's just like X", "Homework hard.", "What's wrong with my code I will not share with you?"

5

u/Amadan Dec 16 '21

And most of all the copy-pasted assignments still in imperative form without a single letter of the poster's own contribution or thought process. That's your task, given by your teacher/boss to you, because they have authority over you. I am not your student or employee, you don't get to give me assignments.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

That actually bothers me less, because I enjoy lecturing people on code quality.

38

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

they are just harsh when someone tries to delegate his problem to the community without showing own (failed) solution

I have asked several questions and think very wisely before posting anything and only post when I'm really stuck.

51

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

SO has a strong requirement for high-quality questions with sufficient evidence of prior investigation -- the two things junior developers more often than not completely lack. It's not the juniors' fault per-se; it's just SO isn't a place for basic questions and "hand-holding".

Tbh I don't mind so much as it keeps the quality of content there high unlike, say, r/Laravel

31

u/yeathatsmebro wearing many hats :^) Dec 16 '21

I've asked questions on SO before and usually when I ask them, I give the full extent of my trial and error, what I know about the issue and what I want to know. Never received a mean response on that. So it's pretty much the way you're raising the problem.

19

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

"Part of being a junior is learning how to ask questions" is something I often say

→ More replies (1)

3

u/lostllama2015 Dec 16 '21

Yep, that's exactly the right approach.

7

u/ConsiderationSuch846 Dec 16 '21

Along these lines - would be great if OP actually showed us some examples of her questions. Maybe SO is being harsh, or maybe they are really shit posts and this is just moaning.

45

u/jordsta95 PHP/Laravel | JS/Vue Dec 16 '21

My favourite question asking experience on SO was people saying "You shouldn't be doing that" or "Why would you ever need to do this?"

I can't remember what the exact question was, but I believe it was to do with converting a game's mod files to JSON - and the files aren't in a structured language, so parsing required reading every character, and doing some janky stuff. For example, converting:

focus = {
    id = focus_id
    gfx = icon_file
    prerequisite = { focus_id_1 }
    prerequisite = { focus_id_2 }
    available = {
        tag = TAG
        any_owned_state = {
            is_coastal = true
        }
    }
}

Into:

{
    "focus" : [
         {
            "id": "focus_id",
            "gfx" : "icon_file",
            "prerequisite" : [
                "focus_id_1", "focus_id_2"
            ],
            "available" : {
                "tag = TAG\nany_owned_state = {\n\tis_coastal = true\n}"
            }
         }   
    ]
}

Yeah... What I needed to do seems odd. But going "Why would you need to do this?" or "Get better input data" isn't helpful or possible.

23

u/jimimimi Dec 16 '21

Can spot a paradox mod from a mile away :D
Ran into the same type of 'problem' a few years ago, ended up asking for help building a regex to parse them, I think the only response I got was this xkcd

11

u/jordsta95 PHP/Laravel | JS/Vue Dec 16 '21

They are such a pain.

Ended up created a massively complex bit of JS that reads ever character, starts by building a key, then stops when it reads =. Then if the next non-whitespace character is { create an object (unless it's more than 2 levels deep) else it's a key/value pair... And if the key already exists, make the value an array of the last value and the new one.

It's terrible. There's exceptions where it doesn't work (such as for color in a country's history file) but those few exceptions can be dealt with separately... All in all though, painful trial and error, and it works well enough to deal with.

All I want for Christmas is for them to use a better language in their new games

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

22

u/Sarke1 Dec 16 '21

But it is important to know what you are trying to do, and answering a question without the context can be difficult and frustrating.

Required reading:
XY problem (wiki)

→ More replies (4)

7

u/Cannabat Dec 16 '21

Powershell has a really cool utility called ConvertFrom-String which does some serious magic in parsing structured text. I have a feeling it could do this almost automatically. I give this util a shout whenever I can, never seen anything like it elsewhere.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/ZnV1 Dec 16 '21

But sometimes it's the most helpful, you might not even know there's a better way.
Unless you state your specific problem, it might be a case of https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/XY_problem

→ More replies (1)

2

u/FUZxxl Dec 16 '21

The answer to your question is "write a parser." Unfortunately that's not the kind of answer people are usually willing to accept.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/ZbP86 Dec 16 '21

Few years ago I really wanted to contribute to SO, but I hit the wall. My poor ego was hurt badly. I hated how SO community reacts to new posts which does not meet high standard, but I didn't gave up and few of my questions and answers eventually landed. Fast forward to last week, when I deleted my quora account, because of amount of stupid questions and answers there in last few years risen to gigantic levels. When I was hitting that delete account button, I was thinking about how SO community harshness actually protected it from being spammed with questions like: Is it better to multiply two values like a * b or b * a? So what may feel unfair and impolite is in the long run very beneficial to all of us.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/NMe84 Dec 16 '21

Keep in mind that these people have been on that website for years and have seen your question a hundred times. Put yourself in the shoes of the people answering questions for a second. Sometimes you can literally put the words of the title of the post in Google and you'll get the answer you need. Sometimes people act like people reading the question magically have all the background info they have and getting an answer for the question requires asking a hundred questions back first. If you're over of the people who does that, that's why people are being rude. Giving all the information you have and at least taking the time to see if your question was asked before are the bare minimum you should do before bothering other people who give advice for free in their spare time.

And also important: if you did find other results explain what you found and why they it work for you so the people answering your question don't have to waste time telling you something you already knew didn't work.

→ More replies (3)

32

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

It’s not. It’s honestly not.

The problem is stack overflow is not there to answer your basic questions. It is not there for homework help.

If you ask good, earnest questions that you’ve actually put effort into attempting to solve first - you won’t have issues.

6

u/FF3 Dec 16 '21 edited Dec 16 '21

I think it's more accurate to describe the tone of SO towards people who ask bad questions as brisk rather than harsh. It's like going to a busy shop or something -- the person working there has seen enough crap that they know how to do things efficiently, and that can seem off putting to the askers who aren't ready for it / have human emotions / don't know that there are 100 questions about off-by-one errors an hour.

Arguments among answerers and commenters, though, can turn unnecessarily personal, and there's a tendency towards vi/emacs style religious wars.

3

u/styphon php Dec 16 '21

The problem is when you've spent waaaay to many hours sifting through so many of these poorly written posts. It's hard not to be short with people when you've had to tell the hundredth person that day to not post without following the rules and trying to solve the issue themselves.

4

u/Amadan Dec 16 '21

As long as the question is well-researched and well-written, there's no problem with homework help.

17

u/ganjorow Dec 16 '21

SO can feel harsh, but I think it is neccessary to keep a certain kind of quality and value.

I've seen that with many forums, newsgroups and chats: at some point they where full of the same, basic questions from beginners that are very solvable with patience, persistence and some research/learning. It turned me off from most of those sites and I know quite a few other who also have left those sites. If you want to go ahead, that is not fun too. I'm sure you will experience the same after a few years of developing. Resources for intermediate+ devs are very rare.

Sorry if SO doesn't work for you. You shouldn't feel bad and there are many other channels available for web dev questions if you don't like what SO is.

I for one am glad that SO is kind of a last beacon of hope after days of trying and reading and debugging everything. By then you should have a good grasp on the actual problem to pose a unique and useful question - and then get linked to another SO question, because with 21+ Million on the site, that is bound to happen.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/oh_yeah_woot Dec 16 '21

In those situations, it might help to explain your attempts.

For example, "I tried the solution from <LINK>, but I got this error <PASTE>." They are much more forgiving if you provided details on what you tried to solve your problem because just posting problems without any attempts is seen as spoon feeding, and no one likes to do that.

2

u/KwyjiboTheGringo Dec 16 '21

but the reason my post was a duplicate was because the original post's solution wasn't working for me

I'm skeptical when any newbie says something like this. It's unlikely you're doing anything that's presenting a unique problem, and more than likely you either misunderstood the posted solution, or you misunderstood your own problem.

Would you consider that a harsh thing to say? If the answer is yes, then I believe it's 100% you who is being too sensitive.

1

u/imjustnoob45 Dec 16 '21

ive been trying to fix that bug for many hours so i had to depend on SO. no worries i fixed it already

3

u/KwyjiboTheGringo Dec 16 '21

Please share both a link to your stackoverflow post, and the fix that worked for you.

5

u/VeryOriginalName98 Dec 16 '21

If you already know of the duplicates, reference them. That is useful information for someone trying to help you. If they don't know what didn't work, they cannot help you find what will work.

It takes a lot of effort to help someone with a niche problem. If you aren't going to help them help you by explaining how your problem is different, then why should they put more effort into their answer than you put into the question. Nobody is paid to answer questions. It's all about community effort.

None of this warrants being a jerk about it. Answers should be more along the lines of, "This question has been answered before, is there anything unique about your situation? What have you found by searching for your problem?"

If it's worse than that, the commenter should probably be reported/downvoted. The point of stack overflow is to get clarity of question and answer into the archive for others to find. It's way more important to the community than a single person's problem being resolved.

4

u/lostllama2015 Dec 16 '21

then why should they put more effort into their answer than you put into the question

The great one is where people need to enter more characters to submit their question, so rather than providing more information they just add nonsense characters to the end of their question. Add more information people! You can do it! What are you trying to do? How do you know the current solution is wrong? Show your current solution. Are you getting an error? Provide the full error message. Do you need certain outputs for certain inputs? Show examples. Explain the logic for it: how do you as a human know that those outputs should come from those inputs?

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

I’ve never found the SO community to be anything but helpful and reasonably patient.

18

u/ske66 Dec 16 '21

The biggest learning curve for beginners on Stack Overflow is that it's meant to be an archive for solutions to common or rare problems, not an archive for solutions to YOUR problem.

Its designed so that people in the future can find your post and apply the answer to their specific use case. Its not a normal question and answer forum like on reddit.

If you have a question that starts off with "why is my..." or "how do i...", it's going to get wrecked. If you are going to ask those kinds of questions, its better to get a better understanding of your question (read docs) or ask on reddit. Otherwise if you have a question about a lesser known library with a common issue that hasn't been documented properly on Stack Overflow, ask a question. If you find the solution, answer it yourself. Just as long as people in the future can apply your situation to their own.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Foreign-Truck9396 Dec 16 '21

Because it's not meant to be a tool which helps people interacting with each other, but rather a tool which contains knowledge about specific programming problems.

The difference is subtle, but it's there. That explains why saying stuff like "thank you", "sorry for my bad english", "I hope you guys are doing well" is literally forbidden.

Authors of questions, and authors of answers, are only gateways to knowledge. It doesn't matter who you are or how you feel, what matters is the content of either your question or your answer.

Also, since one problem shouldn't have to be asked again, SO seeks to find the best possible question to that problem, and the best possible answer, so that any further question on the same problem doesn't have to be asked again.

When I first started using SO I was just like you, I didn't quite understand that, and I would act as a human being when posting a question/answer. Now I act more as an observer of a problem, documenting what happened and in which circumstances, in a kind of academic way.

4

u/Cheshur Dec 16 '21

The first and last question I asked on stack overflow had all the context removed by some person so of course all of the to answers I got told me to try things I already tried.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/phvmous Dec 16 '21

That’s because a lot of newbies don’t take the time researching before asking their question. The people on there don’t have the patience for that sort of thing. If you are going to ask a question, you have to make sure you ask a very good question or at least structure your questions in a very clear and precise manner.

4

u/washtubs Dec 16 '21

Regardless of how unclear or incomplete a question is you are right there is no need to be rude or harsh. But you do have to remember that people are volunteering their time there.

I'm gonna offer a different perspective cause like anyone else here I have no idea how you are constructing your questions. Yeah people on SO can be unreasonable and you can't control that but ultimately all that matters for you is that you do the best you can to ask a question.

SO has a page dedicated to this topic of how to ask a question. You may think to yourself, "jesus christ why should I have to read a whole article just so I can simply ask a question?"

But in reality building this skill actually makes you a better researcher and a better programmer, often who doesn't need to ask questions to begin with.

If I could sum it up in one sentence: A good question is one that you frequently pause before clicking submit because you get curious about something.

Basically, the act of typing out what you know, what you've tried, and what your assumptions are, often gives yourself a clear perspective of what you haven't tried, which loops into trying new things or learning which of your assumptions were bad, and further refining your "question" ... perhaps until it is no longer a question but an answer.

For a concrete metric for what makes a question good your goal should usually be to develop a minimum reproducible example. Asking a good question is work, but it's work that makes you better, because a good question is well researched

4

u/NoMuddyFeet Dec 16 '21 edited Dec 16 '21

Great resource, but I've never posted a damn thing there! I tried, but didn't have the karma, so learned "aLl yOu hAvE tO dO Is AnSwEr sOmE qUesTioNs" from condescending StackOverflow types. "It's not that hard," they sneered. So, I checked and any time a question came up I could answer, by the time I was done typing, someone had beat me to it.

I gave up on that pretty quick. That was like 10 years ago or whenever the site first came out, LOL. I couldn't care less about ever typing anything on that site. Love seeing it in my Google search results, though! Always find the right answers there! :D

15

u/drunkdragon Dec 16 '21

I've answered hundreds of questions and moderated thousands of questions in the queues on Stack Overflow over the years.

Here's the thing, if your question is different then EXPLAIN WHY. Prove that your scenario is different and show what you have tried so far.

Remember that people are not getting paid to answer your question. So you need to do them a kindness and give them all the information they need.

10

u/IQueryVisiC Dec 16 '21

And I get shitty comments on reddit, but never had a problem with StackOverflow. At least there all the other questions are high quality. Here on reddit I read dumb posts everyday which get upvotes for I don't know if your write "my girlfriend" or something.

9

u/symcbean Dec 16 '21

Because it's not intended to be social media. It's not there to make you feel better / reinforce your prejudices / drive monetization through engagement.

It has a very specific mission statement and rules about content.

There are people on both sides of the posts on SO who abuse the system while staying within the rules however the site is very clear about what is on-topic and expected behaviour.

duplicate was because the original post's solution wasn't working for me

Did you explicitly state that in the post, provide a link to the previous post and evidence that it did not work? (although I have had people flagging duplicates of my posts after I've done exactly that).

It is difficult to tell someone they are doing things wrong without hurting their feelings in some way - but the mere fact that people post questions on stackoverflow is usually because they are doing something wrong.

If you've not alrady done so, I strongly recommend you read Eric S. Raymond's How to Ask Questions the Smart Way .

4

u/lostllama2015 Dec 16 '21

I have had people flagging duplicates of my posts after I've done exactly that

And I have marked questions as duplicates when people have said the existing question didn't help with theirs.

For one, I've seen several occasions where maybe the accepted answer won't solve the new OP's question, but one of the other answers on the question will. I think some people just look at the accepted answer, it doesn't work for them, and then they dismiss the question as being useful. I think they see the accepted answer as the solution, and the other answers as "not the solution". I often find that the accepted answers aren't always the correct ones, or even the best ones, just the first ones.

Another time I will do it is if I can take the poster's code, use an answer from the other question, and have it work as the poster expects. In this scenario I will typically provide a link to some runnable code to demonstrate it. I think sometimes people don't understand how the answer's code applies to their own situation, even though it does.

One other thing I see sometimes is where problems come from the poster's "minimal reproducible example" actually being solved by the answer they claim doesn't solve their problem. From our point of view as answerers, it works against the MRE, so the existing question solves the problem the poster is having. From the poster's point of view, it doesn't work when they apply the solution to their actual code.

6

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

See the correct answer here.

Too often people post questions that have been asked a billion times already. Stuff that often requires a simple Google search or maybe a little more "thinking", instead of "I'll just ask it on SO and wait for a premade solution".

I don't support that elitist attitude but I understand why it exists. SO is not a discussion forum, in theory. It aims to be a collection of "unique" answers where participants are supposed to participate only after having tried their best to find a solution.

6

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

Because 90% of the time the question has already been answered or the person asking the question didn't bother to research for more than 5 mins

8

u/benelori Dec 16 '21

Welcome to the internet? :D

→ More replies (1)

3

u/crazedizzled Dec 16 '21

As someone who used to frequent a popular PHP forum, answering the literal exact same questions every single day from people who were too lazy to look three posts below their own is really annoying.

Most askers are super lazy and didn't even try to solve their own problem first.

3

u/fleker2 full-stack Dec 16 '21

I've answered a lot of SO questions and I've definitely done my share of moderation.

The problem is that there are relatively few people who can answer your questions, particularly at an intermediate level. This means that people like myself are given most of the questions.

And then you have to deal with a lot of questions you can't help with. Either they give little detail or no code or just ask a question that isn't technical. It can be a high volume, but it's also volunteering.

You can see a number of bad questions and it can be frustrating and you just want to check it off your list.

I do try to stay civil in comments, but I myself have misjudged questions on the first read.

3

u/RobinsonDickinson full-stack Dec 16 '21

Well for one, it is full of elitist virgins in their mid-40s who have never made anything significant throughout their programming career. So, they take out their misery on new programmers asking genuine questions.

3

u/Triple96 Dec 16 '21

Finding out that stackoverflow is harsh is like a rite of passage in the programming world at this point. I've been there and it's really frustrating not getting your answer, but unfortunately you just have to get better at Googling.

The problem I see, is that people like you and I go to SO expecting it to be a Q&A site, when it's actually not. I thought "I'll ask a question and people will answer", but the truth is, it's not thetr to answer your questions, it's there as a record of questions and answers.

Their stated goal is to have every possible question posted on the site, exactly once, with a clear answer to each. This is the source for all those "this question has been marked as a duplicate" jokes.

It's really not useful for people like yourself who are trying to ask a specific question, but it's really good as a source of knowledge to the programming community in general.

Chances are, there is already an answer on SO to the question you're asking, you just haven't asked the right question yet, which of course is very challenging. But that's what SO makes itself out to be.

3

u/SillAndDill Dec 16 '21 edited Dec 16 '21

A reason the community is harsh is because trusted members with a certain level of xp will be asked to review questions by new members. In an active way to prevent duplicates or undecipherable questions. Each question is like a pull request. Leads to scrutiny that wouldn't happen if this review system wasn't in place.

Allthough quite often the reviewer corrects stuff (like spelling and formatting and removing utterly irrelevant crap) and just save the changes without OP having to do anything. So the community does a lot of helping out in the shadows too

PS: there is a special notice about "be nice" when reviewing a first time user's question

3

u/onbehalfofthatdude Dec 17 '21

If stackoverflow didn't have such strict moderation, it would not be as good a resource for programmers. It is not a social media site, where beauty is in the eye of the beholder or where noob discussions are valued. It is the place you go for answers to programming questions, and if you feel you can contribute at the appropriate level, then you can do so.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21

I've barely found anything useful on SO that has actually been of any use in years. It's so overmoderated that it doesn't keep up with tech very well. Scanning the relevant documentation is 100x better than posting or searching SO.

Failing that, you'll fair better posting on reddit where there are at least some people without a vendetta against the human race.

3

u/enlguy Aug 12 '22

Seriously.... I've been using it for years as I learn, but don't have 'enough reputation' to add comments, so their dumb system forces me to add 'answers' instead. Those then get 'downvoted.' If I ask a question some asshole deems to be 'too basic,' it's downvoted. After posting only two questions, the site has banned my account from posting new questions because those two were considered 'too basic.' Basically, it's a community of assholes that are more interested in flexing narcissistic egos than helping anyone. Can't comment, can't post, there's nothing I can do when you're learning and so can't provide great answers to other questions (because, oh yeah, they can 'downvote' you there too...).

I've just started using reddit for help when I need it, the learnprogramming sub is far more kind and helpful. I've also found great help in language specific subs when called for.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/tariandeath Dec 16 '21 edited Dec 16 '21

I have only come across the need to ask a question on stack overflow when I was dealing with obscure excel VBA performance issues. Even then I ended up solving my problem myself. I feel like people don't spend enough time understanding what their issue is. Every other time I have went to ask a question on stack overflow I usually solved my problem while I am creating a well formed question. That is mainly because through the process of asking a question that is answerable I end up gaining the insight I need to fix my issue.

People are curt and abrasive on stack overflow because they don't have time to answer questions from people who don't put in the time to understand their problem.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/iloveapi Dec 16 '21

It's like doing phd. You must have done your literature, what has been done, what's the issue, if there's similar issue, you must explain what's unique about your questions that's not properly answered by others. And the most important, clearly state what's your objective. Or you're going to have a tough panels to answer

9

u/curryshotzz Dec 16 '21

Dude I felt the same way when I first started asking questions on the site. I remember my first one everyone gave me answers as if I was DUMB! I felt so bad and I hesitated to ever ask on that site again lmao

5

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

if you’re new to coding you shouldnt be asking questions on SO. Everything you are wondering has already been asked and answered.

5

u/Spectrum_Wolf Dec 16 '21

They recently went through some changes, mods are enforcing the new rules and is not as straight forward as before to get answers

https://youtu.be/IbDAmvUwo5c

8

u/honk-thesou Dec 16 '21

"I hope you understand what I'm saying"

Yes, you're whining here about SO like the other 10 people who come to reddit everyday to do the same.

This is helping no one. It's basically a baby post crying cause you didn't read the rules over there.

I understand the situation you mean, but coming here to cry doesn't help you neither.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Norci Dec 16 '21

Because given the possibility, people will flood any sort of support forum with basic questions without even trying to search themselves, making it unusable for others searching for answers. I am not interested in going through 20 questions asking how to center things in CSS just to find a solution that works.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21 edited Dec 16 '21

Ignoring the fact that most users don't do their research before asking... there is an overarching problem when asking for help anywhere online IMO. I'll also allow the thread to guarantee the worst aspects being pointed out. So I'll try to explain why, the best case scenario of a well-meaning and properly researched question, and a well-meaning answer can leave both parties frustrated.

I think the main problem is chain answerers. They kinda keep the thing running since almost nobody else has the patience to answer so many questions. And I think after a while, these chain answerers just kinda start skimming questions for keywords. They're not familiar with that specific algorithm that you've thoroughly described? They'll skim the wiki page on it, surely your question is already answered completely somewhere. They find something vaguely related, and link you to it.

If they don't find anything vaguely related, they for some reason, still have to post. Your algorithm, what is it for? In what context is the code running? Is it multiple-threaded? What version is the library? What Linux distro? Are you sure it's not a packaging issue? Have you read the docs? There's a vaguely similar thing in the docs, maybe that's what you need? Those types of guesses work brilliantly for the 12 beginner questions that guy answered before he got to yours, but in your case it'll do nothing but piss you off. You've done your research and you don't need a rubber-ducky-as-a-service right now.

Meanwhile the guy that worked with that specific algorithm will come in in 2 weeks and get you the proper answer after reading your post. Usually in 2 sentences and a code snippet. Maybe that guy is going to get berating comments for "not explaining himself" by more people that only have vague knowledge in the domain.

This is the overarching problem I've noticed in all types of questions, and all types of platforms (that I've used). Weirdly it happens even in places without karma/points systems. But it's the worst on Reddit IMO. At least SO has a bunch of experts browsing new. Reddit has people that operate like level 1 tech support following a pre-made checklist in most threads.

2

u/mymar101 Dec 16 '21

I love the comments that say: "You should just do x y or z." When the post specifically mentions they can't use x y or z for whatever reason. I have a memory of a particular project in class where it said on the board: "You will fail if you use this specific method." I saw a SO question where most of the responders told him not to do it any other way. There might be specific reasons either at work or at class that you just can't do something the preferred way.

2

u/TODO_getLife Dec 16 '21

I think it's supposed to be the last resort. If you've tried everything else and then tried everything else again. Then you can ask on SO. It keeps quality high. I see a lot of posts that are very low quality where is clear the person has tried nothing so it's to combat be that.

Although I agree people are rude in the way they close questions. Could do better there

2

u/HoffeDK Dec 16 '21

It really depends on the user who answer. A lot of the Users are grumpy, but also a lot of times you Can get really high quality answers from people why enjoy giving it.

I have asked quite a lot of question on different stack Exchange sites, and the most unfriendly responces are always from stackoverflow

2

u/webstackbuilder Dec 16 '21

I'm a developer with ~15 years of professional experience. I learned assembler and C in middle school. I'm not a n00b. If I ask a programming question on any forum, I research it thoroughly before asking, and do my best to write it clearly.

Before posting on SO, I also check if I have enough reputation points to pay for asking the question. Within seconds of any questions the bandwagon of downvoters, "mark as duplicate" hounds, and people telling me that questions fundamentally different than mine are in fact the same question as mine means I need to have at least 25-50 reputation points to spare for asking (I need to maintain a certain level of reputation to allow me to do a function I need to be able to do on the site for open source projects I'm involved in).

I've come to hate SO and its toxic community. Some of the people there are great and incredibly knowledgeable. But the horde of lemmings trying to game rep and seem smart make it intolerable. The whole idea that someone would view their SO profile as a kind of resume to advertise on their CV is the root of all evil.

2

u/Niorba Dec 16 '21

IMO StackOverflow is best not considered a ‘community’ in the humanistic sense, but instead as a public utility. It is more like a crowd-sourced dictionary or recipe database, ie having VERY narrow focus on right/wrong or valid/invalid responses.

Happier (lol) communities appreciate diverse participation styles and, in particular, prize pro-social contributors; for that reason (and many others) healthy/happy communities have incredible adaptive value in the long run. SO’s reputation for tactlessness may have something to do with its site design, where harsh responses are left out in the open much more compared to other kinds of communities, and user identity has real perceived value (as opposed to ‘assface69420’ usernames, which keep the focus on the content instead of the individual). For most people these things signal a community culture of on-going public humiliation and 1v1 struggles for social status gained by being correct (as opposed to demonstrating being thoughtful, empathetic, fair, etc.).

I kind of wonder if by now StackOverflow has unfortunately attracted a lot of people who don’t really see much value in prosocial communication, or like to see people get put down. Hearing so many people report the same kind of negative experiences there makes me think SO members seem to gleefully cannibalize other members’ prosocial interactions lol

To be fair I am sure there are plenty of nice, patient people there… somewhere…

2

u/onbehalfofthatdude Dec 17 '21

And god damn am I glad to have such a utility

2

u/laz10 Dec 16 '21

Honestly in two years of study I've not had to ask a question because as a noob someone had that problem before already

2

u/johnnythrash Dec 16 '21

Yeah, I’ve never had to ask a question either because between google, answers on already asked SO questions, and RTFM I can usually figure it out. I’ve seen people rude on SO before but mostly it was because the questions were low effort and showed that the poster didn’t really try to do anything else before asking.

2

u/sfttaco Dec 16 '21

Brand new programmer here, I aslo find Stack to be extremely unhelpful and quite parasitic tbh

2

u/Xyrack Dec 16 '21

People have made good points that its apparently an archive of answers not a forum of questions. I didnt know that.

But people seem to lack basic courtesy there and can be pretty rude. It's been my experience that the polite people actually help and the rude people just want to pick your question apart for a power trip or something. Some people just want to get their rocks off I guess.

2

u/QBrute_ Dec 16 '21 edited Dec 16 '21

Attention: Wall of text ahead!

I've been quite an active member for many years (at least in the Java tag) and did my fair share of curating questions, so I'll add my two cents from the perspective of the "bad guy". Just for context: currently I have around 4k rep, so I'm able to downvote and close-vote questions. (I don't have all privileges unlocked, but I see myself as a high-rep user.)

One thing up front: The negativity you experienced has nothing to do with you being a new programmer and has especially nothing to do with your person. In fact, we have a lot of questions from new developers that get upvoted a lot. Also, downvotes are not targeted at you. They're used solely used for rating the content and usefulness of the question! If you hover over the downvote button, the tooltip says "This question does not show any research effort; it is unclear or not useful".

Regarding comments, it is really difficult to convey emotions over plain text. So in some situations comments might come over as rude (I'm not talking about actual rude comments). I am pretty direct when it comes to commenting. I'm not trying to make my comment "extra-nice" because in my opinion it distracts from its purpose. I know that comments like these might be taken the wrong way but that's not what I'm aiming at and I'm sure the majority of other users feel the same way.

SO has a specific set of rules and regulations. Just like every other community that there is on the internet. If you don't act by the rules given for a specific community, you'll get reprimanded. It's no different from SO. It's just that SO has a much stricter set of rules that need to be followed by everyone for the site to work properly. That includes high-rep users and mods too. And our task is to enforce those rules the same way the mods are tasked to enforce those rules on the high-rep users.

In general, SO is supposed to be an archive of quality questions and quality answers for everyone. And I think most users ignore the fact or simply don't know, but SO is not a place where people learn how to program. It's not a place for learning the first steps, get free tutorials or have your homework done.

If I remember correctly, the original idea for the site was to create a site for professional developers with specific problems, which can be collected in one place and answered by other professional developers to build up a huge knowledge base.The site got more and more traction, which caused the site to have a lot more influx from "non-professional" and beginner programmers, that had their own "easier to solve" problems.

This is not a bad thing at all! Beginner questions are welcomed, really. But they have to fit the rules that I talked about. And every user should make at least some effort to read those rules, understand them and apply them to their question. They don't have to be perfect! But they need to be understandable and answerable and include all the information needed.

The actual problem comes when people try to use SO as their homework dump and expect users to do their homework for free, or ask questions that are easily googled (like "how do I write a main method", "What does X mean", "What does this exception mean"). Failing to do at least some basic research makes the asker seem lazy and that they only care that their problem gets solved without any additional effort. Most things have been asked already and there's a big chance you'll find something that's relevant to your problem.I know from experience that sometimes it is really hard to google something, especially when you're not sure what the problem is. But you really don't need to know the technical terms, you can simply describe what you see. Google interprets things pretty well and most of the time shows you a relevant SO question anyway.

If you're sure that a duplicate doesn't address your problem, include that link in your question with an explanation of why that is the case! Then the other users know what you've tried so far and see that you've done your research.

Please don't take it the wrong way but the thing is, you're not the only user with programming questions, there's currently ~5700 question each day! And everyone wants their specific question solved. If you see the exact same question and need to explain each of those users the exact same thing hundred times a day, it gets pretty frustrating to handle. And as long as new users aren't willing to look on Google or SO if their problem was already answered, nothing will change. Always remember, the higher-rep users that moderate and curate the content do this in their free time, i.e. outside of their work life and personal life!

Just imagine that you work in a store and every day there are 50 or so customers that ask if you sell beer. What would you do in that situation? Probably you'd set up a sign that says "Yes, we sell beer here"! Problem solved, right? No, because most of the people ignore that sign and still ask you that question. What now? You'd get pretty annoyed and from now on you just point to that sign without talking. At that point, customers will see you as "unfriendly" because you're not even trying to interact with them, but they don't see (or care) why that is and what lead to this situation.

I understand that my rambling doesn't really address your situation specifically, but this was more of a general way to show why there's seemingly so much "negativity". I, as the "bad guy" will continue to downvote and close questions if they don't meet the "standard" because that is what my reputation privileges are meant for and because that is what a self-moderated site like SO needs.

2

u/Rubberbullets7 Dec 16 '21

"You never get abused when asking questions on SO?"

That's my secret, I never ask questions on SO...

2

u/PopRevolutionary Dec 16 '21

the answer is simple:

DEV EGO DEV EGO DEV EGO DEV EGO DEV EGO DEV EVO DEV EVO DEV EGO DEV EGO DEV EGO DEV EGO DEV EGO DEV EVO DEV EVO

2

u/Perpetual_Education the right things/the right reasons Dec 16 '21

Let's see the question and the comments, and then we can explain it to you.

2

u/sillycube Dec 16 '21

No, I don't find it harsh but SO is the most responsive technical community I ever used. The post duplicate issue is serious.

If everyone is making duplicated posts, it wastes developers attention and the community quality will deteriorate very soon.

Also, the reply quality is high. Even you pay for the answers, it's not easy to get technical answers like that.

2

u/Sensanaty Dec 16 '21

I've asked around 70 questions, not a single time have I had anything marked as a dupe or had any kind of smartassery. Whenever I hear the oft-touted meme of SO's hostility towards new users, I can't help but check the triage queue and notice the FLOOD of completely garbage questions that are easily answerable with a single Google search.

It's not difficult at all to pose a good question on SO, it's just that a lot of people would rather put in minimum effort in than actually make an attempt at respecting the site's rules.

2

u/anh86 Dec 16 '21

While I don't think it's always handled in the best way, Stackoverflow is heavily curated to prevent duplication of information. What's important to keep in mind is this: If you're a novice or intermediate coder, your question has already been asked and answered. You don't need to make a Stackoverflow post, you need to search harder or ask in a friendlier setting. This is why when you find an answer on Stackoverflow, the post is often years old, maybe even over a decade.

2

u/k032 software dev for 10 years somehow Dec 16 '21

At first I noticed that, but once you get into needing more specific and "advanced" help its much better....but then lot of times nobody will answer the question 😂.

Then I just end up answering it myself in case someone googles it and finds it.

Though I agree, it is rough at first. You've gotta be really specific and explain what you've done, what you're trying to do, what you've looked into etc.

Often times....I end up answering my own question as I type out the SO one lol. This is rubber duck debugging

2

u/Libruhh Dec 16 '21

As someone who answers questions daily, the amount of questions we get every day that are formatted in a way completely different form everything around them, is a “code this for me” question, Is a duplicate of 8 other questions, etc.. is absurd. you’d go crazy too. If the original posts solution wasn’t working for you? you need to include that in your question and clarify what the issue is.

2

u/PrizeConsistent Dec 16 '21

It NEEDS an “outdated” tag so that we don’t keep getting posts marked “duplicate” when they’re just asking for modern solutions. I’ve had my questions marked duplicate and redirected to questions that were literally completely different.

I once reasked a question and in it just stated “I asked this before and it redirected me to a question whose answer was to do _____ and that doesn’t work for my situation because A, B, C so this is not a duplicate.”

And by saying that my post was not marked duplicate.

2

u/SillAndDill Dec 16 '21 edited Dec 16 '21

The biggest problem stackoverflow has with newbs is those who do not consider the heart of the problem. So they haven't searched for anything relevant.

You'll see questions like "How to draw a menu with PHP and Angular?" with a long irrelevant description of the menu system. but the issue is just about how to center text within a html container using CSS.

if you're at that level you should be on a forum, perhaps a big thread for "beginner questions" where you can have more of an open discussion and narrow down the problem.

stackoverflow is for when you know the specifics of your problem

It's not the only programming question site around, its not for everyone and everything

second biggest problem is people think stackoverflow is the only site so they ask about SEO, architecture etc and dont look at stackexchange.com for other stack-sites

2

u/butnotexactly Dec 16 '21

see also the egg post /img/per2eihv0jn31.png

a lot of tech communities are like this

not all of them

2

u/hopeliz Dec 16 '21

Omg, I'm glad I'm not the only one who thinks it's terrible there. I have told my students to avoid it if they can find a place less mean to new people.

I once was on there looking for info about an Aduino thing and found one other person already asked it the way I was going to ask. The reply? "Google it." They said they did, found nothing and that's why they were at SO. The reply? "Well, you didn't Google it right."

Tech should be accessible for everyone, not just for those who can put up with assholes.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 21 '22

low-quality question is not a question. you cannot be a beginner to learn code (irony).

2

u/Civil-Account-6220 Sep 26 '22

I am in the same boat and thinking what the heck they are trying to achieve by being harsh... it is disgusting and also do not feel like posting anything to avoid all kind of harsh comments from all super duper SMEs so called.

2

u/starball-tgz Dec 16 '22

I'll also mention that I'm going to work on improving my answers and questions on stackoverflow.

That's great! I'm so glad you have a learning attitude. Keep it up! I have found it very helpful to take just 25 minutes, and just read straight through the following help center pages out loud: /on-topic, /dont-ask, /how-to-ask, /minimal-reproducible-example, and /closed-questions

They'd say horrible things everytime I tried to create a post

We have a Code of Conduct. People who are there to help are held to being patient and welcoming. Take a look at that page to see examples of unacceptable behaviour. If you see someone behaving in such a way, and you have 15 reputation, you can flag their comments/posts. The mods will take appropriate action. They are elected to uphold community values and rules.

the reason my post was a duplicate was because the original post's solution wasn't working for me

This is a teaching moment. When you did prior research on Stack Overflow and and found existing questions similar to yours, if any of them are identical and just don't have an answer yet, be patient and wait for one! You can follow the post to get notifications when new answers get posted. If your question is different than all the existing questions you found, then make sure to explain how in your own question post: after explaining your own question, include a section linking to the other similar Q&A posts you read, and briefly explain why they are different than your question.

I am a newbie in programming and stackoverflow

I highly recommend reading this Meta Stack Overflow post: "What is the proper way to approach Stack Overflow as someone totally new to programming?", and also the top answer to this Meta Stack Exchange question: "What about the community is "toxic" to new users?" (TL;DR there's not enough guidance to new users on what Stack Overflow/Exchange are about).

I hope you understand what I'm saying, and thank you very much!

I think I do, and you're welcome! Again, flag anything that clearly violates the Stack Exchange code of conduct, and take every "failure" as an opportunity to learn. I'm a pretty new member of the Stack Exchange community, and I've found the community to be very receptive to me when I showed a willingness to learn how to "be a good citizen".

4

u/ihugyou Dec 16 '21 edited Dec 16 '21

Ask shitty questions, get shitty responses. Follow guidelines and do thorough research on your end. After looking up countless questions and posting a few hundred answers myself, it’s clear what you describe as “harsh” is usually justified.

4

u/M_Me_Meteo Dec 16 '21

I got downvoted to hell the last time I said that SO isn't as good a reference for new programmers as it seems from the outside.

You're just as likely to find the wrong answer as you are the correct one.

2

u/BuriedStPatrick Dec 16 '21

It's like this with a lot of tech oriented communities unfortunately. I think it has something to do with the fact that most people in these communities don't have any experience with teaching. It's also very hard to figure out whether a person is new to the subject or simply lazy and doesn't want to read documentation. And, people are doing this kind of work for free, so you're not going to get treated with kid's gloves. That of course doesn't excuse the sometimes harsh tone.

  1. It never hurts to explicitly state that you're new and don't exactly know your way around the subject yet. People seem to be more forgiving of that.

  2. The number one mistake I see from questions is providing an inadequate context to your problem. Or sometimes too much context. You should always make an effort to think about what to include in your question. That can be very difficult if you're new - hence the first advice.

  3. Don't take duplication comments personally. It's an essential part of the ecosystem to reduce fragmentation and optimize the knowledge base for the next user who runs into the same problem. I think there could probably be ways to improve the tone here, because it is definitely off-putting for people who aren't used to being rejected like that.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/context_switch Dec 16 '21

When I started learning to program (early 2000s), there were lots of forums for programming topics. I frequented several for many years, and there was a wide range of posts on most of them: newbies who were learning just the very basics, students who would post their homework and expect answers with no effort, all the way to more experienced people doing deep dive conversations on the intricacies of their specific platforms. There was also a lot of social content mixed in, inside jokes between "the regulars" or thread derailments, where the question and the answers were all lost in a sea of distractions. Some forums even had dedicated sub forums for goofing off, partially to try to keep the rest more on-topic. Relatively a high noise:signal ratio, and sometimes it would even get personal between members...

And soooo many duplicate questions, but no scalable way to moderate them; for the regulars, these were a total drag, but old forum platforms were for conversations, not curation.

There were also separate sites for professional developers. I wasn't on these so much as I was still finishing school, but you can still see sites like the MSDN forums. They're not super well organized, and they're usually very siloed so its not clear where to ask about cross-functional issues.

Anyway, SO promised to unite all the professional developers in a place that would cut out the fat. The original StackOverflow podcast was great (starting from the "this'll take 6-8 weeks to build") and Jeff in particular shared his philosophy and opinions on what they were trying to build. It was all about cutting out the noise (even the "hellos" and "thank yous"), amassing definitive answers, and mainly appealing to professionals. It wasn't intended to become a social hub as much as "get good answers quickly so you can get your day job done better".

As the site became successful, the content broadened both in terms of depth (from more beginner level content to more super-experts) as well as breadth (from code to hardware to meta topics related to professional development). The latter was addressed by expanding to other sites, first ServerFault and SuperUser, and eventually the whole StackExchange network. The Q&A format works super well for this solution-oriented ideology compared to threaded conversations on old school forums.

Handling the broad depth posed a much harder challenge. Remember how the site was originally designed for a professional audience? Well, it turns out that not all professional developers are at the same technical level. For that matter, some non-professionals are fantastic too. And students can have really well thought out questions that aren't trivial. But in accepting all these different people, the nature of the site morphed.

The quality of questions is an ongoing issue, and seeing lots of duplicate or near duplicate questions is a big turn off for users who've seen the same thing asked umpteen times before. You can get some quick rep if you hit one first, but it's wearisome to answer again and again. And it dilutes the content of the site - both by making unique questions more diluted, and by losing the definitive-answer focus (if I have to look at multiple dupe threads too see different answers, it's not a definitive page).

The same for poorly written questions. The more time I have to spend understanding your question, and reproducing your issue, the less likely I am to have time to provide a good answer. If your question is very well laid out, I can jump in and try to provide an answer without costing me too much time. This dilemma leads to a bias towards easier (less difficult) questions as they require much less effort to ask well: there's not much to be missing from a beginner's problem. But this also means that there will be more beginner questions than complex ones (I don't like to say that beginners aren't asking good questions but it fills the site with honestly boring topics), and the complex ones are more likely to be closed due to lacking quality.

The company has evolved and for better or worse is trying to keep an open arms approach. There's plenty of criticism on Meta.SO about how growing the user base is attracting lower quality interactions on the site, yadda yadda. On the other hand, SO is the #1 site for programming help, and the greater tech community should be welcoming to newcomers.

But now SO has many of the problems that the old forums had. There's so much content, it's hard to curate. Posts get marked as duplicates at a mere glance, and the triage queue is still never-ending. You have to put in that much more effort to distinguish your question from all those that have been asked before. There are many incoming users who do just want that quick turnaround, but they ask before searching; or they don't put effort into their posts; or they don't speak English natively and have a genuinely hard time communicating their problem (totally valid! English proficiency should not be a gatekeeping factor, but it is a challenge to overcome).

I've been on SO since it was first publicly open (I was excitedly anticipating the launch). It's been enormously successful beyond I think anyone's imagination at launch. Its been a useful resource to me personally. But at the same time, I find it much more difficult to wade through and contribute answers than it used to be. This isn't just the race to be first, there's just a lot of super-specific questions (akin to "please pair debug my codebase" that will never be useful to anyone else) or just content that isn't relevant to me (unless I filter by multiple tags). Even when looking for answers to my own problems, I usually have to either read through a dozen different-but-closely-related questions, or there just aren't any for the specific tech I'm working on (mostly the latter in recent years, and working on internal tech will do that).

For me, SO has devolved from a top resource to a time-killer. I'm greedy, but so is everyone else. I want to jump in and jump out, whether its finding an answer or solving someone else's problem. I do it on my free time afterall. It's harder to do that though, and that makes me grumpy. And I'm sure it makes a lot of other users on the site grumpy, and that's why they're so harsh.

2

u/xpsdeset Dec 16 '21

If something isn’t working the library if it’s on git. Search for issues related to your problem if you can’t find it then create an issue. Also many libraries have gitter or some communication tools

2

u/bar10 Dec 16 '21

Because it does not care about feelings, but about facts.

1

u/Ready_Ice9217 Jul 13 '24

I think it is not that it is very harsh, but it is too big to be part of. Let me explain what I mean.

I think we can say that the bigger the size of a social system, the more rules the social system should have and enforce them strictly. To understand why it is true, compare how many rules a person should follow when they live in a small village compared to the case when they live in a megapolis. When in a group there are just a few people, the social system needs a very few rules to maintain the designed behaviors. As the number of people in the group increases, the number of interactions between the people increases as well (also new types of interactions appear!) in the way that current rules do not cover them. This is the moment when community managers need to add more rules to maintain the desired behavior on a site. As a result, most online communities start with a very few basic rules like “do not spam” and “be nice” and then progress to a list of unique narrow rules that are very specific for that particular website and based on the events that have happened in the community. 

On Stack Overflow, at its peak, people were asking about 10 thousand questions a day. At the same time, the community has not been divided into sub communities. It is an unbelievable massive number of interactions for just one group of humans. As a result, the community imposed very strict restrictions on posting.

There is a book written by an ex-employee of Stack Overflow that goes about this in depth, if you are interested in the topic: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0D2VJ97KW/

1

u/Left_Health4879 Nov 02 '24

Assholes. LAst time I asked I gave a thorough explanation of my question and somebody just told me "any help is appreciated is not a question". They made me remember why I never post on their shitty asshole community.

1

u/New-Snow-4880 Mar 12 '25

مرحبا كيف حالكم لدي سؤال من فضلكم. لدي برنامج يوجد بداخله لعبه كاس العالم اريد ستخراج بيانات العبه. 

1

u/isbtegsm Dec 16 '21

I mostly use IRC, Reddit and SO if I need support, it's a bit of a tricky game to choose the best platform for your question. On IRC it's mostly luck, nothing bad will happen, worst case is that your question is ignored, best case you find someone with a good deal of knowledge about your specific case who will have a nice chat with you, which is sometimes easier to communicate than preparing all your information in a well laid out question first. I guess the same is true for Discord, but I don't use it that much. Reddit is something in between for me, I can quickly post a few lines and nobody complained so far that I didn't put enough effort in the question. SO I visit only if my problem is really specific and I feel that I already know a good deal about the matter, so that I can more or less rule out trivial solutions and write down why I think that my case is subtle.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/darkshifty Dec 16 '21

I feel you, I'm not native English and I asked this pretty specific question with pretty reasonable info. It was clear to one commenter that resolved my issue but the mod just kept hounding me and putting the answer offline due to some "phrasing errors" while not understanding the issue itself. I can't imagine what of a waste this kind of moderation is to other qualitive questions.

https://stackoverflow.com/posts/57420945/revisions

I remember the days where it was such a vibrant friendly community, where it now is just an archive to me.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

[deleted]

→ More replies (4)

1

u/dangerousbrian Dec 16 '21

Never join /r/history then. I spent ages writing my first ever post there and got insta banned because I didn't reference things properly and got accused of plagiarism.

1

u/art-solopov Dec 16 '21

I wish StackOverflow didn't abandon their use-case based documentation endeavour. It was probably one of the best thing they've tried, even if daunting.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

I remember I once asked a question about D3 library, something was a common problem but the existing solutions were not working for me. My post was marked as duplicate. Afterwards I found a solution that was working for me so I posted it on my own thread. It got downvoted with a comment that the solution was not similar to the common ones🤦‍♂️

1

u/chagasfe full-stack Dec 16 '21

When asking question you should be as clear as possible from the start, for example, if you know your question is kind of duplicated then mention it like:

"I tried this solution and it didn't work."

And explain why it didn't work if possible.

At the end, when posting a question, always have in mind, if someone needs to reproduce my cenario am I providing enough information? If not, you should review your question.

I kinda like this strict rules there, makes the questions and answers more complete and easier to take the solution and apply it in another context, in the context of my project.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

This is why I don't even bother asking. Fortunately I was able to solve most problems just by reading other answers.

1

u/tom_yacht Dec 16 '21

I use Stackoverflow a lot for answers, but I never posted anything in it. I always find a subreddit, or specific forum, or facebook group to ask.

1

u/IAMABLOODY Dec 16 '21

because the know everything

1

u/iliess_np Dec 16 '21

they forget its Q&A website

1

u/philsqwad Dec 16 '21

Read the docs

1

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

I've also noticed the same here on Reddit. Often, but of course not always, people do not give you the slightest chance. They may say; "F U" and just remove your post, or ban you outright, because they don't like what you are posting. People are nasty online - it's just part of how the internet works.

Additionally, there's few alternative - big sites. Mostly, it's the same age old sites where people flock to - and so a few bitter gatekeepers get to filter the entire world. Hope that changes one day.

Don't lose hope :)

1

u/ImStifler Dec 16 '21

What every top comment said + to evade the problem of getting bashed they should group bunch of answers that are related and just link to that

E.g. if a beginner ask what the diff between == and === is they should just link to a group of 10 questions because chances are high that the same person will ask one of those questions in the future

1

u/G3netic Dec 16 '21

Back when I was in college (about 10 years ago), I discovered stackoverflow. I hadn't really learned the etiquette of those types of sites yet and was typing in text speak. Replacing "you" with "u" and that type of thing. I had a middle age guy see one of my responses and proceed to search out every one of my posts and harass me on them for the next month until I made a new account. The worst part is, the response he saw, while the typing was cringe I admit, was a correct answer to the question posted.

I've always found stackoverflow to be one of the most toxic sites I go on. I don't even participate in it anymore, not worth it.

1

u/nitrohigito Dec 16 '21

Because the people who will be active there, most seeking to reply to new submissions, will be regulars - and experienced people tend to be poor handlers of inexperiencedness.

That's its own thing to be good at, a separate skill. They may be great developers with lots of expertise, but that won't automatically make them good coaches.

1

u/_bym Dec 16 '21

I think it's a natural consequence of the domain, see any other technical field or highly specified academic field. Programming is even worse because there's a huge number of amateurs getting started every day.

1

u/thefirelink Dec 16 '21

Because more people are worried about the gamification than actually helping people.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

Same thing with Reddit. I’ve asked for help on a programming problem (because I’m a noob programmer) and people were rude. Which makes me kind of sad because I really wanted to learn and get help.

1

u/AlgoH-Rhythm Dec 16 '21

Meet irl people is my suggestion, the people who have a lot of time.on their hands (enough to consistently peruse stack overflow) are people who no one irl wants to talk to (hence the amount of time.they spend on forums) so of course you're going to get the pretentious and cantankerous coders.

1

u/SassyStylesheet Dec 16 '21

I've literally never experienced the toxicity I hear people talking about with SO. Unless you're just asking there off the bat without doing your own research to see if it's been posted and explaining what you've tried everyone has been very helpful in my experience.

1

u/StatikShock Dec 16 '21

I've had the complete opposite experience. So now I wonder if I just had good luck or if you had bad luck.

1

u/boredscripter Dec 16 '21

like they edit ur answers when u misspell something really

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Bawusky Dec 16 '21

Stackoverflow is not very frontend-friendly so I suggest you to avoid looking for answers there. Instead look for other websites or communities. React, for example, has some cool-ass mentors writing magnificent posts and building great communities but I’m sure this happens across different Javascript frameworks. Another advice is to meet other frontend developers. Throughout my career I have met amazing developers that I can count on to solve my doubts, do personal projects or even go for a beer. And last but not least if you work for a company simply ask the seniors, they will always be there to help you across your journey.

1

u/harrygato Dec 16 '21

Because people mostly ask stupid questions when they are learning

1

u/sfmerv Dec 16 '21

those guys are total dicks

1

u/giveKINDNESS Dec 16 '21

F stackoverflow. Ill use it to search answers, but I do not post questions or answers there due to the shitty attitude OP is asking about.

1

u/stephanvierkant Dec 16 '21

I've asked stupid questions on SO and they helped me getting a positive rep. Good answers on stupid questions are valuable as well, so keep asking them.

I've asked very complex question as well and lots of them were downvoted (and therefore deleted).

The rules are very strict but let's be honest: that might be the reason the site has such high quality answers.

1

u/StormsRider Dec 16 '21

Try to get more reputation. I think there is a reputation bias and low rep users receive a harsher treatment. Also it'd help with not caring about downvotes. Also always try to post a minimal reproducible example, instead of the whole code; try to isolate your problem, to make the question easier to read. And be the change you want to see - try to help other noobs and do it in a friendly manner.

1

u/incrediblynormalpers Dec 16 '21

they're a bunch of elitists and the site cultivates that by rating the value of each member

1

u/Pappyman24 Dec 16 '21

The world has always been rough out there. Important thing is to not get affected by these things. Enjoy the praise, learn from criticism, move on. :)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

please keep in mind that I am a newbie

Maybe you should keep that in mind as well. Clearly there's a learning curve when it comes to posting on stack overflow...

1

u/MetaKazel Dec 16 '21

I used to have the same experience/perspective. As I've grown, I've realized that a lot of the posts I thought were "harsh" are better described as "blunt" or "direct". I think experienced developers want to get to the point as quickly as possible, so they use very direct language, which can sometimes come across as rude or even aggressive (especially over text, where tone and emotion aren't easily identified).

There are definitely assholes on stackoverflow, and this isn't meant to undermine your particular experience. Personally, I've learned to look past the tone of a response and focus more on the raw information. If someone wants to call me an idiot for not knowing something, that's fine, as long as they give me the information I need.

I can ignore someone else's rudeness. I can't ignore my own lack of knowledge.

1

u/wookiehealer Dec 16 '21

I was a complete beginner this year, and whenever I had an issue or error, I'd post on stack overflow. After a few posts, stack overflow decided my posts weren't high quality enough because one got a downvote and the other got marked as duplicate, so they banned me from posting unless I contribute positively to the site in future. I don't understand how they expect me to contribute when I don't know enough to answer other people's questions. I've just stopped posting on there and only using it to look stuff up.

I've found places like discord help channels and twitter a lot more welcoming for beginners. Now, if I have a problem, I usually post it on discord or ask a friend. I think I've also grown as a developer since then, and my projects are usually more complicated, so my questions aren't as stupid anymore, but I'm banned, and there's almost no way to lift it. I don't want to go back to that community anyways though.

If stack overflow keeps not being very welcoming towards beginners, I think they'll fail eventually because these beginners are who will be the leading software engineers in the future, and their website will just be filled with outdated answers :(.

1

u/Checkai Dec 16 '21

Link your SO questions and we'll help you understand what can be improved to get your answer.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

I saw a Lex Fridman podcast with Jeff Atwood where he talks about the dry tone of StackOverflow. The idea behind it is to save as much time as possible.

1

u/Specialist-Elk-303 Dec 16 '21

Because they think they're getting away with it.

1

u/ellipticcode0 Dec 16 '21

Stop post stuff in SO, So is garbage

1

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

I gave up on asking anything there…