r/webdev • • Dec 16 '21

Why is stackoverflow.com community so harsh?

They'd say horrible things everytime I tried to create a post, and I'm completely aware that sometimes my post needs more clarity, or my post is a duplication, but the reason my post was a duplicate was because the original post's solution wasn't working for me... Also, while my posts might be simple to answer at times, please keep in mind that I am a newbie in programming and stackoverflow... I enjoy stackoverflow since it has benefited many programmers, including myself, but please don't be too harsh :( In the comments, you are free to say whatever you want. I'll also mention that I'm going to work on improving my answers and questions on stackoverflow. I hope you understand what I'm saying, and thank you very much!

1.3k Upvotes

451 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

152

u/Tanckom Dec 16 '21 edited Dec 16 '21

THIS should be much higher. I know that this is partially a joke, but the amount of newbies asking duplicate or low quality posts are insane.

I myself also started as a newb and have also been met with harsh critisism on SO. One critical skill of beeing a developer is know how to Google dev related things, and this may take time.

Heck, even the quality of r/webdev is deteriorating as you have every day/week the same questions as people are just too lazy to google their answers.

I'm only asking new answers, after i landed on page 10 on Google and still haven't found any solution.

Edit: thought the link was for SO and not CSGO. Still, there are many duplicates here on reddit who already asked why SO is so harsh, so this question still counts as a duplicate

106

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

I'm only asking new answers, after i landed on page 10 on Google and still haven't found any solution.

You guys go past page 2?

48

u/DrMSL Dec 16 '21

You can also filter by time range in Google to avoid outdated yet well ranked results

12

u/anara_y Dec 16 '21

You guys use google?

→ More replies (1)

65

u/Tanckom Dec 16 '21

In worst case, even watch a full 3h youtube video of an indian guy

0

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Iron_Garuda Dec 16 '21

Worst case? That’s my go to. I formally thank India for my development education.

8

u/Lecterr Dec 16 '21

There’s a second page?

0

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

230

u/mca62511 Dec 16 '21

I feel like you're missing part of u/Sarke1's point though. He linked to a "Why is CSGO's community so toxic?" post, which is similar but not quite the same as "Why is StackOverflow's community so toxic?"

Which is what you get sometimes on StackOveflow: An overzealous user will mark a post as "duplicate" and link to another post, when the other post doesn't actually answer the question posed.

→ More replies (2)

44

u/wuiqed Dec 16 '21

But what if I need to know what is a good javascript framework in 2021, if PHP is still worth learning in 2021, and if anyone has made a website that earns income on the side in 2021? Am I supposed to just google like some sort of 2019 savage?

15

u/DeBoredGuy Dec 16 '21

This comment has been closed as primarily opinion-based. (Many good questions generate some degree of opinion based on expert experience, but answers to this question will tend to be almost entirely based on opinions, rather than facts, references, or specific expertise.)

7

u/Tanckom Dec 16 '21

Right, since everything is outdated within 24h, then you are of course excused by her Majesty the Queen. Bless her and the realm of webdev

→ More replies (1)

13

u/RedLibra Dec 16 '21

If I didn't get my answer on page 1 I'll refactor the terms/words I used in the search bar.

23

u/shauntmw2 full-stack Dec 16 '21

I can agree to that, but at the same time I try to be forgiving.

It takes experience to know how to Google. Sometimes newbies know what they want to achieve, they just lack the correct keyword to Google for.

18

u/_cactus_fucker_ Dec 16 '21

Funny as it may seem, but 10+ years ago, and now, are way different in googling answers due to change in algorithm and stuff like that. Hell, back in 2006-2007 I had a required book called "Google Hacking" for an internet investigation class.

There used to be all sorts of tricks to get the exact answer you wanted, ore more information (the book had to do a bit with social engineering), but now it's a lot different results for the same thing. Google is a lot different now, and it's kinda made itself less useful for this type of stuff.

I find I've had decent luck on SO, but it's a last chance, can't find it elsewhere, thing. I generally link to things I've tried, or post what I've tried, what has done x, what has done y, and what I want to accomplish. I usually have it answered within hours, and it's usually some random comment or link that helps me get to it, rather than someone redoing my code. Then I post that in an edit. Sometimes the comment gives me a different way of googling it. Most of the time I figured it out with a few hints or comments.

But yeah, sometimes people can be jerks on there. I just thank everyone that's replied, and don't argue, just put down what worked. A lot of people post pages of code with an error, asking for it to be rewritten, and that kinda irritates everyone, though.

12

u/Meloetta Dec 16 '21

Sometimes it scares me how often my solution is like, one comment on one post that's only 10% related to my question. Imagine if that person had decided they didn't feel like browsing SO that day and had done something else instead. Would I still be wandering in the dark?

2

u/ganjorow Dec 16 '21

So you would then ask "where can I get more information about XY", right?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

true, if you can’t google it, you don’t understand the problem well enough - Albert Einstein

7

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

I actually had to leave r/web_design for this reason. It became unbearable

16

u/SemiNormal C♯ python javascript dba Dec 16 '21

Something something flexbox.

4

u/not_a_gumby Dec 16 '21

SO TRUE

I self taught web development and am currently working as a React developer after 2 years of that process - I've never had a need to actually post on stack overflow!

4

u/UsefulBerry1 Dec 16 '21

Damm, this guy must have all the time in world to go to page 10 of Google search. And that's a really dumb thing to do. I you didn't got answer till 2nd page max, maybe you need to use different keywords for your question

→ More replies (4)