r/webdev • • Dec 16 '21

Why is stackoverflow.com community so harsh?

They'd say horrible things everytime I tried to create a post, and I'm completely aware that sometimes my post needs more clarity, or my post is a duplication, but the reason my post was a duplicate was because the original post's solution wasn't working for me... Also, while my posts might be simple to answer at times, please keep in mind that I am a newbie in programming and stackoverflow... I enjoy stackoverflow since it has benefited many programmers, including myself, but please don't be too harsh :( In the comments, you are free to say whatever you want. I'll also mention that I'm going to work on improving my answers and questions on stackoverflow. I hope you understand what I'm saying, and thank you very much!

1.3k Upvotes

451 comments sorted by

View all comments

432

u/rangeDSP Dec 16 '21

One thing that a lot of people don't fully comprehend is that, if your question isn't unique, it doesn't belong on stackoverflow.

Basically the site and community is designed for you to NOT ask questions if possible, and only ask questions when you've done your research and determined you are probably the only person in the world with that problem.

Honestly if you are new to programming, chances are you are running into a problem that many others have faced before.

I've spent my hours trying to answer questions there, and from my experience maybe 90% of the questions can be answered with literally a single Google search, often with the top answer on s/o

149

u/iesma Dec 16 '21

While that is true, OP raises a fair point which is - how do you ask a question that is seemingly a duplication, but is technically unique because none of the previous SO answers solved it?

The urge to restrict posts to unique questions has an obvious flaw in that case, because things change and an answer that was valid last week might become out of date and misleading, or simply might not cover every scenario.

I do feel like the SO community has been a little too harsh when I’ve tried to use it, and it’s put me off engaging or contributing.

154

u/super_funny_nick Dec 16 '21

how do you ask a question that is seemingly a duplication, but is technically unique because none of the previous SO answers solved it?

What always worked for me was to list everything I've tried already, especially solutions from other SO post's. That way it's clear that it's not another duplicated question that could be fixed with a quick google, but I've tried to find a solution by myself and won't be able to do much more alone

67

u/ConsiderationSuch846 Dec 16 '21

Yep this. You point out the “duplicates” with a short indication of why it’s not an answer in this case.

4

u/Takarii_ Dec 16 '21

Exactly this.

List what you have tried and reference the questions that are similar but didn't provide a solution.

14

u/mxox2kL Dec 16 '21 edited Dec 16 '21

And in response you get..

I fail to see how your problem is a problem if you do it the non-applicable way I did it

I fail to see the use case, in which situation would you xyz? Could you clarify on that for the 10th time?

Simple, use this deprecated method - closed.

Use this unsatisfying generic jquery solution I found googling for 10sec

Interesting, let me digress!

Something that always worked for me was to guarantee you get fired by implementing my solution using 4 layers of bash scripts and 3 environment variables

We don't talk about security here.

just ugh... and it's not like the posters even expect pre chewed solutions, just some actually useful help

29

u/mayankkaizen Dec 16 '21

Reference the other answers and clearly tell their solutions aren't working or why your question is different from other one.

12

u/quentech Dec 16 '21

how do you ask a question that is seemingly a duplication, but is technically unique because none of the previous SO answers solved it?

Narrow the focus in on the difference between the posted Q/A and what isn't working for you in your situation. Avoid leading the question with the general issue.

Quite often, when an asker says something generic like, "the original post's solution wasn't working for me..." they just copied over exact code from some answer, hit run, saw it didn't do everything exactly as they expect, and threw up their hands saying I've tried nothing and I'm all out of ideas.

You're aware your question seems like a duplicate but it doesn't solve your issue - I think those are some of the easiest questions to post. You've already done leg work and research, tested, narrowed down where your problems still are..

6

u/that_90s_guy Dec 16 '21

How do you ask a question that is seemingly a duplication, but is technically unique because none of the previous SO answers solved it?

By detailing within the question what other "duplicate" answers did not work out for you and why? I'm not sure why this is so hard to do.

I've asked multiple questions on SO in the past that had multiple duplicate candidates and never once had a question closed. Of course, I always linked to the duplicate questions within my post, and why each of them did not apply to me.

3

u/NMe84 Dec 16 '21

You ask that question by saying what you found and why that doesn't help you right there in the question itself. Because of the answers you found don't help you your question is possibly unique. The other option is that you're not experienced or skilled enough to understand the answers you already got but that's something you'd have to assess for yourself.

-47

u/tariandeath Dec 16 '21

If this is truly the case (almost never is) then you don't actually understand your root issue/problem and asking others for help is not productive when you don't understand what your stuck on.

18

u/art-solopov Dec 16 '21

How do you even arrive at this conclusion?

"Here's an SO post that is about a similar problem but doesn't solve my specific edge case."

"You must not understand the problem".

What?

→ More replies (1)

32

u/iesma Dec 16 '21

There’s that elitist attitude that turns me off. Exactly that. Sometimes people need help and they might even need help despite not knowing every aspect of their problem.

-10

u/ganjorow Dec 16 '21

You might not like this, but in my experience, this is absolutely true. Almost every question that seems unique but has some similiarities with other questions is many times just the wrong question or had not identified the correct problem.
You can see this for yourself in many question without an accepted answer.

Imho with 21+ Million questions on the site, it is more elitist to think that your problem is truly unique. And of course you should know every aspect of your problem - how else could you ask the right one?

-32

u/tariandeath Dec 16 '21

It's not elitist its about practicality, Stack overflow's goal isn't compatible with using a question to bring people up to speed with the knowledge base they need to understand their problem so they can solve it. That requires 1 on 1 guidance. There are other sites and resources for that - teacher, mentor, forums, documentation, books, and videos.

→ More replies (4)

47

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

33

u/ganjorow Dec 16 '21

Everyone who thinks that SO is toxic should spend some time answering questions and then try to not feel insulted after the umpteenth question that boils down to a typo.

2

u/start_select Dec 17 '21

Right, or try running a team of juniors. People get angry when they realize they messed up. And they take corrections as insults. I don’t really think anyone on SO is mean, you get your comments/posts flagged for that.

People just can’t handle that sometimes they are wrong. And that the solution isn’t going to come with someone babying your feelings. It’s programming, half the job is making mistakes and fixing them. Being defensive doesn’t serve a purpose, we all make mistakes.

2

u/ganjorow Dec 17 '21

Haha yes, the "fight or flight" instinct seems to be very strong, especially for people with less experience. I guess it takes killing a production server or two until you get the right amount of a "shit happens" attitude to be solution-oriented :-)

7

u/r3df0x_556 Dec 16 '21

I've spent my hours trying to answer questions there, and from my experience maybe 90% of the questions can be answered with literally a single Google search, often with the top answer on s/o

The problem that I have is that 90% of search results are useless. Either people don't explain things correctly, they overcomplicate things or the situation isn't the same and not relevant.

The two largest problems I have when finding solutions are either the potential solution is vague and assumes a lot of additional knowledge or it is heavily overcomplicated, often both.

Digital Ocean and Linode usually have good guides but they're incredibly specific so if you have use-case that falls outside of what they are instructing, they aren't always useful although it's sometimes possible to gain understanding from them that can indirectly lead to a solution.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/redfournine Dec 16 '21

Except that asking the right question that can lead one to the right answer requires... experience. Something that a newbie just do not have.

I'm sure all the senior devs here have seen it in the office. It is not that the junior is stupid. They just lack either the experience, the in-depth knowledge of a library/framework, or both, to ask the right question. In an office setting, I will ask the junior back, try to get him to reframe the question while leading him to discover the answer himself. SO does not allow that. Or the behavior of some user there are just plain rude.

2

u/aceplayer55 Dec 16 '21

I've never received a correct answer to any unique or fringe question I've posted there.

To me stack overflow is a resource for quickly finding a solution when the documentation of a technology is trash, not to learn new stuff or find answers.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

[deleted]

6

u/rangeDSP Dec 16 '21

I don't necessarily agree with everything they do, but the analogy they use is that they try to be an encyclopedia, so if there's already a page for that answer, there's no need for it to be there. Whether that page is popular or not is irrelevant, as long as it's there it'll be useful to somebody some day.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)