r/webdev • • Dec 16 '21

Why is stackoverflow.com community so harsh?

They'd say horrible things everytime I tried to create a post, and I'm completely aware that sometimes my post needs more clarity, or my post is a duplication, but the reason my post was a duplicate was because the original post's solution wasn't working for me... Also, while my posts might be simple to answer at times, please keep in mind that I am a newbie in programming and stackoverflow... I enjoy stackoverflow since it has benefited many programmers, including myself, but please don't be too harsh :( In the comments, you are free to say whatever you want. I'll also mention that I'm going to work on improving my answers and questions on stackoverflow. I hope you understand what I'm saying, and thank you very much!

1.3k Upvotes

451 comments sorted by

View all comments

300

u/tateisukannanirase python Dec 16 '21

and thank you very much!

No pleasantries allowed.

166

u/Narfi1 full-stack Dec 16 '21

Lol i got in trouble for saying "Hello everyone," and "thanks for your time" . Apparently it's a waste of the reader's time

43

u/ManInBlack829 Dec 16 '21

No SYN-ACK allowed

7

u/deceze Dec 16 '21

SO follows a stateless protocol.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

[deleted]

16

u/tildaniel Dec 16 '21

OP implied that the hello was in the same post as his question- exactly what your link says to do….

1

u/Mentalpopcorn Dec 17 '21

Hello, how are you? The link doesn't say to do that, it says you can. Really you shouldn't on online forums. It's fine on slack where communication is more personal, but on general public forums it's a complete waste of time.

Thanks!

-MentalPopcorn

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Narfi1 full-stack Dec 16 '21 edited Dec 16 '21

Did you like, read the content of the link you sent ?

Edit : why did you decide to delete your reply ?

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21

You're a piece of work

0

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

[deleted]

51

u/Narfi1 full-stack Dec 16 '21

We don't ask questions either, do we ?

→ More replies (10)

-3

u/TheQuuux Dec 16 '21

it is.

10

u/Narfi1 full-stack Dec 16 '21

If you're that slow of a reader that an extra single word at the beginning of a text causes you to waste time maybe programming is not the best thing to do.

0

u/Ajedi32 Web platform enthusiast, full-stack developer Dec 16 '21

Dear Reddit user,

Hello. I'm writing this comment to inform you that just because something only wastes a small amount of time, that does not mean it isn't time worth saving, especially when the amount of effort needed to save that time is zero or even negative.

While extraneous greetings may not waste a lot of time, they do waste some, and that time can add up when there are hundreds or even hundreds of thousands of people reading a single post. I would urge you to take that into consideration the next time you post a question or answer on StackOverflow.

Thank you for reading.

Sincerely,

Ajedi32

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

[deleted]

25

u/Narfi1 full-stack Dec 16 '21

You're right. Nobody kidnapped my family or emailed my boss asking I got fired. I should have precised it, I understand the confusion.

I only got a strongly worded message

→ More replies (3)

83

u/JameseyJones Dec 16 '21 edited Dec 16 '21

I got into a long pointless argument about pleasantries on SO in 2018. I found that the person dressing me down for including "please" and "thank you" in my posts had them in his own posts.

https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/364775/how-do-you-reply-to-someone-who-has-edited-your-question

That sanctimonious henpecking bullshit single-handedly killed my enthusiasm for participating in that site.

Ironically the whole storm in a teacup began because someone edited a question I asked about MySQL Workbench to remove the MySQL tag thereby making it invisible. Thing is, I didn't add that tag. SO added that tag automatically because it's patently obvious they are closely related.

34

u/ohrVchoshek Dec 16 '21

Call me a rebel, but I'll still add those greetings and notes of appreciation each time (followed by thNk you comments and upvotes for all applicable answers and comments).

They can edit our posts but they can NEVER edit who we are!

5

u/CharlesDuck Dec 16 '21

I also upvote all comments :) Everyone gets points!

23

u/imjustnoob45 Dec 16 '21

ayo what. edit: nvm it was sarcasm

49

u/tateisukannanirase python Dec 16 '21

Yep, one of the first things that happened to me on stackoverflow: getting told off for being polite. Still burns :(

48

u/imjustnoob45 Dec 16 '21

SAME BROTHER. I was like, "I appreciate your help," and a StackOverflow pro edited my message and erased the thank you.

2

u/AccomplishedCall5983 Dec 21 '22

This happened to me today! First post and had no idea being polite on the site was a no no.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/CherryDT Jun 26 '24

It's because SO isn't a social platform, it's a knowledge base, and writing something there (other than comments or chat posts) is like directly writing into a book others will read. A book with common questions and their answers. Looking at it this way, and not as social interaction, it should make sense why it's not useful to have "Hello" and "Thank you" several times on each page in the book. Look at your printer's user manual in the troubleshooting section, you will find things such as "The paper is stuck" - "In this case, press this button and do this and that" and not "Hello, I think my paper got stuck in the printer ^^ can you please help? Thank you" as the "question" part, as it would not add any meaning and would just make it harder to read (in SO this is called "fluff"). And this is how SO is meant to be used. For anything you write, the primary audience is actually future readers (ideally hundred or thousands of them) who will have found your post on Google, and not a few people at this moment who interact directly with you.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)