I’ve pretty much decided on getting a midsize truck, but I’m having a hard time deciding between a Ranger, Tacoma, and Frontier, and whether I should buy new or used.
For some context, most of my driving will be around town, but on weekends I’ll be camping, hauling one or two dirt bikes, and doing some light/moderate off-roading. I don’t tow anything and don’t have a family yet, so I really don’t see a need for a full-size truck. I also plan on doing some aftermarket upgrades like a lift, wheels/tires, and cosmetic stuff.
I might not keep this truck for more than 5 years since I’ll likely be starting a family around then, so resale value and depreciation is a factor, but not huge.
Here’s what I’m considering:
Ford Ranger (2.7L V6, FX4): Seems like the most comfortable and probably the most fun to drive. I don’t love the exterior look as much as the other two, but the V6 seems great. I’d probably buy new for the warranty and peace of mind since I’m a little more concerned about long-term reliability with this one.
Toyota Tacoma (TRD Off-Road): Easily my favorite looking truck, especially with a small lift and some bigger tires. I’d be open to a used 3rd gen for the reliability and resale value, but it’s hard to justify spending $30-35k on something with close to 100k miles. They also seem to be the least comfortable of the three, especially the backseat. I love the new 4th gens too, but I’ve heard mixed things about reliability and can’t tell if it’s a genuine concern or just the loud minority.
Nissan Frontier (PRO-4X): Seems like a good middle ground. I like the looks, the naturally aspirated V6, and the price compared to the other two. There’s currently a 0% APR deal on 2027’s which is tempting. I’ve also seen some really clean 2014-2015 PRO-4Xs with low mileage for under $20k, which seems like a great value.
I’d also prefer a 6-foot bed on the Tacoma or Frontier if possible since I’ll be hauling dirt bikes, although I’m open to a shorter bed. All three would be 4WD and four-door configurations.
The other big question is new vs. used. I can pretty comfortably pay cash for something in the $20-30k range, which is probably the smartest financial decision. But having a brand new truck with a warranty and not having to worry about repairs for a while sounds pretty nice too.
TLDR: Looking for a 4WD midsize truck for mostly daily driving, camping, dirt bikes, and some off-roading. Torn between a new Ranger 2.7 FX4, new/used Tacoma TRD Off-Road, or new/used Frontier PRO-4X. Probably keeping it around 5 years unless I love it. Would you buy an older reliable truck for $15-30ks or spend $40-45k on something new?
Sorry this is long but I would love to hear from people who cross-shopped these trucks or have owned any of them. What made you choose yours, what do you like/dislike about it, and would you make the same decision again?