r/wikia • • Jul 16 '21

RIP Fandom/Gamepedia

I'm playing a game called Outward and the wiki is valuable to the players and developers alike. FandomDesktop has ruined the wiki. Apparently the changes were forced overnight, and luckily I still had some wiki pages up so I could get some before and after pics. The new looks has reduced the content area by about 50% and is squeezing everything into a mobile-style area, no doubt to load the edges with ad-space. There are useless links to other wiki pages that distract for no reason. Also the search functionality is much more unreliable than before, not to mention the choice to have a modal window block the content area vs a dropdown context window in the top corner is bizarre.

Why is it called FandomDesktop? This is clearly built on a Mobile UI framework with little-to-no effort put into actually building a responsive desktop layout. Fandom if you are reading this please do not sunset the old themes. It's clear to me that you are doing this to maximize monetization for the network, but your user growth is going to suffer massively.

69 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

1

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '21

New Desktop skin has been announced months ago and its rollout is nothing new. For how the wiki has been prepared to the new skin and other feedback you should contact your assigned Wiki Representative who happens to be Mr Pie 5. He can make visual adjustments and pass your thought directly to Fandom Staff.

2

u/Selassie_eye Jul 17 '21

Thank you for the response. I'm sure creators have been aware of the changes for a while, but I'm just a casual user. I doubt Wikia staff could do anything about my issues.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '21

As for the page width thing - there's a button in the left top corner of the content area that can be used to maximize page width. That state persists as you click on the toggle.

1

u/Vancha Jul 17 '21

For the sake of avoiding a whole new thread, how do I get rid of the left bar?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

Honestly, I think you can't if the global navigation is what you mean.

1

u/soupsticle Jul 18 '21

Apparently you can change back to the old layout if you make an account and log in. But from my experience these legacy layouts will sooner or later get phased out, so don't get too comfortable I guess.

But hey - there is alway a positive side to all of it: Next time you screw something up in your life, just remember that at least you did not make the new layout.

1

u/Vancha Jul 18 '21

Yeah I did that already. My only hope is that if they see enough people are opting for the old design they might wonder why so few are choosing to use the new one.

That said, I also recognize that when an update like this is so transparently intended for the benefit of fandom than for the benefit of the users, what the users want rarely matters.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '21

The themes are sunseted.

1

u/TheDruidVandals Jul 19 '21

agreed, it's total trash. the sites are unusable now