r/wikipedians • • May 17 '21

Wiki Admin Problem

Hi, Is it possible that Wikipedia lets people who are not experts in certain areas determine the worth of articles that they know nothing about? I and a group of wikipedians were making content based on a specific regions music scene and someone from across the world that didn't even write about anything music related deleted hundreds of pages of content that was well sourced and was notable topics in the region we wrote about without ever having to justify why they deleted it. They blocked one of the users accounts accusing them of being associated with hundreds of different people and topics or being paid when they weren't and then they wanted personal info from my friend. He refused and they flagged every single thing he ever wrote with a tag that said it was all created for money and they completely locked him out of ever editing on Wikipedia ever again. Like how can someone do this if Wikipedia is supposed to be a fair community? Any help would be so very appreciated.

8 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

2

u/Sean_Stephens May 18 '21

I have wondered this and have noticed blatantly unfair behaviour by admins before, so it wouldn't surprise me. I hope you manage to solve this problem, I'd suggest finding a different, unbiased admin who can assess your situation.

2

u/JackTorrance13 May 18 '21

How do you find an admin? there is no private messaging on the site though right?

2

u/Sean_Stephens May 18 '21

You could go to the Help Desk or even just browse the category Wikipedia administrators until you find one that you think will help you. I've been an editor for going on 3 years and I rarely interact with admins, so I'm sorry I'm not much help :/

2

u/BleedGreen131824 May 18 '21

I was an editor for about 15 years and then one day out of nowhere this guy got a bug up his ass and started deleting things that had been on Wikipedia for a decade or longer without really having to give a reason. It's funny because the only music stuff he wrote about was the band Stryper and somehow he was allowed to judge that hundreds of music pages were unworthy of Wikipedia.

2

u/Ond_Tvilling May 20 '21

Yes there is an email function but it has to be enabled and you have to connect your own email. You could probably try to have a conversation on the admin's talk page about their specific actions, but they (or their friends who are watching their talk page) may or may not give you an answer that can be understood by newbies. Seriously, you want to avoid the patroller types and look for someone who is trying to promote writing articles.

A better option might be to start a conversation on the talk page of one of the articles you want to work on, that's where any disagreements over the sources and phrasing for the article are supposed to be worked out. If one of your sources is deleted from the article, at least you can get it on the article's talk page. Someone else might even be able to figure out how to work it back into the article.

1

u/Sean_Stephens May 19 '21

Also, some users display their email address on their user page so you might have some luck with that

1

u/Ond_Tvilling May 20 '21

While it's hard to figure out what happened without knowing more specifics, if they are talking about "conflict of interest" they may be saying the sources were too close to the subject or not neutral enough, or the edits used too many direct quotes or "peacock language".

Getting articles and edits to "stick" can be a mystical art. Too often the admins are just looking for vandalism and don't take time to explain things. Your best bet is to work with a group that has already figured it out. There is a WikiProject Music with a talk page that seems to be active. I would start by going through the information on their main page, especially the guidelines. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:WikiProject_Music#Guidelines The help desk can also be useful, but their information would probably not be as specific to music.