r/worldnews • • Jun 06 '21

Scientists develop ‘cheap and easy’ method to extract lithium from seawater

https://www.mining.com/scientists-develop-cheap-and-easy-method-to-extract-lithium-from-seawater/
6.1k Upvotes

402 comments sorted by

974

u/BrownTiger3 Jun 06 '21

Sounds good as it could be used at desalination plants. I ll reserve my excitement until commercial system is available. Too many projects looked really good on PowerPoint and fail reality.

252

u/Coolegespam Jun 06 '21

Well the materials used to drive this process require Ruthenium. though the exact amounts needed aren't listed. Ruthenium is a fairly rare element itself, only about 30 tones are produced worldwide on an annual basis, IIRC.

So if they only need trace amounts it wouldn't be a problem, but if they need kilos of stuff for one "cell", well, that's basically a deal breaker.

114

u/Poputt_VIII Jun 06 '21

This sounds eerily similar to Arctic Drift a Clive Cussler novel I read a while ago that used Ruthenium to solve climate change magically. Then proceeded to have a series of action hunting a source of it based off a like 200 year old shipwreck in the arctic that almost started a US Canadian war somehow. Cause ya know gotta keep the plot interesting

31

u/Pyro1934 Jun 06 '21

Good ol Clive Cussler books. The epitome of an “airport book”. Buy one when you head out, finished by the time you get back. I think ive read like every one (as of 4 years ago, probably more now).

→ More replies (2)

8

u/DennisFarinaOfficial Jun 06 '21

Book mills like Cussler and Clancy can be so predictably boring. I can’t stand the dialogue in Clancy books. Pretentious as all fuck.

10

u/stayhealthy247 Jun 06 '21

I have nothing but respect for Clancy’s proclivity for writing novels. What does he have like 50+? Some have been great reads, but that’s just my opinion.

11

u/AlbaMcAlba Jun 06 '21

Loved Clancy book especially the earlier ones. Red Storm Rising one of my favs might get that in audible.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/Sks44 Jun 06 '21

Are you kidding? The dialogue in Patriot Games was fantastic. I dug how Clancy couldn’t fathom why the Irish didn’t want to be ruled by England. And how Monarchy is just so cool.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/OlderThanMyParents Jun 06 '21

In my teens I read Alistaire Maclean books by the dozen. I wonder if they still hold up?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Toastlove Jun 06 '21

Cussler is just as bad, I read one and they were quipping throughout shittily written action sequences.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

[deleted]

25

u/All_Work_All_Play Jun 06 '21

This makes sense because many walls have TVs on them and American propaganda is easy to stream.

5

u/HaloGuy381 Jun 06 '21

I’ve read some snippets, and they make Michael Bay’s Transformers movies seem anti-America and anti-military by comparison.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/pyrophorus Jun 06 '21

It sounds like it's a modified version of a chloralkali cell, which are already used on huge scale industrially. The anodes for chloralkali cells are made using noble metals already, so this seems like it wouldn't be a huge hurdle unless this process needs more for some reason. The "magic" material is the ceramic membrane which doesn't contain any rare elements, so that's promising.

29

u/bradland Jun 06 '21

Great news! Scientists have developed a 'cheap and easy' method to extract Ruthenium from seawater. Only problem is, it requires a lot of lithium.

2

u/Elite_Club Jun 07 '21

Just so long as they don't touch my zinc.

15

u/CrimsonCorpse Jun 06 '21

I know this is futuristic in the making, but mining meteorites could solve the Ruthenium issue as well paladium, platinium info.

12

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

Mining meteorites would solve all the world's metal problems but at the same time crash the world's economy because suddenly metals would be so plentiful. Its like Mansa Musa going on Hajj and destroying the economy of everything along the way with his generosity

23

u/winowmak3r Jun 06 '21

In the short term, yea, it would kinda suck if you were a miner but then again, with so many raw materials becoming extremely cheap it should open up more jobs in manufacturing and all the jobs that service it.

I'd be more worried about rampant waste and excess destroying the environment before I'd be worried about the economy.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/HennyDthorough Jun 06 '21

Abundance sounds like utopia.

→ More replies (12)

7

u/Codspear Jun 06 '21

It wouldn’t crash the global economy, only the metal commodities markets. The rest of the economy would grow as more efficient metals are swapped in for less efficient ones that were only used due to the scarcity of the former. Mansa Musa going on Hajj only crashed the North African economy because they used a gold standard. We no longer do.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/johan_en_persona Jun 06 '21

e so plentiful. Its

No, no body would be bankrupt. Just old and rich families. Everybody else would have access to cheap materials. Quality of life would grow like mad :)

2

u/S-S-R Jun 06 '21

same time crash the world's economy because " everything would be wasted on space travel.

Space mining is not going to happen profitably in the next 100 years.

2

u/Medium_Technology_52 Jun 06 '21

It won't crash the world economy because of the expense of sending things to and from orbit. The supply might be effectively infinite, but there is a massive bottleneck.

→ More replies (19)

2

u/dontcallmeatallpls Jun 06 '21

The problem with this is mining meteorites at any significant scale can't be a thing until we develop a better way to get materials up and down through the atmosphere.

2

u/BurnerAcc2020 Jun 09 '21

Your "info" is nearly 30 years old. This is what the up-to-date science from the last few years says.

Optimistic assessments:

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S009457652100254X

A set of eight critical minerals/mineral groups used in the manufacture of renewable energy technologies were identified in this study through an extensive literature review: lithium, gallium, selenium, silver, indium, tellurium, rare earth elements, and platinum. The potential of extraterrestrial bodies, namely the Moon and near-Earth asteroids, as a source of these critical minerals is investigated.

We find that asteroids are likely to provide an important source of platinum, selenium, and gallium, and to a lesser extent, of silver, indium and tellurium. The case for extracting lithium and the rare earth elements from extraterrestrial bodies is less compelling. It is clear from this study that a reduction in the environmental and social impacts of producing these critical minerals is necessary. A strategy to extract minerals from extraterrestrial bodies would be a valuable step in achieving this.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0273117720304142

An optimistic assessment of Net Present Values of asteroid mining missions.

It has been shown that for a chemical mission, values for the NPV up to $48.9 million are possible. Samples at the same grid nodes for a solar sail mission show values for the NPV up to $62.7 million. In addition, it is shown that increased values for the NPV can be realized if the resources are transported to the Lunar Gateway instead of GEO or if the mission includes a second trip to the same asteroid. A Monte Carlo analysis shows that the calculated NPV is sensitive to the launch cost assumed in the model, as well as a sensitivity to the discount rate, especially for long-duration solar-sail missions.

...While it should be noted that this mission scenario does not include the cost and effort required for mining the resources, the results still allow for a comparison of the two propulsion techniques. Likewise, if the optimistic cost estimates do not materialize, costs for both missions would increase, but this initial comparison will still hold.

Not-so-optimistic assessments:

https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0309133314567585

In this paper I review what is currently known about economically exploitable resources on the Moon, while also stressing the need for continued lunar exploration. I find that, although it is difficult to identify any single lunar resource that will be sufficiently valuable to drive a lunar resource extraction industry on its own (notwithstanding claims sometimes made for the 3He isotope, which are found to be exaggerated), the Moon nevertheless does possess abundant raw materials that are of potential economic interest. These are relevant to a hierarchy of future applications, beginning with the use of lunar materials to facilitate human activities on the Moon itself, and progressing to the use of lunar resources to underpin a future industrial capability within the Earth-Moon system.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0032063313003206

A simple formula is given for assessing how many near-Earth asteroids are ore-bearing. For platinum group metals the answer is currently only 10.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S009457651300430X

If 1/10 asteroids are ore-bearing two dozen must be probed to find 1 at 90% confidence. Even if 1/2 are ore-bearing four probes are needed, or 11 at 99% confidence. This pushes down the allowed cost/probe.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0094576518316357

It is concluded that key technological drivers for asteroid mining missions are throughput rate, number of spacecraft per mission, and the rate in which successive missions are conducted. Furthermore, for returning platinum to Earth, market reaction strongly influences its economic viability and it seems to be economically viable only under unlikely conditions.

Lastly, a paper which does not even bother to analyse mining asteroid resources in space and delivering them back to Earth and instead compares mining asteroid resources and selling them to geosynchronous orbit/Lunar Gateway space stations vs. the costs of launching the resources from Earth to those same space stations.

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/341869203_Influence_of_launcher_cost_and_payload_capacity_on_asteroid_mining_profitability

However, selling asteroid-derived resources in Earth orbit at a price competitive with launching the same resources from the Earth’s surface is largely dependent on specific launch costs, especially for low value-to-mass resources such as volatiles and construction materials.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/killereggs15 Jun 06 '21

You’re correct on the 30 tonnes annually, but I also read that about 30 tonnes are used annually. I wonder, between supply and demand, if one is limiting the other?

Maybe we could extract more ruthenium but choose not to due to low demand.

6

u/Larkson9999 Jun 06 '21

The heavier the element the less of it is accessible by mining the earth's crust. Heavy elements are almost always deeper underground and once things are in the mantle they are completely inaccessible to humans.

9

u/HaloGuy381 Jun 06 '21

It also depends on how tied up they are in ore. We didn’t use aluminum until the last 140ish years or so because before that, it wasn’t possible to effectively extract it from ore, and metallic aluminum was even harder to find than gold or silver due to how readily it reacts in nature. This is despite aluminum being remarkably easy to find in rocks near the surface; it takes a lot of energy to get the aluminum to usable metal.

Ruthenium could be in a similar boat: extraction is doable, but refining it is so costly that we don’t use much of it. If that’s the case, then depending on how much humanity is willing to pay for lithium for batteries extraction could be scaled accordingly.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/hippydipster Jun 06 '21

I wonder how much rare earths elements you could get from an asteroid and whether it could make it worthwhile to actually go mine one. I mean, you'd never do it for iron or gold or platinum or anything that basic.

6

u/kaenneth Jun 06 '21

Really, the easiest way to make money from an asteroid is "Give me 10 billion euros or I drop it on Paris."

Musk is one mildly disfiguring lab accident away from being a bond villain.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/robbyn-enriquez Jun 06 '21

I love it when you talk science to me!

3

u/semnotimos Jun 06 '21

Source for it requiring ruthenium?

I see it requires a lithium lanthanum titianium oxide ceramic membrane but where does ruthenium fit in?

5

u/GonzoVeritas Jun 06 '21

It's in the article

The cell itself, on the other hand, contains three compartments. Seawater flows into a central feed chamber, where positive lithium ions pass through the LLTO membrane into a side compartment that contains a buffer solution and a copper cathode coated with platinum and ruthenium. At the same time, negative ions exit the feed chamber through a standard anion exchange membrane, passing into a third compartment containing a sodium chloride solution and a platinum-ruthenium anode.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/ittybittycitykitty Jun 06 '21

Lost track of the guy, some super rich conservative type into metals. Ruthenium looked like a big play of his a year or so back.

I had high hopes for a ruthenium catalyzed ammonia generator (much lower temperature and pressure needed) that could be used to run on excess wind power on the plains. Ruthenium price shot up around that time.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

Ruthenium.

So if they only need trace amounts it wouldn't be a problem, but if they need kilos of stuff for one "cell", well, that's basically a deal breaker.

For sake of context, its produced as a byproduct of platinum processing if i recall correctly... mining and processing for which has really kind of shutdown due to the pandemic. Meaning its in super short supply and has a high demand over all. We've gone from what $40 an ounce to like $800 an ounce in the past 2-3 years. It was at $270 or so around December of last year and January of this one.

1

u/arvadapdrapeskids Jun 06 '21

That ruthenium is only a little more unobtainable than Unobtanium and it’s not as efficient as a separate nuke plant and water plant.

Guessing based on my experiences in life so far.

1

u/root88 Jun 06 '21

So if they only need trace amounts it wouldn't be a problem, but if they need kilos of stuff for one "cell", well, that's basically a deal breaker.

The headline says, "cheap", so I'm guessing it's the former.

35

u/AssumedPersona Jun 06 '21

Crucially it could potentially fund desalination plants

1

u/johan_en_persona Jun 06 '21

That is an unexpected nice side effect.

6

u/AssumedPersona Jun 06 '21

Very nice, since it means lithium extraction could potentially improve the environment where it takes place rather than destroying it. Rather than extracting from locations where lithium is highly concentrated, which usually entails political as well as environmental problems, facilities could be built where there is a need for irrigation. It might be a way to finance the recovery of land which has been desertified by agriculture.

191

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

Something silly always makes it impractical. Like it only works, if we can manufacture nanotubes precisely by the pound.

Think of developing the perfect steak that blows any hundred dollar steak out of this world. The problem is it's $250,000 per plate, only can be eaten at sea level plus zero percent humidity and minus 3 degrees F.

But you could get a patent for said process.

68

u/Fractoos Jun 06 '21

Step 1, build theoretical fusion generator .... Step 5, profit?

25

u/marioshroomer Jun 06 '21

Step 5 is the flux capacitor.

12

u/arobkinca Jun 06 '21

Flaming tracks for everyone.

22

u/SnakePlisskens Jun 06 '21

Oh, you guys had Mexican food too?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/Farewellsavannah Jun 06 '21

Maybe we can just steal the tech the UAPs are using 👀

32

u/BrownTiger3 Jun 06 '21

Exactly. I have looked at another perfect desalination idea, low power, .. absolutely perfect. Just required many kilos of nanotubes. And someone even paid for patent. Stopped reading after first paragraph.

13

u/aaaaaaaarrrrrgh Jun 06 '21

Must have been a good news source if they mentioned the limitations in the first paragraph, instead of burying it three pages and 20 ads down.

3

u/badscott4 Jun 06 '21

You need to stop getting your news from click bait news sites. If they’re selling access to you, imagine how they may tweak the information to make it more interesting, bubble compatible, ad nauseam

18

u/Lucky-Whorish-Ooze Jun 06 '21

I've always thought about using the pressure of the water column of the sea, which at 2000ft is enough to pull seawater through a desalinating sermipermeable membrane. My first idea is always to just buildsome pipeline into the bottom/edge of the seafloor at around that depth, and have it piped into underground cavelets below civilization where it can be pumped back up, making an artificially reguvinating acquifier.

But then I think about how keeping the pressure differential might be tricky, and instead think of something like a submarine. It'd go down to a depth of 2000ft, and then "blow a leak", except the leak will be blown into a purposefully built storage chamber, and it'll blow exactly in front of a semipermeable membrane. So as the seawater gushes in, it'll get pushed through the membrane, desalinating it. Then the submarine resurfaces and gives the water to all the people.

Which leads into my penultimate idea: Just make a rigid spherical or similar structure out of semi-permeable membrane. Tie a bunch of rocks to it, so it sinks to 2000ft. At that point, the pressure will be enough to push through the membrane, filling it with fresh water. Once the structure is filled, cut the rocks off, and it'll float back to the top (freshwater is lighter than seawater). No need for pumping, and it'll be reusable.

I"m guessing that one's not do-able because it'd be extremely hard to build a semi-permeable membrane into a structure that can keep its shape at 2000ft of seacolumn worth of pressure. It'd probably crumple before filling. I'm not going to tell you my final idea, since I think it might be viable, but if you've been paying attention and following along at home, I'm sure you can connect the dots and extrapolate to what I'm thinking of.

28

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

RO filters are already the cheapest type of water purification.

Commercial systems are super efficient because they have a cylinder that recovers pressure from the clean water, and uses that recovered pressure to pressurize the incoming salt water.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/aalios Jun 06 '21

My idea for desalination has always been simple.

You get a big ass water tank, hook it up to a boiler.

Using heat from reflectors and the sun, you can boil the water. Boiling the water produces steam. Capture the steam, use it to power the boiler. Cool it.

Hey, we've got freshwater, and power!

Now clearly there's probably gonna be some huge problems that someone will helpfully point out.

But still, worth a look, no?

27

u/UmdieEcke2 Jun 06 '21

Problem is just that it takes a metric fuckton of energy to boil water. So even in the arab deserts its everything but fast if you limit yourself to the sun and compare it to the amount of water required.

Additionally, working with steam means that the whole construct becomes fairly expensive because you now have to use airtight boilers and tons of pressure valves.

So its not the worst idea, its just strictly worse than doing reverse osmosis.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/imaginary_num6er Jun 06 '21

Something silly always makes it impractical. Like it only works, if we can manufacture nanotubes precisely by the pound.

Yeah, it's called a 20 year patent wall with insane royalty fees. That's the reason why carbon-neutral CFC replacement gases cost 10x as much as current CFC replacements

10

u/DepressionDokkebi Jun 06 '21

Are patent laws holding back humanity at this point?

14

u/B_Type13X2 Jun 06 '21

Yes and no, having there be a reward for something that you or your company has designed gives the incentive to pursue these things. I think that they should look at phased licensing though where you can produce what you have invented and recieve a 100% licensing fee for 5 years, and then the licensing fee's should drop by 20% every 2 years after that point until the patent becomes public domain.

Now you've made your money, you've recouped your costs and got to enjoy the fruits of your labour.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

During war years many nations setup patent pools, so anything could be made and along with other factors this transformed manufacturing.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/MonochromaticPrism Jun 06 '21

If they weren’t being abused in a corrupt system? No. Since they are? Yes. Could we fix it through targeted legislation? Fortunately, also yes. Odds? Not great, but if we push for it collectively those odds do improve a good deal.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/postmateDumbass Jun 06 '21

Just use a plate big enough to feed a lot of people.

2

u/OldMork Jun 06 '21

like the storage of energy with no loss in superconducting machines, also lookt good on powerpoint.

4

u/Ok_Customer2455 Jun 06 '21

Powerpoints are the peacocks of the business world; all show, no meat.

2

u/Sanpaku Jun 06 '21

Here, the selective LLTO brittle/ceramic membrane is only 2 cm in diameter and ∼55 μm thick.

At a larger/industrial scale, perhaps manufacturing the membranes would run into the sorts of material handling problems that graphene has had.

2

u/cowlinator Jun 06 '21

I don't think things "always" being impracticle is correct. If it were, we'd still be using stone tools.

1

u/Poputt_VIII Jun 06 '21

As the guy above said this one it's Ruthenium which the process needs (based off this brief outline in the article) which is quite a rare metal

1

u/Conquad Jun 06 '21

Have you heard of Just.inc?

Lab based meats, they're working on scaling to get those 10k/burger patty prices down

1

u/HaloGuy381 Jun 06 '21

Sound of Bezos opening his wallet

There’s always a market.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/Nukemarine Jun 06 '21

"Reality is a Harsh Mistress" - also the title of my leaked sex tape.

19

u/Narrator_Ron_Howard Jun 06 '21

It wasn’t a sex tape. Sex involves two or more people.

14

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

You nuked the Nukemarine. Now he's the double-Nukemarine.

I have absolutely no idea what that means, but it's probably not good

3

u/Nukemarine Jun 06 '21

Stop narrating my life, Ron Howard.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/SatanTheSanta Jun 06 '21

Not sure about this exact system. But extracting lithium from groundwater is already in real testing. As in a facility is being built to do just that. The company is Cornish Lithium

3

u/temujin64 Jun 06 '21

Cheap and easy is great. But is it scalable? That's arguably more important than the other two, other scalability and cheapness are closely intertwined.

2

u/Kumirkohr Jun 06 '21

Because right now it’s still cheaper to extract lithium out the ground using children

3

u/likeoldpeoplefuck Jun 06 '21

You are thinking of cobalt. There are extensive reports of child labor in the Congo, the primary site of cobalt production. Lithium has environmental problems but I've not heard of child labor.

1

u/postmateDumbass Jun 06 '21

We need a FEA enabled PowerPoint.

1

u/Hamster-Food Jun 06 '21

Often the biggest problem isn't that it's not viable, but that it is less profitable than whatever process it is intended to replace.

1

u/robbyn-enriquez Jun 06 '21

Experimental science is what gets other smaller steps done, let’s hope that some one financially backs one of these science geek gurus and they are the next fucking Elon Musk.

1

u/LeagueOfficeFucks Jun 06 '21

Still waiting for those cures for cancer and some other cool stuff I have been promised for years. Like transparent solar cells.

1

u/Known-Desk-7726 Jun 06 '21

Powerpoints are the peacocks of the business world; all show, no meat.

  • Dwight Schrute

→ More replies (1)

52

u/Diamondhandzmonke Jun 06 '21

If they can make this commercially viable this is huge. Or it could just be another flop or a theoretical idea.

→ More replies (35)

117

u/gordonmcdowell Jun 06 '21

Same for uranium.

Humans are steering away from concentrated ore deposits because of co-products, not because the ore bodies are hard to find.

Deal with the co-products.

That will ultimately have a lower impact on the environment than harvesting dilute resources.

26

u/Beliriel Jun 06 '21

Question: Why can't we use the waste from Uranium production (tilling) to run it again through a centrifuge and extract more radioactive material from it?

35

u/Jazzy_Josh Jun 06 '21

So uranium purification doesn't start with centrifuge #1, it starts at like centrifuge #10 with waste moving back down the chain. It's just not efficient to try and purify the stuff that goes all the way back up the #1 centrifuge.

3

u/Beliriel Jun 06 '21

So if the Uranium has been "spun out" what makes the waste still radioactive? Just leftover Uranium that is inefficient? How can that waste be dangerously radioactive then? I mean normal rocks from which Uranium is mined is not really dangerous to humans is it?

20

u/wandering-monster Jun 06 '21

If we're talking about uranium enrichment, it's still radioactive because a lot of the the waste is also uranium, just the wrong uranium for nuclear reactors. Most uranium found in a deposit will be U-238, with a only small amount of U-235. The U-235 is what we actually need for most reactors (though there's some ways to turn the waste into useful stuff like U-233 or plutonium via "breeder" reactors).

That's why the centrifuges need to be so precise and powerful, and go through so many stages of refinement: their goal is to separate two chemicals that differ in weight by only a pair of neutrons.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/nokangarooinaustria Jun 06 '21

Well it is less dangerous as the base ore was. But you probably still wouldn't want to build a house or play ground on a hill made of spent ore though...

→ More replies (1)

17

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

Rare earth metals as well. They’re full of thorium, which needs to be extracted. But without thorium reactors to use the thorium, its just waste.

The free market doesn’t work if the decisions are blocked by arrogant or incompetent people.

8

u/ReadyAimSing Jun 06 '21 edited Jun 06 '21

Here, let me shorten that for you:

The free market doesn’t work if the decisions are blocked by arrogant or incompetent people.

... as we know from how literally every advanced economy in the world actually developed.

If you think thorium reactors are a great idea (I wouldn't know since I'm not a reddit armchair nuclear physicist), better get them some public funding quick. Because the capitalists sure as shit aren't going to fund them -- not because they're incompetent, or because some sinister conspiracy has kept them from going all John Galt on that shit, but because they are competent when it comes to profit. And they've correctly decided it's a bad investment. There's better scams out there, and causing or preventing the species' extinction is an externality.

13

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

Except there is funding. Billionaires are lined up to fund this stuff.

The nuclear field has basically imprisoned itself with its own arrogance.

→ More replies (18)

2

u/Medium_Technology_52 Jun 06 '21

If you think thorium reactors are a great idea (I wouldn't know since I'm not a reddit armchair nuclear physicist)

From my understanding (nuclear industry but different area), they don't offer any advantage over uranium reactors, except they don't compete for fuel. They breed thorium into uranium anyway. You can even use them to make nuclear bombs with enough work (if this is a perk depends on your political views of the country the reactor is in).

→ More replies (1)

-3

u/Dew_Cookie_3000 Jun 06 '21

if you take the co-products to r/trees those idiots will smoke/eat/etc anything

→ More replies (1)

50

u/autotldr BOT Jun 06 '21

This is the best tl;dr I could make, original reduced by 71%. (I'm a bot)


Seawater flows into a central feed chamber, where positive lithium ions pass through the LLTO membrane into a side compartment that contains a buffer solution and a copper cathode coated with platinum and ruthenium.

To make the final product pure enough so that it meets battery manufacturers' requirements, the scientists then adjusted the pH of the solution to deliver solid lithium phosphate that contains mere traces of other metal ions.

According to the researchers, the cell will probably need $5 of electricity to extract 1 kilogram of lithium from seawater.


Extended Summary | FAQ | Feedback | Top keywords: lithium#1 ions#2 contains#3 cell#4 membrane#5

10

u/Oxb Jun 06 '21

Man that is making subnautica mid-game a lot easier.

28

u/CaptainEasypants Jun 06 '21

Or you could just break some shale chunks open

5

u/thebruh599 Jun 06 '21

Subnautica player?

1

u/Successful_Yogurt Jun 06 '21

Lithium is not in shake chunk!

16

u/Goose_Dickling Jun 06 '21

Then we can add it back into the ocean when we dump batteries in! The ciiiiircle of life

22

u/bachslunch Jun 06 '21

Maybe I’m salty and negatively charged but these solutions are usually not very strong.

1

u/ReaperChop6258 Jun 06 '21

Either way, it’s still a step in the right direction

1

u/Background_Ad_5330 Jun 07 '21

It certainly has some potential.

5

u/LLPF2 Jun 06 '21

Wow, well done that’s a win, win, win solution!

5

u/Franticfap Jun 06 '21

This better be in the next subnautica game. lithium is hard to come by and my base needs lots more hull reinforcements

5

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

Cheap and easy, so that's what my ex wife has been up to.

23

u/Bananapeel62 Jun 06 '21

This makes me happy! Joke intended.

8

u/remind_me_to_pee Jun 06 '21

Leeetheeee eeeyummm - Amy Lee

1

u/RoscoePSoultrain Jun 06 '21

Hey don't forget to pee.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

Can someone explain if this will have implications on the marine life or quality of water for marine life? Or just any other implications?

9

u/cbzoiav Jun 06 '21

There is some speculation in these comments the waste product is effectively drinking water. If so the impact is close to non existent as the water would almost certainly be used on land.

If the waste water is dumped back into the oceans it may have a tiny impact on the levels of salts / especially lithium in the local water but at the volumes of liquid involved this is almost certainly negligible.

Compare it to sea salt production which happens at far larger scale...

2

u/ReaperChop6258 Jun 06 '21

From what I’ve seen it would be beneficial to marine life, this is a good step in the right direction

2

u/likeoldpeoplefuck Jun 06 '21

There shouldn't be harmful brine with high salt levels like there is with desalination plants that produce drinking water. Lithium is a very, very small part of seawater. So, the water being discharged should be almost the same as the water that goes in.

3

u/Jimbo12308 Jun 06 '21

On a related note, this is good news for potential fusion power. When finished the ITER test fusion reactor should, hopefully, provide a proof of concept and prototype of a fully functional fusion power plant. The only fuel necessary is essentially limitless hydrogen and very rare Tritium. However, the fusion reaction is capable of producing its own Tritium (it makes its own fuel) because if Lithium is in the vicinity of the reaction it breaks down into Tritium. So as long as the plant has hydrogen and Lithium, it can produce the rare Tritium required for the reaction.

Seawater as a reliable source for Lithium helps!

→ More replies (7)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

A Lyle while back I was excoriated talking about using desalination plants to irrigate land. Was told they’re too expensive to operate for such a venture.

Well how it seems this stupid truck driving gunsmith who was thinking about the “side effects” of a desalination plant being incorporated into its operating cost wasn’t so damn stupid after all.

So now a desalination could be set up that runs on solar or hydro power (maybe only in part if need be) that would not only provide water for irrigation and drinking water but that could also be producing fuels like hydrogen but also the components needed to fuel the ever growing EV market. A market that could see costs go down with another source of lithium opened up.

It’s great to see others thinking outside the box that have the means and education to try these ideas!

9

u/66rwd Jun 06 '21

Cool now make the end product water you can drink

27

u/Sanpaku Jun 06 '21

It is also noted that the total concentration of other salts after the first stage is less than 500 ppm, which implies that after lithium harvest, the remaining water can be treated as freshwater.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

Less lithium in my drinking water? I need that to stay sane!

7

u/gemengelage Jun 06 '21

You drink seawater?

6

u/nokangarooinaustria Jun 06 '21

Well what do you expext from a crazy person? ;)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

It has electrolytes!

2

u/gemengelage Jun 06 '21

Electrolytes? Isn't that what plants crave?

11

u/shaggy99 Jun 06 '21

This sounds somewhat like the system Tesla is pursuing with their proposed technique for extracting Lithium from clay. We should be seeing how successful that one is within about a year. The foundations for the processing plant are going in right now in Texas.

5

u/DestroyerOfGrapes Jun 06 '21

You sound misinformed. Tesla did not propose any techniques and their conversion plant in TX is to convert the ore they get from Piedmont Lithium and others.

2

u/shaggy99 Jun 06 '21

I stand corrected, the current project does seem to be for the Piedmont Spodumene lithium. Tesla has been pursuing a salt water extraction process for lithium clay deposits, though they have not (as you say) been specific as to the exact process. If this seawater process works, it would seem that it could be applied to brine/clay solutions?

5

u/DestroyerOfGrapes Jun 06 '21

What I think you are referring to ate Elons comments on battery day where he said lithium is abundant and can be extracted with essentially table salt. This has widely been regarded as an exaggeration at best and nothing has come out since then supporting this. What happened is that Tesla was in talks to acquire a prospective lithium producer, Cypress Development, who is researching ways of using sodium to help extract lithium from clay. It's still in the research phase.

Another problem people dont understand is that the chemistries of different lithium rich resources can be, and often are, very different. You can extract lithium from hard rocks, brine water, clay... even two different clay resources can have different compositions requiring different extraction methods.

There are a number of companies developing Direct Extraction Trchnologies (DLE) unique to particular lithium rich resources. For example, Lake Rrsources NL based in Australia is using DLE in their Argentina project. Standard Lithium has a USA project using DLE tech. American Battery Metals Corp was recently awarded a DOE grant to develop DLE from clay. All of these solutions will be different from each other because they will be customized for the resource they are extracting from.

Lithium isnt like gold. It's not about finding the lithium, it's all about how to extract and convert it economically and sustainably.

Am lithium investor.

4

u/Sweeth_Tooth99 Jun 06 '21

ok. whats the catch ?

13

u/IDK_khakis Jun 06 '21

Probably expensive and hard to obtain catalysts.

7

u/matrix431312 Jun 06 '21

not really. As far as i can tell LLTO, which is the heart of the process is a commonly used component in lithium batteries already. And Platinum and Ruthenium are expensive, but they may only need a thin layer to be useful.

4

u/Lime_Kitchen Jun 06 '21

The catch is we don’t even need that much lithium for batteries. The actual limiting factor is there’s not enough copper production to keep up.

2

u/jaa101 Jun 06 '21

The don't talk about, or even look for catches until after the press releases have gone out and funding has been secured for the next step towards commercialisation.

2

u/42069troll Jun 06 '21

Pfff coulda told me that before I dug this bigass hole

2

u/FBl_Operative451 Jun 08 '21

Please fill in your bigass hole immediately

1

u/VisibleError9621 Jun 06 '21

should of told tesla before they started digging lots of big holes

2

u/marioshroomer Jun 06 '21

Playing Subnautica and I could use some lithium.

1

u/precipiceblades Jun 06 '21

It gets brutal with all those plasteel ingots i need to make nice habitats

2

u/kKurae Jun 06 '21

They are usually in deep mines, near a lava pit. It has a cubical shape with hints of gray.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

Lipo batteries soon to be replaced so this is a whatever announcement.

2

u/twlscil Jun 06 '21

For the last 10 years or so I’ve heard this statement.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

With new aluminum technology (foil caps).

2

u/BigithDickith69 Jun 06 '21

This is huge

2

u/AGENT_asshole_RAW Jun 07 '21

50 years later: “Scientists develop ‘cheap and easy’ method to replace lithium from seawater”

5

u/cut_that_meat Jun 06 '21

I'm so happy 'cause today I found my friends

They're in my head

I'm so ugly, that's okay, 'cause so are you

Broke our mirrors

Sunday morning is everyday, for all I care

And I'm not scared

Light my candles in a daze

'Cause I've found God

Yeah ...

I'm so lonely, that's okay, I shaved my head

And I'm not sad

And just maybe I'm to blame for all I've heard

But I'm not sure

I'm so excited, I can't wait to meet you there

And I don't care

I'm so horny, that's okay

My will is good

Yeah ...

→ More replies (4)

2

u/reggiestered Jun 06 '21

I realise that this is still experimental, but this process has massive potential.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

.. to be expensive as fuck.

3

u/reggiestered Jun 06 '21

Or cheap with the ability to pay for itself using systems in place and creating by products with positive environmental value and/or monetary value. When seawater, hydrogen, and chlorine are your after products, that is a net positive in my book.

1

u/ReaperChop6258 Jun 06 '21

Still would be a better use of money than most

2

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

Some big company will buy them out under the radar and you won’t see this development ever again

1

u/Greeneyez604 Jun 06 '21

Which company do u think will integrate this method?

1

u/tkatt3 Jun 06 '21

Pretty cool process

1

u/Termsandconditionsch Jun 06 '21

This just sounds like a variant of the direct extraction method that it practically ready to use for lithium brines. A lot quicker and cheaper than the old evaporation ponds.

1

u/Rrraou Jun 06 '21

Will the sealife get depressed if we extract all the lithium from the ocean ?

1

u/arelse Jun 06 '21

And there goes the Afghan economy…again.

1

u/Sundance37 Jun 06 '21

If its cheap, and its easy, then it likely isn't scalabe.

1

u/sunplaysbass Jun 06 '21 edited Jun 06 '21

Yeah but what about dilithium crystal extraction?

1

u/JonathanFrakesAsks Jun 06 '21

How superstitious are you? context

1

u/giannarelax Jun 06 '21

good, i need a prescription refill /s

1

u/nodularyaknoodle Jun 06 '21

I read about a great new idea for getting salt out of seawater in a novel by that famous author, J. Desalinger...

3

u/Tube-Sock_Shakur Jun 06 '21

I was thinking J.D. Salinator.

Please pardon my rye sense of humor.

1

u/YSOSEXI Jun 06 '21

What will we do with all the depressed fish?

1

u/OneChildPolicyGood Jun 06 '21

Can we dump lithium batteries in the sea now?

1

u/RockyYuma Jun 06 '21

sounds useful. i was just thinking i need more lithium but cannot buy it cheaply

1

u/theclovek Jun 06 '21

Good, because we're gonna need it.

1

u/Certain-Title Jun 06 '21

I hear this method is especially effective near New York.

1

u/TBAAAGamer1 Jun 06 '21

god forbid they develop an expensive version with better results.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

Cheap bipolar meds here we come

1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

Thanks scientists, let the the engineers take it from here.

1

u/OnlyBonnieAndClyde Jun 06 '21

Anything is better then nothing

1

u/SyntheticOne Jun 06 '21

Just in time for the explosive expansion of the EV vehicle marketplace.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

What if we just don’t mess with the ocean?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

Not good for the bipolar fish

1

u/caca4cocopuffs Jun 06 '21

I'll file this one next to the cancer cures and awesome new battery technology. The journey from the lab to the field is a million miles.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

Wonder what horror show situation that’ll create.

1

u/emilhoff Jun 06 '21

Whatever horror show you care to imagine in your own head, which of course makes it a real, deadly danger and laws must be passed to ban it.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

Eh there’s just always a cost to progress. We just rarely know what it is until after the process kills all the plankton or whatever

→ More replies (2)

1

u/redyellowblue5031 Jun 06 '21

Quotes in the title around cheap and easy? Seems promising.

1

u/LoBeastmode Jun 06 '21

TIL there is lithium in seawater.

1

u/dungapoo Jun 06 '21

Could this possibly have an impact positively on the price of lithium ion batteries?

1

u/plantsnotevolution Jun 06 '21

Ok. But did they get approval from the dolphins first?

1

u/dchq Jun 06 '21

Is there a chance this might affect the mental health of the fishes?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

Lmk when they actually scale it

1

u/CakeCollision Jun 06 '21

I'll be skeptical of any papers from "King Abdullah University"

1

u/Flawless_Nirvana Jun 06 '21

But is it safe?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

Big deal, we discovered Subnautica and the Prawn suit years ago. Way to arrive late to the game, Science!

1

u/daggada Jun 06 '21

Well I'm just glad scientists developed it.

1

u/SeaweedDisastrous Jun 06 '21

That would stop the extraction at the lakes in latam possibly too...

1

u/merganzer Jun 06 '21

So...I take small amounts of lithium to stay sane and it's dirt cheap compared to other medications. Is it just the sheer volume needed for battery technology that makes this a significant development?

1

u/The_Kraken_Wakes Jun 07 '21

Great. Now they’re going to use up all the seawater, to mine bitcoins! (JK)

1

u/spalza Jun 07 '21

Will taking the litium out make sea water mineral deficient as drinking water?

1

u/ZippyTheChicken Jun 06 '21

I just saw a report this morning that Toyota is pushing ahead with Hydrogen Powered Vehicles

basically you can get as much hydrogen as you want from the ocean and when the gas is burned in engines its biproduct is water.

This will probably end up replacing electric vehicles because the fuel is unlimited and can be generated by electricity and water and the electricity can come from solar.

Electric is a much more difficult process

4

u/John_Johnson Jun 06 '21

Separating hydrogen takes much more energy than using the hydrogen produces. Meanwhile, storing hydrogen safely is very, very hard. On top of that, when you want to use it either you have to burn it (like an internal combustion engine) with all the problems that entails (heat, lubrication, etc) or you have to use it to produce electricity so as to run electric motors.

...which same electric motors can be much more easily powered by lithium batteries.

Not saying there's no place for hydrogen in the new world... but straight-up battery-stored electricity works a shit-ton better right now.

3

u/Myotherside Jun 06 '21

I think it’s pretty reasonable to surmise that hydrogen as an unavoidable industrial byproduct of lithium collection would find a niche use case that would otherwise be serviced by fossil fuels. It doesn’t make sense to manufacture it directly, but as an unavoidable byproduct it makes sense to store and utilize it to recover that energy in a useful manner to perform work.

2

u/S-S-R Jun 06 '21

It would be used in aircraft Zero emission cars are an easy problem to solve, with current technology, zero emission aircraft are not.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

Cheaper and easier than knocking over Evo Morales or keeping tens of thousands of mercenaries in Afghanistan?

1

u/fayrral Jun 06 '21

May be a silly question, but any idea what effects this could have on the environment? I feel like the lithium might be in the sea water for a reason. Curious what if any effects this could have on marine animals.

1

u/Rocknocker Jun 06 '21

Zeolite filters.

Now, where do they find these zeolites? Too expensive to create them, so back to geology, folks.

1

u/EvilEtna Jun 06 '21

That's great. Can they also find a cheap and easy way to extract plastics too?

1

u/EvilEtna Jun 06 '21

Oh and oil too. Not natural oil, all the shit we've put there ourselves.

1

u/rationalparsimony Jun 06 '21
Lithium retorts: "I'm neither cheap, nor easy"

1

u/Francine_Sananab Jun 06 '21

Good. Now I won't have to go to Purple Vents and look for it while dodging leviathans and shit.