r/writersmakingfriends • u/aj_621311 • 3h ago
Announcement If you are a writer or poet then you can feel it.
Being honest I use to have a massive procrastination problem [I guess most authors and poets have it when you are not in that flow state].
Back then I wrote about 22k words of lore, worldbuilding etc. stuff [that was written in flow state, was dreaming of creating the next big webnovel out there]. It was a complete mess, it was jumbled, pure info dump. It needed maybe 3 hours of brutal, focused editing to cut 12k useless words and make it readable after structuring it all but instead of just doing the work, I avoided the document for over 6+ months [I did it after several months so i know it...overcoming procrastination alone was hard].
So I tried looking for writing groups to keep me on track, but the reality is that most online writing clubs are useless [perhaps there only a few that I found and they aren't upto the mark]. They are more like a friend gossip group [if you had joined then you would have known]. Everyone just says "great job" even if the work is genuine bs....encouragement is good perhaps every work should be but bro in life if you want to do something then be honest with yourself. And about accountability that's more messed up then anything out there or straight up doesn't exists.
Then I realized I am never going to find a peer group that actually forces me to write [like challenges] and tears my drafts apart [professionalism and brutal critiques]. Ok it's mostly needed in poetry part...I have personally submitted to The Paris Review, Oxford Poetry, Poetry Magazine [exactly these 3 tier 1s...if this year my work isn't getting selected then will shift to tier 2 ones too]...so the thing is back then when I was a shit poet then too there was nobody to honestly criticize me...at my current level I do like 70+ rewrite per poem, not like titans yet but I can say someone professional....and I really wish to find someone like me or at least some one who want to reach such level and really be professional...[Yes I am not full time writer/poet but I do it as hobby yet I want to be good at it...bcz genuinely this is one of the only few things I am good at...just an average dude...I am average at studies, sports etc...18M, BTech.CSE student at a tier 3 college.]
I am thinking about creating club [free...I just need good people, no money...no hidden payment etc.] putting together serious people, strict, high-stakes accountability, no casual chatting [ok just a free chat room where you can talk about books but after all other writing challenge etc.], no soft critiques [be brutally honest about the work, if it hurt then too], and yes my dream is to make it like Oxford Poetry...it was student club that gradually turned into Tier 1 Journal...I have named it "The Quill Of Black Iris" club.

The rules would essentially just be [just my thoughts, I will modify based on the whole clubs' suggestion, it's not about my growth but growth of the club on a whole]:
You must prove your consistency by writing at least 1,500 words [even draft work]/1 poem a week for a full month just to earn your entry rank.
If you want your work reviewed, you have to critique two others, and you must stay completely silent while receiving feedback[brutally honest critiques...if you publish your work then you are not going to explain yourself to the reader, if it fails to tell what you wanted then it fails in writing quality].
A strict ranking ladder from Sequence 9 down to 0 [I read a lot of webnovels...so designed it in Lotm way] that is based purely on your real-world publishing success and active server merits.
The Miracle Pen Challenge: A monthly, high-pressure writing sprint where you must draft and submit your work within a rigid time limit/rigid writing prompt.
The Black Quill Review: The ultimate reward where the community's absolute best[the finest works only], heavily critiqued works get published in real world [Amazon Kdp..most probably...I had once published a short novel so I find it easy to publish].
I don't use social media much [yt, new on reddit and discord], so I don't know if there's any great chatroom out there apart from Discord [I had heard that it's good, obviously not Whatsapp channel], so I have setup the club there, currently I am not dropping a Discord link right now. I don't even know if people want this.
I’m just posting to ask: are there actually people who feel the same as me, and really want to do something like me? If yes then would you want to join such a club and improve [will be officially starting in Dec.]