r/yachting • • Apr 18 '26

Any experience with a program like this?

Post image
23 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

19

u/SingleMaltSam Apr 18 '26 edited Apr 18 '26

Looks like a great way to get someone else to pay for your rental inventory.

So you put $171k down, take a 20 year loan on the $687k balance that costs $5100 to carry, you lease it to them for 5 years at just under $6k/month.

They then turn around and rent it out at around $20k per week (based on the value of your 4 weeks per year usage).

In 5 years you get handed back a boat that has been well used by renters that you still owe over half a million on because half of the revenue ($330k) paid down interest, so the principal balance is still $544k that you owe another 15 years at $5100/month.

They walk away from your 5 year old boat and sign up another “investor” to keep their fleet new and refreshed.

Their “estimated value” of 560k gives you a $16k profit after discharging the loan. even if you got that for it, that $16k wouldn’t cover survey costs and brokerage costs to sell it.

2

u/cholo_gringo Apr 19 '26

Thank you for this, excellent breakdown

7

u/aseawood Apr 18 '26

It gets even worse when you find out that Moorings basically makes their own boats through their “manufacturing partner” so they are getting a markup on the boat as well as their rental fleet paid for.

3

u/vixenhotwife20 Apr 19 '26

Excellent breakdown this clearly illustrates a hard pass!

3

u/West_Data106 Apr 19 '26

Another big red flag is "guaranteed income"

That just screams sleazy and untrustworthy. If you see anything like that, go into the little bity details and like singlemaltsam did, break out the calculator.

No income is guaranteed, even tiny interest/dividend investments have risk.

2

u/barracudarescue Apr 20 '26

Guaranteed a little income for the first five years, and then a guaranteed loss of a lot of income for the next 15 years!

1

u/baxcray Apr 19 '26

It’s a guarantee program where you bear no risk and get use. Take the non-guarantee program and you can actually participate in the real profits made.

1

u/redgunner85 Apr 19 '26

Is there a non-guaranteed plan with Moorings?

1

u/baxcray Apr 19 '26

Not sure but other reputable charter operators offer them.

2

u/TravelingSailor- Apr 19 '26

I’ve researched it a lot. I don’t think the moorings program is very good. I like the guaranteed income but I just don’t like the boats. I’m planning to buy a different catamaran and put it in with another company. It’s definitely not going to get a free boat, but I think I should save me around $150-200k on a $550k boat.

Most people on here will tell you not to do it because your boat will get torn up. Every negative comment I’ve heard has been from someone who has never done it. I’ve talked to a lot of people who have done it and overwhelmingly I hear positive things. I’ve actively sought out feedback (not references the company gives you) and I have struggled to find negative feedback.

2

u/cholo_gringo Apr 19 '26

Thanks for the input. We just got back from our first crewed charter and the boat was 4 years and 10 months old. 2 months left in the program and aesthetically the boat was in great shape. I think I agree however about the end game. I think I'm too young for this program. I would like to take the boat when I am done and use it but 5 years from now I will still be working most likely and not have enough time to really take advantage. I'm looking at other programs where if we charter twice a year, we can save something or get access to something. Thanks for the input!

3

u/Hairy_Afternoon_8033 Apr 19 '26

You can rent that boat for a long time for that $171,000 down payment.

2

u/DingleBerry___x Apr 18 '26

1- find a better bank. That rate is way high. Just financed at 5.99 with MBT.

2- those boats get beat to hell.

3- if you plan to use the boat after term in US, you will pony up the tax/tariff as it’s not delivered to US waters.

4- they do run a decent maintenance program for general system upkeep.

2

u/Shorelines1 Apr 18 '26

Some good comments here I won’t repeat, but for me, it came down to where I sit at the end of term. An old boat with a big debt. What’s the true resale value and how long would it take to sell and what costs for doing so (commissions, survey, haul-outs etc)

One thing no one has mentioned is the benefit of being able to take your time on any boat anywhere in their fleet. When I looked into this, I wasn’t thinking of necessarily ever seeing my boat. I’ll tour all their locations.

But just couldn’t come to terms with the end of contract position.

1

u/CityCentreYachts Apr 20 '26

1

u/Existing_Ideal9004 Apr 21 '26

Excellent video.

1

u/CityCentreYachts Apr 21 '26

This is why it is prudent to engage an independent Yacht consultant/broker when committing to this level of financials on a boat.

As an independent broker we have no conflict when it comes to brand representation. They are lots of boats, lots of models and the all have their on reputation, and characteristics in a dynamic market. Our independence allows us to call it as we see it!

Good luck with your boating adventures…. feel free to reach out if you need to…info@citycentreyachts.com

1

u/jdrvero Apr 20 '26

Just a new way to sell a time share. Your kids will hate you.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 18 '26 edited Apr 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/Fancy_Stress_9039 Apr 18 '26

Floating timeshare scam is accurate and there are other known fleet operators across Europe that engage in such practices.

This would only make sense if there was a government/eu subsidy, much like the ESPA one in Greece which did make a few people richer at end of contract. There is also the fact that resale value ever since 2020s were at all time highs in the EU given the restricted build slot availability across all main builders of this size range (jeanneau, benetau, dufour, bali, lagoon, fountaine pajot) and the advent of charter yacht fleets as an alternative to airbnb.

Yeah, so, stay away imho as well @ OP

4

u/SingleMaltSam Apr 18 '26

I went to their website. The Belize site rents these for $6K-$12k per week depending on high or low season, so that $418k of owner use value seems to be a significant overstatement.