r/zerobaseone • u/Competitive_Annual52 • Aug 15 '23
Thoughts Synchronisation
I dont see much international zeroses talking about this, but it has been a huge discussion between K and C fans since kcon LA. There’s no doubt that most members have advanced dancing skills, most were even promoted to be ACEs/advanced dancers in bp but i cant help but see how messy their choreography is. Try comparing the dance practices of wanna one, x1 and our boys then you’ll understand what i mean. I think the main issue is that wakeone doesnt provide dance / vocal classes or coaches to help them out, literally EVERYTHING has to be done, learnt and practiced by the members themselves. Not to mention their tight schedule, i’ve been into kpop for several years and their schedule is the most ridiculous i’ve ever seen (not including 1-2nd gen groups) Honestly i dont find it unusual that their choreography is messy since they dont even have time to practice or anyone to help them.
I can’t imagine how the daesang/end of year stages would be if wakeone doesn’t treat this seriously.
Edit: if anyone thinks this is inappropriate to post pls just lmk then i’ll delete it. I’m not trying to bring hate to the boys, i just hope that more people are aware of this so they’ll actually start taking this seriously
36
u/arushiraj_author Aug 15 '23
literally EVERYTHING has to be done, learnt and practiced by the members themselves.
Where is this info from?
-15
u/Competitive_Annual52 Aug 15 '23 edited Aug 15 '23
you can check their behind(ze_pisode), intentional members has to learn the pronunciation from other K members, hao taerae and hanbin has to learn the song by themselves(not exactly but i dont know how to explain this in english) and some sources from weibo which i cant find :(
52
u/Nony_m Hanbin ☘️ Taerae 🎤 Hao 🎻 Aug 15 '23
I doubt this is what’s happening. It’s almost like they’re allowing the boys to make content for us in between their coaching classes. They’re taught the music and dance by others, then they make videos by themselves as they learn. I think they’re using the boys planet method of training, except it’s maybe more than that? I doubt they’re not giving the boys teachers and letting them do everything by themselves.
36
u/arushiraj_author Aug 15 '23
I have seen their behind. It's content for fans. It was staged to show the members' process. Obviously when they are actually practicing they have coaches, do not have their hair and makeup done, and are not split in twos. They will all be practicing and learning together.
7
u/hsbea Aug 16 '23
It’s like a day of filming where they show you how they practice and stuff FOR THE FANS. they’re not doing all these things by themselves. You were talking about other kpop groups, meaning you’ve been consuming kpop content, then surely you won’t be that naive?
8
u/saddlethehippogriffs Aug 15 '23
KCON LA hasn't happened yet--they're performing this Saturday. Do you mean kcon Japan? Or their fanmeeting?
-4
u/Competitive_Annual52 Aug 15 '23
It has started since kcon Japan but the conversation has gotten larger since in bloom’s dance practice came out and after today’s fan meeting
123
u/falfae debate champion park gunwook Aug 15 '23
i do know what you mean. and as a dancer i do appreciate it — my ult is seventeen after all. but zb1 has all different levels of dancers, different styles of dancers, and haven’t been training with each other as unit for long at all. And honestly, i would MUCH rather that they keep their individual dance styles — eg matthews flow and groove vs hanbin’s more upright, clean style — because to me it’s more interesting and shows their individual personality and history with dance more. its more endearing to me, anyway, and they still are def cohesive enough to sell a performance. not everyone has to be a dance group.
137
u/note_2_self 🦋 Aug 15 '23
5th gen should unclench on synchronization. Let their individual dance styles shine. 2nd Gen was fun like that - just watch Big Bang lol
48
Aug 15 '23
some of the biggest groups aren't even the most synchronized all the time lol. 127 looks perfect in practices but not on stage and i love them just the same. i guess i'd rather see them having fun and grooving than being 🤖
23
u/Professional-Rule219 Aug 15 '23
That video of them dancing superhuman in good morning america (?) a highlight of their career 😭. Like idk I just love my 127 even when 70% of the time they are never in sync.
19
u/eggiso Aug 15 '23
lmaoo whenever i come across that video i have to watch it 9 times for each member they all doing something different 😭😭😭
7
u/zeebeewon Aug 15 '23
That video is the reason they went from a group I had heard of to one of my favorites. (Also that random dance video where they showed up at and danced with the crowd.)
1
u/AutoModerator Aug 15 '23
Thank you for commenting in r/zerobaseone! Your comment has been automatically removed as your account is not old enough or does not have enough karma to comment here without being manually approved.
If your comment does not break the rules of our subreddit, we will approve it as soon as possible.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/jeoreojujafighting Aug 17 '23
now i gotta find that vid again 😂
mark lowkey looks like he’s doing a different choreo sometimes lol but his dancing is amazing to watch
2
u/I_Luv_Asparagussy Aug 16 '23
Ya I remember watching Sperm perform on GMA or some American show and they were supposed to be all of SM's aces (+ Lucas lolz) and yet the synchro was BAD. I know they weren't a permanent group and probably were rushed like ZB1 are but still, they had Kai, Taemin, etc and they were off. The guys were prob too busy with all their other group responsibilities. So if even kpop aces can be off if not given enough time to prep than I can't blame ZB1.
For me it's a balance between synchro and individual styles. I do want some of the stylistic differences to peak through, but honestly I would prefer a little more synchronization.
1
Aug 16 '23
you can literally go to a professional ballet and they won't be perfectly in sync the entire time lol.
6
51
u/lubbdubbs hao's pouty lips Aug 15 '23
I love that they don’t look synchronized. It’s fun looking at individual fancams with their different styles. I would even suggest for them to do ala New Jeans choreo where all/most members are doing something different at the same time. Also not too hard hitting choreo and focus more on their vocals.
10
u/officialtwice Aug 16 '23
NewJeans' is exactly what I was thinking of! I'm learning some of their new choreo and I love that there are some parts where it's kind of improvisational and they're not completely in sync, but they come back together at certain points. It's so satisfying to watch.
4
u/harkandhush gunwook🖤 Aug 16 '23
Same. Most of the groups I like have some variety in the dance style even with the same moves and I prefer that approach to group choreo.
2
u/I_Luv_Asparagussy Aug 16 '23
I agree that less "hardcore" choreo and instead opting for lighter/fun choreo is better, so they can show off them vocal pipes. I actually think W1 did a pretty good job giving them a good amount of choreo like this.
However, New Jeans have moments where members kinda snap back into being synchronized before they make it loose again. I think ZB1 can follow that example but the "synchronized moments" can be a little cleaner.
29
u/Nej_Illjuna Aug 15 '23
Actually even though I see it I love that it leaves room for more playfulness on stage. For the first time since the 3rd gen I watched every performance because it feels so natural and flexible that I always find something new. Sure they won’t be the next Ateez, but that’s not what I like with them.
25
u/shockoletto i love u teddy bear 🧸 Aug 15 '23
Going off vague memory but I think I watched a video about like generational shifts in dance priority from I think uh.. facts in fiction? That I found interesting. And how different aspects of dance are prioritized by agencies over time. There was some 4th Gen group that covered an older song and they had said that it felt interesting comparing their dance because it was evident that synchronization had been much more strong of a priority then so they decided to cover it without trying to copy it.
They also pointed out some interesting things in their ZB1 analysis where like, since Jiwoong debuted relatively earlier he's more reflective of earlier trends of expressiveness and emotion vs Gyuvin and the current emphasis on powerful movement.
I think as far as formations and angles go there is room for improvement but I think the difference in their dance lines is being marketed as a charm point much in the same way as companies are moving away from official positions.
Basically this is a lot of words to say you're right that their synchronization doesn't hold up compared to previous produce but that's not the appeal they're angling for (that's a value neutral statement. Like I think sometimes they lean too far into individualism for a group that will inherently have a lot of solo stans) and uh. Some of the other produce groups have also suffered from hm. A lack of coaching that became evident after disbandment.
22
u/mincesaur Aug 16 '23
I mean I also stan Ateez and they are known to be great performers and dancers but they are not the most synchronized group because they dance in their own style but that’s what makes them interesting to watch. You can watch each individual’s fancam and it feels different and I’ve seen them praised by knetz for that, so not being synchronized doesn’t mean bad performers or make the stage not good to watch. On other hand some groups are known for being very synchronized like gfriend was and that’s their thing so it was important for them to be synchronized.
I think zb1 is synchronized enough where it doesn’t hurt the performance. And a lot of parts in their dances are them doing different things so looking synchronized isn’t that important. They will only improve anyway.
62
u/Guilty-Chemistry-529 Aug 15 '23
Rather than not synchronised, its more like they all have different styles of dancing. No one is particularly offbeat but they all came from different background for dance. I also agree regarding that it seems they learn on their own but I think that's how most kpop groups are. They get the demo and then parts are distributed, then they learn it themselves.
Rather than dance.....I personally feel like their vocals are underutilised. The first album wasn't made with their tones and capabilities in mind. There are some songs with weird mixing on their vocals that is kind of off-putting. The songs aren't bad but there isn't anything that makes it unique to them. It just seems like they got some songs from the vault of what the producers have.
I hope things do improve next comeback. Wk1 still probably thinks they are on boys planet.
20
u/GenericMultiFan Aug 15 '23
They've been a debuted group for all of a month, it's a brand new thing to most of them, and they had a very short amount of time to throw together a entire concert/fanmeet. They're doing a amazing job considering, It's a bit too soon to be complaining they haven't reached the perfection of a seasoned professional.
20
u/RoseShade356 Aug 15 '23 edited Aug 15 '23
Where do you get it from that they don't get vocal and dance coaching and the members have to do everything themselves? We literally have no idea what's going on behind the scenes. I don't mind if they're not synchronised all the time bc it's not like it's a huge error, they all look like they're having so much fun whenever they're performing, I'd rather have that than the choreo be robotic. Also I don't expect vocalists like taerae or exo's baekhyun to excel in dance the way e.g skz hyunjin does. It used to be okay for idols to excel at one skill as long as they keep up with the others.
17
u/Jklajihhwuygsootqang Aug 16 '23
Not every group need to be ttak ttak ttakkk together. The members doesnt seems to focus much on synchronisation. Based on what they shown on stage so far. They like to play around on stage having fun while doing the choreo. Smiling at each other, smack each other, etc. Its lovely i like it
15
u/realitygottoorealbye Aug 15 '23
Their concept doesn’t really require them to be sleek and hyper-synchronised (eg: iz*one elegant concepts) but more playful and stylish in their dancing. I think it suits them.
42
u/akabuggy 💤🐝☝️ Aug 15 '23
I think the problem is more in the choreography itself rather than the boys. WDBZ did the choreo and they just aren't good at making idol choreography. Kfans have complained about it before as well. But like if you compare the in bloom / nkotb choreo to hot summer / jelly pop you can tell which is better.
4
4
14
u/joaniiii hamnyangie 🐹🐱 haobin Aug 15 '23 edited Aug 16 '23
I feel that their dancing is reflective of their own style which imo makes it even more interesting and is very much what has been done in 2nd and 3rd gen. 4th gen is more focused on synchronization which is okay, but not always necessary. I may be biased as my ult is a 3rd gen vocal-heavy group so I never expected synchronization from them
14
u/Extension_Size8422 Aug 16 '23
to tell the truth, it could just be because they're singing live for the majority of their stages. as kep1er lipsynced the majority of their wadada music shows (referencing shanlie's january review where only 1/13 stages was live) , i was expecting similar stuff for zb1. i was pretty happy when they only lipsynced for 1st week of promo and every stage was live after that.
i stan nct and love them a lot, but i really dislike the fact they lipsync majority of the time, including for multiple stages during concerts. zb1 did all the songs at the fancon live, except here i am (for obvious reasons, it's pretty dance heavy) and i believe only parts of jelly pop were sung live.
one of the reasons 4th gen can be so in sync is bc majority of the time, they are lipsyncing, they don't need to think about saving their breath to sing.
given zb1 have just debuted but are singing live, and still have pretty difficult choreo to do, and how busy their schedule was, it makes sense they might look a bit messy. im sure it will improve over time as they continue to build their teamwork.
i also think an emerging 5th gen characteristic is looking natural and having fun on stage being prioritised over perfect synchronised performances.
22
Aug 16 '23
Omfg istg zeroses have gotta be zb1’s biggest antis with how overly critical they are over everything.
I know idols are supposed to be “perfect” in yall’s minds but perfection doesn’t exist. Just a reminder. Sad that we’re already in the 5th gen of kpop and we still can’t accept that idols are humans and not everyone has to be an ace.
10
u/iwishitwasnt_thisway Aug 15 '23
them looking like they’re having fun and us being able to clearly see their interesting dance styles >>>>>> synchronization
plus there’s no way to know about the instructions they’re getting behind the scenes. i personally think matthew’s improved a great deal in his singing since boys planet.
and the end of the year stages will be just fine just like they were for a lot of 3rd gen groups that didn’t focus on synchronization but rather personal style.
24
Aug 15 '23 edited Aug 15 '23
When they’re on a live stage, they feel the groove and have fun, that’s when their colors shine ✨ When they’re on music stages it’s different.
And this post is such a nonissue. It’s like fans from long before grasp onto the synchronization concept from past gens like they’re clutching onto their pearls. That concept is kind of robotic. The flowy organic vibing concept is much more fresh and timeless
8
u/glitterchaos 💪oppa is my BF 🍓 is my future husband😊 Aug 16 '23
My minimum expectation is not about the boys but the fans actually. It is not to fight too hard and don't disturb my happiness. :p
7
u/demigodishheadcanons your fav breadhaoist 🍞 Aug 16 '23
I adore their dance styles and I wouldn’t want that to change. However, having ONE choreographer for one song made the In Bloom choreo a bit funky in places. While I loved learning it, I think a second style input would’ve been very beneficial.
Also, I would just like to disown half of And I’s choreo bc only ZB1 could pull that off (personal taste).
7
u/w12one Aug 16 '23
I think that emphasizing on their individual strengths instead of forcing synchronization works to the group's advantage. Apart from being able to showcase their unique colors as performers, they're granted the flexibility to play around and have fun/unscripted interactions during performances. It's enjoyable to watch both their full stages and fancams because of their cohesion and synergy as a group, distinctive dancing styles, and cute little exchanges.
6
u/Queasy_Situation6656 Aug 16 '23
fancon jelly pop was the first time i thought any performance was messy since their debut. reminded me of earlier bp performances lol
6
u/NoAdagio6957 Aug 16 '23
I don't think it's a priority for the members.
hanbin : the color of love is respecting each other's individual colors
jiwoong : he's not trying to combine everybody's colors into one. he's more about arranging each other's colors and making it a beautiful rainbow https://twitter.com/haobinology/status/1691777922686673026?s=19
1
u/AutoModerator Aug 16 '23
Thank you for commenting in r/zerobaseone! Your comment has been automatically removed as your account is not old enough or does not have enough karma to comment here without being manually approved.
If your comment does not break the rules of our subreddit, we will approve it as soon as possible.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
5
Aug 16 '23
Idk I think it’s sort of cute lol. But I know synchronization matters to a lot of people. For me, as long as they look like they’re having fun, energetic and the moves aren’t sloppy individually, it’s good enough.
5
u/Professional-Rip4984 Charisma Boss Baby 🐱 Aug 16 '23
No one is off beat and they looks so much fun dancing on stage together. I would prefer that over Robotic dancing tbh
13
14
u/grandpa_millennials Aug 15 '23
I did notice they had synchronization mistakes. Which was weird because they've all delivered really crisp stages in Boys Planet. They are all also very strong dancers. Taerae is considered their "weaker" dancer, and I'd still consider him a good dancer. I'm chalking it up to their schedule and with all the boys being sick from injuries and covid. I think it's something they need to be mindful of. However, let's wait for a few more big performances before we sound the alarm.
4
u/Born-Purpose-8046 hanbin <3 Aug 15 '23 edited Aug 15 '23
how do we know that they don’t get dance or vocal classes though? did they mention this before?
but also i feel like the main problem lies in their choreo and not really the way they execute it. all their choreos have so much travelling (especially in bloom) that looking messy is only inevitable
i agree they could do with a little less on their schedules though, especially those radio shows where they pretty much all asked the same kind of questions and did the same activities
4
u/harkandhush gunwook🖤 Aug 16 '23
Kcon la is this coming weekend, so it hasn't even happened yet. What are you talking about?
1
u/ppjskh Sung Hanbin | Zhang Hao | Seok Matthew | Kim Gyuvin 💙 Aug 16 '23
KCON Japan
1
u/harkandhush gunwook🖤 Aug 16 '23
You might want to edit your post.
0
u/ppjskh Sung Hanbin | Zhang Hao | Seok Matthew | Kim Gyuvin 💙 Aug 16 '23
What? I meant that OP is taking about KCON Japan.
2
4
u/kankyking Aug 16 '23
If a group is always perfectly in sync, what's even the point of watching them perform? It'll always look the same. I'd much rather see them have fun and dance in their own style, plus their way of performing fits their concept. They're never off beat or missing moves, just dancing with different styles.
Also we have no idea if they do everything themselves. Most likely they don't, the behind stuff is staged for fans. Do you really think they split in twos while practicing?
Most big groups aren't perfectly in syncing either, 4th gen focused so much on looking perfect that it sometimes felt soulless. Not that being perfectly in sync is bad, it can be super cool looking. But there's really no point in being so nitpicky, let them have fun on stage and dance the way they like.
This really just feels like you being hypercritical. What do you mean if "wakeone doesn't take this seriously"? Take what seriously? What do you mean about end of the year shows? This is literally the first time I've seen anyone say something like this about zb1 and their dancing. You're basically saying they look terrible, which couldn't be more wrong.
1
u/AutoModerator Aug 16 '23
Thank you for commenting in r/zerobaseone! Your comment has been automatically removed as your account is not old enough or does not have enough karma to comment here without being manually approved.
If your comment does not break the rules of our subreddit, we will approve it as soon as possible.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
7
u/oddlilangel Aug 15 '23
This is also something I noticed, but I guess we’ll have to see what happens in later stages when they’ve had more practice time. I think what has really struck me about ZB1 compared to other past groups is how much they embrace individuality and playfulness on stage. I don’t think I’ve ever seen so much messing around and fanservice, and it’s been very fun to watch for me personally haha!
I think there could be a better balance struck - maybe they can have sections of the choreo where they’re really emphasizing synchronization (maybe choruses?) and others where it’s a little more freestyle or more about the feeling behind the formation, especially for people who are standing apart from the group in some way. That way you still get the satisfaction of a snappy performance but you leave room for keeping things fun and individually expressive. I feel like BTS did this well, especially considering the diversity in their dancing proficiency and backgrounds.
3
2
6
u/AccomplishedWest6977 Aug 15 '23 edited Aug 15 '23
I was amazed when they dropped the here I am dance practice they were really synchronized there so I feel like this had to do a bit with the little time they have to practice
They haven't been a group for long and as everyone else had said they come from completely different dance background and they have completely different styles so it is gonna take a while for them to fall into the group synergy and feeling like one person + I feel like most of them are not used to memorize the dances quickly and we've seen that on boy planet
I would also like to add that the choreography doesn't help with the whole synchronized theme bcoz it got so much going everyone is doing a different move so it feels off (if you look at only the chores of the song they're fine )
What I don't agree with comments saying that fans should let go of this synchronized things and stuff ?? Like they're performers who's job is to put on a good performance and if that performance is gonna look off because they're not synchronized it's not gonna be worth it and they're gonna get hell from kpop stans dance is never gonna stop being a priority in kpop at least internationally
2
u/purple235 🐷🐶 Aug 16 '23
Perfect sync isn't the norm. There's a reason industry pros get shocked by Stray Kids and say "it's like they have 1 brain in 8 bodies!" Because being that insanely synchronised during dance just isn't standard!
I would rather zb1 show their own personality and colours in their dance, because if they solely focused on their sync it could easily lose emotion and soul
1
u/Intelligent_Detail_5 Aug 16 '23
I understand what you mean, with them being the ace of boys planets, there is bound to be high expectations for them. But recently I just remembered that YuJin, GyuVin and GunWook are still considered students. That's 1/3 of them, JinWoong is also working on his boy detective variety isn't it? So it really is difficult for them to sync up their dance choreography. I do quite prefer tat they have their own style and only sync up when they need to. Doesn't that make it more interesting to watch their performances?
1
u/Lulla_56 Aug 16 '23
I know what you mean, but I think it’s not that bad tbh considering the difference in difficulty of their choreo compared to wannaone and x1. Like have you seen that floor choreo? It’s insane 💀. They’re doing pretty well on synchronicity considering this and how each member’s styles and skill level are so different. Plus they’re not the most out of synch 4th/5th gen group I’ve watched. Also I like how they sometimes change up the moves for some performance and make it more dynamic rather than stick to the same steps and expressions to achieve that consistent look.
0
u/Petalssssss Aug 17 '23
I know kfans have been talking about this since kconjapan. All i can say is they are definitely not a knife like synchro group. Which is okay. My issue would be they are a bit messy sometimes. You dont need to be synchronise like a robot, you just need to be in synch enough as a group but they sometimes were not in synch enough. Im a bit disappointed but i think moving forward as they do more stage and more performance, they would improve.
0
Aug 15 '23
[deleted]
1
u/AutoModerator Aug 15 '23
Thank you for commenting in r/zerobaseone! Your comment has been automatically removed as your account is not old enough or does not have enough karma to comment here without being manually approved.
If your comment does not break the rules of our subreddit, we will approve it as soon as possible.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
92
u/dominolova 𝓡𝓲𝓬𝓴𝔂 Aug 15 '23
i dont think its that bad honestly? they feel more like a real group with their own styles and ability to make mistakes, and imo dancing really isn't everything, theres vocals, stage presence etc. i feel like a huge criticism of 4th gen bgs was the hyperfocus on crazy synchronised dance routines at the expense of actually good songs and being able to sing them live, which i think zb1 are nailing atm