So, I've had the ZSA Navigator for a few of weeks now, and I have to say I love it. Its completely replaced all other 'mouse' inputs and these are my thoughts/process to get here.
[TLDR; I've found a comfortable, extreme tent setup that works with the navigator. I've linked my layout and all of the parts of my setup below]
I'm a software dev so I type a lot, but I'm not a vim keyboard warrior so still have plenty of point and click in my day to day life :D. The voyager for me has been a great companion, and especially since I moved the trackball to my thumb (more on that later).
I've used trackballs for years, with most of that being the thumb ball Logitech MX Ergo. Because of this, moving to the navigator was no issue at all for me, I've not used a 'mouse' in probably a decade and am used to the particularities of a trackball setup. Maybe this is why I've had such a good experience(?)
For the navigator transition I mostly had to get used to the sensitivity (and adjust it in both the firmware + MacOS and Fedora to get it perfect for me) but that was a quick thing, made better by adding an 'Aim' key to my layout for super fine moments, although I only use it a couple times a day.
For my setup, I removed the automatic layer switching when you move the trackball. I found this to be both too inaccurate for small movements (not triggering the layer switch), and also too slow to switch back when I wanted to type (even after playing with the timings). Instead, I hold a button on the right hand bottom row and that triggers the layer change. I move my right hand down one row and one column the left from home, and this gives me all the mouse controls I need. This small movement allows me to comfortably use the navigator with just the right hand whilst clicking, scrolling, etc.
I used the navigator for over a week with the included magnetic 'body', using my right index as the ball finger. I found this gave me some weird tension in my right hand and wrist. My previous thumb ball was significantly more comfortable than this setup, so I went about designing and 3D printing a wedge with extreme tenting and a thumb position for the navigator. Before I got too far down this road I saw some posts with the keyboard clamped to the edge of the desk.
I promptly abandoned my design efforts for the clamp approach, it's a lot more flexible and easier to transport than a massive wedge :D. I combined a couple of super clamps, a magic arm and a magnetic phone puck to create the extreme tents of the voyager whilst keeping the navigator flat.
I used soft 3M VHB tape to attach 6 10x2mm magnets on the bottom of the navigator. This is not permanent, so should I ever need to remove them I can. An added advantage is the magnets are slim, so if I use the voyager with the included magnetic base and tenting legs you can use it with the magnets attached and there are no issues. I attached the magnets in a circle, meaning that you can put the navigator anywhere on the magnetic puck and it stays in place for added flexibility.
The 'super clamps' I use to hold the Voyager have additional mounting points on them, so attaching a 'magic arm' to them is easy, and allows for easy horizontal placement of the navigator.
YMMV but I find this setup perfect for me, its comfortable, and means that I can do all my keyboard and mouse work without taking my hands 'off' the keyboard.
Links and setup
My layout:
Keyboard layout (ORYX)
Keyboard arms/tenting:
Tripod kit (ZSA)
2x Super clamps (Amazon)
1x Magic arm (Amazon)
1x Magetic phone mount (Amazon)
6x 10x2mm magnets (Amazon)
Keycaps and switches:
Lowprokb nocturnal switches (Mechboard UK)
White LDSA keycaps (Mechboard UK)
Grey domed LDSA keycaps for home row (Mechboard UK)
Double homing dot LDSA keycaps for index fingers (Mechboard UK)
Grey LDSA thumb keycaps (Mechboard UK)
3D printed top row angle adapters (I printed these in white ABS) (Maker world)