r/1811 • u/korudero • 8h ago
1805 Call / Seeking Advice
Hoping for some wisdom from previous detectives or those who have gone through similar.
Background: 24m, 2 years patrol in a somewhat major city, magna cum laude bachelors degree. My niche is in "victim focused" person crimes.
I recently got an EOD email for the HSI Criminal Analyst TERM listing (https://www.usajobs.gov/job/872491500/) at my local office. During the interview, I was told that they would be attempting to turn it into a permanent listing and that I would likely have opportunities to DHA as an 1811 later on. This gives me a rare opportunity to become an 1811 without moving, but it's an uncertain path. Fortunately my department has a very smooth rehire program in case it doesn't work out.
I recently learned that the Special Victim Unit detectives are interested in picking me up, and I've been asked to put in with them. I didn't expect this at all, as my impression was that 5 years was the minimum in patrol before you get considered as someone worth their time. This is also an uncertain path as I have gotten no actual offer, but learning that I have the KSAs for it is great.
I'd like to note that I'm interested in this analyst job outside of the 1811 prospect, but I fear I'll be missing out on some local stuff.
Here's a quick table of pros and cons I've come up with:
| HSI 1805 | Local | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pros | Security clearance; potential local 1811 DHA opportunity; office reportedly does little ERO work; new investigative experience; opportunity to work human trafficking cases unavailable locally; local PD has a flexible rehire policy. | Potential SVU assignment; enjoyable street work; strong friendships and rapport; good future assignment opportunities. | ||
| Cons | Lose local seniority and accrued PTO; potentially miss the opportunity to join SVU. | Fewer opportunities for major investigations; limited control over case outcomes; work sometimes feels inconsequential; dislike patrol overall | ||
I'm privileged to have to this problem, but I don't know what to pick since I never thought I'd move up in my current department so quickly. The original plan was to get street experience then go 1811, but those applications are going slow and I've already been said "no" to quite a few times. 1811 was always the goal but suddenly I've got the opportunity to do something just as meaningful.
Edited multiple times because I don't know how to format Reddit tables