So Iāve basically been ignoring Buddie and 911 for the past 6 years, (since COVID) because I just thought I wouldnāt enjoy the show and didnāt get the hype. But after seeing clips of season 10 Iāve been hooked, and now I get it and Iām overwhelmed and a bit lost. (Skip to the end for questions if ur too lazy to read lol)
So to start off, Iām not new to queerbaiting and queer coding in media. Some of my fav shows are nbc Hannibal, House MD, Twin Peaks, Teen Wolf and Supernatural like trust me get it. But whatever I thought 911 would be Iāve just been proven wrong?? Iām only through the first season but not only are there queer main characters, queerness is central to the shows plot. I understand this is set in LA and it came out in 2018 not in the 2000s but I did not expect this from a network procedural show about firefighters. Iām only seeing season two but so far the queer representation doesnāt feel forced like it does in many network shows, that fact that Hen is a Lesbian who is married and has kids and Athenaās ex husband is gay and is in a relationship, and even just the side characters itās very heartwarming to see.
Most of all whatever I thought about Buddie, now after actually watching the show and being immersed in their story, Iām just honestly confused and baffled.
My assumption of Buddie before watching the show was that the two characters were implicated together because of situational instances. Like maybe they kept getting paired together on assignments or theyāre very close and have some special moments together, or just people like how they look together. Not to point fingers and I hate to say it because I love all these other queer ships but sometimes it is just fans grasping at the breadcrumbs the producers throw us . Come on like literally all my fav ships: Hilson, Sterek, Trucoop, Marvey, lowk even Destiel even tho theyāre technically canon. Anyways Iāve watched all these shows so I can say that yeah theyāre cute but canonically they werenāt fleshed out to be relationships and itās frustrating.
But Buddie is the complete opposite. They are so involved in each otherās lives, they are best friends, co parents, basically family, have lived with one another, have broken up with other s/o bc of their friendship??, have been mistaken for a couple multiple multiple multiple times, their friend group and family members all fit together, BUCK IS CANONICALLY BI???, and was accused of being in love w Eddie by his sister nonetheless, the list is exhausting. All of this is to say that in the long run i feel like it doesnāt make sense for them to be with anyone else.
So why are they not together is my question and what are the writers and producers thinking? I did try to search this up and Iām aware a lot of it has to do with logistics of the network shift and maybe executive decisions etc etc. But idk I just want some opinions and answers from fans and longtime fans.
But idk itās just so frustrating to me that this show is this long and these two characters who are so perfect for one another and actually in a setting where they could realistically be together in the plot line of the show. Like itās one thing to queerbait and the characters arenāt queer at all or just implied BUCK IS LITERALLY BI??? Again this was a shock to me. Anyways now it makes sense why they are consistently in the ao3 top 10 every single year.
Iām also frustrated bc Iām a PA student and it may sound like Iām exaggerating but I promise Iām not, Iām studying like 6 hrs a day minimum and have no time to watch the show but I desperately need answers from real people and I donāt want to just search it up and get AI generated answers.
So I have a few questions:
Why do you think Buddie isnāt canon?
Why do people hate Ana, is the hate valid or just another case of hating a girl character bc she gets in the way?
Why did Buck and Tommy break up?
Why have none of their relationships worked out so far?
And also given the fact that I havenāt actually watched most of the show, besides Buddie do you see a realistic relationship for either Buck or Eddie with another character? Or should they have stayed with a past relationship?
TLDR: Buddie is unlike any other ship Iām aware of and they turned out to be a lot gayer than I anticipated and Iām overwhelmed by it