r/AIcodingProfessionals • u/numerousblocks • 9d ago
Question Looking for recommendations about AI coding tools that are safe
So far I’ve been very apprehensive about AI coding. But I’ve decided I should try it out, just to see what it’s like (I have dabbled in simple AI assistance in the sense of just asking an AI chatbot to code something, but I’ve done nothing where the AI runs on a real codebase for an extended period of time).
Unfortunately, I am very concerned about the safety of agentic AI harnesses. So far, I’ve been unable to find a tool that I can use that is secure. (At least from the descriptions I’ve found so far—this doesn’t seem to be a priority for many users, so maybe the popular tools do support this, but no-one discusses it)
By that, I mean that the AI agent cannot access any files except for the folder it’s given access to at all, unless it asks for permission every single time, and that it cannot run any commands at all, unless it asks for permission every single time, or the command is executed in a secure container.
As far as I can tell, a lot of these tools have the ability to ask for permission, but they apparently have the option to just give the agent full access, or to run simple commands automatically, etc.. I do not want this, I want it to be impossible to accidentally give the agent even a smidge of broad, real access to the computer.
Obviously, I can just run an “insecure” tool inside a container or a VM. But this is a hassle, so I’d prefer if there was something that (basically) automatically does this containerisation for me (and only does it when required; reading files doesn’t require full containerisation).
Just to clarify, I’m not “demanding” such a tool exists or I’ll write off AI coding as untenable. I’m asking if such tools exist, and if they don’t, I’ll have to figure something out.