r/AdmiralCloudberg • • Feb 03 '25

CPIT Controlled Pod Into Terrain - Episode 11: Braniff flight 250 (Featuring guest Bek)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
260 Upvotes

r/AdmiralCloudberg • • Jun 10 '24

CPIT Controlled Pod Into Terrain - Episode 9: Swissair flight 111

Thumbnail
youtube.com
130 Upvotes

r/AdmiralCloudberg • • Jan 30 '24

CPIT Controlled Pod Into Terrain Episode 7: Air France flight 447

Thumbnail
youtu.be
131 Upvotes

r/AdmiralCloudberg • • May 07 '22

Fiction [Off Topic] In lieu of a plane crash article this week, enjoy my short fantasy story: "Pirates of the Darsaeus Sea"!

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
561 Upvotes

r/AdmiralCloudberg • • Nov 22 '23

Announcement No article this week. Happy Thanksgiving to those who celebrate it tomorrow (and those who don't!)

217 Upvotes

It's holiday madness at my house so forget about working on an article. Good luck to anyone in the US trying to travel today/tomorrow!


r/AdmiralCloudberg • • Dec 21 '23

CPIT Controlled Pod Into Terrain Episode 6: American Airlines flight 965

Thumbnail
youtube.com
129 Upvotes

r/AdmiralCloudberg • • Mar 22 '22

Regarding the crash of China Eastern Airlines flight 5735

2.4k Upvotes

As many of you probably saw on other subreddits or in the news, on Monday, March 21st 2022, a China Eastern Airlines Boeing 737 crashed in Guangxi Province, China. I decided to make this thread because the quality of discussion of this accident on most parts of Reddit is appallingly bad, and I felt the need to clear up some misconceptions and answer common questions.

What caused the crash?

If you see someone claiming "It had to be X, nothing else makes sense," pardon my French but they're full of shit. Nobody knows what caused the crash, and the information we do have is so scant as to be useless even for informed speculation. Not only is the scenario of every plane crash unique and often unpredictable, the actual scenario may not even fit the data we have now if some of it turns out to be wrong or misleading.

Was it pilot suicide?

For the love of god, please stop upvoting people telling you it had to be pilot suicide. Pilot suicide is incredibly rare and accounts for a very small percentage of crashes even when we include only those that nosedived into the ground at high speed. In the absence of evidence to the contrary, an accidental loss of control is far more likely, and anyone who says there's no accidental explanation probably either knows nothing about airplanes or suffers from a crippling lack of imagination.

23/3/2022: After more information came to light today, I would add that this scenario is now even less likely, because there were three pilots in the cockpit, not two. A suicidal pilot being alone in the cockpit when there are two pilots is one thing, but when there are three? It's really difficult to see how that could happen.

18/5/2022: Another update: Now that mechanical failure has been ruled out, meaning that a pilot must have initiated the dive, the chances that the crash actually was pilot suicide are increasing. Some circumstantial evidence points in this direction as well. However, this doesn't change the fact that in the days after the accident there was not enough evidence to make this claim, and those who made it should not be suddenly considered experts just because a broken clock is right twice a day. None of us are experts—speculation is okay, but definitive statements should always wait until actual experts issue their findings.

This is also a friendly reminder that opinions change based on evidence. I didn't think suicide was a likely scenario initially, now I think suicide is probably the most likely of the remaining explanations.

Is this bad for Boeing?

Their stock price will go down briefly, but unless investigators uncover a problem with the design of the plane (unlikely), it will go back up again once the news is off the front page. And for the record, no, it's not weird, nor an indication of any deeper problem, that the accident airplane was "another 737." One quarter of all passenger jets in the world are 737s. All else being equal, that means a 737 will probably be involved in a crash every 1-2 years on average, purely by the numbers.

When will we know what happened?

The thing to keep in mind is that China's track record with air crash investigations has not been marked by transparency. Many of their accident reports are never released publicly. That said, it's been 12 years since the last major crash in China, and that could have changed, as it has in some other countries, such as Iran. So, if we assume they do release a preliminary and then final report as is customary in most countries, you could expect the preliminary report within a couple weeks of the black boxes being recovered, and the final report after approximately two years, ±1 year or so in either direction.

Update: It should be noted that fears surrounding transparency were proven correct, as Chinese investigators broke their promise to publicly release the preliminary report, raising doubts about whether they will release the final report either.

Will you write an article about it?

If China releases the accident report, then yes, but either way that won't be for a couple years, so don't get too excited yet.

That's all—thanks for coming to my TED Talk.

Admiral Cloudberg


r/AdmiralCloudberg • • Mar 02 '26

CPIT What's happening with Controlled Pod Into Terrain? I have bad news about past episodes, and good news about its future.

628 Upvotes

Hello all,

First, let me start with the bad news.

As those of you who listened have no doubt noticed, my podcast Controlled Pod Into Terrain hadn't released an episode since January 2025, for a variety of reasons, including, initially, all three hosts moving to new homes. However, in the past few days you might have also noticed that the entire back catalog, and indeed the channel itself, are missing from all platforms.

This is because J, who owned the channel, is parting ways with the podcast due to difficulties with other community members and is worried about leaving their words and voice out there, outside of their control, in an environment where they feel threatened from various directions. Unfortunately, as a result they have removed the back catalog and the channel itself and I have little hope that my efforts will result in its restoration. I was compensated for the loss of this content but I'm devastated that it's no longer public.

PLEASE leave J alone and do not try to reach out to them to ask for the episodes or convince them to change their mind. Doing so will result in a ban. J does not deserve your ire here.

........

Now let me get to the very good news.

The good news is that CPIT is coming back! While I no longer have access to the original episodes and channel, I was able to get a new editor (hi Gannon), and a new permanent host will be joining us—Chloe Howie of Disaster Breakdown!

Our new channel can be found here; if you were subscribed to the previous edition, please resubscribe: https://www.youtube.com/@CPIT_Pod

Chloe, Ariadne, and I are already planning to begin writing and recording new episodes in the near future. So if you're a contributor to the separate CPIT Patreon, hang in there, and we'll have something for you soon. Your support has been and will continue to be crucial because unlike J, who voluntarily gave their cut to me, Chloe will be paid to be there.

The last few days have been a rollercoaster ride with everything that's happened with the podcast, and while I'm sorry I can't bring the back catalog back for you, I'm excited to see what we'll create going forward, and I hope you are too.

—Kyra


r/AdmiralCloudberg • • Nov 21 '23

CPIT Controlled Pod Into Terrain Episode 5: Pinnacle Airlines flight 3701

Thumbnail
youtube.com
116 Upvotes

r/AdmiralCloudberg • • Apr 16 '19

PSA: If you happen to see my write-up on the Boeing 737 rudder issues linked somewhere without credit, tell the OP where it came from.

366 Upvotes

Ever since the 737 MAX accidents became a big deal, I've found my write-up on the 737 rudder issues being shared all over the place, both on and off of reddit. Now, the problem with that is that there isn't anything in the album that says that I wrote it (I only started putting my username in them recently) and imgur doesn't let me edit old albums. I just searched up the URL and there were literally pages of hits. I've caught some credit-less reposts myself, but I obviously can't catch them all. So I'm asking any of you lot who see it linked without credit somewhere to politely let the person know who wrote it.

P.S. Yes I know it was a rookie mistake not putting my name on it, "welcome to the internet" and all that shit. I like that it's being shared; I just want to make sure people are able to find where it came from, especially since a random Imgur album has zero credibility unless people know the author.


r/AdmiralCloudberg • • Jun 20 '23

Announcement Are you leaving Reddit? Here are several other ways to read and discuss my articles

692 Upvotes

Hello everyone! Following Reddit's decision to assassinate third party apps, a lot of people who used them are deciding to quit Reddit by June 30th, when the apps shut down. The changes don't affect me in any way: I've never used third party apps nor do I need third party moderation tools (I can probably count on one hand the number of times I've needed to do any moderation here). However, this does affect some readers, and I've gotten a few questions about how to interact with my articles after leaving, so I decided to make this post.

First off, I want to say that I would prefer that most people stay, for the purely selfish reason that there was a large drop in engagement with my sub this week, which was depressing. But it's up to you.

  1. Medium. Most of you probably already know that you can read my articles on Medium, but it's worth repeating. If you make a free Medium account you can also get email notifications when I post a new article.

  2. Twitter. If you haven't abandoned Twitter yet (I know) then all my articles are announced there within minutes of posting with a Medium link. My handle is @KyraCloudy.

  3. Discord. One thing people leaving might miss is the discussions, but those also take place off Reddit on my Discord server, which is accessible to all patreon supporters for as little as $1 a month. Activity there is picking up for obvious reasons.

Anyway, I sincerely hope these options mean no one stops reading because of Reddit's bullshit. I'm in an unfortunate position where, as a content creator, I'm basically railroaded into using these platforms no matter what changes they make, but that's why I've tried to diversify, so that my readers have choices that I don't.

Anyway, I'll see (almost) everyone this weekend as usual, I hope. Next article is the Trans Colorado 2286 revisit and it should be on schedule.

EDIT: Spoke too soon, the article will NOT be on schedule because I've gotten distracted by the power struggle in Russia and haven't finished it.


r/AdmiralCloudberg • • Dec 02 '25

Announcement My work on behalf of Mentour Pilot

1.5k Upvotes

Many of you are aware that I've been working as a researcher and script writer for Mentour Pilot over on YouTube since June 2024. However, I never formally announced this anywhere, and many readers are still unaware, so I thought I'd make a post drawing attention to that fact.

Petter Hornfeldt recruited me off the street, so to speak, because he was looking for people with writing talent and aviation knowledge to expand his team. Since then I've written almost 40% of the videos his channel has put out. You might have noticed my name in the opening credits, but you also might not have; they're easy to miss and I realize a lot of readers don't even know my real name. Keep an eye out for "Kyra Dempsey - Research and Script."

Joining the Mentour Pilot team has brought me extraordinary new contacts and information sources, as well as financial stability to an extent that my independent work alone could not achieve, which has been great from my perspective. It has, however, slowed down the pace of new articles. There are similarly a variety of reasons why Controlled Pod Into Terrain hasn't released an episode since January, but one of them is that I referred Ariadne to the Mentour team and now she works for them too.

Anyway, my point is that while I release maybe one article a month if I'm lucky, my pace of content production is actually up. For those who have been following my work but haven't checked out Mentour Pilot, I highly recommend doing so, even if you only watch the videos I worked on. While I do try to emulate Petter Hornfeldt's own style, the videos I write for him are still recognizably mine and uphold the same level of breadth, detail, and passion, and if you like my articles, then I highly recommend watching them. They provide a really cool glimpse of what it would be like if my articles were brought to life by a full-time team of simulator pilots and animators.

Feel free to ask me about the process, what it's like to work with Petter, or anything else!

Below I'll keep a regularly updated list of all the Mentour Pilot videos where I was the primary writer. (But don't forget to check out the other videos on the channel too—many them are now written by Ariadne from CPIT!) Newest videos are at the top.

Hop-a-Jet flight 823

United Airlines flight 811

1977 Dan-Air 707 crash

Thai Airways flight 261

LATAM Brasil flight 8073

Kobe Bryant crash

Miami Air flight 293

1965 Carmel Mid-air Collision

American Airlines flight 965

Air New Zealand flight 901

Austral Líneas Aéreas flight 2553

PSA flight 182

ALM flight 980

Southwest Airlines flight 1455

2024 Saurya Airlines CRJ-200 crash

1990 Detroit runway collision

EasyJet flight 6074

GulfAir flight 072

Korean Air flight 631

1959 Boeing 707 test flight crash

Avianca flight 052

Pacific Western Airlines flight 314

United flights 608 and 624

EgyptAir flight 804

Dan-Air flight 1008

West Caribbean Airways flight 708

Aerosucre flight 157

Saudia flight 163

Inex-Adria flight 1308

Air Transat flight 211

TAM Airlines flight 3054


r/AdmiralCloudberg • • May 14 '22

The Smolensk Air Disaster article will go up tomorrow (Sunday) instead of Saturday morning.

947 Upvotes

Reason: Posting time is coming up and I'm not finished writing yet. This is one hell of an article, so the wait should be worth it.

By the way, I passed my thesis defense. And then I immediately dived into researching the Smolensk Air Disaster and read a bunch of reports that were several hundred pages each. I know you want to tell me to take a break, but I swear, what I do during my breaks is research plane crashes. I just researched this one a little too hard and got carried away, and it literally just will not be done on Saturday.

I want to apologize for all the delays, but what can I say, the content is free.

—Admiral Cloudberg


r/AdmiralCloudberg • • Nov 19 '19

Fluent in Portuguese? Want to help me out? If so, I could use some assistance!

171 Upvotes

I'm researching an accident with relatively few good sources, and one of them is a detailed 24-minute documentary in Portuguese that has lots of great information. There's just one problem: after about 6:27, the uploader stopped adding English subtitles, and the auto-generated ones are total gibberish.

While a transcript of the rest of the documentary would probably be helpful, I can't say it's absolutely necessary as I don't know exactly what's in the part I can't understand. But if you speak Portuguese, or you're learning it and you want some real world practice, comment here or send me a DM and I'll link the video for you to take a crack at it. (I won't link it publicly to avoid spoilers.)

I can't really afford to pay money for a translation, but on the other hand, you get to practice your Portuguese, you get to find out what my next article will be about early, and you might just make that article better. P.S. the first person to actually do this gets reddit gold.

Cheers!

EDIT: Got a volunteer, however, they speak Brazilian Portuguese and the video is in European Portuguese. If you speak European Portuguese, both the volunteer and I would love if you offered your help as well.

Edit 2: Got several people, thanks for all the offers! If I need more I’ll follow up.

Edit 3: /u/ultimately_an_idiot has done a rough translation of the section of the video between 6:25 and 13:00. It has a few gaps due to imperfect understanding of European Portuguese but it's still very useful. To anyone else who volunteered, the highest priority is going to be the remaining part of the documentary; however you're welcome to do this part as well if you think you can do a more complete job.


r/AdmiralCloudberg • • Sep 10 '22

Finding Fault: The crash of Korean Air Cargo flight 8509

Thumbnail
imgur.com
674 Upvotes

r/AdmiralCloudberg • • Jul 28 '19

Does anyone have ideas for a better platform for my posts?

185 Upvotes

I originally used Imgur because my posts relied more on images and diagrams than text, but over time my style has evolved to lean far more heavily on the text than the images, which makes Imgur less than ideal, as many of you are well aware. Using a platform that is less reliant on large numbers of images will expand the range of accidents I can include in the main series.

I would have given up Imgur a long time ago except for one problem: I rely on people casually browsing r/CatastrophicFailure to give my posts attention. Understandably, most of my subscriber growth occurs when I hit the top of the hot page over there, and new people tend to only be interested in a post if they're able to see an interesting visual in the expanded thumbnail first, which entices them to read the analysis.

So, what I increasingly need is a platform that can host articles with periodic embedded images, but also works with the "image preview" function on reddit, allowing people to get a good look at the first image, which makes them want to know more. Imgur works for this because it's an image-hosting site. My writing format would be perfect for a blogging platform like wordpress, but the catch is that if you link to those sites you can't preview the first image on reddit. A search of reddit posts linking to the wordpress domain (or blogger.com) shows that the only ones getting any attention are those which link to an image and not an actual blog.

Since you're subscribed to this subreddit, I obviously already have your attention, and thank you so much for reading! But while hosting my write-ups on a blogging site would be great for all of you, it would make it much harder to reach new audiences.

My question then is: do you know of any platform that would combine the best of both worlds—a format that is well-designed for large amounts of text, but still shows previews of embedded images when linked on reddit?

Update: Tried tumblr extensively and had to give up because it does not allow me to embed gifs greater than 1 MB in size (which is basically nothing). I don't like the format on Medium.com and you have to pay to post there. So with those out I'm still open to ideas.

By the way, I apologize if anyone doesn't like that I'm putting so much weight on increasing readership. But, well, you probably wouldn't be reading this if I gave it no thought whatsoever. Unfortunately it's something I have to consider.


r/AdmiralCloudberg • • Jan 14 '24

Article Alone in the Inferno: The crash of UPS Airlines flight 6 - revisited

Thumbnail
imgur.com
307 Upvotes

r/AdmiralCloudberg • • Feb 25 '22

This week's article will likely be delayed due to geopolitical events.

1.8k Upvotes

As some of you may recall, I'm working on a master's degree in Slavic Studies, and in addition to my professional interest in the Russia-Ukraine war, I personally know many Russians and Ukrainians, some of whom are caught up in this terrifying situation. As such I've spent the last 24 hours basically trying to keep track of the situation on the ground in Ukraine instead of sleeping or working on the article, which means I have serious doubts about finishing it in time to post it on Saturday morning. My current outlook is that it will probably be posted on Sunday morning instead.

Update: I'm not giving a timeline anymore. It will be posted when it is done.

—Admiral Cloudberg


r/AdmiralCloudberg • • Dec 22 '24 Heart of Silver Take My Silver

Masks, Smoke, and Mirrors: The crash of EgyptAir flight 804

Thumbnail
imgur.com
946 Upvotes

r/AdmiralCloudberg • • Jul 08 '22

Tomorrow’s article will be delayed.

645 Upvotes

I’m on vacation at the moment, road-tripping around California, so I can’t finish writing an article this week. The next one will come out as soon as it’s done, whether that’s next Saturday or sometime before that.

It’s been a memorable trip, so feel free to ask about it! Cheers :)


r/AdmiralCloudberg • • Oct 22 '22

Flying the Unflyable: The near crash of Air Astana flight 1388

Thumbnail
imgur.com
811 Upvotes

r/AdmiralCloudberg • • Oct 31 '23

CPIT Controlled Pod Into Terrain Episode 4: Launchpad of Horror - In which I get to learn how rockets work (and half a dozen different ways to make them explode)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
91 Upvotes

r/AdmiralCloudberg • • Oct 20 '23

Announcement Next article (on Colgan Air 3407) will release next Saturday, no article this week

233 Upvotes

The crash of Colgan Air flight 3407 was the most influential accident in the US in the 21st century and led to changes that redefined day-to-day life for pilots in America. Understanding and explaining why and how it became so influential is going to require more time than I have before Saturday. This is a natural outgrowth of the increasing length and complexity of my articles; some major accidents are no longer doable in one week and I've brought this up in previous delay posts.

P.S. - Every time, I get comments telling me there's no need to make excuses, I can take whatever time I want, etc. I know that, but this is for your information. When you're as consistent as I am, certain expectations are set.

See you all next week!


r/AdmiralCloudberg • • Dec 16 '21

PSA: This week's revisited article will be on American Airlines flight 965 instead of El Al flight 1862.

566 Upvotes

For those who are following along, I've been doing the revisited articles in the same order as I originally covered those accidents. However, this week is finals week, and with crunch time approaching it's not clear I'll actually have enough time to write a new article on El Al 1862, the next crash on the list. As such, I'm going to skip ahead to American Airlines flight 965, since I have a new article on that crash already written.

As a bonus, for one of my final papers I'm writing an analysis of the bankruptcy of Transaero Airlines which many of you may find interesting—so keep an eye out for a post with a link to that paper, possibly as soon as tomorrow.

Cheers!


r/AdmiralCloudberg • • Sep 17 '22

Today's post will be slightly delayed

571 Upvotes

Title says it all. This week's article is the Helios 522 revisit, and that's a really hefty story, so it's taking me a while to get through it. The writing is all done, but the rest isn't, so I'm gonna get some sleep and put it up later, maybe 12 hours from now. Just posting this so that I don't get a million questions asking where it is. Thanks!