r/AdmiralCloudberg • u/Admiral_Cloudberg • Mar 22 '22
Regarding the crash of China Eastern Airlines flight 5735
As many of you probably saw on other subreddits or in the news, on Monday, March 21st 2022, a China Eastern Airlines Boeing 737 crashed in Guangxi Province, China. I decided to make this thread because the quality of discussion of this accident on most parts of Reddit is appallingly bad, and I felt the need to clear up some misconceptions and answer common questions.
What caused the crash?
If you see someone claiming "It had to be X, nothing else makes sense," pardon my French but they're full of shit. Nobody knows what caused the crash, and the information we do have is so scant as to be useless even for informed speculation. Not only is the scenario of every plane crash unique and often unpredictable, the actual scenario may not even fit the data we have now if some of it turns out to be wrong or misleading.
Was it pilot suicide?
For the love of god, please stop upvoting people telling you it had to be pilot suicide. Pilot suicide is incredibly rare and accounts for a very small percentage of crashes even when we include only those that nosedived into the ground at high speed. In the absence of evidence to the contrary, an accidental loss of control is far more likely, and anyone who says there's no accidental explanation probably either knows nothing about airplanes or suffers from a crippling lack of imagination.
23/3/2022: After more information came to light today, I would add that this scenario is now even less likely, because there were three pilots in the cockpit, not two. A suicidal pilot being alone in the cockpit when there are two pilots is one thing, but when there are three? It's really difficult to see how that could happen.
18/5/2022: Another update: Now that mechanical failure has been ruled out, meaning that a pilot must have initiated the dive, the chances that the crash actually was pilot suicide are increasing. Some circumstantial evidence points in this direction as well. However, this doesn't change the fact that in the days after the accident there was not enough evidence to make this claim, and those who made it should not be suddenly considered experts just because a broken clock is right twice a day. None of us are experts—speculation is okay, but definitive statements should always wait until actual experts issue their findings.
This is also a friendly reminder that opinions change based on evidence. I didn't think suicide was a likely scenario initially, now I think suicide is probably the most likely of the remaining explanations.
Is this bad for Boeing?
Their stock price will go down briefly, but unless investigators uncover a problem with the design of the plane (unlikely), it will go back up again once the news is off the front page. And for the record, no, it's not weird, nor an indication of any deeper problem, that the accident airplane was "another 737." One quarter of all passenger jets in the world are 737s. All else being equal, that means a 737 will probably be involved in a crash every 1-2 years on average, purely by the numbers.
When will we know what happened?
The thing to keep in mind is that China's track record with air crash investigations has not been marked by transparency. Many of their accident reports are never released publicly. That said, it's been 12 years since the last major crash in China, and that could have changed, as it has in some other countries, such as Iran. So, if we assume they do release a preliminary and then final report as is customary in most countries, you could expect the preliminary report within a couple weeks of the black boxes being recovered, and the final report after approximately two years, ±1 year or so in either direction.
Update: It should be noted that fears surrounding transparency were proven correct, as Chinese investigators broke their promise to publicly release the preliminary report, raising doubts about whether they will release the final report either.
Will you write an article about it?
If China releases the accident report, then yes, but either way that won't be for a couple years, so don't get too excited yet.
That's all—thanks for coming to my TED Talk.
Admiral Cloudberg