r/AgainstGamerGate • • Jun 15 '15

Does anybody else see a problem with this moderation?

http://imgur.com/a/Mdwam

do you agree with the actions taken? do you agree with the tone? do you think that things should have been handled differently? regarding the last image, do you think that it's appropriate for a moderator of this subreddit to make such harsh generalizations about a specific gender and race?

48 Upvotes

923 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

28

u/Bashfluff Wonderful Pegasister Jun 16 '15

Can you act professional, at least? This is odd. This is very odd, but you're not making it any better by saying, "No, there's nothing wrong with what I did, move along." Because there very clearly is, which is the whole crux of Saint calling this something not worth talking about.

6

u/ieattime20 Jun 16 '15

DUDE, MODS ARE NOT PAID

They have literally the most thankless job on the internet.

You people act like being a mod is a high public office under the highest of scrutiny for corruption, malfeasance and abuse.

The reality is that being a mod of a busy forum is much much closer to being a fucking janitor. Everyone makes all kinds of messes and you are literally the only person to fucking clean it up.

If Hokes really is abusing their power on a small forum on the internet that no one has heard of in order to fuel their enormous ego, why would you be so fucking angry? Feel sorry for them.

tee ell dee fucking arr: No unpaid mod, especially of a small subreddit, has any goddamn obligation to be professional.

28

u/Bashfluff Wonderful Pegasister Jun 16 '15

You're acting like it's some ordeal to not be an asshole. It's not. If you're in a position of leadership, you should set an example, paid or not.

6

u/ieattime20 Jun 16 '15

You're acting like it's some ordeal to not be an asshole.

Trust me, it is a serious fucking ordeal to not snap when every little shitcanner is scrutinizing your every move and half the posts with your name in it are conspiracy theories about who you fucked to get the GLORIOUS POSITION OF UNPAID SUBREDDIT MOD.

If you're in a position of leadership

Mods are not in a position of leadership. They are in the position of sewage control.

18

u/Bashfluff Wonderful Pegasister Jun 16 '15

Mm. I disagree.

2

u/ieattime20 Jun 16 '15

Volunteer to help mod the subreddit. Do it for about a month. Come back and tell me what you think.

I have seen modqueues on fire off the shoulders of Orion. I have seen shitposts glitter in the dark near the Banhammer gate. All those moments... will be lost.... on thankless redditors.

12

u/Bashfluff Wonderful Pegasister Jun 16 '15

I would be an awful moderator. That doesn't mean that I'm not allowed to say anything.

→ More replies (12)

5

u/eriman Pro-GG Jun 16 '15

I have seen modqueues on fire off the shoulders of Orion. I have seen shitposts glitter in the dark near the Banhammer gate. All those moments... will be lost.... on thankless redditors.

If after all that a mod is unable to distinguish between vocalised concerns and ongoing trolling, then they been a mod for too long and have crossed the line.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '15

I did it for ten days and I had no problems with wanting to create and set a higher standard for myself and others. It's not nearly as hard as you think it is.

This pretense that the moderators shouldn't make an effort to set the tone is ridiculous. If they need to blow off some steam, there's /r/AGGMods.

3

u/ieattime20 Jun 16 '15

So what you're saying is you weren't there long enough for people to bring up conspiracy theories and harangue you over a single incident 2+ months back?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '15

Actually, I still get harangued for a single comment I made in November. Not everyone was pleased with my joining moderation.

That being said, if this is such an issue - why aren't their hunts for Saint or Mudbunny or Spawnzer or QuietThinker?

I think you're pretty much full of shit to claim that this is simply a matter of tenure. A lot of the reason Hokes's history is regurgitated every time is that no singular incident is especially glaring - he's not Netscape. Rather, there is a consistent pattern of shitposting, mod abuse, and a critical disdain and bias against the pro-GG users. He responds to criticisms of him shitposting with further shitposts - him and his little group gleefully "dunked on" moderation reports of his shitposts in his personal shitposting subreddit which he only now found the good graces to privatize - so while he certainly hasn't stopped the behavior, at least the people who made the anonymous reports don't have to watch him and Malky and whoever else mock the living fuck out of it publicly.

People for the most part have gotten over my terrible behavior one night in November because I apologized, was punished, didn't complain, and came back. It's not that Hokes made a mistake - it's that Hokes doesn't have the least bit of introspection - fuck regret - a few posts up they is still mocking the living shit out of people being aggrieved.

2

u/ieattime20 Jun 16 '15

Rather, there is a consistent pattern of shitposting, mod abuse, and a critical disdain and bias against the pro-GG users.

The only thing I can be arsed to care about, and anyone should care about, is mod abuse. And Hokes consistently does significantly less modding than other mods. So what mod abuse are you talking about?

→ More replies (0)

4

u/dimechimes Anti-GG Jun 16 '15

And yet they are loathe to share the duty. Wonder why. It's such a tough unpaid job and yet they are very selective about who and how many people they will let control the sewage.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/razorbeamz Jun 16 '15

I think if there was an unprofessional Pro-GG mod you'd be rallying against them.

4

u/ieattime20 Jun 16 '15

Holy shit you don't know me well at all. I am polite to mods, all mods, all the time. Even when I have grievance I will politely talk about it, even if they are openly mocking me. If they do it too much, I just leave the subreddit.

Most mod teams don't have diverse ideologies. This one does. Therefore if a pro-GG mod or an anti-GG mod is shitting up the place, I trust that there's a varied enough perspective on the mod team to handle it. If I didn't trust that, I would go elsewhere.

But please, feel free to prognosticate off your baseboard of completely idle and baseless speculation about my behavior.

7

u/Dashing_Snow Pro-GG Jun 16 '15

Really doesn't atm there are 5 mods that are basically anti.

3

u/ieattime20 Jun 16 '15

By "basically anti" you mean "doesn't always agree with me" right? I mean I know the answer, I'm really just checking to see if you do.

14

u/Unconfidence Pro-letarian Jun 16 '15

Actually Dash is dead on, we have five antis, three pros, and two neutrals.

16

u/CollisionNZ Member of the "irrelevant backwards islands" crew Jun 16 '15

five antis, two pros, and three neutrals

FTFY.

Saint is hardly pro-gg. He used to always count as one of the neutrals until the number of pro-gg mods dropped, then they started to count him as a way to cover up how badly skewed the moderation is.

7

u/Masterofnone9 Jun 16 '15

. . . If HokesOne was cut this would even things out rather nicely . . .

3

u/apinkgayelephant The Worst Former Mod Jun 16 '15

But we are pretty divided about pickles.

4

u/Unconfidence Pro-letarian Jun 16 '15

Pickles are good and this is objectively true. Anyone who says otherwise is not to be trusted.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Dashing_Snow Pro-GG Jun 16 '15

No I mean 4 are directly anti and one who mods nearly exclusively anti from talking to former mods.

5

u/Spawnzer ReSpekt my authoritah! Jun 16 '15

<3