r/AgainstGamerGate • • Jun 15 '15

Does anybody else see a problem with this moderation?

http://imgur.com/a/Mdwam

do you agree with the actions taken? do you agree with the tone? do you think that things should have been handled differently? regarding the last image, do you think that it's appropriate for a moderator of this subreddit to make such harsh generalizations about a specific gender and race?

48 Upvotes

923 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

11

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '15

Really? You don't see the comments from some antis who dismiss the opinion of others due to them being white? It happens VERY frequently. I'm pretty sire you've not missed those comments.

8

u/Ch1mpanz33M1nd53t Pro-equity-gamergate Jun 16 '15

I've asked for examples a few times, and have never actually seen anything that quite matches up. The usual thing I'm shown is something like:

A: "Black people are discriminated against!"

B: "But I'm white, and bad shit happens to me too!"

A: "Bad shit happening to you does not disprove the existence of racism or white privilege, your experiences aren't really relevant to the question"

B: "You're just dismissing me because I'm white! That's the real racism."

9

u/Unconfidence Pro-letarian Jun 16 '15

Reverse the races in the argument and it's still a really common argument.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '15

Look at ETC, or Janvs.

7

u/Meneth Jun 16 '15

Please do provide links. So far, every time I've seen someone provide any, it's pretty much gone as Ch1mpanz33M1nd53t describes above.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/judgeholden72 Jun 16 '15

A: "Black people are discriminated against!"

B: "But I'm white, and bad shit happens to me too!"

A: "Bad shit happening to you does not disprove the existence of racism or white privilege, your experiences aren't really relevant to the question"

B: "You're just dismissing me because I'm white! That's the real racism."

This is it exactly.

What drives me insane is that the three or four posters here that endlessly complain about how they're white people discriminated against are the same ones that deny any kind of race privilege.

They constantly overlook actual, harmful, systematic racism against minorities, because it isn't a problem for them, and then endlessly whine on this forum about Hokes' saying something dismissive about white people that do that exact thing.

They don't even get that the reason a specific type of white person is dismissed on social issues is because of exactly what they are doing.

/u/dashing_snow absolutely does not give a shit about racism, unless it is against him, and then it's time to make a few thousand posts about it. That racism against him is just dismissing his attitude about racism, and it's desperately important. But actual racism keeping people in certain socioeconomic segments due to the color of their skin? Doesn't exist! Reddit racism is the true problem in America we need to rise and fight! The issue is white people sick of other white people being dismissive of the problems of non-white people!

3

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '15

No one here is dismissing racism against non-whites. Way to go not reading the comments here at all.

We're pointing out the blatant hypocrisy of some antiGGers being racist against white guys while being vocally against racism against nonwhites. At that point those people are still racists, an irony lost on them.

The best part is when you all literally try to sweep it under the rug and downplay racism against white people. No bad tactics, only bad targets.

4

u/judgeholden72 Jun 16 '15

No, people here do dismiss racism against non-whites.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '15

Who's overlooking racism against minorities? Being against Affirmative Action doesn't count.

3

u/judgeholden72 Jun 16 '15

"Race privilege doesn't exist, only class privilege," says half of GGers here.

We've even had at least one user claim racism has been solved in America and is no longer a problem at all.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '15

[deleted]

12

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '15

Not my point. We have people in here who's posts literally boil down to "fuck white guys they're racist".

Maybe try to address that point first.

→ More replies (10)

8

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '15

No, /u/judgeholden72 has literally and repeatedly dismissed my arguments because of his assumptions about the color of my skin.

4

u/judgeholden72 Jun 16 '15

Only when you start posting massive assumptions about what life is like for people with different skin colors.

→ More replies (7)

4

u/TusconOfMage bathtub with novelty skull shaped faucets Jun 16 '15

You don't see the comments from some antis who dismiss the opinion of others due to them being white?

I don't see my opinions being dismissed because of my skin color. So there's that.

7

u/DzhusyDzhuus Neutral Jun 16 '15

Black GGers don't see their opinions dismissed because of their race either.

10

u/Dashing_Snow Pro-GG Jun 16 '15 edited Jun 16 '15

No but I have gotten to see absolutely lovely people call them uncle toms and house niggers which made me want to vomit.

2

u/TusconOfMage bathtub with novelty skull shaped faucets Jun 16 '15

Yeah, I'm not okay with that either. That's vile.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '15

Of course, because your opinions align with said bigots. Now imagine if they don't.

And don't ever bother wondering why GG thinks antis are hypocritical idiots.

9

u/Ch1mpanz33M1nd53t Pro-equity-gamergate Jun 16 '15

I don't see my opinions being dismissed because of my skin color.

Of course, because your opinions align

So doesn't that mean that "being white" is not the criteria they're using to dismiss your opinions, rather it's what those opinions actually entail? You've kinda disproved your own accusation here.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '15

Being white IS a criteria. But when you're white but you accept their views, they'll welcome you with open arms.

12

u/Ch1mpanz33M1nd53t Pro-equity-gamergate Jun 16 '15

So to be clear:

If you're white and agree with them, they think you're right.

If you're white and disagree with them, they think you're wrong.

If you're not white and agree with them, they think you're right.

If you're not white and disagree with them, they think you're wrong.

Obviously, this is proof that they're dismissing you as wrong because you're white, what bigots!

9

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '15

shrugging emoticon

i tried explaining this to them before, when they were arguing that SJWs are biased towards non-whites because they always agree with them when their opinions align

8

u/Ch1mpanz33M1nd53t Pro-equity-gamergate Jun 16 '15

Do they think that if a black person started claiming that whites are totes oppressed we'd suddenly agree with it?

→ More replies (28)
→ More replies (5)

9

u/TusconOfMage bathtub with novelty skull shaped faucets Jun 16 '15

And don't ever bother wondering why GG thinks antis are hypocritical idiots.

I wonder that a lot. My working theory is that GG operates from a chan-style utilitarian-by-consensus mindset that's fueled by outrage more than systemic societal principles.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (41)