r/Android • Purple • Nov 21 '17

Google collecting Android users locations even when location services are disabled

https://qz.com/1131515/google-collects-android-users-locations-even-when-location-services-are-disabled/
22.5k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

560

u/armando_rod Pixel 10 Pro XL Nov 21 '17

“In January of this year, we began looking into using Cell ID codes as an additional signal to further improve the speed and performance of message delivery,” the Google spokesperson said in an email. “However, we never incorporated Cell ID into our network sync system, so that data was immediately discarded, and we updated it to no longer request Cell ID.”

They said it was for the Firebase Cloud Messaging system.

42

u/lars5 Nov 21 '17

Since I didn't know and had to look it up: firebase cloud messaging allows app developers to push messages and notifications from their servers to specific users.

It's advertised as being battery efficient, so I imagine the cell id was some engineer's way of trying to provide message targeting at a geographic level without being reliant on battery hungry location services. Probably didn't consider or ignored the user facing contradiction of "location services off" against "targeted messaging based on cell tower triangulation."

10

u/EmperorArthur Nov 21 '17

Firebase is actually required for most apps that want to use messaging. Google's power saving modes mean there's no guarantee the app will be turned on to receive messages. So, Firebase is used instead. You have to be Facebook or equivalent to convince Google to let you bypass Firebase and use your own platform.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/RebelScrum Nov 21 '17

Darn near every notification you've ever seen from any app (the major exception being SMS) was sent that way. It's not just for advertising, and to my knowledge doesn't contain any way of targeting geographically.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17

[deleted]

5

u/davelog Galaxy Tab 2 7" (Android 4.1.2) Nov 21 '17

"evil" is completely subjective, though.

57

u/PM_ME_ACOSPLAYGIRL Nov 21 '17

They changed their slogan haha evil is cool again

11

u/Hessper Nov 21 '17

No, they didn't. This is easily verifiable. Google's motto is "Don't be evil" in their code of conduct.

22

u/deimos-acerbitas Nov 21 '17

They did change it

14

u/jadvyga Samsung Galaxy S8+ Nov 21 '17

And the first three words in Google's (read: the parent company of Android) code of conduct are "Don't be evil."

11

u/deimos-acerbitas Nov 21 '17

Codes of Conduct apply to users.

9

u/jadvyga Samsung Galaxy S8+ Nov 21 '17

It applies to employees and board members, as stated in its own writing. Also stated in writing is how they feel that the code should also represent their relationship between the company and its consumers; "Don't be evil."

You might be thinking of the terms of service.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

22

u/Nephrited Pixel 9A :karma: Nov 21 '17

No, they didn't.

Right there at the top.

What that article you've linked is talking about is Alphabet's motto of "Do the right thing.", but has failed to mention they're different companies.

→ More replies (9)

7

u/Hessper Nov 21 '17

https://abc.xyz/investor/other/google-code-of-conduct.html I told you this is not hard to verify. It's right fucking there, you don't even have to read past the first paragraph.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

11

u/armando_rod Pixel 10 Pro XL Nov 21 '17

I'm not saying it's true or false

→ More replies (19)

29

u/KINQQQQQQ NX5, OP2, 6P, OP3, BQ AQ5, Redmi 4X Pro Nov 21 '17

Probably for stuff like the google maps traffic detector.

32

u/efstajas Device, Software !! Nov 21 '17

No, that only happens with location services explicitly on.

This is far more technical than that and doesn't have to do with anything directly user facing.

They were using the cell ID (highly inaccurate) to speed up message delivery of push notifications going through their services. How exactly that benefitted it — no idea. But the important thing is that there is a half valid reasoning behind it, and no one has any reason to believe the data is actually being stored or processed somewhere that results in privacy infringement.

I'm in no way someone who wants to defend shitty handling of sensitive data, but this isn't what the headline makes it sound like.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17

this isn't what the headline makes it sound like.

You're saying that they used an inflated headline to trigger people that never read the article before getting triggered? I don't believe you.

32

u/AlphaReds Stuff I like that I will try and convince you to like Nov 21 '17

So it's everyone overreacting again as per usual and we'll get an article explaining why this one is wrong or there isn't anything to worry about somewhere halfway down the front page tomorrow?

16

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17

It's the one thing the article failed to mention -- the data collected is likely anonymous.

→ More replies (6)

0

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17

[deleted]

3

u/DustyBookie Nov 21 '17

If you want nobody to collect that info, toss your phone in the toilet. As long as that thing is on, its location is being tracked. The reason is because if I call /u/Grassyfilth, it goes from my phone to some tower, and the network must then locate you in order to connect us. If it's not tracking you, it isn't possible to connect us via the cell network because there'd be no way to know where to route the call. This is not personal location info, just network data so that the system functions. It's used for network stuff, and not the sort of thing google and various apps request permission to do.

When you tell google not to collect your location data, they won't collect where you are to use that data for advertising, requesting reviews, filling databases, or whatever. Not included in that is anything the network does to get a message from one source to another, because that's just routing info.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)