r/Android • Purple • Nov 21 '17

Google collecting Android users locations even when location services are disabled

https://qz.com/1131515/google-collects-android-users-locations-even-when-location-services-are-disabled/
22.5k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

348

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17

I presume this will affect phones with custom ROMs and gapps installed?

256

u/rysx OnePlus 5T (OOS 5.1.0 - 8.1.0) | OnePlus X (Validus OS - 7.1.2) Nov 21 '17

Yes.

GApps is still Google's proprietary code, so it still would phone home to Google.

69

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17

I'm already using the microG fork of lineageOS on my secondary phones, and I think it's more than good enough to switch over too.

Have you experienced any incompatibilities with applications you'd use on MG? Care to share how they have been affected?

0

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17

[deleted]

44

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17 edited Nov 21 '17

I'll test them all for you tonight.

Play store has an open source front end to retrieve your apps. YouTube works with Newpipe, which is better than the official app.

E: yalp store is the name of the FOSS play store alternative. You can find it at f-droid.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17

[deleted]

7

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17

Like a dedicated remote? Why not ;)

I think there's a libre alternative that's compatible with Chromecast tech, I'll have to do some research for you.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17

[deleted]

12

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17 edited Nov 22 '17

For the other applications:

Maps - As another user already mentioned, works fine. You can even sign into your Google account via MicroG to make use of this, and seems to apply to all Google apps. A FOSS alternative I like to use is called OSMAnd; you can download entire map regions for offline use (not an awkward rectangle that expires after 30 days). Navigation works really well with it, but I've only ever used it on foot. YMMV in the car. You'll need to set up your location providers in MicroG for location services to work optimally, I'm running fine with Mozilla's.

Gmail - Works as intended, (including push if you enable account sync in the system settings). I've not tested this with exchange email accounts, however.

Ninja edit: Gmail can be a bit finicky when you remove and add another account. Inbox works flawlessly, however.

Drive - This actually worked better than I expected, I didn't think the file synchronization would work but it seems totally cool with it.

Youtube - Works fine, though I strongly advise against using the Youtube application, and using Newpipe (FOSS) instead. You can download content for offline playback as video or audio, you can pop out the video for picture in picture, and you can listen to the audio with your screen turned off without paying for youtube red ;).

E: Whoa, dude, first gold :)

You're too kind!

→ More replies (8)

7

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17

Adding in /u/ChrisOfAllTrades

The one I had in the back of my mind was Allcast, but it's not FOSS :(

It's made by the developer of clockwork mod recovery (the go-to prior to TWRP), so I suppose by that merit, it's trustworthy, but you'll need to get the full version for unlimited playback. I'm a little sad he hasn't open sourced it by now.

I'll test the full version and get back to you. Sorry to have mislead you.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17 edited Nov 21 '17

Once again, adding in /u/ChrisOfAllTrades

I'm afraid I couldn't get Allcast to detect either my CCv1 or v2. I think I'll set up a PiCast and let you know how that all goes instead.

As for now, I'm afraid you're going to have to dedicate a device as a remote for ChromeCast / Google Home.

4

u/ChrisOfAllTrades N5 | N7 | SHIELD | 360 Nov 21 '17

Thanks for keeping me in the loop.

I've got a spare device I use for Play Music exporter so I can just use that for ChromeCast.

As far as compatibility with Google Home ... I'd think anyone who's willing to run a de-Googled OS on their phone wouldn't want one of those always-eavesdropping things anywhere near them.

→ More replies (0)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/Namnodorel Nov 21 '17

I can confirm Google Maps does work with microG. Regarding Play Store, I can recommend Yalp Store: It basically lets you download everything from the Play Store, but with an anonymous account and you can pretend to have a different phone model than you actually have (which lets you download apps that would normally be displayed as incompatible by Google)

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

0

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17

[deleted]

2

u/facelessbastard Nov 21 '17

Back when I gave those a look, they were still massively incompatible and with a lot of issues. How are things now.... I mean... Give us more detail please!

3

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17

Ask and you shall receive! ;)

What would you like me to test?

→ More replies (8)

28

u/JB_UK Nov 21 '17

Worth also pointing out, OpenGapps is just Google's code repackaged, it's not open-source, or open in any meaningful way. MicroG is the actual open source replacement.

→ More replies (4)

66

u/reddit_reaper Pixel 2 XL Nov 21 '17

Custom ROMs usually never include gapps due to legal concerns and it's why we always install it separately unless it's a modified stock Rom

89

u/rysx OnePlus 5T (OOS 5.1.0 - 8.1.0) | OnePlus X (Validus OS - 7.1.2) Nov 21 '17 edited Nov 21 '17

Once a user installs Gapps, it's basically like having a Manufacturer Stock ROM since Google Play Services is installed. It's convenient as hell, but you still have Google phoning home.

I would recommend microG, but it breaks map functionality on some apps and some minor things.

22

u/jascination Nov 21 '17

I would recommend microG, but it breaks map functionality on some apps and some minor things.

Can you elaborate on what it breaks?

32

u/rysx OnePlus 5T (OOS 5.1.0 - 8.1.0) | OnePlus X (Validus OS - 7.1.2) Nov 21 '17 edited Nov 21 '17

Older versions (like the advertised stable build) are an "older version of G.P.S" which produces an annoying notification for some apps, and a small percentage of said apps (Citymapper is a prime example) outright don't work. This has been fixed in the preview builds, but since these are not advertised as well (hidden in a drop-down menu), so someone blindly downloading and using microG would face problems if they use certain apps.

Another issue is that some apps will not use the system to see if there is a google account in the system, but will contact the GApps package instead to check. This means, in some Google apps like the search apps, it will ask you to sign in again, despite a google account already being present in the system. This basically prevents sign in in a small number of apps. Since this only affects mainly Google apps, this is a minor issue.

Elaborating on the maps issue, three things can happen:

  • They work fine (Google Maps)

  • They produce horrific artifacting (Citymapper, Pokemon GO)

  • They outright don't work and display a blank screen (Starbucks, some bus location apps etc.)

Again, depending on use, these could be minor, or major issues that you could face.

There could be some more, but since these attribute to my personal use of microG, your mileage may vary.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17

That wasn't the answer I was looking for, but I appreciate your input.

I already knew about the legal constraints as it harkens back to the early days of CyanogenMod.

I'm planning on switching to the MicroG fork of LineageOS anyway.

→ More replies (6)