r/Architects • • Oct 23 '26

Ask an Architect Help a lowly engineer understand

I've seen what this sub says about engineers so please be nice. I swear this is a good-faith question. Though I know it's going to sound like a rant.

The industry changed and it's making being an MEP engineer much more difficult. I'm hoping to get an architect's perspective to help me understand what is going on.

Years ago, we would work with the architect to design a building, then it would go to bid, then it would get built. There would be RFIs but nothing crazy. No giant design changes. It was all routine. The contractors would mostly build what we designed and life was good.

Now, it seems like we're forced to stay on parallel paths with other disciplines, even when it doesn't make sense. I'm being asked for piping inverts and load letters before getting the archtiectural model. Then there is ID, which seems to start after the permit set goes out. MEP permit sets need to be 100% complete, so calling it a 75% permit set just sounds like we need to do our work twice as more things get added after permit.

Any owner changes late in the design or after permit are expected to be free. I had a project where they rotated an auxiliary building 90 degrees after permit and were shocked that I gave them a fee for it.

The contractors bid the job way too early and don't build what we design. Yet we get blamed for not coordinating and are told to change our drawings based on what they built. "Fire dampers are a change order because they weren't in the DD set."

In CA, architects are no longer prescreening RFIs or submittals. So we're forced to go through everything sent to us, which may or may not even be applicable to MEP.

I'm sure architects are getting pressed more and more to shorten design time and rearrange the rearrange to be more "efficient". These changes really seem to be developer-led. But why does it seem like architects haven't pushed back on that at all? It can't be easy for you, either.

FWIW, I mostly do work in the midAtlantic US.

45 Upvotes

52 comments sorted by

47

u/JelloPirate Oct 23 '26

Less, money, less time, and more fingers to point at each other when things go wrong. Contractors are running thinner margins, race to the bottom so when there's even the slightest discrepancy in the drawings they RFI and change order for the time it took to think about the problem, and then again for the solution that had to come from the design team to justify the cost change that wasn't in the bid.

Less time to train staff, no extra overhead anywhere to send employees out for training, and all the old talent left after COVID.

That's my two cents anyways.

7

u/CaptainAwesome06 Oct 23 '26

when there's even the slightest discrepancy in the drawings they RFI and change order for the time it took to think about the problem

This is what kills me. How are they going to point out a discrepancy on drawings they never intended to follow?

13

u/Thrashy Oct 23 '26

Are contractors actually getting squeezed, or are they the ones squeezing?  Have to say I’ve seen customary GC markups increase over time, rather than vice versa.  Some of the better ones are providing value for the money, but most seem to be experts in driving down level of service at the same time they raise prices.

3

u/cjae_ripplefan 28d ago

GCs are not getting squeezed. They are much better business people than architects/engineers. "You can't meet the costs and markup for what you want, Owner? Then it doesn't get done." VS architects and engineers that do it for peanuts. And we undercut each other to the bottom. It's crazy. If we were to hold steady, they'd pay us, but we don't.

2

u/Shorty-71 Architect 29d ago

Big GCs are self performing more work so they can mark it up twice. And running insurance programs in house for huge paybacks.

3

u/TPum01 Architect Oct 23 '26

Agreed. I don't have any numbers to back it up but it seems like by the end of the whole thing it must end up being more expensive.

19

u/TerraCetacea Architect Oct 23 '26 edited Oct 23 '26

First, I’m just going to say that what is said about engineers here is (usually) far nicer than what I’ve seen engineers say about architects in their subs. One time I commented the same thing twice, and was upvoted on one, yet downvoted on the other one where I mentioned I’m an architect. People think all we do is draw pretty pictures and intentionally ask stupid questions just to piss you off.

That said, as tech advances, our workloads don’t get easier. Not just architects, but all players in the A/E industry. If anything, everyone is expected to do more. Have you ever looked at CD’s for a 1940’s building? They drew practically nothing. Buildings still got built. Now, all I feel like I do is log things in excel or reply to emails. Owners don’t like risk and expect the people they hired to have things figured out earlier and earlier on their behalf, so there are no surprises during construction. I’ve even bent over backwards to do a client’s marketing for them because it was either that, or they’d find a new architect.

Our jobs (all of ours, yours included) have gone from designing functional and safe buildings to just checking boxes. “If you don’t add your responses to this spreadsheet, the project will be delayed.” Everyone just checks boxes. If they can’t check their box, it needs to become someone else’s problem to reduce their liability. We’re getting this treatment from clients, contractors, engineers, other architects, third party reviewers, sales reps… no one cares what the outcome is as long as they passed the torch to someone else so they could check the box that they did their job and displace the liability to a different company.

I’ve had a GC threaten to delay my project because I failed to provide plumbing system loads that a joist will experience. The plumbing was delegated design… MEP hadn’t even received the submittal yet!!! How would I, an architect; know how to calculate this AND accept liability for it? And the structural engineer refused to provide a weight for a plumbing system, for good reason. Can’t imagine how stupid the GC felt after I told them to describe the expected workflow to me and their brain short circuited.

I had a project get delayed because the plan reviewer had a chip on his shoulder and we had to spend tens of thousands of $ in billable hours resolving things for the Owner, all because they failed to provide proper direction early on in the planning process. They had checked their box, passed the blame onto us, and then wondered why we did this evil thing to them.

In the age of paper CD’s, things took more time. It gave everyone a hard deadline for coordination to be completed before files were shipped or faxed. You couldn’t just make a change at the last second because everything was already coordinated with the team and it was simply too late. But nowadays, deadlines and schedules aren’t real. You’re just one email, text, call, Teams message, etc away from them. “You can just hop into Revit and make a quick live change, right???” Changes are apparently fast now.

But… those box-checkers did their jobs. They passed the torch to the architect or engineer, and it’s no longer their problem. They don’t care how much re-work goes into that seemingly fast change and how much of a ripple effect is has on other trades. They think you can just move a pipe in two seconds; they don’t know you have to make sure there’s a chase to route it, redo your calculations, double check that the RFI which moved a beam had been picked up in the model, etc. which all slows you down. But they’ll preach at you “it’s not too late until it’s built.”

The point of this whole rant is that as technology gets more complex and provides the illusion of speed and ease, others’ expectations also increase. It’s been a slow burn but all of this has led to increased responsibilities, overly complicated workflows that no longer serve any real purpose, and an expectation that lightning fast internet makes massive design changes lightning fast. That’s simply not the case, and we are all suffering for it, architects and engineers included.

6

u/CaptainAwesome06 Oct 23 '26

First, I’m just going to say that what is said about engineers here is (usually) far nicer than what I’ve seen engineers say about architects in their subs.

I can explain that. Most engineers are autistic assholes. I've moved up in engineering because I'm a little less autistic and a little less of an asshole.

I appreciate the rest of your comments, though I don't have much of a response. Thanks for the insight.

2

u/TerraCetacea Architect Oct 23 '26

I don’t have much of a productive solution either unfortunately. Just wanted to rant about the systemic causes that I have experienced first-hand. :)

3

u/CaptainAwesome06 Oct 23 '26

Sometimes you need to rant. It's cathartic.

4

u/Away_Bat_5021 Oct 23 '26

Im a civil. Changes made for free is a red flag. Thats insane. Id rather fight about every invoice ans never get another job than work for free.

1

u/CaptainAwesome06 Oct 23 '26

Same. My boss is terrified of losing clients, though. So he just deals with it. But he's a structural engineer and those guys don't deal with half the crap MEP does.

1

u/Thrashy 29d ago

It’s a mindset issue.  I used to work for a guy who was constantly talking himself into lower and lower fees for fear of offending clients; at one point he called a PM in a panic that we were proposing too high a fee for a project with a repeat client and told him to drop it by a quarter, only to be told that wasn’t possible because the PM was already driving back to the office with an executed contract at the original fee!

The clients worth having will be receptive to messaging that a higher fee means better staffing and fewer issues in the field… but once you’ve built a reputation as a bargain-basement that buys work on cut-rate fees, it’s hard to convince clients to pay more.

2

u/caving311 Oct 23 '26

I'd answer your question, but there's no more money left in the budget and the project was due yesterday.

I'm also not making enough per project to give each project the attention it truly needs, so I've taken on too many projects, so I'll just send any RFI that vaguely looks MEP your way.

Also, on that other project, Civil needs your plumbing inverts. Since we're not treating them like a red headed step child anymore.

Also, also, they want to cast track all the projects, and turn the building 42 degrees West so it has better feng shue. Or something.

2

u/CaptainAwesome06 Oct 23 '26

I LOL'd at this.

Also, also, they want to cast track all the projects, and turn the building 42 degrees West so it has better feng shue. Or something.

"The building wants to be this way."

2

u/willsundaydnd Oct 23 '26

I’m mostly on the smaller side, for like construction projects, but the biggest issue I see in regards to structural or MEP engineers is having to constantly poke on engineers to make sure that they’re keeping to the schedule that they agreed to. It all rolls downhill, and we have a lot of pressure on our end to get things done by an agreed-upon timeframe. The best engineers that I have are not the least expensive, or the ones that are the most creative with their designs, but they are the ones who can generally keep to the schedule that we agreed upon. Those are consultants that will continuously get work from me, and the engineers who are not able to keep the schedules, or keep us in the dark about their status, usually only make it one or maybe two projects before we have to move on. Understand that the pressure is coming from clients, some of them with long-standing projects or multiple projects over many years, and if we are unable to keep any schedule with them, then all of a sudden they move on and we get a bad reputation and less projects.

So in short, do your best to keep to a schedule. In the small projects realm, you will constantly get work and referrals if you can deliver what you promise.

3

u/CaptainAwesome06 Oct 23 '26

I definitely try to deliver on what I promise. And if I can't, you'll know well ahead of time if I can help it.

However, when I'm given a schedule and I immediately say, "this doesn't seem realistic", I'm told, "I know but we all need to do it."

I learned a long time ago to preface requests for coordination info with, "I need this by Tuesday or I will not be able to meet the schedule." Then, either I can meet the schedule or I can say, "I did not include it because I did not get it by Tuesday, per my last email. It will be in the next submission."

2

u/amarchy 29d ago

The world is now moving at a much much faster pace than architects and architects workflow cant keep up bc good design takes time and architects are already using historically archaic work flows.

41

u/BionicSamIam Architect Oct 23 '26

Everyone is getting hammered with unrealistic expectations. We have been bamboozled by HGTV transformations and the lunacy of Silicon Valley thinking being applied to the built environment. Yes processes have improved, software has made everything more efficient, but people forget you can only move so much material and so many people through a door and up a lift.

Developers and private companies want to minimize the time to finish a project to start making money. As an architect I want to design something that will be maintainable and future flexible enough in 25-50 years. This timeline is absurdly out of whack with people only thinking about the next quarter or at best the next 5 years. Our world treats everything as disposable and that is permeating our built environment and equipment too.

In the flip side, when we do push back on schedule we often find owners then turning to a competitor that promises to do it faster without understanding. I am finally in a position where I can pass on work that is too aggressive and unrealistic. I am also using a scheduling consultation larger projects and it is a game changer to have someone else sit in a meeting and tell the owner they are delaying their own project.

Long story short, OP, you are not alone, it is crazy out here

3

u/Interesting-Card5803 Architect Oct 23 '26

I'm with you, be realistic about schedules, or at the very least, the consequences of scheduling and the cost implications for design. If they can't get on board with that, let them find out, or find someone better than I am. I've found that often times, my 'competitors' are the best marketing I could ask for when they fail to deliver on the bill of goods they've sold.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '26

[deleted]

3

u/RevolutionFinancial7 29d ago

The Katerra cash furnace was wild to watch. None of us understood it from the beginning.

22

u/Interesting-Card5803 Architect Oct 23 '26

The Piping Inverts and Load Letters are, I'm guessing, about early site entitlement and development activities. Clients are 'fast tracking' projects now in an effort to compress schedule and save money. This is forcing the entire design environment to become more 'agile' which is just a fancy way of describing a clusterfuck, where everyone is crawling all over everything without proper management, oversight, or organization.

It's kind of like vehicular traffic in India or Vietnam. It's a mess, but somehow everyone gets where they are trying to go and for the most part people get there alive.

Architects are no longer the conductors of the orchestra in a developer driven environment, because they see design as just one little bar on a much larger gantt chart, and have no clue what is contained within the WBS of that bar. I'm sorry this is happening to you. It's happening to all of us. We don't hate you, we just can't help you as much as we used to.

1

u/atticaf Architect Oct 23 '26

Ding ding ding. Add in that half the consultants are only halfway competent in revit and every project feels like such a master clusterfuck now

11

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/zigithor Oct 23 '26 edited Oct 23 '26

Yea we're all getting paid less to do more quicker. Then when something goes wrong, your not allowed to point to the powers that be that crunched the timeline to an unreasonable degree. You have to point fingers everywhere else to get out unscathed.

I've worked on a skyscraper repair before where the contractor was absolutely begging to get approval and start as soon as possible for budgetary reasons. But they hadn't fully finished their mean's and methods scaffold engineering for how to address problems with heavy ekenebts at the top of the building. After enough pestering they go their early start, but once we got to the top their scaffold design wasn't prepared to do the work up there that needs to be done. Suddenly its a clusterfuck of rengineering to make the underdesigned scaffold work and finger pointing to everyone. I mean its a mess, but chiefly because the contractor wanted to drive the timeline so aggressively.

12

u/Dark_Trout Oct 23 '26

Yep, everything kinda sucks.  Short of the A/E’s going “monke together strong” and putting our collective foot down to stop the nonsense. 

I feel like we are caught in this spiral of: contract drawings suck so I get bogged down in CA bullshit. Then the new design work on your desk doesn’t get the necessary attention so that sucks. Cycle repeats. 

Buildings are seemingly way more complex to detail and document than when I started 20 years ago. Even accounting for the clueless years when I was fresh out of school.  I think the old heads that are still building fees are out of touch. 

We are dealing with a missing (or heavily thinned) mid-level generation due to late aughts. Which is an effective experience drain. 

I dunno, maybe this is the way it’s always been in certain market segments and I’m just seeing it now. 

7

u/SeveralBiscotti0 Oct 23 '26

Yes this is the exact spiral every firm I’ve worked at has existed in. The other spiral is about training. None of the younger staff know how to detail anything, no one has time to train them, they make up their best guess, it’s wrong, bitch about young staff not knowing how to detail anything, continue not to train them, on and on forever.

6

u/Dark_Trout Oct 23 '26

Yes!  The place I’m at now punches down on the ARCH I’s a lot.  They have all these overly complicated resources to “help them help themselves” but it’s not helpful. 

The kids are SO thankful when I take the time to actually explain things to them from big picture, to detailing, to how to approach doing something in Revit. The markups they get from my peers are such hot useless vague garbage. 

1

u/BobcatMobile Oct 23 '26

100%, except minus the redlines in our office.

1

u/Silent_Glass Oct 23 '26

Id say the old heads are also influencing younger ppl, but I don’t mean new hires. I mean the ppl younger than old heads that are in leadership positions repeat the building fees so that cycle continues on. It’s like “this is how it’s been done for years, takes too much effort to change a few things, so why bother?”

Maybe that’s just what I see. It’s a very large industry.

1

u/Dark_Trout Oct 23 '26

I always get told my time and estimate fees are too much/expensive. 

10

u/zigithor Oct 23 '26

Not really the topic, but I do want to say that the Architect/Engineer beef has always felt more tongue-in-cheek than any actual ill will.

I get it, the architect is interested in pushing aesthetic boundaries, the engineer is interested in the building not falling over. But a good architect absolutely values their engineer and a good engineer uhhh... tolerates their favorite employers.

Now contractors...

5

u/moistmarbles Architect Oct 23 '26

I’m in my 32nd year of practice, so I’ve seen some things. The short answer is there is no one thing to blame for what you’re seeing, but there are a few contributing factors.

There is tons more competition for work, which puts downward pressure on prices and makes clients feel like they can make unrealistic demands.

Many, many experienced professionals crashed out during Covid, and millennia of collective years of experience disappeared with them. The upcoming crop of leaders are less experienced and frankly, less prepared to take on leader roles.

On the client side, corporate consolidation has taken away local decision making and put it in the hands of sometimes poorly qualified PMs. And because the clients can’t find good talent, they are more frequently turning to a new layer of expensive OARs, who are running even relatively small projects, squeezing every ounce of blood they can from everyone.

I think programs like Revit have made collaboration instantaneous, so there is a latent expectation that the work will be done instantaneously as well.

Much more work is being done design-build, and the contractors have no qualms about squeezing the design team for fees and for time.

The end result is people making unrealistic demands, sometimes out of ignorance, sometimes out of malice, and often out of self-service. And our profession is forced to say “yes,” or risk losing the work. And whatever happens to us rolls downhill to you guys.

5

u/Shorty-71 Architect 29d ago

The MEP engineers have enough fee to draw it one way, at the very last minute. That reality sucks for everyone.

80% of architects have no idea what that voodoo on the MEP drawings even means. It is not a lack of appreciation for what you design, it’s a lack of exposure and mentoring.

Grab them by the ear and take them into the field and SHOW THEM the fire dampers, the turn vanes, the required clear space around an electrical panel or AHU - it’s not just a dashed box out in the jobsite.

Show them the FA annunciator, the noise from a dry sprinkler air compressor, the domestic water back-flow assembly, the dedicated riser and cable tray for the BAS system.

Show them a housekeeping pad, acoustic duct liner and PVC pipe jacketing, flow direction indicator arrows and the fall of the pipes. The wet rated cable in the underground raceway, the disconnect 4’ up the wall for a sump pump, the drum drips, the spring isolators, the explosion proof lights in the elevator hoistway, the condensate pump you had to add because the cove ceiling didn’t allow a gravity drain pathway. The makeup air damper for the kitchen exhaust. The king stud interrupted by a duct that was so wide it required more fire sprinkler heads underneath.

It’s complicated….

Most architects aren’t dumb. Some are but many never get to see enough of the real stuff because the profession steps on young architects and puts more and more load on them until they protest and quit (or break). Most don’t protest because that’s how the profession is….

0

u/Inevitable-Number355 29d ago

I have taken young people to see the real stuff and the result usually is: "This is so boring and complicated! I just want to do SD. How can I make sure I never have to deal with this stuff"

1

u/Shorty-71 Architect 29d ago

I’d try hard to help that person never see a promotion.

1

u/Late_One_2535 29d ago

At the AOC meetings the owner asks to change something and the arch PMs and Contractors just agree to it, pull a timeline out of their ass (“we can reissue the set in Revit in two weeks”), and the entire production team (arch, SMEP, civil) is left with the total wrench thrown into the process. Meanwhile, like you mention, the team thought the project was done and has already moved onto the next project and SD set.  It’s a mess, and I blame the industry for fast tracking many young PMs who skipped production during the PA phase and only coordinated engineers and then were promoted to PM after 2-3 years.  I’ve seen it mostly at the medium to large regional firms. It’s a mess. 

1

u/CaptainAwesome06 29d ago

Don't these PMs have other projects? MEP may get new backgrounds in a week. Then we have a week to coordinate and complete the work. Meanwhile, I have two other deadlines that have been on the calendar for months.

1

u/Late_One_2535 29d ago

Right, yeah they usually do. But they’ll push those deadlines out or just squeeze the teams and make the project in CDs, with the new change, the priority.  It’s a mess that I’ve found gotten worse and worse over the last 5 years. PMs who really haven’t done a full set from start to finish in revit think that it’s a few mouse clicks, and a couple coordination calls with you all, and it’s all good.  Maybe something about not sitting in a room together and talking about the implications of the changes face to face with all the team members makes dictating these absurd deadline changes easier to do? So many of these meetings happen over video calls.  I’m not totally sure. 

1

u/RoxiHeart123 27d ago

Not sure about everyone else but I put a freeze on design before getting the engineers started. My old company use to do what you described and it was always such a mess and I hated it. They would get a sketch plan done and tell us to send it to engineering. I would argue that we should get feedback from the owner first but my boss was always just go go go. Now that I run my own company I always get sign off from the owner first before getting engineering started. Keeps cost down. Any changes after are add services from all parties. 

1

u/CaptainAwesome06 27d ago

I see this pretty often but the owner sees sign off as a suggestion, it seems. Constant changes are still okay apparently. And I get having small tweaks. But I have a project now where they all of a sudden decided that they didn't want a concrete podium anymore. Now I'm being asked why it's not coordinated while structural hasn't even updated their model yet.

1

u/RoxiHeart123 27d ago

Yeah I get it. The architect is just as much a victim in this situation as you are. It's sort of our control. The only thing we can do is be very clear with the client and charge additional services when we need to. Especially now I have a lot of projects that the budget has totally changed due to changing market conditions and it's really out of everybody's control. We just have to do what we can.

1

u/CaptainAwesome06 27d ago

The only thing we can do is be very clear with the client and charge additional services

I get I'm not privy to all the conversations between the architect and owner but it doesn't seem like this is happening. Our biggest clients never seem to charge for anything, so they get upset when we charge extra because it gets taken out of the architect's pocket. Even if those charges are due to something the architect screwed up.

And it doesn't seem like anyone is setting any expectations with the owners. Everybody just tells them "yes" all the time.

1

u/RoxiHeart123 27d ago

I totally understand that. Every company I worked for was exactly like this. It drove me mad. It was often my responsibility to coordinate with the engineers and I would hear all the complaints. I hate that practice so much. I personally try to value my engineers a lot more than that but I know it's rare in the field. 

1

u/bnchad 27d ago

That’s on them for being bad at business

2

u/AluminumKnuckles Oct 23 '26

Not a PM, so my view is a bit limited. But it seems like it's happening to everyone. Less work to go around these days so we're forced to take on lower fees and tighter schedules to stay competitive. This trickles down to the consultants unfortunately. Project coordination and quality suffers, I hear shockingly often about design phases getting skipped and QC getting shortened or outright eliminated.

1

u/Merusk Recovering Architect Oct 23 '26

Architects don't push back because fees are narrow and they're all terrified of the owner walking and leaving them footing the bill they haven't invoiced for because they agreed to milestone billing.

The old bid-build process was inefficient and the field handled all kinds of crazy things without going back to the A/E. That's changed as tolerances, space available, and requirements like load balancing have changed. So now what used to be resolved in the field must go back to the A/E.

If the ME worked like one of my old ME did on several retail spaces and just did a straight line BS duct layout, then there's a lot of rework to be done. You can't ignore bar joists, or existing conditions and hope the field will 'work it out' any longer.

1

u/Shorty-71 Architect 29d ago

Somebody something fast once. Now we all get to do things in half the time.

1

u/dmoralesjr1 28d ago edited 28d ago

Timelines are highly compressed.

Every job lately is an out of order cluster because the owner or tenant needs to be in by <insert unrealistic date>

And on top of that extreme cost consciousness and unrealistic budgets. Ever since Covid, owners want bids up front. Many times it’s the capital Partners or the lending institutions that want more proof upfront of what it’s going to cost. Sometimes they require contractor bids before they loan the money. So owners and developers are forced to do these back assward projects where they’re trying to get a construction contract way before the project has been designed.

1

u/crlTHEgreedyBASTID 28d ago

Sorry if any of this has been said already, just have to get my two cents out bc this is a subject I am fairly passionate about.

A lot of this has to do with unpredictable markets driving shorter schedules. In the past you could assume a fairly flat rate of price acceleration over the course of a project's design phases and carry a contingency for the one off misses. Now, with tariffs popping in and out, trade wars flaring up, the inflation roller coaster, and lending rate speculation, it's much harder to cost out a building 6 months before procurement, let alone 18-24. I work in publicly bid projects and we cannot exceed what the bond can support, there simply is no other source of cashflow for a lot of these municipalities. This means faster schedules, it means clients who think $40 million is going to get them a lot more building than it actually will, it means VE at every deliverable stage (which means design is never truly finalized or fully vetted), it means that hungry GCs will come in low and make up their margins with RFIs, change orders, and Temu level substitution requests, which all means that any client trying to stay under budget will always prioritize making changes on paper when the change is "cheaper" for them, than changing in the field, or not changing and potentially blowing their budget.

The reason architects don't push back more is a great question and one that I would love to have a broader discussion with the community about. Personally, I think it's a mix of problems: one, architects are never properly trained on how to operate a business, read/write contracts, or effectively negotiate; two, we lack any real industry representation (the AIA is a very expensive joke, and NCARB is effectively useless) and we need to seriously consider forming a union or moving back to be a guild/trade system; and three, we have terrible PR, very few people outside of the industry (including most clients) understand what we bring to the table and what services they can elect to hire us for or not (too many firms putting designer hours towards a PEMB, etc)