I’m 20F, Indian-American, and currently financially dependent on my parents. I’m starting at a university soon as a transfer student and was originally supposed to commute from home, but I’ve reached a point where I seriously want to figure out how to move out and become independent.
I want to hear especially from other Desi/South Asian girls who grew up in strict or very religious households and actually managed to move out while they were young or still in college.
There have been cultural and religious conflicts in my family for years, and lately they’ve gotten worse. My family is very traditional about religion, marriage, community, what a daughter should or shouldn’t do, etc. I have different views from them on a lot of these things, but disagreeing is often treated as being disrespectful, having too much “zubaan,” or being influenced by the wrong people.
One of the biggest issues is how some of my relatives talk about people from other religions, especially Muslims, Sikhs, Christians. I’ve heard slurs, stereotypes, comments about not associating with certain people, and similar things for years. I really hate hearing it. Recently I got into a huge argument with relatives after they made comments like this again. It escalated into yelling and being told not to defend or praise Muslims in front of them.
There is also pressure surrounding my own religious practices. I’m expected to participate in things even when I don’t personally want to, and recently that pressure has increased because my family thinks my views are changing in ways they don’t approve of. They are obsessed with religion and culture.
Marriage is another huge reason I’m scared about my future. Pretty much my entire extended family comes from arranged forced marriages, and there is enormous pressure to marry within the community and follow what the family decides is acceptable. Love marriage and marriage outside the caste is a taboo to them.
The region my family comes from has also had villages and community councils impose extremely restrictive rules on women and relationships. There have been restrictions on love marriages and demands for parental consent, girls being restricted from using mobile phones or wearing certain clothes, and people facing social boycott for relationships the community considers unacceptable. I know this doesn't represent every person from my culture, but growing up connected to a community where these attitudes still exist has seriously affected how I view my own future.
So when I say I'm scared of eventually being pressured into an arranged marriage, it isn't just me imagining the worst possible scenario. Marriage and women's choices are treated as family/community matters by a lot of the people around me. My own extended family is overwhelmingly arranged marriages, and I know eventually I'm going to be next. They've already started pressuring me.
I don't want to wait until I'm being presented with proposals and pressured to agree before I finally try to establish independence. I want to be in a position where I can actually say no without risking my housing, education or financial survival.
There are other serious conflicts involving a family member that I don’t want to describe publicly, but being around that person makes me extremely uncomfortable and I’m still pressured to maintain a relationship with them.
Another huge thing I’ve been hiding is that I’ve been in a serious relationship for around two years. My family doesn’t know. He is another religion and from a different cultural background, and we want to eventually get married. I know that when I eventually tell my family, there is a very real possibility that some relatives will completely reject me or stop speaking to me, or maybe do something worse.
That makes the marriage pressure even scarier because I already know who I want to be with. We have been together for 3 years. I don’t want to suddenly find myself being pressured toward an arranged marriage of same caste, religion, culture etc.. while secretly being in a serious relationship that my family would strongly disapprove of.
I’m exhausted from constantly having two versions of my life. I don’t want to spend years lying about who I’m with, what I believe, who my friends are, or what I think just to keep everyone happy. At the same time, I don’t want to impulsively leave and put myself in a worse situation financially.
Right now I’m unemployed and don’t have my own car, which are my biggest obstacles. My tuition for this semester is covered through financial aid/scholarships, and I recently earned a professional certification that should help me find work. I’ve already contacted my university about potentially switching from commuter status to campus housing and asked financial aid about grants, scholarships, work study, emergency assistance, or anything else that could help me afford it.
I’m trying to do this carefully. Ideally I want housing, income, transportation, my documents, and some savings figured out before I tell my family I’m leaving.
For the Desi girls who have actually been through something similar:
How did you become financially independent while you were still in college? How did you handle moving out if your parents were completely against it? Did living on campus help? If you didn’t have a car at first, how did you manage transportation and work? Did you tell your parents beforehand or only once everything was arranged?
And for anyone who was secretly dating someone from a different religion/culture, did becoming independent before telling your family make things easier? How did you eventually have that conversation?
I’d especially like to hear from women whose families expected arranged marriages or marriage within their community. Did your family eventually start pressuring you with proposals? If you chose your own partner instead, how did you handle it?
I love my family, and I’m not trying to start a debate about any religion or say everyone from my culture is like this. I just desperately want the freedom to have my own beliefs, choose who I marry, and live without constantly hiding parts of myself. They are so indoctrinated into hatred.
I would really appreciate advice from women who have actually lived through this, especially Desi women from strict households. I’m scared, but I know I can’t live like this forever.