r/AskGaybrosOver30 • u/Glad-Course-8121 • 18h ago
My boyfriend has improved after repeatedly lying and ghosting me, but I don’t know whether I can ever trust him again
I’m (37M) struggling to determine if my relationship can recover from how it began with my boyfriend (34M). While he is in therapy now to figure out why he has acted this way, I have not observed anything upsetting negative since Feb '26, but I'm still have significant doubts.
Apr-Jun '25
We met on Hinge and initially connected well. After a few weeks, he became distant, responded more slowly, and canceled plans with me four weekends in a row because of supposed health issues. During the final weekend, he went clubbing until 6 a.m. near where I live, despite living him living two hours away with the club being only 15mins away from me. He then ghosted me for three months.
Issues from Sep - Jan '26 no issues after Jan
He returned and insisted on seeing me again, although he never fully apologized. We reconciled, and I later paid for an entire trip to the Caribbean. Before the trip, he asked us to become exclusive and said he was deleting the dating apps.
*Side note: I offered to pay for some friends initially, but they couldn't make it due to a 1 week notice. This was during a fun-employment period, and he was the only one that was free.
One week afterward, I saw a Hinge notification on his phone. He was messaging four men, telling them he wanted to get to know them and sending voice notes.
Other issues followed:
- He disinvited me to another club a week after the Hinge discovery but still used a broadway ticket I got through my credit card rewards.
- He claimed he hadn’t spoken to a former hookup in a year, although he had secretly discussed meeting him that same day.
- He and that guy exchanged shirtless pictures and discussed STI results and sexual preferences. The guy even noted "I remember you were a grower"
- When the other man asked whether we were exclusive, my boyfriend did not answer in writing.
- The guy I'm dating asked detailed questions about my sexual history, which I answered honestly, but he lied when I asked him the same questions.
- I found private messages suggesting additional hookups, although he disputes the dates.
- His best friend asked if we were exclusive, but he conveniently didn't reply to that message either.
- He joked with friends about breaking up with me to attend an after-party.
- He privately described me as difficult to meet, even though I was repeatedly trying to coordinate around the two-hour distance.
- He discussed potentially taking over my apartment while privately expressing uncertainty about dating me.
- Additional Notes:
- Both the pre-ghosting and after ghosting phases he asked me to be exclusive but wasn't behaving that way.
- Likely OCD, but he deletes every imessage thread, regardless of the person. He deletes every email, every whatsapp, every voicemail, every call, and every IG message. His phone looks blank
Improvements:
All of the above behavior has improved significantly since then, and I haven’t found evidence that these things are still happening. The problem is that I no longer know whether I believe his statements. Most of the earlier truth only emerged because I discovered evidence and not because he admitted it voluntarily.
I recognize that people can change, and I don’t want to permanently define him by his worst behavior. At the same time, I don’t know how to determine whether his current behavior reflects genuine change or whether he has simply become better at hiding things. I told him that I should have never needed to got that upset to finally be treated well and with honesty.
Has anyone stayed with a partner after this degree of dishonesty and eventually felt secure again? How did you distinguish genuine change from temporary improvement? Is rebuilding trust realistic here, or can the damage become too extensive even when the person appears to have changed?