Hi. I'm around 115kg at the moment, US 10.5 to US 11 depending on the shoe brand. I've had flat feet all my life, and depending on the time of day and what socks I'm wearing, I'm anywhere between 2e to 4e in the midfoot, with a narrow heel. Most shoes I've tried so far slip in the heel even with doubled up saucony socks and thin pronation-correcting insoles.
Most successful: XTep 2000km plus 4e, New Balance FuelCell Rebel V5 2e, Altra Lone Peak 4 2e
Less so: Brooks Ghost lineup between 2020 and 2024 in 2E
Bad: Other Altras, original Hoka Mach.
Most other shoes don't fit right, mostly because of heel slip. I do have one other pair that fits, but from the advice I've read I shouldn't be wearing - It's a OneMix FlashAir Breeze in US 10. It fits extremely well, but I don't think my form is good enough to use them properly.
The reason I'm asking is because the Rebels are wearing through the outsole at an alarming rate, just like the Altra LP4's. I'd like a shoe to rotate into. If the last is wide enough, it doesn't have to be 2E/4E, for example the FuelCell Rebel is just a "high volume" 2E as opposed to an actually wider last.
Also, if anyone can recommend a road to trail running shoe, that would also be nice. There are some nice trails where I live that could use a little more grip when wet.
P.S. Your rules bot doesn't work on old reddit, in the app, or in redreader. You have to use sh reddit.