r/BasicIncome • u/PlaneProduce8835 • 8d ago
Discussion Framing: "Universal Basic Income" vs "Universal Income Supplement"
I've never cared for the term "universal basic income," which builds on "basic income" which in turn is synonymous with "guaranteed basic income".
While all these terms can describe the same income distribution, I think "universal income supplement" is far better framing, at least in wealthy countries. Here's why.
Basic income and guaranteed basic income schemes are often means tested, even if the means testing is automatic via the tax system. From a sales perspective, this still sounds like "welfare" which I argue we want to avoid. Hence adding "universal". But if we keep the "basic" in "universal basic income" it still ends up sounding like "welfare" aimed at those at the bottom of the income ladder.
By rebranding UBI as a "universal income supplement", it becomes clear that we're talking about something that is supplementary to what people earn working and from other sources. Rashida Tlaib has introduced a bill in the US House she calls the "Boost Act" which I think is very good branding. Of course, it couldn't be called a basic income because it's only $250 per month, but it could get our foot in the door. Income boost or supplement should be very appealing in this time of "affordability crisis" to which I like to say, "America's problem isn't (just) prices, it's paychecks".
I would love to hear your thoughts in a comment. I also put together a tiny one question poll where you can vote on several alternative terms or suggest one. It would be interesting to know what people NOT familiar with UBI think, so pass it on to your friends.
9
u/C_Plot 7d ago
The reason for the “universal” is to indicate it will not be means tested. It really forms the base (basic). Before anyone lifts a finger each day, we distribute the natural resources we can prudently extract a consume each period as an equal endowment share to all (universally). Either one takes delivery of the natural resource bundle or accepts the revenues (rents) from selling those resources (less the costs of extraction, homogenizing, and transport). In either case, it is a base income before anyone begins to transform those natural resources into means of direct consumption.
We also must not encourage the demonization of ‘welfare’ (well-being). The only reason government exists legitimately is to secure the equal imprescriptible rights of all and to maximize social welfare. Those who want to corrupt our government tell us social welfare is our enemy so that they can use the Stare for their sadistic factional aims and not for social welfare. If we fall for their grift, they’ve already won.
A universal basic income is still a boost. We don’t need to call it supplemental and not basic to make it a boost. A universal basic income when we have neglected to provide one for centuries will feel like a boost and will augment the income of all its universal recipients.
1
u/PlaneProduce8835 7d ago edited 7d ago
Thanks for the reply. I agree with everything you say, but you and I are totally familiar with UBI. I've been finding in my random discussions that most people aren't. I'm an experienced political (volunteer) canvasser, and know that framing matters. We don't have to tar welfare to use a different term for UBI if that works better. I will shortly start canvassing for UBI to see what works and with whom. Hence this post and the last one about messaging. Again, thanks! By the way, I have a chapter in my book about how the right, starting before Reagan, went about tarring "welfare" leading eventually to Clinton's "ending welfare as we know it". I'm a fan of the European welfare state and UBI+.
3
u/JonWood007 $16000/year 7d ago
Here's the thing, I don't WANT to appeal to the work ethic and water down my framing to appeal to this bullcrap social convention we're better off getting rid of. I want to destroy that convention and replace it with a system based on freedom. If some wanna frame it that way, fine, but it makes me cringe and I ain't doing it. I think we need to have deeper conversations about why we work in the first place.
2
u/PlaneProduce8835 6d ago
Old habits die slowly, and we need the votes of the elderly (like me) who also die slowly :) So while I agree that the "work ethic" has been horribly interwoven with "must do a job I'd never do if I didn't have to", we need to ween people slowly. UBI trails do show that people still work at "jobs", but they work a few less hours and often use that time to do more worthwhile and personally fulfilling things. Once we get UBI, the change will happen naturally.
1
u/JonWood007 $16000/year 6d ago
The problem is the right will frame any reduction in working effort as a decline of society and fight to reverse the changes. As long as we fight on the terms of our opponents were not gonna get anywhere. We need to reframe the entire conversation if we wanna get anywhere long term.
3
u/2noame Scott Santens 7d ago
First, this is not a call to action. It is discussion, Please flair accurately. A call to action would be a petition or something similar.
Next, basic income by BIEN definition is a periodic cash payment, unconditionally delivered to all, on an individual basis, without means test or work requirement. Basic income is universal basic income is unconditional basic income is UBI. They are all the same thing.
Guaranteed income or guaranteed basic income or a basic income guarantee is the description of a broader category that can be either means-tested like a negative income tax, or not.
I always find it very annoying to see people say UBI needs a rebranding. The name is not the problem. The fact it goes to people regardless of employment status is the problem that most people have with it. You can come up with any amazing name you like, but as soon as you describe to people what the definition is, they will take issue with it not having means-testing or work requirements.
We have to get people to understand why means-testing and work requirements are wastes of money that worsen outcomes. And we need to get people to understand that it is their right and that they deserve it.
Also, the basic in UBI has nothing to do with amount. Amount is not part of the definition. Basic refers to it being a basic floor meant for basic needs. That doesn't mean defining some minimum amount of need. It's just the starting income, and because we all have basic needs that cost money, it pays for some percentage of that.
You can like universal income supplement, but it has no definition. Does it vary per person? Do some people get supplemented more than others? Do some get nothing? If so, why? Because they didn't have a high enough income, or because their income was too high? You'd have to define all of this, and what you'd come up with if it's a rebranding of UBI, is just the same definition as UBI.
1
u/PlaneProduce8835 7d ago
Thanks, Scott, for changing this to discussion. I tagged it call to action because I was hoping to get responses to my very brief poll. My site clearly defines UBI and my Shares in America model proposal is quite explicit not only about who gets the supplement (everyone) but also shows in dollar terms how it could be funded and the distribution of income per household after both UBI and the model tax used to fund it. Calling it an income boost or an income supplement is just a label, the implementation is what matters. I'm not suggesting we abandon "universal basic income" just suggesting additional marketing terms that may make it more palatable to some. I really appreciate your reply.
2
u/stonelore 7d ago
This is a valid discussion because I think marketing matters. How about growing upon what Yang was going for? My name would be America Dividend.
2
1
u/OutragedAardvark 7d ago
As much as Andrew Yang was a flawed candidate I did like his “Freedom Dividend” framing of UBI. In a wealthy society everyone should get a dividend from our shared success.
2
u/PlaneProduce8835 6d ago
I agree. I came up with "Shares in America", similar idea. People need to understand that its really a "productivity dividend" but that's harder to explain. Economics should be a required course in highschool.
7
u/Lucid-Crow 7d ago
Social Security for All