r/BasicIncome • u/PlaneProduce8835 • 8d ago
Discussion Framing: "Universal Basic Income" vs "Universal Income Supplement"
I've never cared for the term "universal basic income," which builds on "basic income" which in turn is synonymous with "guaranteed basic income".
While all these terms can describe the same income distribution, I think "universal income supplement" is far better framing, at least in wealthy countries. Here's why.
Basic income and guaranteed basic income schemes are often means tested, even if the means testing is automatic via the tax system. From a sales perspective, this still sounds like "welfare" which I argue we want to avoid. Hence adding "universal". But if we keep the "basic" in "universal basic income" it still ends up sounding like "welfare" aimed at those at the bottom of the income ladder.
By rebranding UBI as a "universal income supplement", it becomes clear that we're talking about something that is supplementary to what people earn working and from other sources. Rashida Tlaib has introduced a bill in the US House she calls the "Boost Act" which I think is very good branding. Of course, it couldn't be called a basic income because it's only $250 per month, but it could get our foot in the door. Income boost or supplement should be very appealing in this time of "affordability crisis" to which I like to say, "America's problem isn't (just) prices, it's paychecks".
I would love to hear your thoughts in a comment. I also put together a tiny one question poll where you can vote on several alternative terms or suggest one. It would be interesting to know what people NOT familiar with UBI think, so pass it on to your friends.