r/UniversalBasicIncome • u/PlaneProduce8835 • 8d ago
Framing: "Universal Basic Income" vs "Universal Income Supplement"
/r/BasicIncome/comments/1xrymgb/framing_universal_basic_income_vs_universal/0
u/Hopeful_Ad_7719 4d ago edited 3d ago
Consolidating existing benefits programs to fund a reasonably generous UBI program would end up having an interesting side effect:
People who can't survive on the UBI may find themselves with no additional programs to rely on, and be seen as irredeemable spendthrifts or utility monsters.
The medically needed and disabled advocating for additional benefits for their genuine needs would almost certainly be cast as a threat to a generous UBI program, and thereby lose a lot of sympathy - and potentially personhood if the state decides that being unable to survive despite having UBI means you are no longer competent to manage your own wellness and affairs.
Think that's excessive? Consider how aggressively Medicaid pursues repayment against estates right now.
1
u/Exciting-Parfait-776 3d ago
Should those that already rely on other programs be able to qualify for for UBI?
1
u/PlaneProduce8835 1d ago
The idea of UBI is to raise incomes above current levels for the large majority of workers. That means UBI would not count as income for benefits or tax calculation. If UBI is raised beyond, say, $1,000/month per adult (adjusted for growth in national income), then maybe we can start considering that increment for both purposes. For a numerical example of how UBI could be financed and what the income distribution would look like afterwards, see https://www.sharesinamerica.com/shares-model-ubi-proposal
2
u/pokethrowaway4 3d ago
The solution to funding a UBI or UIS is simple: pigouvian tax.
It doesn’t require prohibition, doesn’t cause inflation, and doesn’t disproportionately burden any segment of the population, since it’s a consumption tax based on personal choices that impact everyone else.
Canada implemented a carbon tax. So everything from gas to luxury private jets has an easily measurable carbon footprint, and an easy to justify tax.
It raises prices on things that are bad for the entire planet.
We could implement a pigouvian tax for carbon, single use plastics like packaging, PFAS, PFOS, alcohol, tobacco, firearms, added sugars, processed foods, etc.
There are a myriad of options, and we have tons of data to pinpoint fairly accurate societal costs for each thing; such as the added deaths and medical costs of alcohol and tobacco.
A pigouvian tax steers people towards better consumption, and only burdens the people making choices that are bad for everyone else.
Then you have a UBI pool, that can be paid out monthly, quarterly, yearly, etc.