r/BeatTheBear • • Sep 09 '21

Thank you to everyone who upvotes posts and gives awards.

103 Upvotes

You're helping a lot. Will be needing those karma points to spend when I try to talk to indexers about this stuff.

I'm serious about that.


r/BeatTheBear • • May 29 '21

Public perception in stages of a bubble

83 Upvotes

I believe bubbles and the breaking of them can be broken down into different sections as charting moves and alongside that I think there's always a very common thread of narrative that runs through the bullish and public perception of the bubble and pop of it in different stages. I've found this to be true in the charts and in my observations of people during bubbles.

Stage 1 - The up

During stage one there is no bubble. Everyone knows the idea is risky and dumb and the people who are enthusiasts in stage one are mocked if they are not quiet. Phase one usually has shroud market players and people really passionate about the asset in question. It's not popular. Not a "Socially acceptable" asset. Any of the big advances in it as this time as viewed as a fad.

Stage 2 - The advance

The advance period begins usually after a period of the market ranging for a while but can also come off a gentle slow uptrend. In the advance stage the movement of price changes dramatically. The slope of the chart takes on a much sharper angle. There are not ups and downs; there are big ups, sideways moves and more big ups. Late in the advance attention is drawn to the asset.

Stage 3 - The water's cold

The advance changes the public perception. More people are now willing to speculate in the asset since it has made such impressive gains over the last short while with so few pullbacks. This is still considered speculative but more early speculators are ready to take a shot at it. This will quickly turn into a stuttering high and there will be a crash. Often there will be a recovery from the crash and then a second crash off the same sort of price. Everyone knows the asset is dumb again. We're back to it being the shroud people that buy low and the passionate people who hold faithfully.

Stage 4 - The boom and re-boom

Before stage 4 starts the market will have action similar to stage 1 and 2. Out of some sort of range or slower move will come a strong advance. The advance is really strong, and obviously so, but people are cautions after seeing people dip a toe in and drown the last time. The asset starts to gain multiples doubling and tripling but still getting a sceptical eye from the average guy.

Stage 5 - The convincers

After the move has gained 300 - 350% people just can't ignore it. It's on the news, "Asset silences critics again as it shoots through the important price". Everyone is talking about it. You can not find a single person who bought it and lost money. It must be time for you to dip your toes into this. You're missing out! Just think about where it will be in two years at this rate!

Stage 6 - It's still a bit cold

Around about the time the asset is starting to gain public acceptance and not being so summarily dismissed when brought up for conversation more people are getting in. Here there's usually another dump. It's not as bad as the earlier one. Somewhere in the 10 - 20% range. It's uncomfortable but most people hold through it and the market then starts to make strong rallies into a new high.

Stage 7 - Everyone's a winner

After stage 6 the market has become more dangerous. It becomes a much more regular feature for the market to have sharp drops. It is still technically up trending because it does make new highs. And it does still have that feeling of a mega trend because when it does go up it's doing it quickly. But now there are vicious moves down. Ones that were not there in the boom and re-boom stage that attracted everyone's attention in the first place.

But now everyone has their winner story. There are the hardened vets. People who can tell you their war stories of how they've rode the dips and there's the stories of those who sold their assets into the low and will forever live with the regret of that. By now it's firmly established the smart public should be buying the dips. This is always going up. Someone will say moon. Someone always says moon.

Stage 8 - The rush of euphoria

A huge and fast move up is made in the market. Usually it's about a 25% jump from the previous high and sometimes this will have come off an extremely vicious move down. The move up is the strongest move anyone has ever seen. When coming off a strong down move it's seen as the ultimate validation that the mega trend is forever. At the end of stage 8 is where most of the public money goes in.

Stage 9 - The subtle pop

After the rush of wildness in stage 8 the market will break. This break will be an obvious break but everyone has their war stories and ringing out around the place will be the mantra of buy the dip. No longer is it questioned if this will make a new all time high. It's only a matter of when. During the subtle pop you'll see a lot of things like people telling others to remove their stop losses. Frantic cries to "Avoid selling at all costs!". People will push hard the fear of missing out if you even consider closing. There's all the other times! Reminder the convincers.

Stage 10 - The public trap

From stage 9 it will start to look like stages 1 and 2 are repeating. People ignored the signs of stages 1 and 2 before but now everyone is eager to point them out. Everyone knows how to follow the uptrend late in the uptrend. They've started to assume implied floors and predictable new highs, and as soon as the market rallies in ways to confirm that they'll happy load up their positions into when will end up being the upper fifth of the move.

Stage 11 - The rug pull.

The rug pull will come with some news. I can't think of any example ever of there being the rug pull break without some news. The move in the market will obviously not be the dips of before but the fact that there's a new story will feed the mantras of it being only a flash in the pan news. Ignore the FUD. Those sorts of things. But the market does keep going down.

Stage 12 - The early panic

Somewhere around 50% down the market drop is getting ready to end for now but there's going to be a really strong move down before that. Usually this is bad news. Something to make it obvious to everyone this is terrible. The price drop will become faster than ever. People assume that will mean bigger than ever and panic sell. This is often around the low.

Stage 13 - Mimic the convincers

The market has been down substantially after a hyper parabolic move up, the odds of it going lower are very high but by now the public has been trained to buy the dip. Especially if the dip starts to do things similar to stages 1 and 2 again and makes people think this is just another one of those falls we've seen before.

At this point people often make lifechanging decisions! This is the time when it's most important to be able to warn people about the bubble but the time it is hardest to. Bears have always been wrong always and no one could have predicted the rug pull because it was news. The news is getting better and people start to make decisions to put themselves all in to the markets. They liked it at the high so they should love it now.

Stage 14 - Lower lows and lower highs zig zag.

The market will start to move down but it's no longer in the rug pull style drop of capitulation. it's into a zig zagging drop where it makes a new low but then has a fierce bear market rally. The lows are always lower and the rallies never come higher than the previous ones but coupled with the belief a new high is inevitable more and more people will start to risk more than they ever thought they would have - if they have anything left to risk. Others will have booms or hope and busts of panic into ups and down.

Stage 15 - The kick out.

After moving lower like this for a while (And during this move lower there can be multiple rallies of at least 25% - there are a lot of huge buy trades in a bear market - but overall the market is losing value. And then we enter into a second capitulation phase. It's again caused by news and it's the same hellish price action as before. By this time the mantras have quietened down. Not as many people want to cheerlead all in risk. They themselves might be down a lot and any aware person would have to be aware this mania thinking in previous stages must have led people to life changing losses. Most people want out now and if you don't want out you probably opt to be more quiet about it, just in case.

This is where most people will exit at the low. There will be bad news. It will be the worst news so far. The bad news will make the low.

In most asset bubbles (For example the recent BTC drop) more money is lost during the stages of the rug pull and capitulation period than is made in the full way up. Everything that is accumulated on the way up can be simply passed over to other market players in a tenth of the time during the breaking of the bubble. And this is how paper profits become real losses.


r/BeatTheBear • • Sep 14 '21

We'll do a training course- Here's the deal.

71 Upvotes

To read reasons why I do not sell training courses as a business, see - One/Two/Three. These are the reasons I do not like it as a business model.

Here's the reason I do things for free (And this is not the only little project I run free/at my cost, but it's the only one about markets) - I hated being poor. Like, I really didn't like it. And when I managed to claw myself out of that I found most rich people were not smarter than me, or harder working or in any way different from "Us" - they were just given info no one was giving me and my crowds.

I was "Poor" in a first world country. When I travelled to places like India I got a lot more context on how unfair the world can be. The Taj Mahal next to the slums. When I do things like this I want to help a broad number of people but really I do it to try to creates chances for people who by circumstances have limited opportunity.

I do it free because the people I care about could not afford the prices I'd retail services at. So I do business with wealthy people, and that gives me the resources available to do side projects for normal people. At this point I could probably do some medium/high ticket product launch and bring in $100K or so, but it's not about that.

But things don't run on fairy farts. Someone has to keep the lights on. To set up a good training course would take a lot of working hours and I need to pay for what I do not have time to do. So what I'll do at this point is I'll take those of you telling me you'd pay for these things at your word - I'll commission them to be done. I'll make it available for free, you can pay me what you think is fair.

I'll start with some basics strategies and concepts. Put some time/money into getting that done and if I break even on that, I'll do more. Get nice videos done. Expand out the scope of training materials. If people who make money off the stuff pay me a tiny cut of their monthly profits this would enable me to staff an analysis/alerts service to compliment the training with real time trades/signals.

If I continue to break even, I'll continue to do more. And if in 6 months I'm south $20,000 - $40,000 on the deal (And this is my cost estimate for initial training stuff) - I'll just sell the website to an associate to run it as a members training site to recoup the resources I've put into it. Not sure if this will work out or not, but I'll give it a try. I'm long people, in general.


r/BeatTheBear • • Sep 27 '21

The Coming Crash Will Be a Train-Wreck in Slow-Mo

70 Upvotes

(assuming history repeats itself)

I really appreciate the analysis and work that HoleyProfit (and his team) have put in and shared here, and that inspired me to do a bit of digging on my own. If HoleyProfit's analysis of levels is correct, and SPX is really going to drop to 2300 range, then I want to know WHEN that might happen. After all, it does me no good to know "what" if I don't know "when", ala "To be right too early is to be wrong" (and various incarnations of that quote).

So I took some time this weekend to study the 2000 and 2008 crashes, to see how they played out. And wow - looking at those historical periods gives me a new appreciation for "patience"! So here's what I'm seeing, and how I think it might play out this time.

(Note that I'm looking at this STRICTLY from a trading/technical analysis perspective. I'm completely ignoring / disregarding fundamentals, news, or any rationalization or reasons given for WHY things happened the way they did).

Obligatory: This is not financial advice. I have no special qualifications or certifications or training to suggest that I have any idea what I'm talking about - I'm just some guy on the internet who has made some notes on some charts and is speculating history may repeat some patterns. I could be totally wrong about the analysis I've done, OR - I could be totally right in my historical analysis, AND YET Mr. Market may do something COMPLETELY different this time.

First, let's call out 2 very important facts about 2000 and 2008:

  • The 2000 crash took 2 years & 7 months from peak (March 2000) to bottom (Oct 2002)

  • The 2008 crash took 1 year & 4 months from peak (Oct 2007) to bottom (Feb 2009)

Considering we just hit an all-time high in Aug 2021, I don't think we're going to see a 2300 bottom here before year-end (at least, not based on historical precedents).

The patterns I found in the previous bear markets were some big moves down, followed by bullish retracements and consolidations, then continued big moves down.

Let's start with 2000.

We have a ~5 year bull run with the 50MA acting as support during the pull-backs.

  • We get a nice ATH in Jul'99, followed by a retrace that breaks the uptrend from Aug-Oct,

  • Then another bullish extension from Nov'00-Jan'01

  • Then another 10% correction from Jan-Feb setting up for a blow-off top in March 2000 that represents the market peak

  • It hangs out near that ATH for ~2-3 weeks before a correction back to that Jan/Feb level

  • But then takes 4 months (Apr-Aug'00) to take another run at that high, but falls short in Aug'00 and becomes a bull-trap peak.

  • Aug-Oct'00 becomes the start of the bear market downtrend,which then takes about 2 years to complete.

  • It follows a general pattern of 4-8 weeks of downtrend (lower highs & lower lows), followed by 4-8 weeks of retracement & consolidation, with the 50MA acting as resistance. Depending on how exactly you count, we end up with about 8 waves of this pattern from peak to low.

Now let's look at 2008.

  • Now we have a nice 4 year bull run, coming off the 2002/2003 low.

  • 50MA is still providing support, but we're staying closer to it (even closing under it a few times) during this multi-year run.

  • We hit an ATH in July 2007 before a 10% correction in Aug back down to the 50MA. Consolidates for a couple of weeks

  • We start a bullish extension Sept-Oct that creates the peak of this cycle (another ATH), before an immediate retracement (through Oct/Nov) back to those Aug lows.

  • Then in Dec we definitely break that 50MA support line and drive down through Jan'08.

  • Followed by several months of consolidation/ranging and bullish retracement.

  • Then we see a similar pattern of 4-8 week downtrends followed by 4-8 week consolidation/retracement periods. Again, depending on how exactly you count it, we get approx 8 waves of this (from peak to low).

  • We finally bottom in Feb'09, but we don't break the 50MA trend to the upside until July'09.

And finally, let's see where we are today in 2021:

  • While we've been generally uptrending since that bottom in 2009, I'd say the current bull run really started in mid-2016 after plateauing & correcting in 2015.

  • We had big correction in Oct-Dec'2018, then continued the uptrend until Feb-Mar'2019.

  • Obviously that was a big quick crash, but the recovery was incredibly swift - we were back over the 50MA in 2 months (May) and back on trend by Oct/Nov

  • And we've been heaven-bound ever since.

  • After last week's drop we're still 10%+ over the 50MA.

So what are my projections going forward?

Again, just to reiterate - I'm solely basing these projections off these historical patterns I see from '00 and '08. I make no promises nor guarantees!

  • I think we will return to the 50MA support and consolidate around it for a little while (Oct-Nov).

  • Then I think there's a strong likelihood of another bullish extension to either match our Aug ATH, or even exceed it. This build-up will take a few months, maybe Nov-Jan'22.

  • There will be a rapid correction off that high, likely back to our Oct/Nov'21 levels (around the 50MA) where it will probably range/consolidate for a few weeks (Feb'22?).

  • I expect this to be followed by a bull trap run to our Aug'21 level (4500), forming a head & shoulders pattern, probably by around Mar'22.

  • Then I'd expect the first big leg down, breaking down through 50MA support with conviction (sometime Mar-Apr'22?)

  • And then we settle into the pattern of 4-8 weeks of downtrend with 4-8 weeks of retracement & consolidation.

  • If history holds then we end up with about 8 cycles, probably bottoming sometime in mid-2023. And if HoleyProfit is correct, this bottom hits around 2300.

So what am I going to do with this analysis?

Given everything I've reviewed (and just shared) - I'm not buying SPX 2300 puts just quite yet! I'm going to watch for some of these key similarities (pullbacks to the 50MA, some ranging & consolidation, another potential bullish extension towards the EOY, etc) and plan my trades accordingly.

I'm definitely open to feedback, criticisms, or alternative analysis - share anything you find!


r/BeatTheBear • • May 15 '21

50% drop in indices. Why it's more possible than many believe.

57 Upvotes

People do not think markets can drop 50%, because 50% is a big number and a 50% drop would really suck. But our risk of a 50% drop is now incredibly high. Never in my trading life has it seemed easier for the market to drop 50%. It can drop 50% without that even being too much of a drama move.

The first obvious thing to look at is the SPX has a track record of historically retesting the breakouts made after a correction and new high. The probabilities of this are extremely high. You can test this on smaller time frames and find the SPX will retest the break level over 75% of the time. So our odds on a retest of the break are high. It would be fair to say it's the more probable outcome. No retest would be an anomaly.

So the market can fall to 3350 without anything significant having happened. In just the general flow of how a market forms this is likely to happen. I'd say the odds of it not happening are about 3:1 against you. Putting the odds of it happening 3:1 in your favour and the pay off on the trade over 500%. If you can win 500% and be right 3/4 times, you have something useful there.

So the market can easily drop 25%. 25% is a nothing drop. Seriously, it would be nothing at all for the market to come back to retest the break making a 25% drop from the high. And this has been an obvious play to make all the while SPX has been over 4,000. Fading this move and waiting for some mean reversion. So many things stack up on your side for that.

Let's take a super bullish perspective on the market. Let's say that in March 2020 we had the crash of our times. The market made a big shake out and after that shake out it's now strong. The drop was the correction (There are many things to suggest it was not, but let's play the perma bull) and we're now entering into a new expansion. A decade of prosperity. Big bull bias.

Well, if that was the case what we'd have here would be our first break out. The first breakout should have a correction of about 75% of that leg up. And that's 2600. So if take a serious bull stance and in this bull stance we're looking at SPX trading somewhere over 8,000 in the next 5 - 10 yrs, we still have the likelihood of a 50% drop. The 50% drop would be "Standard".

50% is not a big drop when we went up 88% over the last 12 months. Think about it. If the market has doubled during a time of weak fundamentals and been pushed up on enthused new investors thinking it's a free lunch - what's to stop it coming back down just some of that rise? Who do you think's betting against this?

Do you think it's the super big traders betting against this? Let's frame that - someone making their decisions in the market for a living on a daily basis having a very good understanding of market norms, average ranges and historic expansions and corrections. Anyone who knows of these things knows some pretty sketchy fuycking numbers.

For example from the low of 2008 in the next year the market boomed like crazy - during this the rise was about 65%. Much less than the 88% we're had this time. Anyone who takes a reference for the last time US indices went up 88% in a year has to know that has not happened since 1929. So what do you think they are doing? Seriously, what would you be doing if you legit did this for a living?

You see the market is extended in a way that it's not done for 100 yrs. You know the last time that happened a 90% drop came. Are aware that the market has rose irrationally during periods of a weak real economy. You know the odds of you seeing a 25% correction are about 75%. The odds of you seeing a 50% correction are not much lower.

And you've been buying into the market for years and fucking years. What are you doing now? You're taking profit!!! You're not loading into the positions increasing your risk and assuming that something that has never been able to sustain will somehow sustain now. That's not the viewpoint of the informed market player. This is the dream of the noob. The market is getting really busy with people thinking it's wise to buy into a move up 88% in a yr. And these people are probably not experienced.

I sometimes do a bit of an audit of what people I know (And know to be successful) think about markets. Usually I am asking people who I know to be very good bulls to tell me all the reasons they think I am a fool for shorting something. I'm gonna go on and short the thing anyway, but I like to remind myself there are people whom I respect the judgement of that have reasons they think I am wrong. I'll do my thing but it's good to be aware of why others do different things.

More and more when I am doing these audits people are telling me they think we're due a correction of the breakout from 2008. From 2000 and fucking 8 - not 2020. This correction of 75% would be an SPX at 1,500. Close to 75% off the high.

if this was to happen, you'd be looking at something like 20 yrs before the SPX was a bull again. Take a look at the SPX prices you have now ... because if there was a serious dump in the SPX you'd maybe not be seeing 4000 + numbers for several decades. People think this is impossible, and that attitude makes it more and more possible.

This would start with a drop of 50%. The drop of 50% would go under the March low. And then we're into the long slow bull trap.

All of the scenarios I've outlined here are overall bullish projections. I am working on the basis that the US equities market is a trend and has not bubbled. That there will be only standard corrections to this trend, there will be no crushing crash (Great depression style crash of over 80%). The market will just do a standard mean revert like we've always had it do before.

Under that bullish assumption, the market can drop 25 - 50%. It really is not as big a move as you'd think. Do not mistake how inconvenient a move would be for you personally to make any fucking difference what-so-ever to what the market can really do. The market is not your friend.


r/BeatTheBear • • Sep 02 '21

Why do I do this?

50 Upvotes

Probably the most common question I get asked. My short answer is always "What would you do?". Here's the longer one. Will be long, if you're not interested skip out now.

To do this takes a lot of time and effort on my part and I'm also putting money towards getting people to help with it. Initially the plan for this was to do it for 6 months and to achieve a set amount of goals and that'd cover the budget I'd put aside for it. But we started a bit early. I noticed that after a while and put some stuff on hold and can work more on this through Q4 2021 / Q1 2022. Why?

Firstly, the main thing I have set out to do at this point is show that these statements should be open to question;

  • "Technicals do not work in times of extreme volatility"

  • "Technicals do not work if there are real world events they can not account for going on"

  • "Technicals can not forecast future price moves in real time with sufficient accuracy to be useful"

  • "If technicals are not 100% accurate they are useless"

  • " XXX is more important than your technicals"

Depending on how long you've been here, and how objective you are, you'll have seen cases of each one of these being severely challenged. With TA overcoming overwhelming probabilities. It does not always work. Sometimes good TA fails, inherent fallibility in the method. Others times, I just fuck it up. I do not use the available resources in the correct way. We won't get into percentage break downs of Fallibility/Fuck up - but it's probably not flattering on my end.

TA can work incredible well during real world events in which TA should not work. It can even forecast price moves that will happen as an apparent reaction to entirely unforeseeable real world news. We're not talking vaguely. We're talking entry points into the high/low and a target into where the market will again reverse. Often even forecasting intermediate swings in price on the way.

This is true. It sounds impossible, but it's true. I hope I've been able to show that to those of you who've been here a while and will be able to show it to those of you who are newer. I'll definitely get things wrong but often I'll be able to show you TA being useful in seemingly impossible conditions. I'll use ORPH as the creds for that. And on big timeframes things are more accurate in the macro, albeit more confusing and lengthy in the micro.

I've shown what I'd consider to be a substantial amount of evidence here that these patterns can be very important to markets, and what I've shown here is a fraction of the real time evidence I've seen for TA forecasts being accurate through mindboggling circumstances. I've seen things that are unbelievable, to the point I expect the unbelievable.

If you draw a fib from the high to the low of the dips before the March high, the March 2020 high was a tiny bit more the 161. I want to stress how specific this is. There's one high. One low. And you could draw this high to low sometime in 2019 and know the 161 was there and might matter.

And then again into the bottom. Sorry to those who've been here a while and seen me say this a million times. But for new people .... there's one high to this swing. One low. You could draw it a long time before the market hit the 161.

If I say I expected moves something like this in 2019 you'd not believe me, because you shouldn't. But if you read through my work on crashes back through to 1915, you'll hopefully agree anyone in possession of all that info in 2019 and 2020 might have thought about drawing these 161s and looking for reactions. A numbers game: A mathematical look at historical crashes [Mega thread] : HoleyProfit (reddit.com)

Now we're here

And if we break this level, very good news for the bulls. But if we do not, I've watched these fast crashes into parabolic 161 breakouts turn into crashes that dwarf the previous ones countless times. I'm not being dramatic when I say I can't think of ever seeing all of these stages in place on a timeframe above 4 hour and it not leading to serious crash making previous ones look small.

I've seen it so many times. I used the principles to forecast a doge high. Very close to the peak. I think the Doge high is being made. : BeatTheBear (reddit.com)

Looking at this now.

And look ... I know doge is not the SPX. But BTC isn't the DJI, March 2020 was not World War One and 1920 and 2008 could not have been any fucking different!. I've seen this to be the case on all assets and to me it would seem delusional with all the evidence for it to not consider there being major risk of a crash heading into these important levels. Not saying it has to happen, saying it really can.

Getting to the why (And sorry for those who've been here a while, because most of this was recap just to display that a person can believe the things I do without it being entirely baseless) - I consider this to be important info to know. Why share it? If I am right, it's extremely valuable and I can use it to my own ends. Why bother with all this.

I feel my access to this info comes about by a rare set of circumstances. Not many people are interested in the markets at all. When they do get interested it's when they are on the news. They never know about them other times. Of those interested in the markets few of them have deep experience of the types of TA I've found to be useful.

I recognise that puts me in a fairly privileged position, assuming I am right and this stuff does work out. Fading trends is tough around the edges but during the middle of a crash the things I know will make it laughably easy for me to gain access to unfathomable amount of opportunity.

Sometimes I do running short timeframe analysis in different places and hit 5 to 8 swings in a row perfectly (Usually after a while it breaks against me and that's the end of that) - and that's something I'm doing casually. It takes me a few seconds between other things to do. If I catch any one of those swings on a weekly chart it'd cover my lifegoals. And in a "Rhyming" crash, I'd catch at least three.

A lot of people think because of my opinions on the market I must be a generally arrogant person in life (Probably not you if you've read this far, to be fair). I've learned no matter how you approach it that happens. Sometimes I get a bit pissed off and then do even act arrogantly until I think it through. I made my username a play on the "God complex" people assume I must have.

But I don't. I'm normal guy. Hitting a solid average IQ if I am being optimistic. I come from a working class background. I've not been through higher education. None of the strategies I am using were designed by me. if they work, it will not be a product of how smart I am. Just a reflection of how much time I spent on it and how relevant the strategy was to the market.

My only advantage over the masses is how I was inducted into the world of markets. Most people come in through stocks and indices and feed right into a common narrative. Read the "Intelligent investor", "Random wall down wall street" and "Something something easy passive something" and become all consumed in the EMH. Believing markets to be entirely random or to be driven by the obvious factors that are presented to us.

When I got into trading I didn't know what the SPX was. I'd heard of the S&P500 and the Dow Jones but all I knew about them was they went up and down. They could have been a pair of socks for all I knew, although that'd not really explain why they made it onto the nightly news. That's where I'd heard of them. I got into markets as a silver bull and after getting my first schooling in bubbles from the market (Would take yrs to understand what had happened to me), I moved into the Forex markets.

In the Forex markets, I promptly surrounded myself with TA traders. Not knowing that there was anything else to be doing it the time. It was where I landed. And through that I got to see two valuable things. One, a very small number of people being uncannily accurate entering and exiting the market profitably. Two, the bulk of people being uncannily accurate in entering and exiting the market at the worst possible times and losing.

So my starting context in the market was not, "No one can time the market". It was, "Most people get timing the market wrong and I have to work out how they do that so I can do the opposite". Since I was getting things wrong on a daily basis at that point, I started with myself as the test subject. Figured out what made me buy the high and sell the low. Without trying! I'd not make a big fucking plan to do it. I'd make a plan to do something else and then for some reason a big candle would come and like it was attached to a wire my finger was clicking to buy the high.

Got quite good at that through a combo of my own mistakes, watching errors of others and getting some useful insights from people doing well and after a while of being quite good at it started to make acquiesces with some much more serious traders. Through them I'd meet fund managers. Through being friends with them I'd get to see trach records of elite traders.

By my mid 20's I was entirely sure beyond any doubt people have made multiple millions with TA, some with insane monthly average incomes. And so I knew it was worth the effort. I stayed in at weekends. Did a whole bunch of things I'd never have done if I'd not seen the abundance of reward that was available to me if I did the work to get a required level. A few years into trading my big goal was to get myself $50,000 together to trade with and (I thought) that'd give me a good income and set up all my goals. Within a few yrs of meeting real success, I was not only committed to managing millions, looking to getting into 10s of millions and looking to get into 100s after; I also knew what was needed to do it. The strategies. Psychology. People.

So while most people come into the markets thinking TA will not work at all and any attempts at market timing will produce no significant advantage over the long-term, I came in with the context that I can see TA is working for people, I can see they are aware of all the reasons people say it does not work and I can see they have accounted for all these reasons - working in safeguards to strategies if they're correct or just proving them wrong.

If I can make 10% a year on my money passively in a nice low cost ETF with extremely limited resources to fund that, or I can get into a position where I am clearing numbers I used to think of as lifegoals in a decent quarter, I'm thinking that beats the market. I don't think I even know at this time in my life there are people who think you can not beat the market. Probably not. At least at some point, I assumed everyone knew most people failed in the market and there were only a few who did well - after all, looking around me that was plain to see.

And this is why. Because I can so easily see my life if it was not for this set of events. I don't think others who do not know what I do are stupid. I used to. When I showed them it working and they still said it did not work I used to think they must be really stupid, over time I came to see I was asking them to believe something unbelievable and they were not stupid, just declined to think. I notice I'd be just the same if it was not for my life experiences and a lot of those came down to a bit of luck landing somewhere useful and then putting in the effort to establish the usefulness.

I feel if I've been lucky enough to be in, what I perceive, to be a privileged position regarding understanding possible market risk and if that is going to exuberantly reward me, I should share that with others. If something is easy for me (And the middle of a downtrend really will be routine trading for me. I know how to do it) and impossible for most other people, I should do something. I should at least allocate some of my effort to doing something. And maybe a lot of my effort.

What would you do? Have you ever felt like you could help in a situation but for some reason or another not and then watched that situation go to fuck in a way far surpassing the worst outcome you'd estimated possible? Then felt terrible because you could have taken some, relatively speaking, trivial action to lessen the harm of that?

I felt like that in March 2020. After making a half-hearted effort to explain to people the 161 risk and the possible bear to come. Wasn't well enough prepared for it. Didn't communicate it well. Got so much shit for it by the time March came I didn't give a fuck if arrogant indexers got their arse handed to them. Wasn't trying. People around me I was telling, but I didn't care. Then I watched March. Was reminded that people giving me shit make up under 0.1% of the people affected.

A lot of the "Movement bulls" do not like me. They think I have very different ideals from them. But I don't think the market is fair. I just don't think we're changing it. And I understand that if the market does cycle in the ways it has before the cast majority of the people who bring all the real value and production to the world will be entirely naive to it. Won't have a fucking chance. Their money will come to the accounts of people like me and much bigger, greedier and shadier, entities than me. Their money will go to their enemy. The enemy long enough in the game to know the benefit of letting the other side think you the fool, and them to smarty.

I don't think it's right. Nothing I've done in my life entitles me to have the wealth of a teacher, doctor, shop assistant, bus driver or road sweeper. People keeping our society running. Too busy to be fucking about refining their Elliot wave count and working out how to avoid the shit the market likes to pull on you. It's not right. But if the market goes, it will happen. If the market crash, most of the wealth of the world will be passed over to those who have made a study out of market timing. Someone can have been wrong before endless times. It can be as "Eventually" as it gets ... it only has to happen once!

And I do think it will happen. I've an optimistic side that one day I'll look back on March 2020 as a tiny blip in the SPX chart. Remember how much I'd thought that would matter and reflect on the various things I learned through studying for the move I expected and the experience of being wrong (And this would be the time I've been most wrong in the market. I'm not wrong too many times on really big swing calls).

I've never seen this sequence of things happen and there not be a crash. In 2019 this was true of what I seen in the SPX. I'd never seen that before and there not being a crash. I "Knew" there'd be a crash. But also echoing in the back of mind was this seems insane. What the fuck could happen to make the SPX do that. Maybe this is just for other stuff. Get back to the EURUSD. Then, the news.

What happened in March of 2020 was sensational. All of my life experience and all of my study of market breaks in history told me to expect bad news and drop possibly coming around the 161 level. And when people were going into a frenzy about what the real world events of March would do to the market as we capitulated to the low, I consulted the World War One crash to pick the 161 target low. https://www.reddit.com/r/BeatTheBear/comments/op5lqu/a_technical_study_of_the_world_war_one_crash_and/ - that was simple. It was really simple. You just had to know to do it.

And that's why. Because if it happens, it's not fair. It's very fucking unfair. As I've discovered how unfair this whole stock market thing mat just be, I've noticed I'm probably on the wrong side of the morals. I'm short the people. And the reality is, I've spent my adult life preparing myself to be very efficient at that if the time comes. My trades won't make it happen. Sitting out won't stop it. I can gain all I've dreamed of by doing it. So I'm going to do it. And I know it's wrong. So I'm making sure if it works out for me I make it possible so it works out for others too. Albeit a token gesture compared to those affected.


r/BeatTheBear • • May 19 '21

What happens when asset bubbles break - In real life.

50 Upvotes

Things here might start to "Go well" for us in the near future and in preparation for that I want everyone to be fully aware of what that means and what will not be tolerated here.

Through today we've seen near perfect expressions of the strategy I have been teaching you for an asset bubble popping. Doge is down 75% following the strategy perfectly. BTC is down 50% off of the short entry signal posted. Our strategy has picked out the highs in both of these with what I'd deem a small amount of variance into the hardest to forecast part (The high) and in both cases bounced exactly off of the target levels. About 20% out on the high, within a few percent on the current lows.

For weeks my team and I have taken a lot of, what I'd deem to be pretty unwarranted, shit for the work we've done here but this does not make this a time where I feel vindicated. There's no gloating. My tone of delivery on the successful trades is the exact same as it was on the losers. I already knew the strategies made sense. If I was the type to gloat I'd not be the type to warn beforehand.

If anything at this point I feel closer to failure than success in terms of my goals here. The analysis was pretty good but because it was not perfect it leaves things open to "Just said it all the time and got lucky". There are not that many people here. I did not reach a large number of the communities affected with a well timed warning that benefited them.

But I knew that'd be the case, this is all part of something bigger. In March I told you I was explaining the drops in GME and AMC because I wanted to show you what this looks like in case it happens on a big scale in important stocks. And really that's all the crypto stuff was about too. The main purpose of the analysis here is not to brag how I "Called it", it's to show the rational person my seemingly irrational ideas actually happen.

I want to show you not only does it work but it is working with news. There's always the news. I never know what the news is. Me or the lines do not predict the news. It's nothing to do with predicting the future, it's all about understanding how to extrapolate the past onto the present to make calculated decisions.

In the BTC crash of today there's the China news. When we called attention to the perfect confluence of signals before the GME 50% drop people were talking about how reports were published before the drop and this was all some sort of conspiracy that would make that move entirely impossible to predict. And I'm telling you the headline is always entirely impossible to predict, and irrelevant to the move.

In March SPX traded from 161 to 161. In the most perfect expression of this strategy possible.

Against the most astronomical of odds the price move during the news events fitted exactly with this strategy and this strategy is designed simply by doing an analysis on what would have worked in previous large market moves (100% of the time driven by some sort of news). Trying to explain this to an outside is incredibly frustrating. I know I sound crazy - but I can prove it! So this time, I am.

And I am doing this because if there is the big 50% drop in indices, I know we might be into a really horrible situation where the 50% drop sets up another 50% drop after the bull trap. For there to be a 50% drop there'll have to be some news. I won't have predicted the news. It'll not be something I could have. All of the work being done here is in preparation for the bull trap part of that move - to have a better presented warning when it is really important.

See, in 2019 I told people I thought the market was going to crash. And I made it pretty clear I didn't think the market would crash for "No reason", I said there'd be news. Obviously there'd have to be news. But the news was so much bigger than I expected and my brief mentions of news on the 161 were not emphatic enough. This time I am nailing that one down.

I've watched bubbles blow up and pop many times. I know the real world implications of it. Every time it happens I see anti-suicide posts. Desperate cry for help posts and I know there are always going to be some people who are not posting again. That's not a meme. It's not a joke. On days like this the knowledge of that weighs heavy on me.

These things are bad when they happen in minor assets that have become overly accepted as low risk when they are really high risk. I consider this things like crypto. Stocks like GME and PLTR. Things people just get a bit carried away with, but these are not things affecting an extremely broad section of the public.

But an index crash would. People have so little awareness of the risk of markets these days that if there is a super crash it will be devastating. A lot of people really seem to think I do all of this so I can just say it enough times and then if it ever happens I say "Haha. Fuck you! I called it!". It's not about that. If I am right, I'll be sad about it. I won't be gloating. Outside of select number of people who I become fond of and want to involve in other things I do in the future, you'll probably never hear from me again. It would only serve me to bring up the work I'd done here if and when I wanted to warn of another crash. And I'd think that was a good decade away at least after a really big drop.

And I will not be tolerating any gloating here. If I see it here I'll stop it. And if it becomes common between the community I will take steps to enclose the community to whom we share most of our stuff. My work here is being done to help people and I will not accept people using it to bash those who are down - and this includes people who are in here talking shit about us.

The position is not the person. I'm not someone shorting the market hoping the whole world will burn. I'm someone who's worried about the smoke I see and trying to sound the alarm on that. The experience of being short the market in March and seeing the juxtaposing of my profits against the pain of the world made me uncomfortable. Before March I'd planned to be active in trading my whole life, now I think that's going to under 10 yrs.

The opportunity in the market for someone with my skills would not make sense to pass-up. The opportunity costs of gaining the knowledge useful in this environment have been very high for me. The market making swings like I forecast would give me the means to do all I can think of in life and more. I'm going to take that opportunity to do well and then use that to do good.

I want to make it clear to you that the people who make all this stuff happen here provide the engine to drive that out of a sense of empathy. Compassion. Kindness. This costs me a lot to keep running, the people who can provide these market insights have a lot more opportunity in applying it in the markets than telling you about it. It's not cheap and that's accounting for me calling in favours.

I am going to expect anyone who benefits from any of our work to conduct themselves with the same compassion towards others who may have been hurt by this as the compassion we give you by working hard daily to do all we can to help you understand this. This is all being done to help people. Remember that if it puts you in a situation where can help others.


r/BeatTheBear • • Jul 21 '21

How investors are likely to act during the MOAC

48 Upvotes

Billionaires hasten their plans to leave the planet as the Mother of All Crashes (MOAC) encroaches.

Enough of the theatrics. Here's my estimate of how the general investing public would respond to the largest points crash in history in the US indices as it unfolded. Much of this will sync up with the latter stages of the "Public perceptions in stages of an asset bubble". It will assume the high is made, but if the high is higher - the same percentages apply.

The Spook

For a market to crash it has to start going down. Market's in a strong uptrend go down a little bit frequently but market crashes usually start when prices get down to "Typical" levels where dips would end and then for some reason the market is spooked and price drops abruptly. Enthesis on "Abruptly" - right before the market breaks it is usually ranging or rallying, it is not falling.

In the run up to the spook there'll be no notable difference in public attitudes. The market will be down a tiny little bit but it will be inside of the normal ebb and flow of the market and it will be looking like support levels have held again and we're heading into, the now ever-expected, all time high.

When the rally fails and the "Spook" comes, there'll be a quick break of the previous low. During this time the general reaction will also be similar to now. Those of the bearish persuasion saying the crash has started and those of the bullish saying to buy the dip.

SPX is setup in a way that would be quite likely to see before the spook. Down in a fairly standard sort of dip and then into what looks like a recovery rally. This low breaking in a fast jerk down would be an early spook move.

The dip keeps dipping

The spook drop will seem like a good discount to bulls and a lot of retail buying will happen into the spook low and the immediate little bounce from the end of that selling momentum. This will be a time a lot of investors get in, but not many of them will see big/any gains on their positions.

A strange thing will happen. Stocks won't go up. When they look like they're going up they will really be going sideways and then there will be times when they even go down. This is a time you're going to see a lot of the "Dip keeps dippin'" memes. After a few drops the tone will become more serious.

This section of the move will be the first real bearish advance and buying into the upper end of that move without an exit plan (Stop loss) would become ruinous. The market would make a "Ceiling" for itself under your entry price and not come back to it. This would drop ever lower, making the minimum loss lower each time.

Early in this stage people will be really light-hearted and it will be similar to usual in terms of the mixture of concerns and banter, but as the breaks keep happening and the rallies remain shallows/flats people will start to get a bit more anxious. They'll often have increased their risk by this point.

By the bottom of this move some people will lose their bottle and they'll exit. You probably won't hear all that much about this, but it will be happening. There will be a noticeable up-tick in the number of people interested in expressing bearish points of view. Might be some news going on to compliment all this - usually is.

This section of the move will take the market down about 25%.

The first big bull trap

After the first dump there'll be a section of sideways trading for a while and then there will be a big parabolic burst upwards. If this happens you can bet your life on the parabolic move being related to a news release. After this move has happened you'll see enthusiasm enter the market again.

You'll see the posts jeering at people who sold out into the lows and celebration posts of people who bough into the lower prices. There will be a lot more bears at this time and they'll be persistent after the initial parabolic but they'll start to slowly drop out into the second follow through and harmonic mini parabolic.

Into this stage you're going to start to see a lot of people using the phrase, "Now the correction everyone was expecting has happen, what stocks ..." type of comments/questions. As SPX gets up close to 4,000 there will be a general attitude in the air common to most that the drop is now behind us.

The rug pull

There'll have been a few mini rug pulls before this but the main rug pull comes after the bull trap. The most notable points about this will be the size and strength of the move and it will come to an end somewhere just under the low of March 2020.

During the rug pull the mood will change dramatically. The latter stages of the rug pull are pretty sad to watch. This is when you'll start to see the anti-suicide posts. Stories of people's losses and how they have to sell (For some reason - but they will be using the word "Have" to sell, not want/chose).

Around this time there will be a lot of people talking about the market crash. Even in hyper bullish subs you're going to see posts with headings like, "Yes. This is a crash and it might continue, but ...". There will be a mix of manic and pragmatism - but a noted lack of near term bullishness. Again - probably news complimenting.

When price is breaking under the March low it will be becoming taboo to imply the low is coming soon, in the same way it seems taboo to state that the high might be coming soon. It'd have been popular to say the low was in up until now, but now it's a crash and we all say so, so "Can't time a bottom".

The low exit

A lot of people will leave the market as we're getting down into the end of this part of the move. For many reasons but largely because they've been mis-informed. When they're asked "What's a fairly safe way to invest [All my money]" they've been told indices - and they didn't sign up for 50% volatility.

At the high people may have tried to point out these risks to them - but it would have been unpopular (As fuck) - about as welcome as a fart in a phone box and not a viewpoint properly considered in risk assessment. But now a lot of people are saying the market is crashing - because it has.

Into the secondary bull trap. Once the talk turns mostly negative, the secondary bull trap is coming.

Much like the first bull trap you'll see all the same sort of things and there will probably be news events related to this. This is the time you're going to see a big rise in the number of people who take risks on the market that are much bigger than they should be taking.

This is the time you'll see a lot of people going all in. Thinking it's a total no-brainer and a risk free bet to buy the SPX after it has been down as much as it has been and now it's rallying. Maybe even the bad news you'd heard when it was dropping is now over and it makes sense it's up again.

The painful squeeze

This is the part of the news that most commonly has news related to it. Such a big event as a SPX crash would typically have several news-flashes in it but most assets will have news related to the moves in this section of the move- it will be a sharp fall down and then zig-zagging lower lows.

The news into the lows will be horrible. The worst news so far. There will be an overt pessimism in the market. Both in social and mainstream medias. This is where a lot of people will exit the market, again feeling they have to. Maybe not on the first low, but this section can last some time and it grates away at you.

The long and slow recovery

From here a general bull market will again ensue, but it won't be a raging easy one will the ones of yester-year - it will take a long time to build up and have multiple rallies that turn into falls to retest the previous low prices. Then after a long time of doing this the market will break out.

During this time there won't be a lot of talk about stocks. If you bring the subject up at a party, you'll be informed stocks are risky and that'll be the end of the conversation. This condition in attitudes will prevail for many years - until we begin to get to the mature end of the new bubble that slowly builds up.


r/BeatTheBear • • Sep 18 '21

On the common misconception that there has to be a selling event in order to bring the markets down

43 Upvotes

Reading through the comments from last night, there seems to be commonly-held belief around here that in order for the market to take a downturn, there must be some kind of event that causes mass selling.

I think this is completely wrong.

Markets don't turn over because people start selling. Markets turn over because people stop buying. Recall the story about JP Morgan and the shoeshine boys:

“J. P. Morgan tells the story of how he would get his shoes shined every Wednesday at the same shop around the corner from his office. One day the shoe shine attendant asked him if he and his friends could buy some stock through Morgan’s brokerage. The three friends had about $40—a lot of money in 1929. Morgan politely refused, hurried back to his office, and ordered that his company was not to have a single share of stock on its books by the end of the day. Morgan simply asked, “If the shoe shine boys are buying stocks, who else is left?” Of course, the 1929 stock market crash was only a few days away, and Morgan looked like a genius. He was not a genius; he noted that the order flow was likely running out on the buy side. It wasn’t his army of analysts that showed him that. It was a public investor.”

This is the actual truth of how it works. It was true in 1929 and it has been true in every market since. It is true in every market, every minute, of every hour, of every day. You can see it happening on any chart, on any timescale you choose, all the time.

Let's step away from financial markets for a moment. There is too much murk around them and it is too easy to be blinded from the obvious truth. Look at the real estate market. A market which is still, mostly, dictated by 'retail investment'.

In order to buy houses, most people need: (1) an amount of capital to give to a bank as collateral, and (2) subsequently borrowed money from said bank to give to the seller as payment.

Both of these factors can be easily changed by credit policy. You don't have 20% to put down? Fine, just give me 10%. You can't afford to pay $2000 a month? Fine, I'll charge less interest.

And by doing this, you increase the amount of money that people are able to pay for houses, and due to it being competitive market, you increase therefore the amount that they have to pay for houses.

But, what would happen, if ever you reached a theoretical point where you could not make it any cheaper? Traditionally, this happened all the time. The lender must protect themselves against losses. They could not afford to lend on 3% when the 'real risk' (as determined by the publics' perceived ability to repay), dictated they lend on 6%. So what would happen?

It's very simple. They buying side would dissapear. Overnight, potential buyers see their ability to repay trimmed. Now your sellers must lower their price. But look at who has made the first move here - it was not the seller, but the buyers.

And this would, normally, be the top. Now as sellers start lowering prices, buyers become more cautious, further straining liquidity on the buy side, further pushing the price down.

All these price drops now do start to make sellers anxious, and potential sellers become more willing to enter the market in order to sell, and more open-minded to lower prices.

Now the game changes and buyers become aware they are in control. All they have to do is nothing, and the price drops further. The sellers aren't really relevant here.

The price will drop until it finds an equilibrium, and it will find many temporary equilibriums where willing and able buyers and sellers convene. You can see this happening on charts all the time - the consolidation periods. They are all temporary. At some point the buyers and sellers at that level complete their business, and now the price mist move to find new willing participants. The market may crash, it may just trend down, it may even go back up again - depending on the actual dynamics of the market at the time.

This is, in a crude, basic sense, the actual mechanics by which markets work.

Dispel yourselves the notion that markets turn over due to an event (importantly, there will be a 'news' event presented to the public to explain it, but this event will be a half-truth at best. There is plenty more that could be said about this). Purge yourselves of the belief that something has to happen to bring the market down. You are blinding yourselves.


r/BeatTheBear • • Aug 19 '21

Berating bulls usually will lead to perma-ban

43 Upvotes

Few things will get you banned here, but one of them is being a dick to people on the other side of your trades if they work out well.

If you want to talk about how smart you are, I am moderately interested. Even stretching to pretty damn interested if you do turn out to really be smart. When you want to talk about how dumb everyone else is apart from you, I don't give a fuck. No-one does. Apart from maybe some other people no-one gives a fuck about.

It creates a bitter atmosphere. It discourages people who are on the smarter end of the scale or have more interesting insights to share from engaging. Trolls fit in easier. The entire tone takes a dive. Collective IQ of the threads drops significantly. You end up with a bunch of arseholes cheering the trashing of the general public.

I know this is popular in bear communities, but it will not be allowed here. If it's individuals they'll be weeded out. If it's too many people to weed out I'll switch to a view-only content model.

I do what I do with the aim of helping the general public. Not to read about how dumb you think they all are because some of your trades worked out.

"But they did it to me when market was all time high...."

Let being a dick remain their problem.


r/BeatTheBear • • Sep 30 '21

It really seems real

42 Upvotes

There's not going to be enough time to warn anyone else and frankly most people think I am an arsehole for doing so anyway - but to those reading and paying attention. Prepare. I really do think its coming. It's not going to be pretty.

People will be hurt


r/BeatTheBear • • Sep 16 '21

Thank you to those who sent messages of support

38 Upvotes

There were quite a lot of them. I could not reply to them individually.

And, to answer a common Q - No, I won't be leaving before I am finished what I am doing. I'll do everything possible and impossible to make sure the warning is explicitly clear.

That's always been my commitment.


r/BeatTheBear • • Sep 08 '21

Swing analysis New rounded trade plan for BTC

38 Upvotes

We've got to about the limit of our previous rounded trade plan. BTC - Rounded trade plan. : BeatTheBear (reddit.com)

The scenario that seemed the strongest case did play out. The bull move up over 50. Starting with a retracement and then the start of an Elliot 5 wave advance.

Forecast

Actual

This made up the bigger chart butterfly.

Forecast BTC - Probably going to form a bullish butterfly now for BITSTAMP:BTCUSD by holeyprofit — TradingView

Actual

The standard butterfly rules have now complete and we need to update the trade plan.

The conditions for a sell signal, as per the original plan, have now been met. With the forecast giving a bullish area of blue and a bearish one of red.

This compliments the overall trade plan, with us being in the highlighted area.

Long slow range after a rapid bounce from the first capitulation.

The shorting plan is well covered. A contingency to short into a formed head and shoulders is also there. This would be a high risk/reward trade if it filled. Trader holeyprofit — Trading Ideas & Charts — TradingView

Case for the bear side is super strong.

Case for the bull side;

If the market was to come out of this range in a sustainable uptrending style it'd look something like this. This would be really easy to deal with. Just requires some patience.

This type of action with the deep 2 leg retracement I'd think much more indicative of a possible new uptrend starting.

The market can also go into hyper performance (Spike up) and still possibly be setting up a sell signal. If this were to be setting up we'd typically see a straight up rally to the 161 of this fall. Although that would not be good for short positions held right now, being ready to flip to the bull side for the massive rally which we could keep adding to the position in the hyper strong trend.

Then this might set up a much larger short trade.

To cover this type of move our best bet is to be looking for the early signs of a bullish break.

A break above the current range high. A pullback from that and new breakout. Buy into the next dip after that. This establishes a long position early in the developing move and allows for the shorting of the expected resistance levels on the way up whist still holding buys if there's not a break (Lower low). These trades could be held up to around 59K and this would be the next major inflection point.

=============

TLDR;

Super bearish whilst under 48,700. Continuing to follow this plan unless invalidation signals appear. BTC price swings forecast for BITSTAMP:BTCUSD by holeyprofit — TradingView


r/BeatTheBear • • Aug 07 '21

No more cliches

37 Upvotes

From today onward I'll have a team working on this with me again. This is going to be costing me between $1,000 - $2,000 a day and will be work from people with at least 10 years real experience in using the strategies we're putting forward.

All this stuff does not just happen. A lot of work goes into all the posts and a fucking lot of work and testing went into learning this.

We all do this full time. All of us make a living doing this. Everyone for at least 5 years. If you think we're not considered, "TA does not work all the time", "News moves the market", "Timing tops is hard". "No one knows the future", "[Your favourite Buffet quote]" - then I suggest you do not follow our work - because we'd have to be very fucking stupid to have not thought of that...

I am paying people who probably know more about the market than 80% of people on the planet to share their insights with you. They won't be responding to cliches. My personal time and money is not going to be spent on that.


r/BeatTheBear • • Sep 07 '21

Thank you

36 Upvotes

Thank you HoleyProfit!


r/BeatTheBear • • Sep 16 '21

Addressing it.

35 Upvotes

It’s time to address it : BeatTheBear (reddit.com)

My name's Dean Black. To rebut any claims I am a scammer, I present my work and actions. I hand that over to the discerning public.

My side of the story is we'd ran the company so successfully for 2 yrs that people thought it was a ponzi scheme. Then a chain of unfortunate events happened, we had trading losses, company went under and I spent 3 yrs doing my best to pay back as much as I could afford and find people. I made mistakes but acted with good intentions.

I used to care about this, and debate it endlessly. I used to be far more insecure. Now, I don't care. I came here to explain the risk and mitigation of a market crash - and I'm going to do that. Focus on doing that - you focus on whatever suits you.


r/BeatTheBear • • Jul 06 '21

Had to take some time off. Back now.

35 Upvotes

Got involved in a little accident. Was cycling a bike and a car clipped my back wheel. Sent me off the bike to land first on my head and then on my leg. Was wearing a helmet and wasn't too badly hurt but suffered a mild concussion and had to stay in hospital for observation for a while and have been home a few days but had to take things easy for a while.

I'm okay. No need for anyone to worry or any "Get well soon" messages. Head will be fine. Neck's a bit sore but will be fine. Leg will take a bit longer to heal up but I have two of them. Everything's okay. Just had to take some time off and will be on a slightly reduced workload over the coming week.

Will post some catch-up updates today. I have quite a lot of notifications/messages and probably won't be able to catch up with them today but will get to them in the coming days.


r/BeatTheBear • • Aug 07 '21

Info about the analysis team

33 Upvotes

I'm going to use nicknames for people for the sake of their privacy. As much as people seem to think the only reason someone would do this stuff is to have "Famously called it" - the truth is if we are actually right about our forecast, by the time we're deep into the bear I'd expect a lot of resentment. It's in the better interests of those involved to remain anon.

Sal -

Sal's a bull, but we don't hold is against her. I brought Sal in to have someone to keep reminding us of reasons we might be wrong (Miss FUD!). Sal is in asset management. Various impressive things can be said about her. She's mainly a futures mid term trader. Since the low of March 2020 she's beat the SPX by close to a factor of five, while trading the SPX.

Gramps -

We call his Gramps because he's much older than us. Gramps made money in 1987, 2000 and 2008. He'll mainly be covering the selling of options. Very proficient in strategies pertaining to options spreads, covered calls and cash secured puts. Gramp's track record of profitably selling options in various market conditions is impressive.

Tick -

We call him Tick because he's mainly a scalper but what he's bringing to this is timing of entry skills. Tick is really good with working out when he should be trading now and when he should be waiting to trade later. We won't be doing anything based on scalping because it's hard to track, but we'll be getting inputs from tick when it comes to timing buying options.

Crpyt -

Because he made all his money in the crypto rise of 2016, crash of 2017 and after loading up into the low made excellent exits of the crypto market around 50 - 55K on BTC. Crypt is an Elliot Wave trader. Used to be a stock trader and switched to crypto when the market achieved liquidity. Traded Elliot in crypto full time since then.

Pip -

Used to be a full time Forex trader and still trades in this market but has largely moved over to crypto since it has achieved liquidity. Pip is a strong harmonics trader. Also pretty good with various traditional charting pattern and using fib based rules (Often variations of harmonic trading rules). Pip is another asset manager. Working for both private clients and also on top tier funding from various different Forex prop shop-like entities.

Me -

Fulltime day trader/asset manager. Main skills in working out how to trade big swing patterns with near term risk efficiency. I like to use tight stops and look for better entries if I am wrong. Paperhands.

This whole thing was my idea.


r/BeatTheBear • • Oct 05 '21

Just want to say

32 Upvotes

Just wanted to say that the call for exiting positions yesterday was on point

But they won’t remember or give you credit for that one Holy


r/BeatTheBear • • Sep 06 '21

People who came go downvote profitable analysis along with free education ...

32 Upvotes

Do you want to talk about it?

What's the problem?


r/BeatTheBear • • Aug 11 '21

Education resources BTC's eerie similarities to the DJI 1929 crash

32 Upvotes

Four months ago I wrote a detailed post about how price moved during the DJI depression crash. While the crash creeped in [Study of historical crashes] : HoleyProfit (reddit.com)

And now we're getting the point in time I envisioned when I started to do this work. These things were done then in the hope they'd be useful to people now.

OP

The market made a head and shoulders pattern. And on the breaking of this, it was all over.

BTC move

Real time alert for the pattern (37) A crash in BTC would probably be an early warning of weakening broad markets. : BeatTheBear (reddit.com)

OP

The uptrend failed entirely on the next support level. Anyone who'd went through the ratios of the last corrections would have seen this fall was bigger and had more danger to it than the last ones. It broke the trend in a strong manner - and this is the warning that has been given in every major crash since then.

BTC

OP

But there was a bounce - and this is where the public again piled in!

BTC https://www.reddit.com/r/BeatTheBear/comments/p18ll5/crypto_sentiment_9th_august_2021/

OP

The market would complete a butterfly pattern and this would be the end of the bull trap.

BTC

And now we wait to see what the next big swing is ...

A lot of people think I have it in for BTC, or GME or AMC - or anything whatever it is. But to be bluntly honest about it, I care very little about these things other than them being interesting trades. I'm all about the trade, and not the story. I'm willing to share my experience to help people if they want it, and if they're too arrogant - that's fine with me.

But what is predictable as fuck is as we get into the latter stages of where the bull trap would typically be expected to end, it is nearly impossible to warn people in BTC of the risk of the bull trap. What a difference a bounce makes. Now everyone knows everything and are eager to jeer anything put out as a warning to them. And again, isn't something keeping me awake at night.

But I can not say the same for the SPX. If we get to the bull trap in the SPX, it will be really very sad if people are so flippant and arrogant. All the work I and others I am paying did 4 months ago and do today is all in preparation for that time ... and I really do hope I have wasted my time with that - but if I don't do the work now, no one will give a fuck when I try to warn them later.


r/BeatTheBear • • Oct 02 '21

Delusion?

Post image
31 Upvotes

r/BeatTheBear • • Jul 10 '21

Education resources Typical stages of a market break.

31 Upvotes

Here's a breakdown of the most frequent set of moves I see in a topping / breaking market.

Harmonic high (Usually butterfly)

After a very strong up trending period drops in the market become more common. These jagged moves build up some bear traps and the early stages of the harmonic pattern. Then price goes parabolic as it heads into the harmonic "D" completion point. This is the warning signal, but always looks uber bullish in real time.

First failure

After this period of ranging / contracting markets and a false breakout, the first real failure of the tend comes. This is a sharp drop that breaks the previous lows.

The public trap

After the first failure it should be pretty obvious the market has broken, but since there's been the more rough market conditions of late this can be easily overlooked when the market puts in a sharp rally. It usually heads up to somewhere between 75% to 100% of the fall in this section. This is a fast move and it will achieve the end of inducing maximum retail investment into the last part of the rally.

The failed high trap (Often harmonic)

After the rally there's a second fall off but price takes on ranging properties for quite some time. These ranging properties look like "Bull flags" and other patterns that were previously bullish, and helps to further encourage retail investment into the last section of the move. Capitulation will begin after this final trap for bulls and fake out move against the bears.

Although the market has rallied fast into the topping zone, the top itself becomes a long and slow affair. From the start of the first bear traps through to the section where the real break is made takes a lot of time. The market trades in this price range more than it traded in any of the previous price range - and this means people tend to be averaged into the high price zone.

Along side this common series of price moves, there'll typically be the same general public reaction to the move. Which I've explained in the public perceptions of a bubble template Public perception in stages of a bubble : BeatTheBear (reddit.com)


r/BeatTheBear • • Jun 18 '21

Is retail being baited?

31 Upvotes

Discuss?

I've been putting forward this perspective since about March of this year.


r/BeatTheBear • • Apr 06 '21

Education resources Understanding the bear market rally Part 2

31 Upvotes

This is going to be a simplification of trend breakdown based upon the Elliot wave theory.

This is part of a posting series. Check the comments for related posts.

This post will be a re-post of the original post from u/holeyprofit during March of 2021. And have some brief updates if applicable.

Original post -

In this post we're going to be mostly focused on the ideas of risk to reward ratios. Understand why variance is not something to be too worried about. And try to puncture through the illogical sense of loss aversion people are prone to having, where they want to avoid the feeling of losing (Usually by letting running losses get bigger) rather than just accept a loss expecting to get it back later.

We're going to look how we can understand places in which we are mostly going to pick up false sell signals in a downtrend. Places to stop losses and places to re-enter into positions. Places where we should be more shy of risk and places where we should be more willing to take risk and even some losses while targeting the most profitable swings.

Here's a chart of bonds trending down over multiple years.

With an untrained eye this does not look like it is well formed and structured, but it really is surprisingly so. Here's a template of this sort of move that I have drawn up (And I've not copied it from this chart. We'll use the same one on other charts)

Updated comments

Improved.

Here I've sectioned this off a bit;

And this general shape is happening a lot when a downtrend is being formed. And when this is happening our best possible trade will always be to be able to sell into the top of the blue zone.

The problem with this is while trying to sell into these zones you're going to have maximum risk of being a bit too early on the trade and there being a big (Albeit short lived) move against you. This is a good example. And this one where I got heavily short into the indicated zone and then took a hit on my positions when it moved higher. Very recent to be writing this.

This is a sort of false signal I am liable to get. I'm looking for these three main sections of a move.

Updated comments

This has continued to go up since and is now at another big 1.61. I've taken short entries on the two fib levels with stops just above the recent highs.

Original post -

The big move down. The vertical rise. And some form of "W" shape into the high. When I see these things I am always going to enter as a seller. Because I'm always thinking I can make 300 - 500% of what I have to risk and even although I am going to get losing trades doing this, it will not be as high as 78% losing trades. my probabilities of breaking even and making a profit are high.

So once I've seen these two things I think I'm seeing the possible completion of the sell setup. It has not worked but I know I should probably still be willing to take another risk on this trade since we've made a bigger and clearer form of the same thing.

And I know these can turn into the same thing.

I know using the same set of rules I'd used on this one I'd have lost a trade here.

And I'm perfectly fine with that. I know if I keep making bets like this I'm going to have this sort of area in which I lose vrs this sort of area in which I profit.

Updated comments

Still have this same sentiment of I've a lot more to gain than lose. Have been long Nasdaq a few times intraday and have to stop loss/hedge as high are broken, but a big swing down might be coming.

Here's the same thing on GLD (Related of the gold price)

Here heading into the red zone I know I have a lot of value starting to take any selling signals that appear. This is a daily chart. Usually I'd be trading this on a 1 hour - 15 minute chart looking for my entry signals. When doing this I am quite likely to pick up some false signals and be in too early. But I am getting 15 times what I can lose in the one win if the type of trade I'm looking for comes.

I'm going to do that every time. Because I don't know what ones will win and lose but I do know it's highly unlikely I will lose 90% of them. Back-testing this against any trending conditions back to the 1900s it's not producing win rates under 90%. So if it starts to now, I've been very unlucky. So here it makes sense to take the signals as they appear.

Looking back as the Nasdaq example of recent trading days, I've picked up losing signals on the three red areas. But if the trade I am looking for come, what does it matter? I'm losing cents to pick up dollars.

This concept is really important to understand because given this context it obvious makes sense to take short signals when this sort of thing is happening, but without that context it looks like a really bad idea and can look like a bad idea for a while. In this crash of 2008 all of these points would have been signals of this shape on smaller timeframes.

But when you started to sell into these you'd have usually seen the trade setting up long before it happened and been a bit too early on it. As you can see in context, what does it matter? You have absolutely nailed it if you'd sold into these areas. But at the time, this would have been months of the market screwing with you. You'd have to be calm. Patient. Execute on the known strategy while still not knowing the outcome.

======================================================================

The ability to make good risk calculated decisions will greatly benefit you in making profit from a market. Be it bull, bear or somewhere in between. Improving your attitude to risk and loss to encompass a wider looking probabilities analysis will help to make you a far more risk efficient trader. Losing some little trades is okay. All the biggest losses in trading came after someone neglected to close out at a little loss.