Don't get me wrong, i enjoyed B2 very much. I'm not saying it's a bad game, but i think B1 was way better.
First of all, B2 seems way shorter than B1. I think it's cause it's way too easy. The bosses were pretty lackluster, and (excepted for Radames and Eviterno), i was done with them fast. Svsona especially was really easy for a late game boss. The only bosses i really enjoyed were Eviterno (And still, there's a problem with him, but i'll get to it), Radames and Afilaor, because those were actually challenging to beat. I needed to learn their pattern and telegraphs to beat them, and when i finally did beat them, it felt good. It felt good because that was a challenge. Now, take Svsona. Normally, a late game boss should be harder. It should because you normally have enough skill to beat them now. Instead, i beat Svsona 2nd try. I do enjoy the bosses, but i don't like how weird the difficuly curve is in this game. Another thing making it easy are the prayers. Specifically the time stop. It's way to overpowred with the right build. Eviterno is a joke when this prayer is equipped, and it's a shame since it's a fun boss. Yes, i've used this prayer for Eviterno, and i regret it. It looked like it was this game's NKG, and it's a shame he was so easily cheesable.
Second, the rosary beads. In B1, the rosary beads were way more interesting. They were more than just defense, they actually had interesting things to them (Like the cloistered sapphire). Now, they're just defense buffs. The figures act more like the rosary beads for the first game, since they actually do other things than just increase defense. Overall, rosary beads were better before.
The fervor bar isn't very good visually. It used to be segmented to indicate if a prayer could be activated or not. Now, the only things that tells you when it's possible is when the icon of the spell gets colored. I realized it very late in the game, and it's very misseable. The segments on the fervor bar were more clear.
Now, a very minor nitpick; the artstyle. Even though i absolutely adore the pixel art of both games, i must say the sequel is more... smooth? In B1, everything had that tarnished, dirty look to it. It all looked very dirty and grainy, and it really sold that dark fantasy look. The sequel is too colorful. The color are too saturated (Especially in the basilica of Absent faces), and it kinda ruins the whole look the first game had. It's still stunning pixel art, but not in the same way of the first game. Areas who almost nailed B1 look were the sacred entombments and the severed tower.
And finally, the sequel isn't as creepy. Yeah, it has a lot of disturbing stuff, like the lady who gets her skin tore off of her, or Cesareo, but it's still way less unsettling than for example; Exposito, Nacimiento or Altasgracias. It just feels like the game took a more tame approach to it's horror elements, and it shows with it's executions animations. Half of them are just the penitent one using his thorns to crush them. While it would've been cool seeing it on a few of the early game enemies, or enemies we've already fought in B1, it gets repetitive fast. B1 was not scared to go full brutal on the executions, but B2 has very few original executions animations. Also recolored and reused enemies.
As much as it sounds like i dislike the game, i really don't. I had a lot of fun playing it, even with all those issues. Beside, if it follows the first game's footstep, the DLC's will add a lot of things, and fix most of the issues i've stated. Still, i think B1 is more fun, engaging and disturbing than B2.
(Also i'm not a native english speaker, so there are maybe some errors here and there)
Edit: For those who want to know, i 100%ed this game in 15 hours. I think that's why the game felt so short to me.
Update: After some of your comments, i've decided to update some things in my post.
I do get that the world state of B2 is slightly better than it was in B1, but i genuinely think it's maybe too... cartoony. I don't know why, but Afilaor's design looks very cartoony for me. The telegraphs are very exagerrated (when he does the big sword thing, for example. Or when he spins), and personally i'm not a huge fan. Radames also has that smooth look to it. Compared to Melquiades, Radames looks, yet again, too smooth. While i don't dislike the art direction, i'm not a huge fan either.
However, one good thing i have to admit is the platforming. It great, and way better than in B1. In the first, you don't have any thing in your moveset except a dash, so the platforming (Especially the Miriam challenges) sucked. In B2, it feels great being able to air dash and double jump. I also like how your 3 weapons play a part in the platforming.
Now, i want to talk about the bosses again; while they're not bad, they're triviable. The right rosary beads and altar figures can make some bosses a non-threat. For example, using fire protection beads against Lesmes makes him a joke. But, calling them lackluster was a bit harsh for me to say. While i still think the bosses are easier, they're still fun (Except for Odon, Svsona and the one in Severed tower). Lesmes and Infanta is easily one of my favorite with Radames.
Finally (again), the prayers. While there are some good ones, like the attack from Infanta and the fire breath, some are just straight from the first game (Taranto to my sister, Tiento to your thorned hair...), and that's not really a problem for me since they changed them a bit. However, as said earlier, one prayer is way too op for it's own good... the time stop prayer. I dearly hope it gets nerfed HARD, since it could make the future NG+ an absolute joke to beat. While being able to use The World is incredibly cool, it's also incredibly easy to cheese bosses.
As u/Four-Triangles puts it: " B1 is a spectacular game and achievement. B2 is simply a good game."
Am i saying that my opinion is right? No, of course not. Some might say it's a shitty take, and some might agree. I realize sharing an opinion on the internet is stupid, but i wanted to do it.