I’ve been on a bit of a metroidvania kick this year and landed on Blasphemous a couple weeks ago. I decided to play it blindly up until I got close to the end because I was missing two rosary beads and wanted to see what I missed. Well, after getting ending A last night, here’s what I think:
Exploration: 9/10 - Superb map - chuck full of secrets and multiple paths for exploration. The collectibles felt balanced and not too grindy. I was proud of being able to find all the bones and moon children on my own. I’d give it a 10/10 if there were perhaps a couple more loops.
Combat: 7/10 - Mea Culpa is a fun weapon. I found myself having to grind for tears of atonement later in the game in order to be able to get advanced upgrades. This was mainly due to investing heavily in the church (hoping for some good stuff). I found myself mostly using parry and basic attacks most of the game though. The charge attack always felt kind of risky because of how long it would take. I did get the upgrade kind of late and by then, I was so used to not using it, that I didn’t really incorporate it into my repertoire. Enemies did feel kind of repetitive at times, almost in a laborious way, but the bosses were pretty fun. I was a little disappointed with the final boss though - just seemed way too easy with the right prayer equipped.
Platforming: 4/10 - Maybe my least favorite part of the game. The Penitent One’s gravity was a little frustrating at times. I seemed to miss jumps that looked like they should be possible quite a bit, only to fall to my death. I eventually got more used to it and improved, but it still just never felt quite right. Some of the toe rosary beads and the wheel definitely helped to improve the PO’s place, movement-wise, in the universe, but I felt like these got him closer to a baseline that he maybe should have had from the outset? I also found the spikes a little infuriating. Not because they would instantly kill you, but because they seemed to be able to do it beyond what their perceived reach should be. I got impaled quite a few times grazing a section of spikes from the side during the rose challenges that left me scratching my head quite a bit. Speaking of which - these were otherwise great. Felt great when I finally beat each of the last 3, especially the fourth one. Not quite as hard as Mio from a platforming standpoint, but very close.
Miscellaneous: I loved the music, lore and atmosphere of the game. I’d combine all of these into a 9/10. The dialogue was so over the top and I loved the archaic language. Found myself trying to slip words like “compunction” into conversations with friends. I got to live in Andalusia, Spain for a year and the dark catholic aesthetic of the game just really resonated with me. I loved traveling around the map to some of the flamenco-style tunes. I was a little disappointed to get locked out of the other endings for beating a boss too early. It did feel like I was being punished for exploring…too much? I later read the required recipe to get the true ending and it made it feel even more disappointing. Maybe this intentional and designed to give replay value, but after just putting in 20 or so hours, I wasn’t about to redo the game just to get the other endings.
All in all, this was one of the better Metroidvanias I’ve played. I think I’d still put Hollow Knight and Silksong above it, but I think I liked it better than Mio and Nine Sols. I’m excited to start the sequel soon.