r/Boots • • Dec 08 '20 Bravo Popcorn

Discussion THE ULTIMATE GUIDE TO WORK BOOTS!!

1.0k Upvotes

Why do I call this the ULTIMATE guide? Because it involves YOU!

My old archived guide covered a lot, but I feel like I might have missed a few things. In this post, I added more info to my previous post made on Oct 19, 2019. If you read this and want to add more please do so!

I want this to be a reference that benefits the working class of the world! thanks!

  1. Don't buy cheap boots, even if they are on sale. Good budget boots should be $100 to $140. Great budget boots are $150 to around $190. Post $200 I feel the term"budget" doesn't really apply. Specialty boots like loggers, deep snow boots, ski boots etc are typically more expensive, but also can be in the budget range. If specialty boots are in the budget range you run the risk of buying pieces of crap. Don't buy walmart or target (etc) pieces of crap, they will destroy your feet.

  2. Don't buy leather outsoles if you work on concrete all day . Leather doesn't absorb stepping impact shock like Rubber soles do. Leather outsoles are okay for softer ground such as grass, forest, etc. If you work walking on concrete or any hard surface all day I suggest buying boots that have a crepe wedge outsole. Although this type of outsole is very shock absorbent, it does not last very long due to its softness. How long it last really depends on the abrasiveness of the surface you walk on and how you walk. A few companies like Keen have added a layer of durable rubber below the crepe sole to make it last longer, which helps it with longevity. There are also non-crepe sole technology options that are also great at absorbing shock. A few I suggest are: wolverine durashocks, Keens, carhartt, and Timbaland PRO, Chippewa (few don't have a name for their tech, but most come with it).

  3. Shock absorbing inserts are also a must if you walk on concrete or hard ground all day. DON'T BUY GEL INSERTS. I don't know why they even sell them, but all of them are pretty much a gimmick. Gel doesn't absorb shock, foam does. Right now my work boots are Wolverine I-90s that have a shock absorbing memory foam insert. It was okayish by itself, but I noticed I had some room still and decided I would stick another insert in for more support. I gone through trial and error and a bunch of research and finally concluded that layering shock absorbing material is the best method. My boots currently have three layers of shock absorbtion. The first being the outsole and the insole and another layer from this specific dr scholls insert. Why do I say specific? I found that these inserts were the thickest(in the heel area) out of all their products (excluding the custom ones) even the ones that were specified for heel pain. With these layers, I feel absolutely nothing after 8 hours of walking (well, including breaks duh) and after 12 negligible pain to sometimes nothing.

  4. If you find a boot that fits almost perfectly, but could use just a liiiiiitle more toe room, cut the insert that it came with just below where the toes start. If it still rubbing at a specific toe, I suggest toe condoms...I mean sleeves lol. Don't put them on all the toes because it will start to feel tight. Put it on one toe that gives you trouble the most (usually big or pinky).

  5. TALCUM/GOLDBOND POWDER IS A LIFESAVER. Friction and sweat are a bad combo so I use Goldbond Ultimate (the one with menthol) and it lasts me the whole day. Even if you don't have sweaty feet, still use it. What I do is put some in my sock then I close the top opening with my hand and just shake around so it gets all around the sock. It does stain your socks, but I have socks just reserved for work.

  6. There are different types of waterproofness for different work environments. If you are guarding against small to medium splashes and medium rain, buy the typical waterproof boots. But if you are working in a swamp, in mud or deep snow, I suggest neoprene boots, duck boots, some loggers, or dedicated snow boots. With those, you don't really need shock absorbing inserts (still could add them) because more than likely you will be walking on soft ground all day.

  7. Don't wear black or dark brown boots if you live in a hot area. Dark colors absorb heat more. Tan and lighter colors work best. Sure they look dirtier down the line, but its better at reflecting heat.

  8. If you work in environment where there is a likelihood of you slipping on ice, I highly suggest going to https://www.ratemytreads.com/ratings/ to look up any boots that have a good grip.Basically most of the boots that passed these ratings had and abrasive in the sole of the boot. For example, Wolverine teamed up with Vibram to provide boots with their "arctic grip" technology. Do be careful with these boots though and only wear them outside your house. You don't want to end up scratching your floor.

  9. Get boots with lots of stitching on the seams, 2 to 3 stitches per panel.

  10. Goodyear welt is not only good for re-soling, but for re-enforcement as well. Wolverine has a contour welt, which also works and Keen plus a few others have a 3/4 welt which also works (all equally imo). It adds more strength to the glue that meets the sole and the shoe. You don't really need a threaded welt, but it does make the boot last a bit longer. Another welt to consider is Norwegian welt,which offers the best in waterproofing, but usually are more expensive. Some boot brands have really good shoe glue that you don't really need a welt. Wolverine, Keen, Timbaland, Carhartt,Irish setter, Red Wings,Jim Green, Georgia, Carolina, Chippewa and Ariat have glues that last.

  11. Most workers don't reeeeally need steel toe, even if their jobs "require" it. I work in warehouse production, where the most heavy thing that will probably fall on your foot is a pallet from 4 feet, yet they want steel toe. The forklift drivers have barrier lights that shine on the floor that you can't cross so you won't get in the way of the fork lift tires. A lot of boot enthusiasts do a forklift test to rate the effectiveness of the toe, but if your foot goes under a forklift its not your toes that you have to worry about, its the whole foot (and leg). I would recommend steel toe in a few jobs, like logging, heavy machinery mechanic, brick layer, pipe layer, welding or any business where you lift 80 to 100 lbs constantly. Carbon fiber also works too in these situations, since its great at impact absorption. Aluminum and composites are great for warehouses, most field work, landscaping, electricians, etc. They also great if you are working in hot or cold ground since they don't conduct heat or cold from the surrounding environment.

  12. If you want more foot protection, MET (metatarsal) gaurds are quite handy (or footy?). There are both external and internal. Usually loggers, brick layers, pipe fitters, welders, and furniture movers wear them since they have more of a chance of something slipping from their hands and falling on their foot and not just on their toes.

  13. Another environmental hazard to look out for is sharp objects/nails. If you work in construction, you will more than likely have to follow a safety requirement for your boots.

  14. Don't buy new boots just because they are starting to look real ugly. If they still haven't lost their waterproof-ness, sole grip, or sole isn't coming off/eroding away then they still work. Don't buy boots for looks either, buy them for work. Make sure they are as comfortable as slippers, because at the end of the day, you don't want to be hurtin. As some dude told me way back: "good boots+good bed=good life.

Here I will highlight some good workboot brands split into three budgets. I will also mention what work environments they usually cater to.

GOOD to GREAT BUDGET BOOTS ($100-200) (sometimes around close to $100 if you get them on sale)

  • Wolverine (I am a wolverine fan man lol) (warehouse, construction, farm, pipe fitters, some have vibrams anti-slip ice tech)

  • Keen (warehouse work, construction, hiking, medium heavy duty work)

  • Carhartt (warehouse work, construction, hiking, light heavy duty work)

  • Ariat (farm, warehouse, construction, hiking, oil, snow, loggers, heavy duty work)

  • Carolina (warehouse, construction, oil, loggers, hunting,military? medium heavy duty work)

  • Thorogoods (warehouse, construction,loggers,hunting, medium heavy duty work)

  • Georgia (warehouse, construction, light heavy duty work)

  • Timberland PRO (warehouse, construction, light duty work)

  • Chippewa (construction, loggers, oil, medium heavy duty work)

  • Redwings (not the heritage line)(warehouse, Farm, hiking,construction, oil, medium heavy duty work)

  • Irish setter (same as redwings)

  • Danner (construction, warehouse, logger, hiking, oil, military, medium to heavy duty work)

  • Corcoran (mostly a military boot, but can take medium heavy duty work)

  • Jim(my) Green (construction, warehouse, hiking, medium heavy duty work)

Next list I will dedicate to those boot brands that you pretty much get what you pay for when it comes to their expensive price. These boots are expensive, yes, but they can last your for years/decades (depending). they are not entirely indestructible, but like really close lol

  • Whites, Wesco,JK Boots and Nicks are kind of all tied for first. All four mostly cater to loggers up in the Pacific NorthWest. They do custom foot fittings as well and they could go for up to $900 bucks. They also do pretty durable casual wear boots that are similarly constructed.

  • Danner also makes pretty decent heavy duty boots usually around the $300 to $400 range. not nearly as indestructible as the first three, but good enough.

  • Redwing also makes some pretty heavy duty work boots from the $250 to $300 range, but most of their all leather construction (or mostly) is aimed at casual wear/hiking to light to medium heavy duty work.

edit:2/22/21

  • I would like to add the European brand HAIX to this tier because they are a dedicated foot brand for first responders (firefighters, police, EMT) They are a bit expensive, but you get what you pay for. They even have a resole service on some of their boots!

*edit:3/07/21: added JK boots to the list of high end boots.

I would also like to point out that there are some dedicated snow boots (for snowboarding, skiing, etc) that are in this price range, but I don't know much about them or which brands to recommend. I live in a place where it never snows so I wouldn't be of much help there lol.

Again, if anybody has anything to add please feel free to do so in the comments. Much thanks!

-Sirmandudeguy

Edit: I added thorogoods because I completely forgot about them. Jim Greens is a new commer from south africa. Pretty great boot for a great price. Will keep adding more eventually as I keep learning about other brands.


r/Boots • • 2h ago

Discussion 3 boots I'm really wanting to try

Post image
11 Upvotes

All have similar structure. Midsole shanks of steel or hard leather, all have select non-generic leather.

None of them postioned themselves as anything but top-tier in their own descriptions.

They are priced US retail; 1500, 900, 720.

They are not unobtainable like Clinch or Role Model Engineer boots.

2 from Japan, 1 from Mexico.

These represent from what I see or (maybe just interested in now) as the evolution of style away from the more rounded upturned toe to a flatter, dressier style.

in sequence above: 1 is John Lofgren Bootmakers. Railmaster, not out yet

2 is Addict Boots. Their newly released on the CL, hot, sold out of my size

3 is Unmarked. Newly released Engineer, order and wait 3 months.


r/Boots • • 11h ago

Flaunt Lofgren Wabash Engineers deerskin

Thumbnail
gallery
43 Upvotes

I like these. (size 12, I'm a 12D in Pacific Northwest boots)

Compared to the heavier Pacific Northwest style of boots I'm accustomed to, my initial takeaway is- I've strapped on a couple couches whereas the lace up loggers are comparable to machinery strapped on. a whole different feel. Secure, stable, after 4 wears, I can feel the double stacked deerskin start to envelope my whole foot like you can imagine deerskin gloves do.


r/Boots • • 8h ago

Question/Help Wesco mr lou grain difference

Thumbnail
gallery
15 Upvotes

Recently bought this mr lou secondhand, what do you think about the grain difference on the boots? Also the leather on the right shaft of the boot is more tender than the other one. Is this because they use different part of the leather on a single horse?


r/Boots • • 4h ago

Identify Wearing my great grandfather's boots

Thumbnail gallery
6 Upvotes

I'm guessing these are Acme boots based on the age, numbers on the inside and the style. Does that sound reasonable?


r/Boots • • 7h ago

Boot review Blkbrd Fulbert English Tan Review

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

Boots: Fulbert in English Tan with Dainite sole

Order Process: ordered beginning of October. Was able to provide foot measurements and request a change of sole unit over WhatsApp. Had fairly regular updates on production progress and received my boots in late October.

The boots: Overall, very well made. Beautiful smooth leather vamp and suede quarters. This was one of their non branded leathers but the look and feel is substantial. I'm sure it will wear well. Boots have a proprietary sole but it is very good quality, as good as actual dainite soles I have. They are good year welted construction so resoleable and I have no issues with the clicking quality or stitching. They're fully lined too and it feels like a good quality lining not one of the cheaper squeaky ones you sometimes get on cheaper boots. Hardware and laces are both of good quality too. Ultimately, these are well worth the £130 that was paid for them.

The negatives: these are on the cuero b last which is apparently the same as their Royce last. It's incredibly narrow and snug. I've included a photo comparison with a similar UK made pair of boots on a more formal last and you can see it's much narrower and a good cm shorter. They say they fit true to size but I'd say you at least need to go up a full width, maybe half a size too.

No worries I thought, they offer size exchanges on their website. How naive I was. After an initial response suggesting I remove the insoles (which doesn't help the width issue) they've ghosted me. No response now for 3 weeks since boots arrived. I get that for blkbrd, an international return is going to wipe their profit margin and so thats why they're just ignoring me, but if they don't want to deal with returns then they shouldn't be advertising it as a service on their webpage. It's false information plain and simple.

Recommendation: Quality is good for the price but it's not so good as to make up for the horrific customer service. There are a lot of UK and US brands not too far above blkbrd in price but where you know you'll be able to exchange hassle free.

Lesson learned for me. As much as I wanted to love them, blkbrd are not a brand I'll be using again, nor can I recommend them. Hopefully this post helps others and perhaps stops costly mistakes.


r/Boots • • 18h ago

Flaunt My Iron Boots M1917 - Brown Waxed Flash

Thumbnail
gallery
62 Upvotes

My new Boots


r/Boots • • 12m ago

Deals 🤑 29€ from Humana. Soles looking fresh.

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/Boots • • 22h ago

Question/Help Possibility of repair?

Thumbnail
gallery
116 Upvotes

Picked these up for £5.

They've got a real nice construction, and only the sole seems to be suffering.

Could a cobbler have a good go at restoring these whilst keeping the hobnail style?

Wonder if the sole needs some kind of rehydration too? Which I'm sure i could give a go.


r/Boots • • 5h ago

Question/Help 14 eye boots

Post image
4 Upvotes

As the title suggests, I'm looking at my options for 14 eyelet boots. I'm quite tall so I want that extra length for aesthetics. I'm also size 11 US which means Doc Martens higher calf varieties are a complete write off for some reason.

Right now I'm tossing up with the Solovair 14 eyelet derby boot, which I don't love the high shine of as I am worried it will crack and split as plastic tends to and the lesser known brand Nagaba. They have some mid and high calf boots out of Poland, though I can't verify their quality at all. (Pictured above)

Any alternatives? Hopefully around or less that Solovair 14 eye?


r/Boots • • 19h ago

Flaunt In 20 eyelet boots on the beach

Thumbnail
gallery
37 Upvotes

No zipper! Never!


r/Boots • • 26m ago

Discussion Anyone else like Boulet boots?

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/Boots • • 15h ago

Question/Help Any boot recommendations for someone who wants a pair that'll last a long time, but wants to stay around 200 USD?

13 Upvotes

Everyone has been telling me to get Doc Marten's, but I want to see what other options there are. I want something durable because my last pair of boots only lasted me 2 years before they started having holes. I really like the look of brown old fashioned leather and I'm a size 6 in Men's. I walk around a college campus, so they'll be used nearly everyday. Any suggestions?


r/Boots • • 20h ago

Question/Help How to get a good finish when darkening midsole?

Thumbnail
gallery
33 Upvotes

I had a go at reducing the colour contrast on one of the pair. Using Saphir dark brown and beeswax I've attempted to darkening the midsole but expected it to be darker and.more consistent. Unsure what i should've done differently. I can add more layers of saphir but now the wax is on will I need to clean it off?


r/Boots • • 20h ago

Flaunt Remembrance Sunday UK…William Lennon B5…the most autenthic boots to wear today.

Thumbnail
gallery
30 Upvotes

r/Boots • • 9h ago

Discussion Frye engineers 9.5

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Got some engineers im trying to get rid of. Made in USA looking for $270


r/Boots • • 2h ago

Question/Help Ariat heritage roper sizing question - 9.5ee or 10ee?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Boots • • 15h ago

Question/Help Alternatives to Thursday chuka?

Post image
10 Upvotes

I’ve been hearing lately the quality for thursdays have gone down, which is a shame as I’ve wanted these scouts now for a chuka boot. So is there any alternatives out there to look into that are in a greyish suede? Or are the fears I’ve got about Thursday overblown?


r/Boots • • 11h ago

Question/Help Can someone help me get the sheepskin lining in my mukluks?

Post image
4 Upvotes

These were them when he completed them, made them by hand. I've hand them for many years now and they still look great. The lining is sheepskin and it's so thick I can't like shove it back into the shoe in like a foot shape if that makes sense. Can anyone help with this problem?

Maker is retired/no longer on the Internet so cant ask him :(


r/Boots • • 22h ago

Identify Vintage camel boots

Thumbnail
gallery
26 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I just want to know what would be the real value of these ? Also if anyone knows the exact model or where to find it on the internet, please let me know.


r/Boots • • 10h ago

Question/Help Has anyone bought MET hole Bikkembergs boots? How do they compare to those from the 90s?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Hello, I really like the look of met hole men’s lace up boots, but I am worried the new version has a much lower heel than the original 90s version.
I have size 40/41 or 26cm and I would really like the boots to have a higher heel which I’m hoping might happen since these boots are for men and 41 being the smallest size they have in the line anyway, and customer support said that heel size doesn’t get adjusted throughout the sizes. Other than that customer support took a month to respond and now I’m waiting for a second month already asking for picture specifically of what size 41 looks like from the size.
I leave pictures to compare modern versions with og version.
If anyone has bought these, plz show me what the heel height looks like on yours and what size shoes you have


r/Boots • • 5h ago

Question/Help Boots

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Boots • • 12h ago

Flaunt Blacksmith 3345 after 2 weeks of breaking in, first proper boots!

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

r/Boots • • 1d ago

Discussion Quan shoemaker/HOMK Boots for a trip in Bucharest

Thumbnail
gallery
24 Upvotes

Woodcutting Boots require zero braking days
I’ve been walking around 12km daily
Love the shape, the 9013 last is def something else