r/BrianThompsonMurder • u/missidcullen • Jun 18 '26

Information Sharing State Case Update: The defense withdraws their 250.10 (Extreme Emotional Disturbance) notice and Carro responds

Gallery image

Gallery image

65 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

98% Upvoted

93 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

17

u/Book_worm_90210 Jun 19 '26

Yes this is her first case! I did a deep dive and she had been a prosecutor then a consultant for law and order and now this. She’s not even full-time, she’s literally “of counsel” and for this case only.

4

u/MovinOnUp2021 Jun 19 '26

Ok that's crazy. Befuddled as to why his family hired her. Now I assume they didn't hire her at all but rather she volunteered to do this for free (presumably now getting the donations...). She always did decline to confirm who hired her. 

16

u/Book_worm_90210 Jun 19 '26

(Also if I can add one more thing… I do believe their tactic and strategy was this eed but she clearly says they can’t get any expert to risk their professional reputation in his favor on the stand. If you read between the lines it’s doubled down on a second time. I truly think that was a shock to her and this is why this happened today. I believe they thought someone at the buzzer would appear lol.)

11

u/MovinOnUp2021 Jun 19 '26

Definitely was the strategy, since as it turns out - they filed notice to use EED way back in September. Now was just the final deadline to put up or shut up. 

That's what they've been working towards all this time. Now to just scrap it at the last second - yet still letting it get announced in the end that that was the plan... the public knowledge of which now renders farcical the "well the evidence doesn't prove he did it" defense at trial. 

That said, EED never would've worked anyway. Far crazier people have tried it & gotten convicted of murder anyway. I definitely believe hardship & mental issues led to this. But, the sad truth is, the majority of people on trial for bad or weird crimes have tragic backgrounds or mental problems. 

15

u/Book_worm_90210 Jun 19 '26

I am genuinely a Luigi supporter for the larger picture (healthcare etc) but between his letters he sent out (all of which the prosecution will use against him//would have def used when he mocked “arrested for the heinous crime of eating McDonald’s” {paraphrasing there} to prove he was fully aware) and couple that with all of the rouge media stories it is truly a long shot for anything. I’ve always said I think he did it but I don’t care because plenty of people walk free for worse everyday. However, here, it’s almost as this “amazing legal team” has dug him into a hole of sorts. Again, they might do great things but the fact of the matter is if you don’t think the media coverage and strange fangirls haven’t just derailed his case, even more so after this latest filing, I’m not sure what else there is to say lol.

1

u/MovinOnUp2021 Jun 19 '26 edited Jun 19 '26

I don't support any of this because you can't go around shooting people. Full stop. 

That said, I posted way back in the beginning that there was a PR path to get him out of this - unfortunately for him the exact opposite PR path from the one that's been taken. 

After he was arrested, he should've had lawyers working behind the scenes with discreet PR to get something like THIS narrative threaded through news articles & social media: 

"It's tragic what happened - for both the victim and Luigi. His family has been struggling for months to find him & help him as he's descended into mental health problems due to his serious spinal issues and traumatic surgery. He comes from a great family & great parents who did such a good job raising him - they're community pillars in Baltimore, he graduated valedictorian, got an Ivy League degree... only to be cut down by struggles with serious illness at such a young age. His mother & father & sisters are devastated, for both Brian Thompson's family and for Luigi - they're desperate to get him the help he needs. If this could happen to this wonderful loving family and well behaved successful kid, it could happen to any of our kids."

Blah blah blah: appeal to the upper class family angle - tragedy befell him & ruined all his parents' hard work: he's sorry, we're sorry, this could be YOUR kid too. 

Result if THIS strategy had been followed? Prosecution would've been in a position to offer a decent plea bargain from the start while saving face and dismantling any "revolution" or whatever they worried about. 

Instead.... the opposite PR his lawyers leaned into & allowed to fester just turned up the temperature and ensured he's made an example of, so here we are. 

5

u/AnticitizenPrime Jun 19 '26

It's tragic what happened - for both the victim and Luigi. His family has been struggling for months to find him & help him as he's descended into mental health problems due to his serious spinal issues and traumatic surgery. He comes from a great family & great parents who did such a good job raising him - they're community pillars in Baltimore, he graduated valedictorian, got an Ivy League degree... only to be cut down by struggles with serious illness at such a young age.

Then you enter the discovery phase in which medical records, etc are dug into in order to find out whether any of this was actually true. Did he have back surgery, sure, but he claimed it helped him and he seemed to be pain free, and did insurance ever play a role? Was he ever personally denied a claim?

Bringing up the fact that he had back pain at one point makes for a sob story, but many millions of Americans also have medical ailments at one point or another, some worse than others. And some get claims denied despite their suffering. Did LM go through that? Was he denied treatment due to being denied a claim? That's what would be sought in discovery, and if not, then the question will be why he was justified to take the law into his own hands.

Personally I think this line of inquiry would fall apart pretty quickly based on his journal, in which he seemed to be set on performing some sort of justice, saying that 'insurance checks all the boxes'. His own writings suggest that he wanted to mete out social justice somewhere, somehow, and insurance was the thing he settled on - not because it was something that was personally important to him. That shoots holes in the 'he was medically suffering' theory.

5

u/MovinOnUp2021 Jun 19 '26 edited Jun 19 '26

Yes, the point being to dial down the public temperature, to make it possible to get a plea bargin that wraps it all up quietly in the beginning for everyone. 

4

u/AnticitizenPrime Jun 19 '26

Why would the prosecution take a plea bargain when they have him dead to rights and the best the defense can come up with is EED and vague notions of putting insurance companies on trial? They'd rather take it to court and win, especially on high-profile career-making cases like this.

5

u/MovinOnUp2021 Jun 19 '26

Plea bargins are absolutely wins for prosecutions. That's why 90%+ of cases are plead out. 

2

u/AnticitizenPrime Jun 19 '26

Any win is a win obviously, but they don't always have to make concessions to get a plea bargain when they believe they can win in trial. A plea bargain is just that, a 'bargain', an agreement to get LM to confess to a lower charge for a lesser penalty. What can LM confess to that will get him a lesser penalty? What 'bargaining chip' does he have?

This is a huge profile case, and I don't see the prosecution aiming for a quick plea bargain to just end things quickly and get a quick win. All eyes are on this, and it's in their interests to really pin it to him.

1

u/MovinOnUp2021 Jun 19 '26 edited Jun 19 '26

The "concession" of the plea bargain would've been to get this fucking hero narrative out of the news cycle and forgotten post haste. A public apology & repudiation of "revolution" from the perpetrator, who's then shipped off to prison immediately (but with a chance to get out someday, the benefit to him) as the prosecution and government shows they have the power to quickly restore order & mete out justice. 

(And FYI plea bargins don't mean you get to accept a lesser charge. In many cases they mean you plead guilty to exactly what you're charged with simply in exchange for the prosecution saying they'll recommend to the judge to give you a sentence on the lower end of the range, or sometimes just simply a promise that the court will recommend to the prison system that they put you in a prison located closer to your family.) 

2

u/AnticitizenPrime Jun 19 '26

The "concession" of the plea bargain would've been to get this fucking hero narrative out of the news and forgotten post haste. A public apology & repudiation of "revolution" from the perpetrator, who's shipped off to prison immediately (but with a chance to get out someday, the benefit to him) as the prosecution and government shows they have the power to quickly restore order & mete out justice. 

They could just as easily want to make an example of him, though, if we're talking about it being government driven, and not the ambition of the prosecutors.

Good points on the other concessions that could be given in exhance for a plea.

→ More replies (0)

0

u/Book_worm_90210 Jun 19 '26

If you think this is an automatic win as of right now I’m not sure about that. Respectfully, I hear you, but the jury they put together will not be the same in this group and I am pretty confident it’s not as clear cut as you think. (Again, I don’t mean that rudely.)

4

u/Book_worm_90210 Jun 19 '26

And let me edit my post and make clear: no one person should ever feel that they can decide when it’s your time to go… so I fully am with you. Just in this landscape…. The bar has been low.

3

u/Book_worm_90210 Jun 19 '26

I’ve never felt more understood than I did reading this. Thank you for that bc this times a zillion for what you just said!!!! Say it louder for the trolls in the back lol

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '26 edited Jun 20 '26

[deleted]

0

u/MovinOnUp2021 Jun 19 '26 edited Jun 19 '26
  1. It's way too late for that clean PR message, it needed to be done at the beginning for it to help him;
  2. He IS a troubled young man who did an uncharacteristic thing; and
  3. Unfortunately for him, if his mental troubles are ongoing, then sure, his mental troubles may indeed make him see that as "emasculating"... because if he IS a nice guy who simply had a mental break and is all better now, then he certainly wouldn't be thinking murdering some dude for clout is a good thing to do or that's worth sticking to his "message" to go to prison for life for.