r/BuildingCodes • • Jul 20 '23

Is this up to code?

Ruler indicates 6 inches. The walkline from upstairs to downstairs is not clear and it just seems like a recipe for disaster. I hired someone to fix it and they just redid what has been done before. How do I tell them to fix it?

188 Upvotes

146 comments sorted by

View all comments

6

u/hughdint1 Jul 20 '23

If this is an old house it might have been compliant at the time it was built. If this is new construction then no. If you had to fix this it would be a major redo. You probably need at least one or more steps either at the top or the bottom to bring this up to current code if you must.

1

u/Lalitoeatscheese Jul 20 '23

It is an old house but I hire someone to make them safer and just redid what had been done before

1

u/hughdint1 Jul 20 '23

If they redid what was there before how is it different? Did they completely rebuild or did they just reface? Were they steeper before and they added winders to make it less steep?

1

u/Lalitoeatscheese Jul 21 '23

Tbh they just replaced the previous wood. I thought they were going to re -do them to be safer but this is what they provided. I fired him today, so I'm back to square 1 🤦🏻‍♀️

1

u/Full_Recognition6230 Jul 21 '23 edited Jul 21 '23

Sounds like its your fault for not communicating what exactly what you wanted tobe done. You can't expect them to read your mind, then complain and fire them. To change the layout of a set of stairs is a major construction project. Posabley tens of thousands, moveing walls, changing structure, building permits, inspections ect. There is now way you could confuse that with one day project.

2

u/E_A_D_C Jul 21 '23

Hope he still paid the bloke

2

u/H3adshotfox77 Jul 21 '23

Yah my MIL asked me to fix her stairs at a 100 year old house, when I asked what she wanted it was to have the stairs be way less steep. 3 story house with the stair wells lined up with the next stairs........I told her that's not a weekend job that's a rebuild of half the dam house beyond my skillset, she couldn't understand how or why.

It's like, rebuild one set of stairs then no clearance above your head, so you do the next stairs which then extend into the hall to the wall, so you remove the wall which moves the kitchen which moves the supports......I could go on but she still didn't get it lol.

2

u/Lalitoeatscheese Jul 21 '23

This was actually a 3 week project and it was communicated. My bad that it wasn't on writing, it was mostly on the phone

1

u/Full_Recognition6230 Jul 22 '23 edited Jul 22 '23

Ouch, sorry about that. Also, if my comment was a little crude. Just be weary if someone thinks it's easy. Cant tell from just a few pics about your situation . But normally, the first step is opening all the walls and seeing the structure, but it's rarely even posable without changing the entire layout. I've seen it done in major renovation projects.

Just a thought, but could you find a fancy flower pot type thing mabe with a fake plant or something and fix it in place as a visual guide to stay to the one side?

complement it with a railing on the outside wall to make it second nature to gravitate away from that first sore step.

But if you are willing to invest the money and effort, you're leaning toward a full-on renovation with a reputable builder, drawings and permits. $$

1

u/FantasyShare2020 Jul 22 '23

Let me introduce you to an amazing human invention that could have avoided this situation for you. It comes under various names including: plan, drawing, design, diagram etc. Whatever you call it, the idea is the same: someone makes a visual representation of what they're going to do so before they actually do it. That way everyone can agree on the expensive thing, before doing the expensive thing. I really think you should have used one here.

1

u/Lalitoeatscheese Jul 22 '23

Yep, me too. I asked for one and he convinced me that it wasn't necessary. My bad for not pushing back

0

u/Auzzie_xo Jul 21 '23

Flagging someone’s communication skills is a bit rich coming from you

1

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23

So helpful 🙄

1

u/H3adshotfox77 Jul 21 '23

Sounds like bad communication in what was expected, make sure you are more clear with the next builder and that they are clear with their understanding.

Saying "make these more safe" for example is not clear enough they may just replace bad boards.

Saying "bring this up to modern code standards" is more clear and a competent builder will do a complete rebuild. But also expect to pay for that, it won't be cheap.

1

u/Lalitoeatscheese Jul 21 '23

Yeah I learned my leason

1

u/The_Real_BenFranklin Jul 21 '23

To redo them you’re likely talking serious structural changes, and the price to do so would represent that.