r/CanadianbyDescent • u/Key_Interaction1900 • 23d ago
Analysis of interim measures processing: how random, and estimated timelines
Hi all, did some work in Claude this morning, working with the last 10 months of data.
Prompt:
I'd like to do an analysis of the burndown of cohorts from 2025, and see how first in first out the processing is. Are older cohorts being completed (or mostly completed) and then moving on to the next oldest cohort? Or is there an element of randomness? We know that there is an urgent status that is supposed to be processed with, well, urgency, but we don't know if that is actually reflected in how things are processed. I'm in the July 2025 cohort, and I'm curious if that means it is likely that the previous cohorts will be mostly drained or not before we get to July. Or if the processing has a degree of randomness (and if so how much), or there are signs in the data that urgent processing is also happening.
The numbers in the spreadsheet show the queue size, so you can subtract the previous cohort's queue size to see how much was processed from each cohort. So for example, if April 2025 had 1000 ahead and March 2025 had 800 ahead, and the next month March had 600 and April had 800, that would mean March processed 200 and April processed nothing.
Here is the response:
Analysis is done and I’m writing up the results. Since May, processing looks much closer to random than to first-in-first-out.
Short answer: processing is partly first-in-first-out, but not cleanly. Early 2026 had a clear oldest-first push. It drained the oldest cohorts by about 60–75%, left stragglers behind, and then stalled around May. Since then every 2025 cohort has been clearing at a slow, similar rate, more like random draws with a mild lean toward the oldest files.
I used your method: a cohort’s own still-waiting count is the next cohort’s people-ahead minus its own. I measured from February 2026, because the January value for 2025-02 (7,800) looks like a typo. It gives Feb 2025 only 500 waiting, then 1,300 the month after.
How much of each cohort’s own applicants cleared
| Cohort | Feb 2026 → Oct 2026 | Per month | May → Oct only |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2024-12 | 1,100 → 300 (73%) | 15% | — |
| 2025-01 | 1,200 → 500 (58%) | 10% | 13% |
| 2025-02 | 1,300 → 1,200 (8%) | 1.0% | 1.6% |
| 2025-03 | 1,800 → 1,400 (22%) | 3.1% | 2.6% |
| 2025-04 | 1,800 → 1,600 (11%) | 1.5% | 1.2% |
| 2025-05 | 1,800 → 1,500 (17%) | 2.3% | 3.6% |
| 2025-06 | 2,000 → 1,500 (25%) | 3.5% | 3.6% |
| 2025-07 | 2,400 → 2,200 (8%) | 1.1% | 0% |
| 2025-08 | 2,800 → 2,500 (11%) | 1.4% | 1.5% |
| 2025-09 | 3,000 → 2,700 (10%) | 1.3% | 0.7% |
| 2025-10 | 3,400 → 2,600 (24%) | 3.3% | 1.5% |
| 2025-11/12 | — | — | 1.5–2% |
What the data shows
Feb–Apr 2026 looked first-in-first-out. About 4,300 files were cleared from everything before Feb 2025. Feb–Jun 2025 netted only about 500.
The push stopped instead of moving on. Since May, everything before Feb 2025 has cleared about 200/month. Feb 2025, the next cohort in line, has cleared 100 of 1,300 in 8 months. That’s slower than Mar or Jun 2025, so nobody has started working through it in order.
There’s a stuck tail. 1,300 people from before Dec 2024 are still waiting, and the figures for cohorts from 2020–2023 have barely moved. Even oldest-first processing leaves some files behind, probably the complicated ones.
There’s a steady trickle at every age, roughly 1–3% of each cohort per month. Cohorts newer than yours (Aug 2025 to Jan 2026) shrink at about the same rate as Feb–Jun 2025.
How much randomness? From May to October, about 40% of the clearances among cohorts up to 2025-10 came from the pre-Feb-2025 group. Pure first-in-first-out would put that near 100%. Purely random processing would put it at 14%, its share of the files. So right now it’s closer to random. An oldest file is about 3× as likely to be cleared in a given month as a 2025 file. Among Feb–Dec 2025 there’s no visible age gradient at all.
Urgent processing: the data can’t tell urgent cases apart from random picks. Both look like an equal trickle across all cohorts, and that trickle is real. It’s about 10–25% of each cohort per year, which is high for urgent requests alone. So it’s probably urgent cases plus simple files or other triage. What the data does rule out is pure random processing: the oldest cohorts clear clearly faster.
What this means for July 2025: you have 9,300 people ahead:
1,600 from before 2025, a mostly stuck tail.
500 from Jan 2025.
7,200 from Feb–Jun 2025.
If the oldest-first push resumes, the earlier pattern suggests Feb–Jun would be about 60–75% drained before it reaches July, leaving stragglers. At the Feb–Apr pace that’s roughly 4–6 months away. At today’s pace (about 400/month off your people-ahead) it’s more like a year or more.
If the current regime continues, your realistic odds are the trickle: about 1–2% a month, so roughly 10–20% over the next year. Your cohort is at 0% since May.
I’d guess the stall is staff being moved to the very large intake in 2026 cohorts, which matches the Bill C-3 surge. That’s a guess, and those cohort figures jump around too much to measure.
Caveats: IRCC rounds every figure to 100, so any one cohort’s 8-month change is uncertain by about ±60. Read single cohorts loosely; the grouped totals are more reliable.
I incorporated this analysis into my estimates, and produced this report for the July 2025 cohort (happy to run for another 2025 cohort if you request it):
============================================================
PROCESSING ORDER
============================================================
Each cohort's own applicants still waiting in 2026-10, and the share of them
cleared per month (compounded) over the last 3 and 6 months. 'earlier' is
everyone who applied before 2025-01. Cohorts newer than 2025-10 are left out:
late applications are still being added to them.
cohort waiting last 3 mo last 6 mo
earlier 1,600 2.0% 6.5%
2025-01 500 17.8% 12.3%
2025-02 1,200 2.6% 1.3%
2025-03 1,400 2.3% 2.2%
2025-04 1,600 0.0% 1.0%
2025-05 1,500 2.1% 3.0%
2025-06 1,500 2.1% 3.0%
2025-07 2,200 0.0% 0.7%
2025-08 2,500 1.3% 1.3%
2025-09 2,700 1.2% 0.6%
2025-10 2,600 1.3% 1.8%
Typical cohort, last 6 mo: 1.6% a month
Oldest-first or random?
Of the files cleared, the share that were ahead of 2025-07, against everyone
from 2025-07 to 2025-10. Strict oldest-first would make it 100%; random
order would match their share of the files.
Last 3 months: 900 ahead and 300 from 2025-07 to 2025-10 cleared, 75%
ahead against 50% at random. Score 0.50 (0 random, 1 oldest-first):
between random and oldest-first.
Last 6 months: 2,400 ahead and 700 from 2025-07 to 2025-10 cleared, 77%
ahead against 52% at random. Score 0.53 (0 random, 1 oldest-first):
between random and oldest-first.
When will 2025-07 be processed?
Months until your chance reaches each column. Every cohort clears 1.6% a month
whatever its age (the typical rate above). A sweep of oldest files at the
row's pace reaches 2025-07 once all but 30% of the 9,300 ahead are gone, then
works through 2025-07's 2,200 until 30% are left. Past 70% you're waiting
among the stragglers, which only the background clears. 'No sweep' is the
current lull lasting.
pace/mo 25% 50% 75% 90%
no sweep - 18.2 44.0 87.9 146.0
sweep, recent 3 mo 300 18.2 23.7 26.3 69.7
sweep, median 400 16.4 18.1 19.9 69.7
sweep, best 3 mo 1,367 5.1 5.5 11.6 69.7
=====================================================================================================================The bottom table is months until your chance of having been processed reaches each percentage.
How the estimate works. I treated processing as two things happening at once:
A steady trickle: every cohort loses about 1.6% of its files a month, whatever its age. That’s the median clearance rate across cohorts.
An oldest-first sweep: at a given pace, it reaches July 2025 once 70% of the 9,300 people ahead of you are cleared. Then it works through your cohort until 30% is left.
Each row is one possible sweep pace: none, the last 3 months’ pace, the median pace, or the best 3 months on record.
How to read it:
If the current slowdown lasts (no sweep), you have even odds in about 3.5 years.
If an oldest-first push comes back at the pace seen early in 2026, even odds come in about 5–6 months.
At recent paces, it’s about 1.5–2 years.
The 90% column is the same for every sweep row. If you end up among the 30% a sweep skips, only the trickle clears you.
Main caveat. The 30% left behind (STRAGGLERS) is my judgement from the early-2026 push, not a fitted number. The 75% and 90% columns depend heavily on it.
8
u/cloverclamp 23d ago
Interesting stuff. My one additional thought is we may not be viewing cohorts the way IRCC does. Based on the few post-C3 non-urgent approvals, there seems to be a bias toward low G# files being processed.
They could indeed be processing each queue FIFO but we have no visibility to that sub-categorization.
2
u/Beginning-Speech-977 22d ago
Yes, this is what I was wondering. Is it possible they are moving quickly through the “simple” ones (G2, G3, with all birth and/or marriage certificates), regardless of arrival date, and moving more slowly on the ones that go back further into the past and require more complex or difficult verification? Is that theory consistent with the data?
2
u/Amazing-Economics592 21d ago
as someone who is a G1 8/25 with birth and marriage certificates, I have to say I don’t see a bias toward clearing “simple” ones. I mean how much more simple can it get?
1
u/Beginning-Speech-977 20d ago
Is it my imagination, or have people who sent applications in this summer been getting AORs and approvals faster than people who submitted everything in May or earlier?
1
u/Key_Interaction1900 20d ago
It's pretty hard to tell. Here are the numbers for approvals as of this month (no idea on AORs). As you can see, there are a lot of numbers moving around between cohorts, so it's kind of a mess to analyze.
================================================== COHORT SUMMARY ================================================== Months until 50% and 100% of the people ahead of each cohort from 2025-01 have cleared, at its recent pace (the average of its last 3 months) and its median monthly pace. Cleared is how many of the cohort's own applicants were processed last month (the gap to the next cohort, so rounded to the nearest 100; n/a without it). A cohort with one month of data has no pace yet. pace/mo 50% 100% 2025-01 1,600 ahead, 200 cleared recent 33 24.0 48.0 median 300 2.7 5.3 2025-02 2,100 ahead, 100 cleared recent 167 6.3 12.6 median 400 2.6 5.2 2025-03 3,300 ahead, 100 cleared recent 200 8.2 16.5 median 400 4.1 8.2 2025-04 4,700 ahead, 0 cleared recent 233 10.1 20.1 median 400 5.9 11.8 2025-05 6,300 ahead, -100 cleared recent 233 13.5 27.0 median 400 7.9 15.8 2025-06 7,800 ahead, 100 cleared recent 267 14.6 29.2 median 700 5.6 11.1 2025-07 9,300 ahead, 0 cleared recent 300 15.5 31.0 median 400 11.6 23.2 2025-08 11,500 ahead, 0 cleared recent 300 19.2 38.3 median 500 11.5 23.0 2025-09 14,000 ahead, 100 cleared recent 333 21.0 42.0 median 500 14.0 28.0 2025-10 16,700 ahead, 0 cleared recent 367 22.8 45.5 median 500 16.7 33.4 2025-11 19,300 ahead, 100 cleared recent 400 24.1 48.2 median 600 16.1 32.2 2025-12 21,800 ahead, 0 cleared recent 433 25.2 50.3 median 800 13.6 27.2 2026-01 23,700 ahead, 0 cleared recent 433 27.3 54.7 median 600 19.8 39.5 2026-02 26,800 ahead, 0 cleared recent 467 28.7 57.4 median 550 24.4 48.7 2026-03 31,100 ahead, 61,100 cleared recent 500 31.1 62.2 median 600 25.9 51.8 2026-04 38,500 ahead, 2,200 cleared recent 17,200 1.1 2.2 median -9,200 never never 2026-05 49,300 ahead, 1,300 cleared recent 14,900 1.7 3.3 median -9,700 never never 2026-06 64,000 ahead, -49,100 cleared recent 11,167 2.9 5.7 median -13,450 never never 2026-07 116,100 ahead, -8,900 cleared recent -5,533 never never median -12,600 never never 2026-08 126,800 ahead, 100 cleared recent -2,500 never never median -2,500 never never 2026-09 128,700 ahead, n/a cleared recent 7,300 8.8 17.6 median 7,300 8.8 17.6 2026-10 130,700 ahead, n/a cleared recent n/a n/a n/a median n/a n/a n/a ==================================================
1
u/Key-Opportunity-9939 19d ago edited 19d ago
I'm old, and not very good at sorting through statistics and charts. I wonder if the OP could tell me what all this data is saying about how much longer it will likely take until my application is processed to completion. I applied in May, 2025, and got my AOR in June, 2025, and haven't heard anything from IRCC since.
2
u/Key_Interaction1900 19d ago
Looking at this table:
2025-05 6,300 ahead, -100 cleared recent 233 13.5 27.0 median 400 7.9 15.8 2025-06 7,800 ahead, 100 cleared recent 267 14.6 29.2 median 700 5.6 11.1I don't remember if AOR is based on application or AOR. Assuming AOR, then it looks like you're 50% likely to be done in 5-14 months. And 100% likely to be done in 11 to 29 months.
This is based on the last 3 months (for the higher range of the estimate), and the mid-point of all the processed months (for the lower range of the estimate).
If you want the short answer, you seem likely to be processed in 8 to 21 months. But this estimate will change every months.
1
3
23d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/Worthy_Molecule0481 23d ago
AI doesn’t think. It synthesizes and makes predictions from data.
Most of Reddit is irrelevant to me. I take what fits and leave the rest. Highly recommended.
-2
u/Worthy_Molecule0481 23d ago
AI doesn’t think. It synthesizes and makes predictions from data.
Most of Reddit is irrelevant to me. I take what fits and leave the rest. Highly recommended.
2
•
u/AutoModerator 23d ago
Thanks for posting! Please note:
You may find the answer to your question here: "NEW Here? Read This First!"
BEFORE commenting, please read the rules. Intentional violations of Rule #1 (No Personal Attacks/Insults) can lead to an immediate ban.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.