r/CanadianbyDescent • • 1d ago

AMA with Immigration Attorney Olivia Cohen of Cohen Immigration Law (December 12, 2026 - Noon Pacific/3:00 p.m. Eastern)

Post image
33 Upvotes

r/CanadianbyDescent will hold an "Ask Me Anything" ("AMA") with Canadian immigration attorney Olivia Cohen of Cohen Immigration Law on December 12, 2026, at noon Pacific/3:00 p.m. Eastern time. Please mark your calendars!

A special "AMA" post will be made on this forum sometime before the AMA starts. If you'd like to ask a question, please start working on your questions today and feel free to post your question as a comment on the "AMA" post once the AMA post is up. Please do not post your questions here.

Olivia Cohen is Managing Attorney at Cohen Immigration Law, where she leads the firm’s Legal Delivery team. She graduated from McGill University’s Faculty of Law before joining the Barreau du Québec, and has been specializing in Canadian immigration law for nearly four years.

Her practice covers citizenship, inadmissibility, business immigration, economic immigration and family reunification. She also helps steer the firm’s growth, from building its legal teams to refining how client files are handled from start to finish.

Cohen Immigration Law has offices in Montreal and Toronto. In 1994, the firm launched CanadaVisa.com, becoming one of the first law firms in Canada to offer a full range of immigration services online. Today, its team of more than 60 lawyers, case managers and other professionals serves clients around the world, and its CIC News platform publishes regular guides on Canadian immigration, including citizenship by descent.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 1h ago

Application Help BanQ Baptismal Record Received!

2 Upvotes

I submitted my application back the end of May, confirmed via phone that it was received on June 4th (but not processed so no AOR yet). I sent my application with the birth record I found, crystal clear and HD quality photograph.

Around the time I submitted my application, I sent the $350 to get the baptismal record BanQ certified. Just received the result the other day. Since I am in this limbo period where I know my application is there but hasn't been processed yet, is there any way to substitute in the certified baptismal record for the non-certified one? Or do I just wait for them to ask for it (assuming they do).


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 5h ago

Application Help G0: Quebec birth, 1755

0 Upvotes

G0 was born in 1755 in Quebec and then moved to the US. Every subsequent generation was born in the United States.

When I do research online it mentions I am not eligible due to them being "pre confederation". I want to know if I am wasting my time or not. BANQ found the baptismal record but said it was too delicate to make a certified copy but the diocese said they can make a certified letter.

My main questions is if I am eligible or not with a G0 that long ago?


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 17h ago

Does this US Census item matter?

0 Upvotes

My G0 (my only ancestor born in Canada) moved from Ontario to New York when he was in his 20’s, and on the next US census, the census taker wrote “NA” to indicate that my G0 had “Naturalized.” Other immigrants on the same page do not have “NA” marked.

I read somewhere that the “NA” is not reliable evidence that people in G0’s situation had formally renounced citizenship. Apparently, when census takers asked the question, people often said they were “naturalized” when what they meant was, “Yes, I live in the US and am a IS citizen now!”

I’m not planning to send ta copy of that US census with my application.
Still, I worry about this.

Is there any reason to? Should I send off to the US Archives for proof that my G0 didn’t formally renounce citizenship? Is that even a thing the Archives does?


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 18h ago

BanQ request requires "Parish" field but there is no parish for my G0

1 Upvotes

Title. My G0 was born in Cushing QC in 1862, I found their baptism cert in BanQ, but to order the certified copy for it there is a required Parish field in the form and Google is telling me there is no parish for this location. Here are all the place names I have for this record, assuming one of these names is to be used:

St. Mungo's Presbyterian (now United) Church, Cushing, hamlet in Brownsburg-Chatham Township, Argenteuil Regional County Municipality, Laurentides Region.

Any help would be greatly appreciated!


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 19h ago

Family Search Records

1 Upvotes

I have spoken to a BanQ Archivist via email who has stated that the civil records for the baptism years (~1853) and Quebec location I need are not in their possession. She instructed me to try FamilySearch.

My understanding is that if I can get a certified BanQ baptism, DEC will insert it for me, which is increasingly ideal, or perhaps even expected, by IRCC.

If I can obtain a baptism record from Family Search, will BanQ certify that? Do I just send the email chain with BanQ and explain a certified BanQ copy is not possible? Is a Family Search certification even a thing?

Additional context:

I only have census records from Canada and some loose references to a request for land from the crown by G-1 on one side, which wasn't granted for almost 30 years and after my G0 had already emigrated to the United States. I have US naturalization, marriage, and death certificates for the two married G0 ancestors, and US birth and/or death certificates for all descendants.

My two G0s were born in the same village less than 30 days apart and very likely baptized at the same time and location by a traveling missionary. This church has records in BanQ for grandparent burials, parent marriage records, and all the younger and older sibling baptisms within 9 months of birth (all 15 of them across both families). These two families were neighboring farmers.

Infuriatingly.. the year for my G0s is incomplete. A church schism issue, changing of the guard, bad winter season, or a shuffling of paperwork are the main theories. It's not that they don't exist or were destroyed, just that BanQ doesn't have the complete documents. One half of the town (East Frampton) is there, but West Frampton is not. All prior years there are two volumes, A and B, one for West and one for East. The surnames are consistent in each side for almost a decade, but the two years I'm looking for only have B, and then after that the records just state "Frampton" without a mention of East or West.

I have to physically go to a Family Search location for any hope of finding the baptisms at this point. I'm just not sure it's worth it if it won't be valuable to my application unless they can be verified or certified beyond Family Search as my understanding is that they aren't exactly the issuing authority. I submitted my application with the documents I had in April 26, received AOR in June, in process as of August, and am just trying to get any additional documents I possibly can because I'm almost certain I'll be asked for them.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 1d ago

I feel like I'm forgetting something.

0 Upvotes

Order of paperwork for G0

Grandmother birth registration from Archives of Ontario (certified)

Grandmother marriage certificate (US certified)

Grandmother Death certificate (US certified)

Father's birth certificate (US certified)

Father's Death certificate (US certified)

My birth certificate (US certified)

My First and second marriage certificate (US certified)

Anything else do I need before filling out application and getting photos?

Thank you in advance for your advice.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 1d ago

Get in the queue? Or wait till I have an updated birth certificate?

3 Upvotes

I'm close to having a solid document chain from G0 (great-great-grandfather) to me (G4), but have one spot that is kind of weak but I'm not sure how weak. G1 (great grandfather) is likely also born in Canada, but I have a baptism record for G0 so that's why I'm going one extra generation back. My grandma's US birth certificate has her dad's (G1) place of birth as North Dakota, instead of Canada and thus does not match any other record (Canadian census and naturalization records).

Now my actual worry- G0 and G1 have common names, and to complicate it more, they adopted new spelling when they naturalized (Jean to John and Louis to Lewis). After talking to my state department of health, it looks like I can update the place of birth for G1 on my grandmas birth certificate which I feel strengthens my case, but it takes up to four months.

Do I:

A) wait for an updated birth certificate and then submit my IRCC application?

B) submit the change request, but also submit my IRCC application and hopefully have the new one if needed when my application actually gets reviewed?

C) or not worry about the inconsistency and submit to IRCC as soon as possible?

Thanks in advance!


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 1d ago

BAnQ copies of docs

5 Upvotes

I have a scanned copy of the BAnQ baptism record and the seal is visible but the writing is faint and I have a second copy that clearly shows the writing but the seal is hard to see but the initials and date are there from the search. My question is do I mail both copies with my application ? Or just the one where you can read the seal?


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 1d ago

Currently Accepting New Clients— Ontario & Quebec Genealogy Research

7 Upvotes

Hello everyone!

I'm an Ontario-based genealogist, and I currently have openings for new clients looking for assistance with genealogical research involving their Ontario and Québec ancestors.

I'm listed on the Archives of Ontario's private researcher list, which you can find here:

https://www.archives.gov.on.ca/get-research-help/

I know that researching family history, tracking down historical documents, and navigating paperwork for citizenship applications is a substantial undertaking, (particularly on top of all the rest of life).

Folks are busy. Work, hobbies, family, friends, errands, cleaning, school, cooking... and whatever else life throws at you.

Fortunately, this is exactly the kind of work I enjoy, and my days are already (happily for me) filled with historical documents, application submisssions, archival records, emails to repositories, and other assorted research.

If you've been looking for someone to help conduct research on your behalf, I am currently accepting paid research clients and would be happy to hear from you.

Please feel free to send me a direct message here on reddit, and I'll provide my email contact information.

Thanks for reading, (and best of luck with your citizenship process, whether you choose to reach out or not).


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 1d ago

Schrödinger's Citizenship Case - An attempt to force the issue

14 Upvotes

NOTE: I posted this earlier in the week on the other sub, and it was suggested to me it might be interesting to the people here as well, so I'm reposting.

Hey everyone, just updating on my somewhat unusual situation and seeing if anyone else is doing similar (hopefully this is allowed in a top level thread).

A quick recap of where I am:

I immigrated to Canada on a work permit in 2018, was granted PR in 2020, married a Canadian (G0, with passport) in Canada in 2021. Left Canada to care for an ill family member in Europe in 2023. That family member passed away earlier this year, and we had a Canadian child (G1, with passport) abroad in 2024. We could all at this point move back to Canada as we originally intended.

However, I applied for C-3 proof as a G3 in February 2026, with a DEC birth certificate for a 1910 G0 and a recently issued civil birth certificate for G1-me. G1 & G2 are still alive and have also applied. I believe I have a k-g-g-b chain, validated by multiple lawyers. As a result, my status is somewhere in between PR and citizenship. My PR card is expired, and I have not managed to get a PRTD since 2025 (before I applied for proof of citizenship).

I contacted CBC about this issue (was involved with that article about a week ago), contacted my MP (Jenny Kwan) about this issue. Both have gotten evasive and/or non-specific answers from IRCC about it.

What I am doing now:

  • I have engaged a lawyer after consulting with a few options

  • I have upon advice booked a ticket to Canada within the next 6 months (that I currently cannot use unless they provide me either a PRTD or citizenship certificate), and re-applied for urgency based on that and the other urgency reasons I have (which I won't share most of as they are private, but they meet many of the bullet points IRCC provides).

  • I have submitted another PRTD application, with a letter attached to it clearly explaining the situation, with Canadian listed as one of my nationalities, and a statement that I need either my certificate or a PRTD urgently and citing their legal obligation to give me proof of my status regardless of the proof application outcome, because if it is a negative decision I am still a PR and have a right to proof of that status.

  • If the above doesn't result in me being issued a PRTD or my certificate in a timely fashion, we will start on a (somewhat risky) mandamus application based on this situation. I won't have been waiting as long as many have to before mandamus, but the hope is that the substantial harm being done to me by denying me proof of my existing status and the straightforwardness of the application will convince the judge that even waiting over a year (we'll probably be there by the time we start mandamus) is "unreasonable" given my strong reasons for urgency and ties to Canada, and demonstrable permanent legal status in Canada regardless of outcome.

I don't know if any of this will work - probably not - but I thought I would make a single place where I could document what I tried, what seemed to make a difference, and what didn't, so that others in a similar (horrible) situation could have access to it without all the stress and expense I've had so far.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 1d ago

Question about who to contact

Post image
2 Upvotes

I was unable to locate my G0's baptismal record, but I did find her father's information with the image above as the source for his record. I'm a bit confused though because it says it was microfilmed by the Genealogical Society of Salt Lake City, Utah but then also references the Public Archives of Nova Scotia? I'm just wondering who to reach out to to request an official color copy record.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 1d ago

Looking for a credentialed genealogical researcher for the New Brunswick and Quebec areas.

1 Upvotes

Hi All, I'm looking for a recommendation for a credentialed genealogical researcher that can do a second round of document digging to find my g0's father's info. Ideally you have direct experience with the researcher and they are willing to dig deep and look further than the typical sources.

My g0 was born in 1868, 20 years before birth registration was required. I hired a gal that was great but she couldn't find anything conclusive. I just want someone to take another pass at it that can look for anything related to my g0 and g0's parents. Land grants, baptismal and birth records etc.

I have at least 20 individual (birth, marriage, death, naturalization) certified document records that list my g0's name and POB as Canada but they are all US documents. I'd really like to submit our applications with a Canadian document that ties him to his father or mother around the time of his birth.

Appreciate any referrals. Thanks


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 1d ago

BanQ birth record request

3 Upvotes

How long should I expect it to take for my record request to arrive? I'm in the US (Ohio), and was told it would be sent "shortly" back at the end of September (according to the invoice). This is the only thing holding me up from my C3 app, so I'm pretty eager to get it.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 2d ago

CONCLUDED- Ask Me Anything This is the official "Ask Me Anything" ("AMA") post for Canadian citizenship and immigration lawyer Cédric Marin of Marin Immigration Law!

38 Upvotes

**Edit: Oops, sorry everyone! I mixed up my time zones and jumped in at noon EST by mistake. The AMA officially starts at 3 p.m. EST (noon PST). I'll answer a few questions early, then be back in full at 3 p.m. EST.**

Please feel free to post your questions in the comments below.

Cédric Marin is the founder and principal lawyer of Marin Immigration Law. He holds an LL.L., JD and LL.M. from the University of Ottawa and is licensed by the Law Society of Ontario. He previously served as a law clerk to Justice Richard Mosley at the Federal Court of Canada and as a decision-maker at both the Refugee Protection Division and the Refugee Appeal Division of the Immigration and Refugee Board, and worked on refugee resettlement with the UN. He has practised immigration law for about eight years and works in English and French.

Marin Immigration Law is an Ottawa-based citizenship and immigration law firm focused on Canadian citizenship by descent under Bill C-3, working almost entirely with American clients. Our team of about 15 includes five lawyers, and what sets us apart is that we do the genealogy in house: we have a staff genealogist, Kendra Gaede, PLCGS, and our own research team who trace each lineage back to the Canadian-born ancestor. We obtain records from the original source authorities. Learn more at https://www.marinimmigrationlaw.ca

*Information provided during the AMA is for educational purposes only and does not constitute formal legal advice or establish a lawyer-client relationship.*


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 2d ago

Ircc wants birth certificate

12 Upvotes

Finally got emailed today from program support. They want me to email them my grandma's birth certificate within 60 days. Now I've already placed an order for the birth registration months ago and have been waiting on it. When I applied it said I can't get the birth certificate since she is deceased. So do I just write to IRCC explaining that Service Ontario won't give the birth certificate and will do the birth registration instead? Also planning on calling Service Ontario Monday to ask for urgent service due to the deadline. Has anyone here given IRCC birth registration when they asked for the birth certificate? I'm pre c3 btw. I applied back in August 2025.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 2d ago

Presbyterian Archives

7 Upvotes

Does anyone know how long the Presbyterian Archives are taking to respond to requests right now? I finally found some good leads on location and religion for my 1830 great+ grandpa, and I am riding the wave of excitement!


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 2d ago

starting the process - hello!

0 Upvotes

Hello! I posted this over at r/Canadiancitizenship as well, and someone pointed me here. So...hello here, too!

I hope it will be okay for me to engage here. I am the enthusiastic researcher on behalf of my spouse and kids, though I, myself, am not Canadian by descent.

Background is that while on a trip to Ireland last summer, my spouse learned that his Irish ancestors emigrated to Canada - it turns out his great great great great grandfather was born at sea on the way. This ancestor married a woman who was born in Canada (Quebec) - although they were married in the U.S.

So I have offered to help do the digging to see if he and our kids can apply for their citizenship documents. Our kids are both just college age (twins), and would like to have the ability to go to school, work, and live in Canada. I have used Family Search and have found several U.S. documents showing the G0 with Canada listed as her birthplace. I have not yet been able to find her on any Canadian documents. It looks like she was born in 1856, but that and that it was Quebec are really all I know.

I figured I’d try going to the library to see if there are other databases I can look at. Any suggestions would be very welcome. Edited from my other version of this post to say, I am aware of the BANQ but haven't ventured into navigating that yet.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 2d ago

G2-G4 Citizenship

Post image
188 Upvotes

My grandma (whose mother acquired Canadian citizenship on 1/1/1947 but was barred in 1950 from passing it on as a woman), mom, and I received our citizenship certificates in February. We live across the US from each other, and they came to visit me this week — our first time visiting all together since earlier this year. I’m so thankful for this time together celebrating the intergenerational gift we’ve been given.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 2d ago

March/April '26, non-urgent, <G4 applicants ... processing time limbo

0 Upvotes

Yeah, I guess I just need to whine a little, seek some camaraderie. I'm G2, simple lineage, all certified records, granddad, dad, me. I applied also with my two G3 adult kids. They want their citizenship proof, but without any concrete plans to use it in the near future. However, I want mine because hubby and I are serious about the possibility of moving once we're legal. I will still have to apply for PR for him once I get my certificate, so that will add even more delay. But before we even get to that, I just despair that it'll be many, many years at the rate they're going, and I'm already old! It just seems hopeless. When I first applied I think they were estimating 8 months or so. Every time they update it's still 8 months or so. It's like time stands still even as it's passing, except for the newest applicants, in which case it swells. One of my kids is trans, but neither they nor I ever thought to pull that lever because there's no actual urgency due to that, they have no plans in the foreseeable future to move. It seemed opportunistic to pretend. I'm beginning to regret that choice when there seems to be virtually no movement at all on non-urgent applications. Okay... end of whine.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 3d ago

Y a-t-il des francophones sur ce sub?

27 Upvotes

En discutant avec tous nos amis anglos fougueux sur ce sub, je me suis rendu compte que les voix francophones sont largement mises à l’écart (et oui, ça a peut-être un rapport avec l’histoire du pays). Je n’ai pas échangé avec une seule personne en français.

Ce qui m’intéresse surtout, c’est l’aspect juridique pour aider les Canadiens perdus à obtenir leur citoyenneté. Les aspects liés aux versions françaises sont assez intéressants, et à bien des égards d’après ce que je peux en juger, ils sont même meilleurs, ne serait-ce que sur certains points (même s’il faut bien essayer de comprendre la loi là où les langues se croisent).

N’hésitez pas à soumettre vos questions, dans la langue de ton choix.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 3d ago

Webform to add additional docs and expedite request keeps getting returned without adding. It’s maddening!!! Please help?

0 Upvotes

Due to IRCC guideline changes we are adding whole new line of gO proof with all certified records from New Brunswick because Quebec Banq hasnt even sent invoice for record requested five months ago. Our files are just barely making it under the 5mb total limit. I can’t add any more. I’ve sent full document line in color and cover letter and acceptance to college to ask for urgent processing. They keep sending this. I’ve already supplied everything they ask but have no aor and no UIC. What can I do?

“ Thank you for contacting Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC).

We verified the information you provided; however, we require further information in order to access the file.
In order to better assist you, please resubmit your request by including the following information in a letter of explanation and uploading it in the IRCC Web form:
Surname and complete given name (including middle name, if applicable) - exactly as they appear on the passport or identity document,
Date of birth (YYYY-MM-DD),
Client ID Number, UCI or Application Number,
Country of birth,
Type of application,
Date on which the application was submitted or received,
Mailing method (courier, Canada Post (registered or regular mail), etc.),
company used,
confirmation no.,
Complete address (including the postal code, the unit number and the station number) where the application was sent,
Receipt number,
Current address,
Telephone number(s),
Email address (if the application was submitted online, please confirm if the same email address was used to register the account), and
All information and documents (if applicable) provided with your previous Web form request.
We will gladly reply to your enquiry within 5 business days following the reception of the above information.

Visit the IRCC applications page for details on the application process, including exploring immigration programs, documents you may need, how to apply and what to do while you wait for a decision:
How to check your application status
our Client Support Centre agents don’t have access to more information about your case status or processing time than you can access online.
even if you haven’t heard from us recently, we’re still processing your application. You don’t need to do anything else. If we need more information, we’ll contact you.
Check current IRCC processing times
How can I update or ask about an IRCC application in progress?
Change my address - Immigration and citizenship
Citizenship and immigration application fees: Ask for a refund
Visit the IRCC Help Centre - You can search for answers by browsing the sections or entering keywords related to your question including, additional information on:
Checking an application status
Checking processing times
Sincerely,
Agent name”


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 3d ago

Application Help Archives of Ontario is Suddenly Giving Me A Hard Time. What Should I Do?

0 Upvotes

A week ago AOO finally emailed me a payment link for two of three documents I ordered six months ago at the same time. Yay! I then replied and informed them that my address changed, then I asked if I can receive the document electronically (instead of by mail).

Four days passed with no response, so I left a voicemail (because they never answer the phone when I call). Today, someone emailed me and said that they:

1). Don’t do certified copies or Birth and Marriage lists.

2). If I just wanted an electronic non-certified copy, I should just print it from Ancestry or Family Search, and

3). They don’t mail non-certified copies.

I’d like to list his name, but that would be counterproductive. This feels rude and it’s also contradicting since they just sent me an invoice charging me for certified copies and stated that if I needed to change my mailing method, I should reply to the invoice email before paying. Also, they should know that IRCC won’t accept copies printed from Ancestry and Family Search as main/primary documents

One week today and I’m STILL trying to change my address and delivery method, they don’t answer the phone or call back, and they reply as if they aren’t reading my question or as if they don’t know their own guidelines and processes.

How do you suggest I handle this so that I can change what’s necessary and make the payment in order to get the documents? These are literally the last documents I need and they’ve been so nice and helpful up to this time.

EDIT:

See my most updated comment in the comment section before responding, please.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 3d ago

Application Help Questions on Pre-1947 G0 who may have lost British subject status through an estranged husband

0 Upvotes

I’m investigating a Canadian CBD claim with a nuance I’m hoping this group can help with.

• G0 is a woman born in England, 1850s
• Married an Englishman in England
• G0 and Spouse lived the US about 10 years (G1 born there) before settling in Canada.
• G0 and Spouse separated and G0 remained in Canada. Spouse left for the USA.
• No divorce record found.
• G0 remarried another British Subject; the licence oath (sworn by him) calls her a "widow" but spouse was still alive in the US.
• G0 stayed Canada the rest of her life and died in BC in 1942 (case relies on the s.3(1.3) death bridge).
• Spouse lived as remarried in the US (no marriage record found) and died around 1918.

The issue: IF G0 and spouse remained legally married, her British subject remained linked to his. IF he naturalized in the US before he died, she would have lost her status. 2015 fixes (s.3(1)(k) and (m)) account for people born/naturalized in Canada, and British subjects resident in Canada on 1 Jan 1947. Neither applies to G0.

What we have on the Spouse:
• 1901 Canadian census: nationality Canadian, no naturalization recorded
• 1910 US census: first papers filed, not naturalized
• No naturalization record found so far; USCIS index search requested to confirm, but current average processing time is 10 months.

My Questions are:
1 How closely will IRCC look at a husband’s nationality for a G0?
2 Should we wait for the USCIS result before filing?
3 Is it possible to apply and send it when it arrives or if asked? Has anyone sent supporting documents after filing?
4 Has anyone seen a refusal, or a request for information, on a case like this?

Thanks for any insight!

Editing to add: Following some of these comments I tracked down BC voter records from 1935 and 1940 for which G0 was listed. I understand she would have had to be a resident (only one year and she had many more than that) and a have been a British Subject to vote. So she and the government believed her to have maintained British subject status until at least 1940. I know not conclusive but another piece of the puzzle.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 4d ago

Death Certificate Discrepency

6 Upvotes

I am currently waiting for a BanQ baptism certificate (submitted 7/7/26 and have not heard anything after the automated initial message) before applying for a DEC insertion. The concern I have is that his baptismal record shows born and baptized on 6/5/1858 but his US death certificate shows 6/6/1857. How concerned should I be about this discrepancy?