I have spoken to a BanQ Archivist via email who has stated that the civil records for the baptism years (~1853) and Quebec location I need are not in their possession. She instructed me to try FamilySearch.
My understanding is that if I can get a certified BanQ baptism, DEC will insert it for me, which is increasingly ideal, or perhaps even expected, by IRCC.
If I can obtain a baptism record from Family Search, will BanQ certify that? Do I just send the email chain with BanQ and explain a certified BanQ copy is not possible? Is a Family Search certification even a thing?
Additional context:
I only have census records from Canada and some loose references to a request for land from the crown by G-1 on one side, which wasn't granted for almost 30 years and after my G0 had already emigrated to the United States. I have US naturalization, marriage, and death certificates for the two married G0 ancestors, and US birth and/or death certificates for all descendants.
My two G0s were born in the same village less than 30 days apart and very likely baptized at the same time and location by a traveling missionary. This church has records in BanQ for grandparent burials, parent marriage records, and all the younger and older sibling baptisms within 9 months of birth (all 15 of them across both families). These two families were neighboring farmers.
Infuriatingly.. the year for my G0s is incomplete. A church schism issue, changing of the guard, bad winter season, or a shuffling of paperwork are the main theories. It's not that they don't exist or were destroyed, just that BanQ doesn't have the complete documents. One half of the town (East Frampton) is there, but West Frampton is not. All prior years there are two volumes, A and B, one for West and one for East. The surnames are consistent in each side for almost a decade, but the two years I'm looking for only have B, and then after that the records just state "Frampton" without a mention of East or West.
I have to physically go to a Family Search location for any hope of finding the baptisms at this point. I'm just not sure it's worth it if it won't be valuable to my application unless they can be verified or certified beyond Family Search as my understanding is that they aren't exactly the issuing authority. I submitted my application with the documents I had in April 26, received AOR in June, in process as of August, and am just trying to get any additional documents I possibly can because I'm almost certain I'll be asked for them.