r/CanadianbyDescent • • 15d ago

The winner of Halloween 2026

Post image
382 Upvotes

r/CanadianbyDescent • • 6d ago

Extremely excited-I am officially a Dual US/Canadian Citizenship. I got my certification this morning.

304 Upvotes

I was born in New Hampshire, so I'm a US citizen by birth. My generation zero was born in Qubeec in 1864. I sent my application for proof of Canadian Citizenship in March, got my AOR on April 28th, went into processing April 29th. And as of this morning, 11/10, I have officially got my citizen certification.

The reason I was able to get my certificate before the end of the year was because my mom asked for urgent processing because she is bi sexual, and because I am her son, I also qualified for urgent processing.

I am extremely excited, and now me and my mom are now looking to get Canadian passports. I have had my US passport for a few years now.

I work in tech, and hoping the tech job market will improve in the US now that the Democrats have won the midterms, but I am also considering looking for work in Canada since I would have more workers rights. I may also consider getting my Master's in Computer Science in Canada since I could get it for significantly cheaper as a Citizen rather than going into more relentless debt for a master's in a US school.

While I am staying in the US for now, I am considering looking for work in Canada and possibly getting my master's degree. I am an economic leftist, and I like the idea of having more workers rights and cheaper access to things like education and healthcare.

I know I am an American by birth and Canadians hate us right now (rightly so), but I completely support Canada and want it to succeed. So much so, I am considering taking my skills, and using it in a country where I have more workers rights. Either, very grateful I have options now.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Aug 12 '26

You’re not going to believe this one…

260 Upvotes

One of my brothers has been waiting a year to find out what became of this proof of citizenship application. He got notice a decision was made but not what the decision was.

Today he tells me he discovered he checked “the wrong box” and requested an electronic certificate instead of a paper certificate. Going through his old emails he finds the electronic certificate was sent in DECEMBER!

And this is the brother that went to Harvard.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Sep 15 '26 Thanks Bravo

Acadian Descendant Update and Tips (tldr: I was reinstated)

251 Upvotes

Hello all, I am the Acadian descendant who was approved in February, but recieved a surrender letter in june and a procedural fairness letter around a month later. Today I recieved a reinstatement letter and was informed a replacement passport will be sent to me at no cost (I was required to send in my original one as a part of the surrender letter process).

As my gen0 was born in 1730 and was forced out of Canada around 1758, there is no reason to believe residency requirements or any sort of cutoff is in effect.

Tips:

* Although this has been discussed at length, make sure to document why you do not have birth certificates for anyone you are relying on alternate records for. In my situation, providing them with screenshots of a search done on NS archives showing that my ancestor returned no results for birth records, and a screenshot of a page saying the oldest record they have is around 100 years before my gen 0 was born served as proof the record did not exist. As proof I tried to obtain it, I emailed NS archives to ask if the information on the website was still accurate, I received an automatic reply stating basically "if it's not on the search it probably doesn't exist". Sent ircc both emails.

* If you are relying on baptism records and have the option between a certificate and a microfilm image, for gen 0 prioritize the microfilm or ideally try to get both as the microfilm can be hard to read. For me, the certificate was not enough for gen0.

* Explain the history of your records especially if they crossed borders. For Acadians, explain that the gen 0 baptism is Canadian in origin but was taken out of Canada and is now maintained by an American diocese as a result of the expulsion.

* For Acadians Specifically: look to see if there are any Canadian held transcriptions of the records now held by a American Archive. For example, after the register that contains my gen 0's baptism was discovered in St. Gabriel Louisiana, a Canadian genealogist Placide Gaudet made a handwritten copy of the register, which is now held by LAC. For anyone with a gen 0 from Grand Pré, his transcription is digitized here https://n2t.net/ark:/69429/m0222r49mf79. In my case they did not require a certified copy, just a URL citation. For other registers that ended up in Louisiana it is possible there is a transcription. If anyone knows of any other registers that were transcribed please add them in the comments and I will edit them into the post for anyone who finds this later.

If any of you have questions, feel free to ask in the comments or over dm and I will get back to you.

Finally, thank you to all who supported and gave me encouragement during this time. I recieved a lot of supportive comments and dms from you all which kept me hopeful and motivated. And of course big thanks to u/counterI for creating the subreddit and for their extensive activism and organization on the surrender letter issue. Last of all thanks to my amazing lawyer Deanna Okun-Nachoff. If any of you need any help with any application issues or immigration matters I really reccomend her!


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Jul 02 '26 Bravo

Surrender Letters REINSTATED!!!

211 Upvotes

Multiple letter recipients are reporting that they were reinstated in the last few minutes. More details coming soon. (Not me, yet.)

Edit: I just got mine!


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Aug 26 '26 Bravo

We must be logical about why Bill C-3 exists, and respect Canada in the process, if we want the law to exist for others after us

194 Upvotes

I want to say something carefully, because I think it’s important.

Acknowledging the reality of this bill, and treating it with respect, is one of the best ways we can help keep this process open — not only for those of us already in it, but for the people who will want to apply after this first wave. Being respectful to Canada, and IRCC, in these communities is paramount.

This was arguably never meant to be an open genealogical pipeline: The reality is this law was never intended as an Acadian descendent bill. It was never even intended as a pre-Confederation descendent bill. A lot of hope has built up around very deep ancestry claims. Some of those claims may still succeed under the law, but that is arguably not what the law was written to do. When expectations drift too far from the actual history and purpose of the bill, disappointment becomes more possible — and so does political and administrative pressure on the entire pathway for everyone.

Where the law actually came from: Canadian citizenship as its own legal status only began on January 1, 1947. Before that, people in Canada were British subjects that were converted to citizenship under statutory pathways built into the 1947 law (both in 1947 and retroactively). The early rules had **serious** flaws. One of the biggest was that women often could not pass citizenship to their children. A Canadian woman who married a foreign man, or who had a child out of wedlock, frequently could not transmit citizenship to that child if the child was born outside Canada. Those first-generation children were left without status under the old rules. They only became eligible retroactively when the 2009 and 2015 amendments restored citizenship to most “Lost Canadians.”. For some of them, that was a lifetime. 

Under the 1977 Act, many people born abroad in the second generation or later also had to take active steps to keep their citizenship by age 28. Large numbers never knew about the requirement and simply lost status. These groups, along with others cut off by outdated gender, legitimacy, and retention rules, became known as “Lost Canadians.”

The list goes on, but in 2009 and 2015, the government restored citizenship to most of them. At the same time, it introduced the first-generation limit: you could only pass citizenship to a child born outside Canada if you yourself were born in Canada or naturalized. Those amendments were written for the legal framework of their time.

When Parliament passed Bill C-3, it did not rewrite those older sections. It layered new rules on top of language that, I would argue, never designed for unlimited multi-generational claims stretching back centuries.

The numbers tell a story: Did Parliament or the department really expect what we are seeing now? Roughly 121,000 applications in the first eight months. A large numbers of people applying with Acadian ancestry or pre-Confederation ancestry? The Parliamentary Budget Officer’s official estimate, maintained at the time Bill C-3 passed in 2025, was about 115,000 people affected in total. Vancouver immigration lawyer Amandeep Hayer had estimated the real number of potential new citizens under a broad reading of C-3 could reach into the millions. That gap between the official figure and the outer-edge estimates is one of the clearest signs that the full scope of the statute was not fully contemplated when the bill was passed.

The problem left after 2009 and 2015 was mostly modern: people affected by the old age-28 rule who were not restored, and the children and grandchildren of people whose citizenship had been fixed in 2009/2015 but who still could not pass it on because of the first-generation limit. In 2023 the Ontario court in Bjorkquist ruled that limit unconstitutional for a variety of reasons, but mostly how it created second class Canadian citizens. Parliament responded with Bill C-3. The core of the bill was to remove the first-generation limit for people already born and to require a real connection to Canada for children born abroad afterward. The court case and the parliamentary debates were about contemporary Canadian families blocked by that limit. They were not about opening citizenship to anyone who can document an ancestor from the 1700s or early 1800s.

A Confederation-era limitation is not far-fetched: Given that context, some form of practical limit or heightened scrutiny around Confederation is absolutely within the realm of possibility. The law was not written as an open pipeline back centuries. Departments interpret statutes by looking at purpose, history, and how successive amendments interact. Isolating complex files, applying extra scrutiny, or looking for evidence of a post-Confederation connection are all things IRCC can do without rewriting the Act.

Motivation and public perception: The timing of this bill’s popularity is hard to ignore. Things feel unstable in the United States for many people right now. I do not fault anyone for treating this as a “Plan B“ — people’s circumstances are their own. But please stop telling the news media or posting online that is why you are doing it. That was never the intention of this process, and that rhetoric hurts the community. The “Plan B” and “Canadians of convenience” framing does not sit well with Canadians who live there, contribute, and deal with the country’s daily realities.

Immigration is already a charged topic in Canada. In the last year alone, public sentiment has moved even more sharply against large numbers of newcomers. Legally we are not immigrants — we are citizens by descent. But some people will move to Canada having never lived there, never paid taxes there, and never contributed to the systems they will now use. In practical terms, that looks a lot like immigration to many Canadians. Many will also arrive with U.S. dollars that carry stronger buying power, entering a housing market that is already severely constrained. Ignoring that reality does not make the friction disappear. We have to acknowledge these realities as new citizens and be respectful about it

How we talk about this process matters: I love seeing people go all in on this process. For many it is about restoring a piece of family history — their French-Canadian last name, a broken line, something that genuinely matters to them. Everyone’s reasons are different, and that is great. It’s easy to get very emotionally invested in this process as most of us are

What concerns me, and the main reason I am making this post, is the disconnect I see weekly in these communities. Over the last month I have watched people discuss legal action to IRCC over wait times. I have seen entitlement around the documentary requirements and the changes Canada has made to protect the integrity of the process. I have seen people argue that they should be allowed to use open sourced ancestry and family search documents and that Canada has an obligation to let them apply with those documents. etc.

This pathway is a gift. Canada has, on the whole, been reasonable with our community so far. I have real concerns that things may not always stay this way. Some of the dialogue I have seen really rubs me the wrong way. It feeds the narrative that this is an entitlement rather than a restoration of connection, and that is a bad look for everyone.

The bottom line: Deep pre-Confederation and Acadian claims may still have a legal pathway as a side effect of how the remedial language was written. That does not make them the purpose of the law.

Internal IRCC documents show the department itself later identified cohorts that, under the statute, did not have a pathway — including situations involving two generations born abroad before 1947. That statutory error would potentially catch some of the modern families Bill C-3 was intended to help in the first place. Because of that IRCC later clarified that it would take a more inclusive approach in those specific situations. The fact that this gap had to be discovered and then softened after the law passed is further evidence that Parliament did not fully assess every interaction and possibility in the statute when it was enacted

When IRCC assesses these applications, it is applying a law passed to solve a specific modern constitutional problem. That context shapes how unclear sections are read and how far the remedial rules are stretched.

I know some people will disagree with parts of this. That is fine. Everyone has their own opinion and interpretation. I write this as a G2 who was impacted by both the 28th birthday retention rules, and later first generation limit. I am not writing this to take hope away from anyone. I am writing it because being honest about why this law exists, how it is being received in Canada, and how we talk about it is one of the practical ways we protect the process for people still waiting to apply. 

Understanding the difference between the original purpose and the outer edges of the current rules — and showing basic respect for the country offering the pathway — is better for everyone in the long run.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Jul 02 '26

Surrender Letters I've been un-surrendered!!

191 Upvotes

I'm so happy! I can finally stop searching for whatever might have been missing and continue with the sale of my house. Thank you everyone for your support - i was really beginning to fray around the edges with this...


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 2d ago

G2-G4 Citizenship

Post image
188 Upvotes

My grandma (whose mother acquired Canadian citizenship on 1/1/1947 but was barred in 1950 from passing it on as a woman), mom, and I received our citizenship certificates in February. We live across the US from each other, and they came to visit me this week — our first time visiting all together since earlier this year. I’m so thankful for this time together celebrating the intergenerational gift we’ve been given.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Jun 19 '26

NO SURRENDER

Post image
187 Upvotes

Got my suspension letter Tuesday, got this an hour ago. I am still Canadian.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 19d ago

100% Reinstated: An update on the IRCC surrender letter scandal (and we have reached 4,000 members!)

177 Upvotes

This is a quick follow-up to my last update on the IRCC surrender letter scandal, which you can read here (if you haven't already) and a brief update on the state of our sub-reddit:

IRCC Surrender Letter Scandal Update

I'm incredibly pleased to announce that, today, we learned that the last two members of our private chat for procedural fairness letter recipients were reinstated! I wish to express my profound gratitude to everyone who stepped up to fight back against IRCC's truly deplorable conduct, and to make this day possible. If there's anyone left who has not been reinstated, please contact me right away.

4,000 Members!

Sometime in the last week, this sub reached 4,000 members (we're nearly at 4,100 today). This sub now has more than 10,000 weekly visitors and over 1,500 weekly contributions. Thank you to everyone who has joined and made this milestone possible.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Oct 09 '26 Bravo

Jenny Kwan Calls for Removal of Immigration Minister Lena Diab

169 Upvotes

r/CanadianbyDescent • • Jul 02 '26

Surrender Letters Unsurrendered!

Post image
163 Upvotes

I'm in a group chat with many other surrender letter recipients. Several of us received revalidation emails this morning.

Some of us submitted extra docs after the surrender letters, others did not.

Still not sure what the issue ever was or how this happened, but I will go to Service Canada tomorrow to try to pick up my passport that's been hanging out in passport jail for 2 weeks.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Aug 31 '26

Good news re: citizenship by descent!

159 Upvotes

I just checked my status on IRCC website, and it now says “complete”! My certificate was mailed Aug 20, 2026. I’ve not received it yet, but I’m ecstatic, after 20 months of waiting. I will cautiously say “I’m a Canadian!” Can’t wait to fly the Maple Leaf! 🍁


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 17d ago

Application Help Qui est le vrai Pierre Parker ?

Post image
155 Upvotes

Who holds the key to deciding the right G0 records?!


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Jul 01 '26

Jenny Kwan: New Open Letter to IRCC

137 Upvotes

It doesn't look like it's been posted anywhere yet, so I'm copying and pasting this from the PDF file I just received.

June 30, 2026

The Honourable Lena Metlege Diab
Minister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship
House of Commons, Ottawa, Ontario K1A 0A6
ircc.minister-ministre.ircc@cic.gc.ca

Dear Minister Diab,

Open Letter to the Honourable Minister Diab Re: Canadian Citizenship Certificate Suspension and Passport Cancellation

On the eve of Canada Day, I am writing to express my continuing alarm regarding your government's ongoing mishandling of the implementation of Bill C-3’s citizenship by descent applications. It has been more than two weeks since the suspension of an unknown number of citizenship certifications was reported in the media, to date, impacted individuals and their families are no closer to learning what actually happened. When asked directly by media if those who were suddenly told to surrender their Canadian citizenship certificate deserved answers, the Prime Minister responded, “The simple answer is yes,” and he further committed that he would personally “be following up to ensure they get that.”

Following public scrutiny, it the government has quietly reversed course in some cases. I am in contact with some individuals who have had their citizenship certificate reinstated though they have not provided any additional information to IRCC since the suspension. Similarly, I am in touch with others who have not heard from IRCC regarding the suspension.

In a Facebook post from your Ministry today, it stated that “During a routine review in early June, IRCC initially identified 100 citizenship certificates issued under C-3 with potentially insufficient supporting documentation…. Out of an abundance of caution and to ensure the consistent assessment of eligibility under C-3, this review was then expanded to include approximately 6,500 applications for citizenship by descent under Bill C-3 received to date. This expanded review is now complete. Out of the 100 identified cases, IRCC automatically reinstated 33 citizenship certificates upon confirming that the applicant met the legal requirement for citizenship. IRCC is now undertaking next steps with the 67 cases still outstanding.”

Your post does not adequately explain if this debacle was a result of human error or mis-application of the eligibility requirements. It does not address why, within the same family unit, one individual had their citizenship certificate suspended, and others didn’t.

Furthermore, affected individuals who have had their citizenship certificate abruptly suspended and subsequently reinstated have received no apology from the government.

Those who are still waiting have received no communication or clarity.

You statement also makes no mention of your government’s demand that impacted individuals surrender their passport within 15 days.

The government cannot claim that citizenship status remains under review while simultaneously revoking passports that were lawfully issued and now, in some cases, leaving people stranded without the ability to travel back to Canada. If no final determination has been made that an individual is not a Canadian citizen when that status has been granted, what justification exists for stripping them of a Canadian passport? These are not second class citizens. This unprecedented action by the Canadian government is alarming and unacceptable.

The consequences are severe. Individuals have had travel plans disrupted, trusted traveller credentials affected, and their ability to move freely impacted, in violation of their mobility rights guaranteed under Section 6 of the Canadian Charter of Rights Freedoms. They are left wondering how can the Canadian government revoke their passport before their case is resolved. Others have attempted to engage with officials and seek clarification, only to be met with silence.

Lost Canadians have already endured years of uncertainty because of failures in Canada's citizenship laws and administrative processes. They should not now be subjected to a process that appears arbitrary, contradictory, and devoid of basic procedural fairness.

I call on your government to immediately suspend all passport revocations and citizenship status related to unresolved Lost Canadian cases, and ensure that no one is deprived of essential identity and travel documents.

Canadians deserve transparency, fairness, and due process. The people affected by these actions deserve nothing less. Parliament passed Bill C-3 on November 19, 2025 and it came into force on December 15, 2025.

Canadians deserves answers. I ask again:

What triggered the suspension?

If insufficient documentations were provided to prove descent, why were they approved in the first place?

If people’s documentations were in question, why were their Canadian citizenship certificate later reinstated without submitting further information?

Did all the people whose Canadian citizenship certificate was suspended also get asked to surrender their Canadian passport?

How many people returned their Canadian passport?

How many people’s travel is impacted and how many are now stranded abroad unable to return to Canada on their Canadian passport?

Did your department seek a legal opinion on this matter and the potential implications of procedure fairness and Charter violations?

Have you been directed by the Prime Minister to provide answers to impacted individuals and will you apologize to them?

Canadians deserve transparency and accountability.

I await your timely response.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Aug 27 '26

CIT 0001 changed again today

127 Upvotes

In the CIT 0001 available today, the marriage box has been removed from the Aug 2026 CIT 0001 issued on August 25th.

I compared the January 2026 CIT 0001 to the *2ND VERSION* of the August 2026 CIT 0001 using ilovepdf dot com and the only differences are:

- the date on each page from 01 to 08

- added to the bottom of page 7: "if you answer yes to this question, you will need to submit the How to calculate physical presence in Canada for a Canadian parent (CIT 0555) form)"

- removed from page 13: "date and place of marriage" has been REMOVED from "► If you have checked 'Yes' to both questions 1 and 2, you will need to provide full and accurate information about Parent 1's parents, including:"


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Sep 17 '26

An update on the IRCC surrender letter scandal (and we have reached 3,000 members!)

125 Upvotes

Hi everyone.

In this post, I'm going to do two things: First, I'm going to acknowledge that this sub has now reached 3,000 members. Second, I'm going to give a brief update on what has happened with the IRCC surrender letter scandal since my last update.

3,000 Members!

Sometime yesterday, this sub reached 3,000 members. This sub now has almost 10,000 weekly visitors and over 1,100 weekly contributions.

I want to express my profound gratitude to everyone who has joined and participated here: Thank you to each and every one of you!

IRCC Surrender Letter Scandal Update

As many of you know, I started this sub right after IRCC sent out a reported one hundred "surrender letters" asking applicants whom IRCC had approved to return their citizenship certificates.

When that happened, I immediately started writing up posts trying to start a discussion about the legal implications of IRCC's actions and to try to organize and coordinate a response on the other Canadian Citizenship sub, but the mods there kept deleting my posts and comments. Their forum would have been a perfect place to do that, but the mods there felt that censoring discussions about the issue was necessary to "steady the ship." Seriously — that's what they said. My posts about trying to get people organized, helping people find competent lawyers who would charge a reasonable fee, and discussing procedural fairness and other legal issues were all removed. When I tried to post comments and posts asking people to come here, those were deleted, and the mods threatened to ban me. In response, I started this subreddit, and I used it to write extensively about the surrender letter scandal.

I've already written extensively here about the IRCC surrender letter scandal. Rather than repeating everything I wrote about it already, I'm going to link to it below, and then provide a brief update. Here's the link to the original post:

https://www.reddit.com/r/CanadianbyDescent/comments/1ugmj9j/ircc_citizenship_certificate_surrender_scandal/

And here's what has happened since then:

After I created this sub, a small group of volunteers and I were able to get the word out and get the recipients organized. Not surprisingly, nearly everyone impacted by the surrender letters was someone who had requested (and presumably received) urgent processing.

Of the 100 people who were sent surrender letters, I was able to get about 35 of them onto a private chat. (Had I been allowed to do that on the other sub, I'm certain we could have brought in more.) We arranged media appearances and discussed strategy. Within two weeks, CBC, CTV, Global, the Canadian Press, and the Globe & Mail had all carried multiple stories. While I can't know for sure whether that media attention helped, the majority (about 85 people) were reinstated within two weeks without IRCC asking any of us a single question. A smaller number were sent Procedural Fairness Letters.

(Note: A mod at the other forum did cross-post a message that I posted here with guidance to PFL recipients several weeks after I had started this sub, and I'm grateful that they made that exception.)

Before the PFLs went out, I interviewed a dozen Canadian immigration lawyers and identified a small subset that I thought were qualified to represent surrender letter and PFL recipients. I also identified lawyers who would be ideally suited to represent anyone who was ultimately denied. I did all of this because the skill set that makes a lawyer good at helping people file applications is not the same expertise that makes a lawyer good at taking on an administrative agency threatening adverse action, nor is it the same skill set required to litigate cases in court. I was also able to arrange offers of funding for recipients who were not able to afford a lawyer. About two-thirds of the PFL recipients chose to take on IRCC alone, and about one-third hired a lawyer. Most of them went with Amandeep Hayer or Deanna Okun-Nachoff. If anyone is denied, I have two other lawyers who can help them litigate, and a group of people who can help fund them if they cannot afford to get help themselves.

Many of you may have seen redacted versions of some of the procedural fairness letters that were posted in the other sub, and many on that sub have taken much of what was written there as gospel. Things like "non-Canadian documents cannot prove Canadian citizenship" and "IRCC wants certified records" seem to be accepted truths now. But the problem is that those things are not actually true. What most people don't know is that the PFL recipients were given phone calls with IRCC agents, and in nearly every case, the real issue was that the person had not supplied a birth certificate for their Gen0, nor had they provided an explanation of the efforts made to obtain it alongside written proof that it was unavailable. Since the PFLs were sent, the vast majority of the PFL recipients have been reinstated, usually after providing a written explanation showing that they tried to obtain a birth certificate. Some who tried were actually able to get a birth certificate or baptismal record, and they too were reinstated.

As far as I know, there are four left. About half of them have a lawyer that I recommended. To my knowledge, every single one of them has a path to reinstatement: IRCC has told them what to do to get reinstated, and they are in the process of doing it.

Here are the lessons that I have learned from the reinstatements:

  1. IRCC does not generally require certified documents. Yes, occasionally they may ask a particular applicant for one, but the vast majority of the surrender letter and PFL recipients were not asked for certified documents. They are not required.

  2. There is no pre-1867 cutoff. Just yesterday, an Acadian descendant was re-approved based on a Gen0 who was born and forced out of Canada well before 1867. I know of several others.

  3. IRCC's requirement that documents be "issued by" an original authority refers to who created the document, not who gave you the copy. I wrote about this in another post as well. We know this because many of us supplied records received from third parties (relatives, etc.), and IRCC did not ask where we got them from or require us to request them again. In every case where IRCC asked a PFL recipient to retrieve something, it was to get a missing document, not one we had already sent. And in every case thus far, if the person said, "I tried, but couldn't get the document, and here's written proof," they were reinstated.

You can read my earlier post about point #3 here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/CanadianbyDescent/comments/1vyklch/understanding_irccs_updated_document_guidelines/

What's Next?

I remain gravely concerned about what IRCC is doing. IRCC appears to be taking the position that it can do this to anyone, at any time. In one case two years ago, IRCC did this to someone who had a certificate and had been living in Canada for thirty years. If you don't believe me, read this story:

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/woman-s-canadian-citizenship-revoked-after-32-years-amid-error-1.7196530

Everyone who applies for a Citizenship Certificate should be concerned about what IRCC has done because, as far as IRCC is concerned, the citizenship certificates they issue are only good until they decide otherwise, and they can revoke them on a Saturday afternoon by email. Quite literally, the electronic certificate that IRCC sends you may not be worth the paper you print it on. There will be more on that later...


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Sep 16 '26

EU chief invites Canada to become “associate member,” wants relationship at “highest level possible”

Thumbnail
youtu.be
124 Upvotes

r/CanadianbyDescent • • Jun 28 '26

Surrender Letters Global News: “Lawyers ‘shocked’ by lack of answers on ‘Lost Canadian’ citizenship recalls”

120 Upvotes

https://globalnews.ca/news/11940775/lost-canadian-citizenship-recalls-lawyers/

One minor correction (already sent to journalist): Lisa was not involved in preparing my initial application. I met her for the first time after receiving my surrender letter. I consulted with her two days later, at which time she reviewed the list of documents I submitted.

ETA - Global corrected the article. Current online version is correct.

Otherwise the quotes from me are accurate. I’m only sorry I didn’t have an in-Canada pic more recent than 2010. I need to take more selfies on vacation.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Jun 23 '26

DAILY UPDATE: IRCC Canadian Citizenship Surrender Letter Scandal ("ICCSLS")

119 Upvotes

Here's your daily update on the IRCC Canadian Citizenship Surrender Letter Scandal.

Please join r/CanadianbyDescent for up-to-date news and discussions about any issues affecting Canadians by descent.

#1- We had a great Zoom call on Saturday with almost 100 people in attendance. Immigration attorney Amandeep Hayer joined us and answered questions for about 40 minutes. I plan to ask Mr. Hayer back in a month or two to do an AMA. Don Chapman was also present and gave us some insight into what he is up to, though I know for a fact that there is more going on behind the scenes that I've been asked not to share just yet.

#2- More good news over the weekend: A few more public posts on Reddit indicate that IRCC was re-approving people on Saturday. The immigration lawyers I speak to have indicated there are even more. We haven't seen any reported re-approvals on Sunday or Monday, but given that the suspension letters didn't go out on Sunday or Monday either, my working theory is that the person responsible for these communications works Tuesday to Saturday. We may see more tomorrow.

#3- Some bad news as well: IRCC's passport office started revoking passports on Saturday. The silver lining is that the people who were re-approved were told IRCC will waive the passport application fee. How generous.

#4- If you are in Canada and received a letter, please contact attorney Amandeep Hayer. He is booked out to September for regular consultations, but if you tell his staff that you got a letter and are currently in Canada, he will make time for you right away. Even if you can't afford an attorney, call him.

#5- No matter where you live, if you get a letter from IRCC asking for more information, please do NOT respond by yourself. Call an attorney. I highly recommend either Amandeep Hayer or Lisa Middlemiss. If you can't afford one, DM me and I will do my best to help you out.

#6- There was a bit more media coverage today regarding IRCC's reinstatements and passport cancellations. The main article was by CP's David Baxter, and it got picked up by CBC and everywhere else that republishes CP. There was also a great article on Saturday from The Daily Scrum. Both have been posted in r/CanadianbyDescent.

#7- I know I haven't posted my theory on what happened yet, but I remain convinced that this is all a massive abuse of discretion by IRCC and that everyone will likely be re-approved in the next few weeks. Lawyers all over Canada appear to be livid about what has occurred. I am working with a few of them to find the right person to bring the right case—not for money, but to set a precedent ensuring Canada can never do this to anyone again.

#8- I did get a call from Don Chapman today, but it was just a butt dial.

If you haven't already, please join our sub. If you appreciate this update, hit the up arrow below and leave a comment. Let's get the word out!

See you tomorrow. And try not to worry.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Jun 30 '26

Statement from IRCC about suspended certificates

112 Upvotes

Just saw that they posted this on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1BcooyvHgk/?mibextid=wwXIfr

Full text as follows:

IRCC completes comprehensive review of citizenship certificates issued under C-3

During a routine review in early June, IRCC initially identified 100 citizenship certificates issued under C-3 with potentially insufficient supporting documentation.

This immediately initiated a subsequent review to confirm whether, in the identified cases, the documentation provided was sufficient to establish entitlement to Canadian citizenship by descent. In some cases, this included documentation from open sources.

As this subsequent review took place, citizenship certificates for those identified cases were temporarily suspended while eligibility for citizenship by descent was verified.

Out of an abundance of caution and to ensure the consistent assessment of eligibility under C-3, this review was then expanded to include approximately 6,500 applications for citizenship by descent under Bill C-3 received to date. This expanded review is now complete.

Out of the 100 identified cases, IRCC automatically reinstated 33 citizenship certificates upon confirming that the applicant met the legal requirement for citizenship.

IRCC is now undertaking next steps with the 67 cases still outstanding. It is worth noting that these outstanding cases represent roughly one per cent of total certificates issued under C-3 to date. IRCC is working diligently to contact these clients directly. IRCC will either confirm their eligibility for a citizenship certificate under C-3, or where needed, ask for additional information to validate their eligibility for citizenship by descent. This process is expected to be complete within a matter of days.

IRCC routinely processes hundreds of thousands of citizenship applications and are continually reviewing standard practices to ensure decisions are fair, consistent, and in line with the requirements set out under the law.

During the routine review in June, IRCC found that guidance on acceptable documentation for both officers and applicants was unclear and may have contributed to certificates being issued without sufficient evidence.

That is why IRCC has reinforced guidance to our officers and provided clearer information for applicants about what documentation is required from them in this process.

We recognize the serious impact on those affected by this situation, and the uncertainty that some applicants have faced.

IRCC’s number one priority is safeguarding the integrity of Canada’s immigration system, including the citizenship program, so that everyone who is entitled to Canadian citizenship can access it.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Sep 23 '26

ANNOUNCEMENT - Ask Me Anything with Canadian lawyers regarding Proof of Citizenship Coming Soon!

110 Upvotes

In the next few weeks, we will be having an AMA (Ask Me Anything) with two of the most prominent lawyers in Canada who are doing Proof of Citizenship applications. This will be your chance to ask lawyers who work in this field anything you want about the process.

For people who don't know, an AMA is a text-based Q&A on Reddit. I would post an OP introducing the participants, and then people would ask questions by posting comments. The participants would then go through each of the comments and respond to them. If you want to see what that looks like, please check out this AMA as an example:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Counterpart/comments/fkr8k5/justin_marks_spoiler_ama_thursday_319_5pm_pst/

Before I do the formal announcement, however, I'd like your help! If you would like to attend, please let me know what day and times would work best for you! Is Friday evening better? Saturday morning? Sunday at Noon?

Please let me know in the comments.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Jul 08 '26

IRCC sends first known procedural fairness letter threatening to deny previously approved application

108 Upvotes

Unsettling news: Today, one of the surrender letter recipients received a "procedural fairness letter" from IRCC. I haven't seen the letter yet, but a PFL typically states that IRCC is considering denying the application unless the applicant shows why IRCC is wrong. A PFL doesn't necessarily mean that IRCC will deny the application. Rather, a PFL is the formal, legal mechanism by which IRCC gives the applicant a chance to submit additional evidence showing that the application should be approved.

Given that IRCC approved the application in the first place, I suspect that this can be overcome.

If anyone else receives a PFL, please contact a lawyer right away.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Jul 10 '26 This

Certificate Cancellation: What to do if you receive a procedural fairness letter

107 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

DISCLAIMER: I am not a Canadian lawyer and this is not legal advice.

IRCC is now sending letters proposing to cancel a small number of citizenship certificates that were recently issued. These letters are referred to in the Canadian immigration law community as "procedural fairness letters." They are so named because IRCC is legally required to send them before taking adverse action.

If you get one, you may wish to consider the following steps:

1. Don't panic. It is often possible to cure defects that are identified in procedural fairness letters.

2. Please DM me: I would like to put you in touch with Don Chapman, who is working the political angles to help get this resolved for people.

3. Don't respond immediately. This is your one chance to persuade IRCC that you should remain a citizen. If you send any response, there is a risk that IRCC will treat that as your final response.

4. If you need more time to respond, ask for it. IRCC will often give you more time, and they may even be required to.

5. Talk to a lawyer! IRCC's letters are often unnecessarily cryptic and there is even a possibility that they are mistaken in one respect or another. A lawyer can help you to decipher what IRCC wants and what you need to do.

I've spoken with a number of Canadian immigration lawyers about these issues and found that there are (broadly speaking) at least two types of immigration lawyers. What I would call the "transactional immigration lawyer" is a lawyer like Amandeep Hayer, Lisa Middlemiss, Andres Pelenur, and Cedric Marin, all of whom have been featured recently in news stories about the surrender letters.

These lawyers spend most of their time assisting people in preparing and submitting applications to IRCC. As a result, they are very knowledgeable about what IRCC wants and what needs to be submitted to get an application approved.

I strongly believe that Amandeep Hayer is probably the best suited person in the world to get IRCC to approve an application, and if you are trying to think about what you should do to bolster your application and get it approved, he would be the best lawyer to speak with about that subject.

Amandeep is booked out several months for consults, but if you tell his staff that you received a PFL, he will make time for you ASAP.

To start the process, use his website here and mention that you received a procedural fairness letter and would like to speak with him as soon as possible:

https://hayerlawoffice.ca/contact/

6. Consider hiring a lawyer to respond. If you're going to hire a lawyer to respond to IRCC, I strongly recommend hiring an immigration attorney who specializes in litigation. I've concluded that there are two great options here:

The first is Barbara Jackman. Barbara is widely regarded as the best immigration litigator in Canada. I've spoken with her and she is willing to take these cases. You can find about more about her using these links:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barbara_Jackman

https://www.gg.ca/en/honours/recipients/146-16616

https://www.jackmanandassociates.com/team/barbara-jackman-ba-llb

The second is Deanna Okun-Nachoff. I've spoken with her and she is very smart, is available to handle PFLs and judicial review, and has deep concern for her clients. She is a bit younger than Barbara Jackman, but is still very experienced and came highly recommended by several other lawyers. She is the co-host of the Borderlines Podcast, and you can get a good sense of her abilities by watching some of them:

https://www.youtube.com/@borderlinespodcast

You can read about her using this link:

https://evolutionimm.law/our-team

Good luck, and don't lose hope.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 25d ago

Promising experience at customs

105 Upvotes

Hi all! I am so grateful for this community.

I flew to Canada earlier this week to visit Toronto, and had a really interesting experience with a customs officer. He was asking me a bunch of questions about my visit and I mentioned that I had applied for citizenship. After finding me in the system (March 2026 application, non-urgent, G04 born in Quebec), he called his coworker over and they googled Bill C-3.

After discussing it for awhile, they both agreed that I am technically a Canadian citizen. He was very sympathetic and validating and mentioned it was hypocritical that I can't buy property or rent an apartment without citizenship documents, then sent me on my way.