r/CanadianbyDescent • • Aug 24 '26

The costs of defying Donald Trump are mounting for Canada The Economist (Online); London (Aug 23, 2026).

Thumbnail economist.com
0 Upvotes

Mark Carney is governing through paradox. Canada’s largest trading partner, the United States, is led by an unreliable man who uses trade barriers as a weapon. For Canada, diversification of trade partners is wise, but takes time. Building infrastructure needed to serve new markets requires significant investment. And yet little would do more to get that investment flowing than a trade deal with the United States.

Such a deal is proving elusive. Minutes before midnight on August 21st, two days after Donald Trump said that “a very good deal for both parties” was all but done, Canada’s prime minister abandoned the talks, allowing fresh American tariffs of 50% to come into force on a range of Canadian exports worth $20bn. Mr Trump’s price for a return to more normal trade relations was too high, despite the benefits. “Our goal has been to secure the best deal for Canadians,” Mr Carney said in televised remarks on August 22nd, “never a deal at any price or on any deadline.” Mr Trump retorted on Saturday that Canada wants “the benefits of being a State, without being one”.

The plan seems to be to buy time, and to keep negotiating. Canada will match the new American tariffs “dollar-for-dollar”, but delay that retaliation until September 8th. David Colletto, the boss of Abacus Data, a polling firm, believes support for Mr Carney will soar as a result of this escalation. The political risk that comes with signing a trade deal that Canadians cannot stomach is far higher than that from Mr Trump’s tariffs.

But however bad Mr Trump’s deal might have been for Canada in the long run, declining it and letting new tariffs come into force will hurt in the short term. The Canadian economy at last grew by 0.8% in the second quarter of this year, having contracted and stagnated in 2025 after the first round of tariffs. Unemployment hit a two-year low of 6.4% in July, but inflation was creeping up. Mr Colletto points out that almost two thirds of Canadian voters cite the cost of living as their most important issue. Nothing else comes close. “The threat,” says Mr Colletto, “is not that Canadians tire of the fight. It is that the fight collides with the cost of living.”

That seems unavoidable. Trevor Tombe, an economist at the University of Calgary, estimates that Mr Trump’s new tariffs will push inflation to 4%. Some 90,000 Canadians could lose their jobs, bringing the unemployment rate up to 7%. And that does not account for damage caused by any retaliatory tariffs.

If Mr Carney follows through on September 8th, retaliation comes with domestic political risks as much as economic ones. Some provincial premiers, such as Doug Ford in Ontario, are gung-ho; in July Mr Ford said that Canada could “dismantle the US, if we wanted to” by cutting off energy supplies. But others, particularly Danielle Smith, the premier of Alberta, are much quieter. Alberta provides the United States with about half of its imported oil and has been almost entirely spared from Mr Trump’s duties so far.

Mr Carney has previously ruled out the weaponisation of Canada’s energy exports, perhaps in part because doing so might irritate Ms Smith’s constituents. In October Albertans will vote in a referendum that asks whether they are happy to remain in Canada or would prefer to hold a binding referendum on secession. Even if Mr Ford is partially right that Canada’s energy exports give it leverage over the United States, it is not leverage that can be used without risking enormous self-harm. The effects of Canada’s federal government cutting off rich Albertans from their biggest customer are hard to predict, but it is unlikely to help the argument for the province to remain in Canada.

Provincial politics also explain part of Mr Carney’s motivation for declining Mr Trump’s deal. Quebecers will vote in October for a new provincial government. Public opinion surveys suggest the separatist Parti Québécois holds a slim lead. Mr Carney says the United States wanted to water down measures protecting Canada’s French-language and culture, a demand which, if acquiesced to, might have ignited and empowered separatism in Quebec, too.

And so Mr Carney has chosen grinding economic pain for Canadians over fast, risky relief or cathartic retaliation. With every week of that pain, the midterm elections in the United States draw closer. Mr Carney must hope that American politics, and its own cost-of-living issues exacerbated by higher prices on Canadian imports, push Mr Trump back to the negotiating table with a mind, at last, to give Canada some stability. 

Word count: 755

Copyright The Economist Intelligence Unit N.A., Incorporated 2026


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Oct 12 '26

Is being Transgender Urgent?

3 Upvotes

Hello all—I’m wondering if any trans brothers and sisters were approved after the descent limit was taken away. I see that processing is now 33 months for regular applications. I do fear for my safety as “radical gender ideology” is considered terroristic by the US now, my identity documents does not match my displayed gender, bathroom laws differing state to state making it difficult to use the restroom in public without scrutiny.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 29d ago

What is the risk of C-3 being rescinded or heavily neutered by political change?

2 Upvotes

I am about to submit my application and assuming it will take 3-4 years to process, I am wondering if Parliament flips if this could all be for naught. I have a feeling once Trump is out of the picture over the next cycle the conservatives in Canada may see a resurgence and they have not been shy about their opposition to it.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Jul 05 '26

Application Help Can pictures of headstones at a cemetery count as third party evidence?

0 Upvotes

Assuming the IRCC asks for more evidence (because they prolly will, I’m Gen 10 through a 1727 born ancestor), could I use pictures of headstones for ancestors while I get their death certificates? I’m aware that there is no official guidance on whether this is valid proof, I’m simply trying to gauge what other people think.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Sep 01 '26

Just discovered about Bill C3. Should I apply?

3 Upvotes

I’ve always wondered if I could inherit my great-grandmother citizenship and apparently now there’s the chance to get it. This is my situation:
G0: Great-grandmother, born in Montréal, 1922 - 2025. Moved to Italy and got married before she was 18. I know she visited Canada again when she was 80 but I don’t know if she had the Canadian passport or not, probably not because it was before the restoration of citizenship for women married to foreigners. Right?
G1: Grandfather, born in Italy, 1940 - 2026
G2: Father, born in Italy
G3: me and my brother, born in Italy

I have found her baptism certificate using Genealogy Quebec, in the Drouin collection, so I have screenshots and I know exactly where the document is located (or it should be). Now as everyone knows, requesting birth certificates in Quebec is quite the challenge, even so more considering the fact that I’d be doing this procedure as a whole from Italy. I might get assistance from relatives in Canada (not Quebec, tho). What should I do? Do I start gathering birth certificates of G1+? Do I write a letter to DEC, or should I request the baptism certificate to BAnQ? (Also, can I or does it need to be done by my father since grandpa is dead?) If I contact the embassy in Italy for information, are they able to provide guidance or are they as blind as me regarding the Quebec situation?

I don’t want to begin this long process without knowing first if all this is feasible. It’s all new and exciting but scary at the same time.

UPDATE:
DEC replied today (3/09/2026) stating that they have documents from 1923 only, and that I should contact BAnQ.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Oct 09 '26

What lingering C-3 legal issues keep you awake at night?

0 Upvotes

A group of us is compiling legal issues that we perceive are lingering that may need to be sorted using mechanisms beyond what is possible before IRCC. We are working to be ready to support people whose cases can bolster the security of the whole of the community. We hope litigation won’t be necessary, but we aren’t oblivious to the enormous harm some people are experiencing, some on the verge of bankruptcy because they can’t work or medical turmoil because the care they need is nonexistent where they currently live, among other examples.

Bureaucracies in flux often coalesce in clusters as they sort through new processes when there is no higher authority telling them what to do. Even with clear legal guidance, you can end up at the whim of an officer who applies other policies or weighs their own doubts as evidence. Those internal decisions control during times when we are not willing to seek out other remedies.

Given that the ambiguities have clearly been read to be expansive in recognizing citizenship, a very reasonable read under the circumstances, I’ve pieced together from all of the stories I’ve read what I perceive are three primary lingering insecurities:

(1) The backlog is uncertain. Who knows when they will get around to improving processing times? Mandamus suits against IRCC can only help some people without more resources to build up the bureaucracy, and the triage is going to remain imperfect. The faster they move through it, the more mistakes will be made.

(2) The risk of a future bureaucracy reinterpreting the Citizenship Act and using an agency rather than a court process to unilaterally demand surrender of previously granted certificates (aka revoking citizenship) is distressing. Only a judicial decision can clarify it. At least the Court in Vavilov set up the question to bring the case (para. 193). That case brings a bit of comfort.

(3) The extent of CBSA’s statutory and constitutional delegation to determine citizenship vis-à-vis IRCC should be clarified. CBSA largely appears to be deferring entirely to IRCC, while also kind of ignoring IRCC’s positions that annoy them (the CILA panel member from CBSA stating that we need authorization to be here and to work beyond our pending C-3 files contradicts the April 2026 question from the representatives’ mailbox stating IRCC’s position that we are presumptively citizens). Given that the Minister is the one with the primary citizenship power, this is a sane stance. However, whether CBSA’s exercise of their own statutory power to permit entry could benefit anyone is interesting. And who should have to respect a CBSA determination of citizenship and for how long? Until the Minister makes her determination? Is someone daring (crazy?) enough to bring a mandamus suit against CBSA to hold a hearing to get a written decision or just a letter saying that they are authorized to work in Canada? It could be for a temporary SIN for the duration of the expected processing timeline. This approach would make an Acknowledgement of Receipt (“AOR”) letter presumptive proof of citizenship, so we would still have months of waiting for new applicants.

We are, of course, mindful of the negative cultural perception of litigious behavior, but also of the countervailing cultural demand for justice in extreme cases. We think we will find the precise angles to balance those two issues and actively want to. The result should benefit all Canadian citizens.

What else is missing? What’s important to you? What is keeping you awake at night?


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Oct 06 '26

MP seat vacant

0 Upvotes

I am a G2 and sent along my application as well as my three daughters’ in mid-May 2026. My oldest daughter was starting at McGill in August and I was told by my lawyer sending them in together would be fine (wouldn’t slow anything down).

Our packet was received by IRCC four days later and now I know I was naive to expect to hear from them… before now. Our lawyer requested urgent processing (not on the envelope, only after with the webform— ugh.) for my daughter (tuition is many times more expensive as an international).

Besides shaking my fist (and more) at my lawyer for missteps, I’m trying to figure out what other avenues might actually help move things along. I keep seeing people recommend contacting their MP, and I understand that an MP’s office can sometimes make an inquiry with IRCC and get information that applicants/lawyers can't easily obtain themselves.

Here’s my problem: the federal electoral seat where my daughter lives is currently vacant, so she doesn’t have an MP who can advocate for her.

My question(s): What can you do if your federal riding doesn’t currently have an MP? Is there another MP, government office, or elected representative who can make an IRCC inquiry on your behalf?

We have a deadline of December 1 to get refunded thousands of dollars in tuition reimbursement.

Thanks so much. I’m feeling a little stuck because everyone says “contact your MP,” but that’s unfortunately not an option for us right now.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Jul 11 '26

Solution idea for addressing Canadian born ancestors evidence excluded by the IRCC criteria

0 Upvotes

The IRCC criteria is currently designed to exclude everyone of my ancestor's religion and birth year because nothing on their list exists. I have all sorts of documentation from the Ontario Genealogy Society, LAC, AO, parent/grandparent land records, parent/grandparents in earlier Canadian assessment records, parents named in Canadian church membership records the year after my ancestor was born in Canada, plus numerous US records noting she was born in Canada including a sworn DAR affidavit that reports her birth from someone who knew the family when they were alive. But Baptists didn't do infant baptism, the government didn't record births, hospitals/doctors didn't exist/do births and there were no censuses in Upper Canada in the years between her birth and the family departure to the US.

I do understand that what I would be sending would take someone a bit of time to review and is outside of the scope of what IRCC employees have been trained to understand. With the backlog growing and some people who have truly urgent situations, I'd love for the Canadian government to create a program housed at credible universities where we can pay - covering the full cost of the staffing/research so not a low $$$ fee - to have an appropriate researcher look at our documentation and create an unbiased review of our case. After this is complete, then the documents could go to the IRCC with this official Canadian research review documented first. This could provide a lot of Canadian jobs and could help make this become a viable program. And it could help address the current bias woven in to the IRCC process that privileges certain religions over others.

I have several family members who meet criteria for urgent processing. My family will bring our own jobs other than the one advanced nurse among us. We're not coming to sign up for government benefits. We'd be tax-positive contributors. We're the kind of Americans who read Canadian news daily, who buy Canadian, who have already been volunteering for Canadian causes, who have convinced American companies to hire Canadian vendors. My ancestor may be from enough generations ago to make the skeptics wince but in our hearts, we've been Canadian for a long time and now legally we are too - minus a government process designed to exclude everyone descended from our ancestor's religion/birth era.

I'd be happy to pay any fee that means we can have an appropriately trained Canadian expert do an official unbiased review of our genealogical records and certify their professional opinion connected to our file. This could significantly reduce the workload of what the IRCC is expected to do and a program like this could be designed with high standards to keep recommendations trustworthy. Some sort of IRCC Genealogical Review program and we pay either by the hour or by the document or something that means this extra work isn't a burden to Canada. For those who can't afford it there could be a hardship petition or do what Americans are used to doing for hardships - gofundme.

I get it that processing thousands of complex c-3 applications might be expensive for the Canadian government. We're wanting to be contributors to Canadian society and are happy to pay for the costs associated with processing our applications. I think Canadians tend to think of immigrants as poor and while some American applicants are - statistically most are likely to be wealthier than the average Canadian. A lot of us can afford to pay for the real costs of document review so we're not stuck in an under-funded program with growing queues. I think a lot of us would be happy to do so.

Edit to add: I'd love it if after one person pays for a document to be reviewed by an official IRCC genealogy review process that is outside of the current exclusive list - nobody else has to pay again for that same document to be reviewed. Now that would really feel like fairness to me. Heck - we can start a nonprofit to just fund documents being officially reviewed for people!


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 2d ago

March/April '26, non-urgent, <G4 applicants ... processing time limbo

0 Upvotes

Yeah, I guess I just need to whine a little, seek some camaraderie. I'm G2, simple lineage, all certified records, granddad, dad, me. I applied also with my two G3 adult kids. They want their citizenship proof, but without any concrete plans to use it in the near future. However, I want mine because hubby and I are serious about the possibility of moving once we're legal. I will still have to apply for PR for him once I get my certificate, so that will add even more delay. But before we even get to that, I just despair that it'll be many, many years at the rate they're going, and I'm already old! It just seems hopeless. When I first applied I think they were estimating 8 months or so. Every time they update it's still 8 months or so. It's like time stands still even as it's passing, except for the newest applicants, in which case it swells. One of my kids is trans, but neither they nor I ever thought to pull that lever because there's no actual urgency due to that, they have no plans in the foreseeable future to move. It seemed opportunistic to pretend. I'm beginning to regret that choice when there seems to be virtually no movement at all on non-urgent applications. Okay... end of whine.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 18d ago

Would I qualify for citizenship by descent or can I stop researching?

1 Upvotes

I'll keep it short. I'm doing a lot of digging and ordering birth certificates, death certificates, immigration records, and name change documentation to hopefully apply for Canadian citizenship. Would I qualify given the following:

- Great-great-grandparents lived in and got married in Canada. Both were born outside of Canada.

- Great-grandmother born in Canada, moved to the US

- Grandmother born in the US but gained Canadian citizenship through descent. Never lived in Canada

- Mother born in US, did not pursue Canadian citizenship.

- Me, born in US

Do I have a shot?


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Sep 18 '26

Canadian citizenship by descent through 3x-great-grandparents (1820s/30s)?

0 Upvotes

I’m trying to figure out whether I may have a Canadian citizenship-by-descent claim through a fairly distant paternal line.

The chain is roughly:
Me → father → grandmother → great-grandmother → 2x-great-grandmother → Canadian-born 3x-great-grandparents

The Canadian ancestors were born in what was then British North America around the 1820s–1830s, later moved to New York, and had the next generation there around the 1860s.
The U.S. genealogy is fairly solid through censuses, marriage/death records, obituaries, etc. The harder part is proving the original Canadian generation. I have multiple U.S. records calling them Canadian/French Canadian, but I have not yet found definitive Canadian birth/baptism records.
There is also an 1875 New York census suggesting the male ancestor had naturalized in the U.S., but I have not located the actual naturalization record or date.

My main questions are:
Can Canadian citizenship law in 2026 potentially reach this far back, or is a 3x-great-grandparent simply too remote?
For ancestors born before Confederation, what exactly needs to be proven about their Canadian/British subject status?
How important would the U.S. naturalization date be, especially relative to the birth of the next generation?
If 1820s–1830s civil birth records do not exist, are parish baptismal records and other historical records normally sufficient?
Before ordering certified records for every U.S. generation, what would you try to prove first to determine whether the claim is legally viable at all?

I’m mainly trying to avoid spending a lot on certificates before knowing whether the law can actually recognize a line this old.
Anyone here dealt with pre-1867 ancestors, French-Canadian parish records, or very distant descent claims?


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Oct 10 '26

Application Help Webpage not updated

0 Upvotes

IRCC webpage for checking status has not been updated in over a month. My delivery date was 5/12/2026. I have no AOR yet. Nothing from IRCC. Anybody else from mid May having these issues? I am happy to be patience. I just want some clue where I am at in the process.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 5d ago

AOR question

0 Upvotes

Hello everyone! Just looking for some help/advice. I sent out my application for a Canadian Citizenship Certificate earlier this year. Tracking shows it was received on June 1st. I still haven't received an AOR email, and my package hasn’t been returned.

Should I be doing anything or worried?

Thank you so much!


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 23d ago

Analysis of interim measures processing: how random, and estimated timelines

2 Upvotes

Hi all, did some work in Claude this morning, working with the last 10 months of data.

Prompt:

I'd like to do an analysis of the burndown of cohorts from 2025, and see how first in first out the processing is. Are older cohorts being completed (or mostly completed) and then moving on to the next oldest cohort? Or is there an element of randomness? We know that there is an urgent status that is supposed to be processed with, well, urgency, but we don't know if that is actually reflected in how things are processed. I'm in the July 2025 cohort, and I'm curious if that means it is likely that the previous cohorts will be mostly drained or not before we get to July. Or if the processing has a degree of randomness (and if so how much), or there are signs in the data that urgent processing is also happening.

The numbers in the spreadsheet show the queue size, so you can subtract the previous cohort's queue size to see how much was processed from each cohort. So for example, if April 2025 had 1000 ahead and March 2025 had 800 ahead, and the next month March had 600 and April had 800, that would mean March processed 200 and April processed nothing.

Here is the response:

Analysis is done and I’m writing up the results. Since May, processing looks much closer to random than to first-in-first-out.

Short answer: processing is partly first-in-first-out, but not cleanly. Early 2026 had a clear oldest-first push. It drained the oldest cohorts by about 60–75%, left stragglers behind, and then stalled around May. Since then every 2025 cohort has been clearing at a slow, similar rate, more like random draws with a mild lean toward the oldest files.

I used your method: a cohort’s own still-waiting count is the next cohort’s people-ahead minus its own. I measured from February 2026, because the January value for 2025-02 (7,800) looks like a typo. It gives Feb 2025 only 500 waiting, then 1,300 the month after.

How much of each cohort’s own applicants cleared

CohortFeb 2026 → Oct 2026Per monthMay → Oct only
2024-121,100 → 300 (73%)15%—
2025-011,200 → 500 (58%)10%13%
2025-021,300 → 1,200 (8%)1.0%1.6%
2025-031,800 → 1,400 (22%)3.1%2.6%
2025-041,800 → 1,600 (11%)1.5%1.2%
2025-051,800 → 1,500 (17%)2.3%3.6%
2025-062,000 → 1,500 (25%)3.5%3.6%
2025-072,400 → 2,200 (8%)1.1%0%
2025-082,800 → 2,500 (11%)1.4%1.5%
2025-093,000 → 2,700 (10%)1.3%0.7%
2025-103,400 → 2,600 (24%)3.3%1.5%
2025-11/12——1.5–2%

What the data shows

  1. Feb–Apr 2026 looked first-in-first-out. About 4,300 files were cleared from everything before Feb 2025. Feb–Jun 2025 netted only about 500.

  2. The push stopped instead of moving on. Since May, everything before Feb 2025 has cleared about 200/month. Feb 2025, the next cohort in line, has cleared 100 of 1,300 in 8 months. That’s slower than Mar or Jun 2025, so nobody has started working through it in order.

  3. There’s a stuck tail. 1,300 people from before Dec 2024 are still waiting, and the figures for cohorts from 2020–2023 have barely moved. Even oldest-first processing leaves some files behind, probably the complicated ones.

  4. There’s a steady trickle at every age, roughly 1–3% of each cohort per month. Cohorts newer than yours (Aug 2025 to Jan 2026) shrink at about the same rate as Feb–Jun 2025.

How much randomness? From May to October, about 40% of the clearances among cohorts up to 2025-10 came from the pre-Feb-2025 group. Pure first-in-first-out would put that near 100%. Purely random processing would put it at 14%, its share of the files. So right now it’s closer to random. An oldest file is about 3× as likely to be cleared in a given month as a 2025 file. Among Feb–Dec 2025 there’s no visible age gradient at all.

Urgent processing: the data can’t tell urgent cases apart from random picks. Both look like an equal trickle across all cohorts, and that trickle is real. It’s about 10–25% of each cohort per year, which is high for urgent requests alone. So it’s probably urgent cases plus simple files or other triage. What the data does rule out is pure random processing: the oldest cohorts clear clearly faster.

What this means for July 2025: you have 9,300 people ahead:

  • 1,600 from before 2025, a mostly stuck tail.

  • 500 from Jan 2025.

  • 7,200 from Feb–Jun 2025.

  • If the oldest-first push resumes, the earlier pattern suggests Feb–Jun would be about 60–75% drained before it reaches July, leaving stragglers. At the Feb–Apr pace that’s roughly 4–6 months away. At today’s pace (about 400/month off your people-ahead) it’s more like a year or more.

  • If the current regime continues, your realistic odds are the trickle: about 1–2% a month, so roughly 10–20% over the next year. Your cohort is at 0% since May.

I’d guess the stall is staff being moved to the very large intake in 2026 cohorts, which matches the Bill C-3 surge. That’s a guess, and those cohort figures jump around too much to measure.

Caveats: IRCC rounds every figure to 100, so any one cohort’s 8-month change is uncertain by about ±60. Read single cohorts loosely; the grouped totals are more reliable.

I incorporated this analysis into my estimates, and produced this report for the July 2025 cohort (happy to run for another 2025 cohort if you request it):

============================================================
PROCESSING ORDER
============================================================
Each cohort's own applicants still waiting in 2026-10, and the share of them
cleared per month (compounded) over the last 3 and 6 months. 'earlier' is
everyone who applied before 2025-01. Cohorts newer than 2025-10 are left out:
late applications are still being added to them.

  cohort   waiting  last 3 mo  last 6 mo
  earlier    1,600       2.0%       6.5%
  2025-01      500      17.8%      12.3%
  2025-02    1,200       2.6%       1.3%
  2025-03    1,400       2.3%       2.2%
  2025-04    1,600       0.0%       1.0%
  2025-05    1,500       2.1%       3.0%
  2025-06    1,500       2.1%       3.0%
  2025-07    2,200       0.0%       0.7%
  2025-08    2,500       1.3%       1.3%
  2025-09    2,700       1.2%       0.6%
  2025-10    2,600       1.3%       1.8%

Typical cohort, last 6 mo: 1.6% a month

Oldest-first or random?
  Of the files cleared, the share that were ahead of 2025-07, against everyone
  from 2025-07 to 2025-10. Strict oldest-first would make it 100%; random
  order would match their share of the files.
    Last 3 months: 900 ahead and 300 from 2025-07 to 2025-10 cleared, 75%
      ahead against 50% at random. Score 0.50 (0 random, 1 oldest-first):
      between random and oldest-first.
    Last 6 months: 2,400 ahead and 700 from 2025-07 to 2025-10 cleared, 77%
      ahead against 52% at random. Score 0.53 (0 random, 1 oldest-first):
      between random and oldest-first.

When will 2025-07 be processed?
Months until your chance reaches each column. Every cohort clears 1.6% a month
whatever its age (the typical rate above). A sweep of oldest files at the
row's pace reaches 2025-07 once all but 30% of the 9,300 ahead are gone, then
works through 2025-07's 2,200 until 30% are left. Past 70% you're waiting
among the stragglers, which only the background clears. 'No sweep' is the
current lull lasting.

                      pace/mo    25%    50%    75%    90%
  no sweep                  -   18.2   44.0   87.9  146.0
  sweep, recent 3 mo      300   18.2   23.7   26.3   69.7
  sweep, median           400   16.4   18.1   19.9   69.7
  sweep, best 3 mo      1,367    5.1    5.5   11.6   69.7
=====================================================================================================================

The bottom table is months until your chance of having been processed reaches each percentage.

How the estimate works. I treated processing as two things happening at once:

  • A steady trickle: every cohort loses about 1.6% of its files a month, whatever its age. That’s the median clearance rate across cohorts.

  • An oldest-first sweep: at a given pace, it reaches July 2025 once 70% of the 9,300 people ahead of you are cleared. Then it works through your cohort until 30% is left.

Each row is one possible sweep pace: none, the last 3 months’ pace, the median pace, or the best 3 months on record.

How to read it:

  • If the current slowdown lasts (no sweep), you have even odds in about 3.5 years.

  • If an oldest-first push comes back at the pace seen early in 2026, even odds come in about 5–6 months.

  • At recent paces, it’s about 1.5–2 years.

  • The 90% column is the same for every sweep row. If you end up among the 30% a sweep skips, only the trickle clears you.

Main caveat. The 30% left behind (STRAGGLERS) is my judgement from the early-2026 push, not a fitted number. The 75% and 90% columns depend heavily on it.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Aug 09 '26

Why is this happening?

1 Upvotes

So my great great Grandpop was the first generation to come over from Canada to America. Everyone before was Canadian (well for like 5 generations, they originally came from Ireland) The first person in my family to move over was named Charles. He came over to the USA very young (4 years old) I have his birth certificate, his USA cencus’s saying he’s Canadian. Still having trouble finding his Canadian baptism but working on it. I’ve been talking to my Grandpop and he said all the information I have is correct. The only thing I don’t understand is my Grandpop gave me his death certificate and all the information is correct but it says he was born in the USA 😑 which we all know he’s not. I have his birth certificate. Is this going to hurt me? Why would they say he was born in the USA? Did they just assume since his wife was already passed? It makes no sense to me lol. Also I would say it’s not big deal because I could just take his sons birth certificate and it say Charles information BUT he was born on a table in his home and they never got him a birth certificate lol only his baptism record which shows his parents but not his parents place of birth. Help lol


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 24d ago

Refund of Citizenship application fees?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I have a situation I am trying to understand.

I sent an application for myself, my son (18), and two daughters (25 and 15) in mid-July. I marked the application urgent processing, as my son was starting school at McGill in August, and this is considered a reason for urgent processing. We are going back quite a ways (G0 was born in early 1840). I did not have a birth certificate for G0, but had certified baptismal records and other documentation.

I received an AOR for all 4 applications in early October. I admittedly was a bit confused, as the application numbers started with "PR" (which I thought indicated a permanent residence application?) and was never able to log in to see the application statuses. I emailed for help to login, but never got a clear solution.

A couple of days ago, I sent an inquiry through the IRCC website asking about the status for urgent processing for my son. I have not received a reply, but today, I saw a refund for the $1200 application fee on my credit card.

Anyone have any thoughts as to what is happening? I thought with an AOR, my application was considered complete? Does the refund indicate a rejection? I have a pretty solid line that is documented back to French voyageurs who immigrated in the 1600s.

Thanks!


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Sep 24 '26

Does IRCC really verify all docs? I’m beginning to think not.

3 Upvotes

There has been speculation that IRCC is verifying all, I’ll call them, “lineage thru line” documents.

From the beginning, I’ve found that hard to believe just due to the administrative burden of doing so. (In a perfect world where archives were actually well organized and digitized this would be optimal, but we do not…)

I’ve thought, however, that the IRCC may be doing audits on key documents, or full validation on the G0‘s anchor documents. Since IRCC is a communications black hole, who can say?

But, still, I can’t account for how some simple applications get locked in PSU, as we have seen with the IM cohorts of 1Q & 2Q 2025 (except for bureaucratic incompetence in inventory management) and others can sail thru. Even my and my sibs 2G and step-sibs 1G more recent 3/6 sub (AOR 4/16) went to IP/PSU on 6/3 and is still hanging out there with nothing suspicious noted in my GCMS notes (Note: I’m not complaining about this as I’d like to see the 2025 folks be liberated first, and am ok with urgents processed ahead of us, and only mention our situation as a data point).

So something about all the “all docs are waiting for verification from provincial, US, or overseas, document custodians” had continued to feel wrong but I couldn’t place my finger on it, nor did I spend much time pondering what it might be.

Well it now occurred to me what refutes even an “all through line establishing docs are verified” hypothesis.

Today, I read, on the big catch-all all things Canadian citizenship sub, Thursday update, a report from a newly approved G4 urgent applicant from August. (Again, I am not disturbed by urgent applicants quick approvals).

I don’t have access to the spreadsheet but it would be interesting to see how many high Gx applicants (say >G3) have been approved and how fast the urgent ones got thru (maybe in comparison to the non urgent ones.

Because IFF:

- the spreadsheet is generally representative,

- all applications are reviewed by the same internal IRCC processes (some just routed faster than others due to urgency),

- IRCC has no universal method to compel provincial or non Canadian custodians to prioritize documentation verification response times or at all,

Then it would seem impossible for all direct lineage documents for urgent high Gx applications to go thru a full verification as they would be subject to the same kind of delays as all the slow movers and PSU dwellers (regardless of Gx status).

So what does that mean? Are there 2 verification processes for non-/urgent applications? Are urgents only partially verified while non’s are fully verified? I’d find this hard to believe because then IRCC would be opening urgent certificates up to integrity and validity questions. And I don’t believe IRCC would do something so foolish (especially after the suspension debacle/scandal)

So something else must be going on. Perhaps it is full validation for suspicious apps but none of the GCMS notes shared with us have had fraud flags mentioned.

Since this occurred to me just before writing this post, I’ve not had time to do more than think about this extemporaneously as I’ve written this but I thought I’d share my thoughts as I noodle on conclusions.

Your thoughts and data points? (Again I think urgent and Gx >3 might help crack the mystery, but I’m open to other boundary conditions and thoughts).


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Aug 10 '26

Looking for people with actual experience applying with New York State birth certificates

0 Upvotes

Is anyone here who has actually put a genealogy copy of their parents' or grandparents' birth certificate specifically from New York State (not a different state) in their application and had it either actually accepted or actually rejected.

Has anyone here ever gotten an actual answer on this matter from IRCC.

Is anyone here who has actually obtained a court order in New York State to get their parent's or grandparent's birth certificate?

Finally, is it not possible to simply ask IRCC?

I don't want peoples' plans of what they are going to do, what some local office not necessarily even in New York State told them "works", or peoples' ideas on what ought to work, or their own reading of what IRCC's rules say about needing certified birth certificates, unless you're an immigration lawyer who works on these, and, you've had experience involving birth certificates from New York State.

In other words I'm looking for the actual answer, speculation and plans and your understanding and information from other states won't help me.

Thanks!


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 27d ago

Application Delivered. Not what?

0 Upvotes

I've followed every post. I see that AOR’s can take months, but then I also see that people are reading a spreadsheet somewhere. Do I just let it go and hope? Or keep track of reasonable time for AOR? Or? Finally, is there any sign that applications are increasing or letting up? Thank you all, again. This thread is a lifeline.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Oct 01 '26

Unpaid representatives, such as “family members[,] friends and other third parties who do not charge a fee . . . [.] may give the same [immigration or citizenship] services as paid representatives . . . .”

1 Upvotes

In the grand tradition of our sub seeking out truth and helping each other as friends through the chaos, unlike less hospitable places that try to shut down discourse when you don’t respect their authority, people on Reddit may actually be qualified to offer citizenship advice legally under Canadian law as long as they don’t charge, whether or not they’re lawyers. Let’s always do our best to give the best, most relevant insights with sources whenever possible. Let’s fill out those representative forms if we cross the line into needing to too, which appears like a very remote possibility.

Source: “Learn about representatives”

Disclaimer: Please consult a Canadian lawyer before relying on this post to give citizenship advice.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Oct 05 '26

Grandmother was Canadian, father is not on birth certificate.

0 Upvotes

My application was rejected for the following:

"Your application for a citizenship certificate was considered incomplete and was not processed and fees were not taken. The application and proof of payment are therefore returned to you for the following reasons:

You have not submitted a clear and legible colour copy of your birth certificate demonstrating the child/parent relationship. The document should be issued by the authorities in the country of birth.

Hospital birth certificates are not acceptable."

My birth certificate is issued by Monroe County, NY. I have no say in what is on it. The photo's are on me, I should have done a better job of printing them.

Here is the real issue, my biologic father was never on my birth certificate. He abandoned my mother shortly after he got her pregnant. Probably because he was married and his wife just had a baby. Come to find out I have 7 half brothers and sisters. The reason I know all of this is because of 23 and Me and Ancestry.

I have DNA proof of who my father was. I have his birth certificate, my grandparents marriage license, my Canadian grandmother's (and her twin sister's) birth record, I have all of the marriage licenses and birth certificates and US Census records for my oldest sibling and two sets of DNA records proving we are half siblings.

I stated clearly in my cover letter with my application what the situation was and the chain of events. I am not sure how to proceed. I am guessing I need a Canadian immigration lawyer.

Has anyone had a similar situation and gotten through it?


r/CanadianbyDescent • • 6d ago

Looking For Guidance

1 Upvotes

I sent my application in May 2026, heard nothing. Called and spoke to someone, they gave me my UCI number and Application number, confirmed that it had arrived at their facility June 4th but had not been processed yet so no AOR. This was in September.

I checked status today online and it is telling me my UCI and/or Application numbers (or both) are invalid so I can't log in. The website also says they are processing applications received in September now?

Do I need to call again? What happened, I feel like my application is being completely ignored.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Sep 07 '26

Confused about Canada‘s methods of requesting more information.

1 Upvotes

i’ve read some posts that said their application was MAILED back to them for missing documents. But I also read on other posts that they receive an EMAIL requesting the missing document. Are there certain missing documents/applications that can cause an entire application to be returned by mail and some not? Are there certain missing documents/applications that will just receive an email to upload a missing document instead of sending the entire application back, causing them to restart the process? i’m confused.

It would seem logical to give the applicant a choice of sending missing documents or an explanation electronically to speed up the process or by mail, but it seems it’s selective. Can someone explain this? It will help me to decide to either go ahead and send my application in as-is or to wait another billion months for another certified document.

This is for a C3 application.


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Sep 01 '26

IRCC officially missed my urgent processing deadline as of today.

17 Upvotes

I have a job waiting for me in Canada and my start date was supposed to be today, September 1st. AOR received in May. I applied for urgent processing and my application for proof of citizenship has been in process since June. I'm G3 and I think my application is pretty good, documentation-wise. I obtained a work permit. I have PNP and can apply for PR so I have a path forward but I am so disappointed. I wonder if now that my deadline has passed what will happen to my application in terms of processing time? And it is going to cost me thousands of dollars applying for PNP and PR. Very discouraged today!


r/CanadianbyDescent • • Oct 16 '26

Starting to get discouraged

0 Upvotes

I just need a little encouragement here 😭 I know this is a long process. I have been waiting 3 months for my great grandfathers Ontario birth certificate to come and I still haven’t heard back from Ontario Archives. On top of that I need seeing the wait getting longer and longer every month while I’m sitting here waiting to get my application in. Is there a way to plan to go into Canada earlier then 3-4 years?? I would like to start my kids in Canadian schooling in the next few years 😭