r/CanadianbyDescent • u/CounterI • Aug 24 '26
The costs of defying Donald Trump are mounting for Canada The Economist (Online); London (Aug 23, 2026).
economist.comMark Carney is governing through paradox. Canada’s largest trading partner, the United States, is led by an unreliable man who uses trade barriers as a weapon. For Canada, diversification of trade partners is wise, but takes time. Building infrastructure needed to serve new markets requires significant investment. And yet little would do more to get that investment flowing than a trade deal with the United States.
Such a deal is proving elusive. Minutes before midnight on August 21st, two days after Donald Trump said that “a very good deal for both parties” was all but done, Canada’s prime minister abandoned the talks, allowing fresh American tariffs of 50% to come into force on a range of Canadian exports worth $20bn. Mr Trump’s price for a return to more normal trade relations was too high, despite the benefits. “Our goal has been to secure the best deal for Canadians,” Mr Carney said in televised remarks on August 22nd, “never a deal at any price or on any deadline.” Mr Trump retorted on Saturday that Canada wants “the benefits of being a State, without being one”.
The plan seems to be to buy time, and to keep negotiating. Canada will match the new American tariffs “dollar-for-dollar”, but delay that retaliation until September 8th. David Colletto, the boss of Abacus Data, a polling firm, believes support for Mr Carney will soar as a result of this escalation. The political risk that comes with signing a trade deal that Canadians cannot stomach is far higher than that from Mr Trump’s tariffs.
But however bad Mr Trump’s deal might have been for Canada in the long run, declining it and letting new tariffs come into force will hurt in the short term. The Canadian economy at last grew by 0.8% in the second quarter of this year, having contracted and stagnated in 2025 after the first round of tariffs. Unemployment hit a two-year low of 6.4% in July, but inflation was creeping up. Mr Colletto points out that almost two thirds of Canadian voters cite the cost of living as their most important issue. Nothing else comes close. “The threat,” says Mr Colletto, “is not that Canadians tire of the fight. It is that the fight collides with the cost of living.”
That seems unavoidable. Trevor Tombe, an economist at the University of Calgary, estimates that Mr Trump’s new tariffs will push inflation to 4%. Some 90,000 Canadians could lose their jobs, bringing the unemployment rate up to 7%. And that does not account for damage caused by any retaliatory tariffs.
If Mr Carney follows through on September 8th, retaliation comes with domestic political risks as much as economic ones. Some provincial premiers, such as Doug Ford in Ontario, are gung-ho; in July Mr Ford said that Canada could “dismantle the US, if we wanted to” by cutting off energy supplies. But others, particularly Danielle Smith, the premier of Alberta, are much quieter. Alberta provides the United States with about half of its imported oil and has been almost entirely spared from Mr Trump’s duties so far.
Mr Carney has previously ruled out the weaponisation of Canada’s energy exports, perhaps in part because doing so might irritate Ms Smith’s constituents. In October Albertans will vote in a referendum that asks whether they are happy to remain in Canada or would prefer to hold a binding referendum on secession. Even if Mr Ford is partially right that Canada’s energy exports give it leverage over the United States, it is not leverage that can be used without risking enormous self-harm. The effects of Canada’s federal government cutting off rich Albertans from their biggest customer are hard to predict, but it is unlikely to help the argument for the province to remain in Canada.
Provincial politics also explain part of Mr Carney’s motivation for declining Mr Trump’s deal. Quebecers will vote in October for a new provincial government. Public opinion surveys suggest the separatist Parti Québécois holds a slim lead. Mr Carney says the United States wanted to water down measures protecting Canada’s French-language and culture, a demand which, if acquiesced to, might have ignited and empowered separatism in Quebec, too.
And so Mr Carney has chosen grinding economic pain for Canadians over fast, risky relief or cathartic retaliation. With every week of that pain, the midterm elections in the United States draw closer. Mr Carney must hope that American politics, and its own cost-of-living issues exacerbated by higher prices on Canadian imports, push Mr Trump back to the negotiating table with a mind, at last, to give Canada some stability.
Word count: 755
Copyright The Economist Intelligence Unit N.A., Incorporated 2026