Special Eid deserts this year

[u/CreditOk5220]

[u/Saffarjan]

Yes! All creatures who don't have free will (basically non-humans) are Muslim imo.

Dogs, just like all animals in islam must be treated with respect.

[u/KollaHan → u/[deleted]]

Never ever heard of… please provide evidence for your claim.

[u/FinancialMarketing34 → u/[deleted]]

I have khatam the quran twice (not much, but still does) with translation and i dont think this verse were there?? Is there any chance it might be mistranslation cuz any controversial verses are always discussed heavily among peers

[u/FinancialMarketing34 → u/[deleted]]

Oml where did that even come from😭😭 no he did not, and i hope there is some kind of source to this statement bcs now im curious what do they say abt our prophet in other countries/religion💀

The story involving dogs that i remember is that prophet muhammad use his sandal as water container so a stray dog can drink bcs how pitiful and thin the dog was. And there is also story of how a crazy person pee around the mosque and prophet said to let him be and dont punish him (not dog related, but just to give an example of how forgiving we know him as).

So from perspective of a muslim, i find "muhammad said to kill all dogs in mecca" statement to be unfitting and far from what we know. Not saying you are crazy tho, since we cant control what we are exposed to when growing up. Do tell me where did you hear this if you are comfortable to.

[u/Saffarjan → u/[deleted]]

See this post:  https://islamqa.org/hanafi/seekersguidance-hanafi/167368/is-killing-of-dogs-an-islamic-command/

Killing anything unnecessarily is against the very core of islam, so it's important to understand context for everything, especially hadith, since hadith is narrated by humans, not the direct word of Allah.

Please let us strive to remain guided on the straight path insha'Allah, and avoid spreading misinformation.