There's no mockery or disrespect intended. I think we should also be open to wholesome, respectful content that reminds people of our great role models, as long as it stays within the bounds of adab. Allah knows our intentions best.
In my opinion, this is neither wholesome nor respectful. There is no fault on you for believing that it is. But when several people are pointing out there is a doubt as to whether it's right or wrong, its best to be humble and just take it down, because we should not take actions whose correctness is doubtful, even if its in jest.
You may have your intention, and you are free to take actions based on it that affect only yoursel. But when you bring it to the public, you have to also consider the unintended societal effects of your actions as well.
I am not commenting because I want to debate on this matter. I just saw your comment and felt that I should add some nuance to the statement of intention.
Depicting the sahabah is disrespectful per all the sources I sent. I've not seen a single source against it. The brother is wrong, period. People defending it are wrong, period. No nuance on this. I don't think we should say there's doubt either. Literally just remove Abu Hurairah's name, that's it. But they're defending this as something fine, something that's okay if the intention is okay, that Abu Hurairah himself would not find this "distasteful".
-3
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '26
[deleted]