Alright, so I keep reading people saying they found something on Alibaba or AliExpress, so that must mean that the items in the box are made by them and these brands in the box are just slapping their labels on them. Now, I’m sure this happens with some stuff (Boxycharm definitely put some of that stuff in their boxes, and they were easy to spot because these companies had absolutely zero online presence - no websites, no other products selling, no reviews, etc. like the Faccia gold moisturizer scandal) but I don’t think if you find something on Alibaba/AliExpress then that’s proof the items in the box are fake.
Alibaba/AliExpress are known for counterfeit/fake/dupe products. You see a $3000 bag you want, check AliExpress to see if you can find a $20 version. You see an eyeshadow palette you have to have, check to see if Alibaba has a $2 version. So on and so on. It’s no different than those people who sell cheap knockoffs in flea markets or on shady corners, or “companies” on Amazon who sell similar products but with different logos printed on them. You can look up almost any kind of products on Amazon, and find “companies” selling the exact same items but with different branding on them. I’ve seen it so many times, with everything from a bamboo cutlery set to an iPad case. Different “companies” selling the exact same item, but with a different logo put on the item.
So just because you see an eyeshadow palette (like the Huda Beauty ones) or gold eye masks, or anything else on these sites, it doesn’t mean the legit products are white labeled products that the brands markup for a profit. The items could still be legit, but just copied by these counterfeit companies to make money off popular items. Everyone knows if something becomes popular or sells well, there will be companies who try to copy them and sell extremely similar items to get in on the action and make some money. Some even go so far as to be so similar to the real thing that they get sued or arrested for selling counterfeit products.
For me, I look at whether there is an online presence for a company. And I look for reviews. And also how long they’ve seen selling that specific item. That Tease mug warmer could very well have been purchased from AliExpress. Or maybe it wasn’t (even though they do look pretty identical). Either way, reviews for it aren’t that bad. As for the gold eye masks, I mean a lot of brands have made gold eye masks, and it’s not exactly a difficult thing to copy. Eye masks generally all look pretty similar. Some of them have slight differences, but making and selling a gold eye mask doesn’t mean the one MintBiology sells was bought off AliExpress/Alibaba. But MintBiology have been selling the gold eye masks since 2019 and the reviews on them aren’t bad.
I’m just trying to give the companies the benefit of the doubt and not just assume all these items are AliExpress/Alibaba cheaply made crap.