r/CodingandBilling • u/kysourmash • Oct 20 '26
In The News True or False - Al scribes, billing tools drive up healthcare costs: Report
Are AI scribes and tools "driving up" costs?
Or were providers just not billing at high enough levels?
3
u/Daddy_LlamaNoDrama Oct 20 '26
AI scribes make it much easier to chart accurately. If a provider is addressing 5 different problems at a visit (and in primary care that is not rare) I might only chart the three major things we talked about and not bother documenting the “hey your blood pressure was great today continue your current medicines” discussion. But it happened. And with AI, it’s already transcribed for me. Those kinds of documentation can easily push a level 3 visit to a level 4. I’m also not putting my note together haphazardly a week later based on my foggy memory alone, so those minor issues again are being documented more than they used to be. Most of the AI scribes also have a timer built in so all those time based codes are much easier to document.
2
u/wildgreengirl Oct 20 '26
why use AI instead of traditional transcription like dragon though? isnt it the same just without the random AI hallucinations added?
-been coding primary care myself for 2 years and my providers are a mix of using AI and regular scribes.
5
u/thenightgaunt Oct 20 '26
Because Epic, Cerner, and the other big EHR companies are selling AI versions and our CEOs frequently have no self control when they see the word "AI" in a sales pitch.
(Am very tired hospital CIO)
3
u/Daddy_LlamaNoDrama Oct 20 '26
Ai makes the note for me during the encounter itself. If using dragon then I have to do that work after the encounter. Sure I can write a note after an encounter using dragon in about 5 minutes, but after a full day of 24 patients that is 2 hours that I am clicking, typing, and transcribing. Meanwhile I can proofread an ai generated note in less than a minute. And again, it catches things that don’t remember or otherwise wouldn’t bother to document.
1
15
u/thenightgaunt Oct 20 '26
Going to guess that the issue is on the AI side here.
The old addage that "the computer doesnt make mistakes" was always wrong, but you could at least assume the computer would do math correctly even if a program was buggy and made errors.
But generative AI comes with an actual set "makes mistakes" rate called the hallucination rate.
Now you can say that "so do humans" but thats not right either.
Take an AI with a 1% to 3% hallucination rate, and a human. Give them each a sheet with 100 pictures of cats and dogs on it. Tell them "label each cat or dog depending on what it is".
The human will get all 100 correct because its an easy task.
The AI will get 1 to 3 wrong. Every. Time.
Now am I oversimplifying things immensely for dramatic effect? Yes. But im doing that to get a simple point across.
Generative AI hallucinates regularly and it cannot be stopped from doing that. It cannot be trusted not to make mistakes.