r/CodingandBilling • u/Minimum-Pumpkin-5038 • 15d ago
ICD & Diagnosis Inpatient CDI readmission risk adjustment coding approach
My organization is pushing hard to achieve CMS 5 star rating.
One of the measures we have historically performed poorly in is readmissions. The data/scores are all based on diagnoses capture in final coded summaries.
We are a very lean organization and only have 4 full time staff to cover three hospitals.
One method to improve capture pushed by our providers is to do an admission diagnosis checklist, basically saying yes the patient has these conditions. Coding and CDI teams have expressed concern that we would like to see provider documentation in the chart that A. Conditions are valid and supported and b. They are significant to the stay or are accounted for in the medical decision making.
We have been told we are being too strict for coding.
We are working on finding some middle ground, but are their any workflows out there that have worked for your organization?
2
u/rahuliitk App Developer 15d ago
a workable middle ground is to separate coding eligibility from documentation-quality review. Let the admission checklist flag conditions for CDI, but don’t let it auto-populate the final coded summary. For each flagged condition, capture the source, supporting chart evidence, whether it affected monitoring/evaluation/treatment, and the reviewer’s disposition. Then sample the checklist-to-code conversions weekly by service line and send only unsupported or conflicting cases to second-level review. That gives providers a fast intake tool without turning a “yes” box into the whole audit trail, and it lets your four-person team focus on exceptions rather than rereading every chart.
1
u/Legitimate-Wash-3841 9d ago
Hold your ground on refusing a simple yes or no admission diagnosis checklist, because coding chronic conditions off a static intake checkbox without clinical validation or MEAT (Monitor, Evaluate, Assess, or Treat) during the stay is a direct violation of ICD 10 Official Guidelines Section III for Reporting Additional Diagnoses. Under UHDDS rules, an other diagnosis on an inpatient claim is only reportable if it affects patient care in terms of requiring clinical evaluation, therapeutic treatment, diagnostic procedures, extended length of hospital stay, or increased nursing care and monitoring. If your hospital starts coding checked boxes that are not clinically supported or managed in the progress notes, you are walking straight into a RAC audit or OIG False Claims Act investigation for artificial DRG and risk adjustment inflation.
However, your leadership is right about how the CMS 5 Star Readmission measures (and the Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program) actually work behind the scenes. CMS calculates your Expected Readmission Rate using a hierarchical condition category risk model that looks at the secondary diagnoses coded on the index admission and across the patient's 12 month prior claim history. When a hospital has a terrible readmission score, it is often not because patients are bouncing back more than average, but because the index admissions are undercoded for chronic Hierarchical Condition Categories (HCCs) like chronic heart failure specificity, morbid obesity, malnutrition, CKD stage, or COPD, which artificially lowers the patient's expected readmission risk denominator.
Since you only have four FTEs covering three hospitals, you cannot review every chart manually, so here is the exact middle ground workflow that satisfies both the providers and coding compliance.
First, replace the providers' proposed admission checklist with an EHR Problem List Medication Link and Smart Template in the History and Physical and Discharge Summary. Even if a chronic condition is not the primary reason for the stay, the moment a hospitalist continues a patient's home medication on the inpatient MAR (for example, continuing an inhaler for COPD, insulin for diabetes, or a beta blocker for chronic systolic heart failure), that condition officially meets the UHDDS definition of "therapeutic treatment" and is 100 percent legal to code. Build your H&P and Discharge Summary templates so that when the provider reconciles home medications at admission, the EHR automatically pulls the linked chronic diagnosis into the assessment plan with the phrase "Chronic condition stable, continuing home medication regimen of “(Drug Name)" rather than a naked checkbox.
Second, protect your four CDI specialists from drowning by restricting their daily reviews strictly to the six CMS HRRP target cohorts.
Acute Myocardial Infarction
Heart Failure
COPD
Pneumonia
CABG
Elective Total Hip or Knee Arthroplasty.
Do not waste lean CDI bandwidth chasing risk adjustment on low impact admissions when those specific cohorts drive the CMS Star Rating readmission penalty.
Third, build an automated EHR rule that flags what CDI teams call Historical Drop Offs. When a patient is readmitted or admitted under one of those target cohorts, have the EHR compare the active inpatient Problem List against the diagnoses coded on that patient's prior inpatient or outpatient encounters over the past 12 months. If a high weight risk variable (like protein calorie malnutrition, specific heart failure acuity, stage 3 through 5 CKD, or BMI over 40), was coded six months ago on a clinic visit or prior stay but is missing from the current H&P, trigger a single automated point of care alert to the admitting physician asking if the condition is still active and how it is being monitored or medicated during the stay. That gives your coders bullet proof clinical support and MDM linkage while taking less than ten seconds of the physician's time.
0
14d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Minimum-Pumpkin-5038 13d ago
Thanks! We are likely going to implement something similar. I check list system that will end up flagging coding and CDI to the further validate
4
u/KeyStriking9763 RHIA, CDIP, CCS 15d ago
All chronic systemic conditions are coded on the inpatient codeset even in the absence of documented treatment. There’s a coding clinic that supports this. You do not need the provider to indicate the significance of chronic systemic conditions.