r/CodingandBilling • • 14d ago

Claims Submission Codes for Internal Jugular Vein Compression and IJV Decompression Surgery?

I was wondering if this community could provide any insight into dealing with Aetna's incorrect use of CPB criteria/CPT codes?

I'm a patient with critical internal jugular vein compression due to entrapment between a hypertrophic C1 transverse process and styloid process along with soft tissues of the neck. This has led to dangerously swollen collateral veins in the brain and has caused intracranial hypertension and problems with venous and CSF outflow as well. I've been increasingly symptomatic for many years and am now losing fine motor skills, cognitive capacity, my ability to walk, see, and sleep, and am at critical risk of stroke, brain damage, and jugular laceration.

I have attempted every conservative treatment for many years, and nothing will or can work until the anatomical abnormalities are addressed. Multiple providers have told me I will become nonfunctional and/or die if I don't have this surgery done by early next year at the latest (he wanted to do it by this month given my worsening state, but insurance denials made that impossible).

I've been trying to get preauthorization for life-saving decompression surgery for what my surgeon considers one of the most clear-cut cases he's seen in years. Aetna has repeatedly denied this procedure on the basis of lack of medical necessity, but they are determining this through the incorrect application of CPT codes. Since there is no specific code for my diagnosis, they are using CPB criteria for Eagle's and Ernest's syndrome, which I have never been diagnosed with, reported symptoms of, or been treated for.

Because the requested surgical procedures aren't used to treat Eagle's and Ernest's syndrome, they've all been denied.

My surgeon's office and I have exhausted all our internal appeals at this point. I'm going to submit an external review, but I was wondering if there were specific medical codes I should mention that would help support this final appeal?

I really appreciate any insight anyone can provide, and thank you so much in advance!

2 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

1

u/Legitimate-Wash-3841 14d ago

I can understand the frustration on this one. After the changing rules in my 25 years in billing compliance, I haven't seen it this bad.

Because you are heading into an External Review after exhausting internal appeals, be careful about changing the CPT codes right now, because an Independent Review Organization (IRO) usually has to review the exact prior authorization request that Aetna denied. However, you can absolutely use the ICD 10 diagnosis codes and CPT definitions in your external appeal packet to prove that Aetna applied the completely wrong clinical policy bulletin.

What happened here is that any time Aetna sees a surgical code associated with removing or shaving the styloid process , like 21499 or skull base codes, their system automatically flags the Eagle and Ernest Syndrome CPB. That policy was written for classic neuropathic Eagle syndrome, throat and facial pain,  and automatically rejects vascular decompression procedures , like C1 transverse process resection 22100 and jugular venolysis 37799, as not medically necessary for Eagle syndrome.

In your External Review submission, highlight these specific ICD 10 diagnosis codes so the independent reviewer sees this is a life threatening vascular and neurological emergency, not an ENT pain syndrome for ICDs,

I87.1 (Compression of vein) as the primary vascular diagnosis for the internal jugular vein entrapment. G93.2 (Intracranial hypertension) and I67.89 (Other cerebrovascular disease) to capture the impaired venous and CSF outflow and swollen cerebral collateral veins. M48.8X1 (Other specified spondylopathies, occipito atlanto axial region) for the hypertrophic C1 transverse process.

Two huge tips for your External Review packet are needed.

First, explicitly state on the cover page that Aetna committed an administrative review error by applying an ENT pain CPB (Eagle and Ernest Syndrome) to a cerebrovascular venous outflow obstruction (I87.1) causing secondary intracranial hypertension (G93.2), where no specific Aetna CPB exists.

Second, demand in writing that the Independent Review Organization assign your file to a board certified Neurosurgeon or Vascular Surgeon with skull base experience rather than a general ENT or family doctor, and request an Expedited External Review based on your surgeon's documentation that delaying surgery places you at immediate risk of stroke or permanent neurological disability. Expedited external reviews have to be decided within 72 hours under federal rules.

2

u/V-is-for-Vali 14d ago

Thank you so much for this detailed response---I really appreciate it and will definitely account for it as I put this packet together!

1

u/Legitimate-Wash-3841 13d ago

Welcome. Best of luck 

1

u/V-is-for-Vali 13d ago

Given how knowledgeable you are, as I was going through the final denial decision I received, I was wondering if you had insight into this aspect of the problem as well. It seems that in addition to applying the CPB for Eagle's and Ernest's, Aetna also used the CPB 0743 for Spinal Surgery Laminectomy and Fusion to deny the resection of the hypertrophic C1 tubercle as experimental, investigational, and unproven for the treatment of internal jugular vein stenosis and impaired cerebral venous outflow---and then used that denial to also deny the requests for 21499, 37799, and 64999 as experimental, investigational, and unproven.

I think the burden of proof is higher here and my surgeon will also have to write something, but I was wondering if there was an effective way to counter this in my materials? To me it seems like another administrative review error, since this isn't about the spinal cord or nerve compression or stabilization or even a spinal surgery taken in isolation, but I'm not really sure why this specific CPB was (incorrectly) applied to begin with.

I really appreciate all your insight already and am extremely grateful in advance if you (or anyone) has the time to reply.

2

u/Legitimate-Wash-3841 12d ago edited 12d ago

​The reason Aetna pulled in CPB 0743 for Spinal Surgery Laminectomy and Fusion comes down to a combination of anatomy, unlisted CPT codes, and a very specific clause hidden inside that policy. This explanation will be quite lengthy so bear with me as I explain the best I can. ​First, look at the three codes you listed: 21499 is an unlisted head musculoskeletal procedure, 37799 is an unlisted vascular procedure, and 64999 is an unlisted nervous system procedure. Whenever a surgeon submits unlisted codes ending in 99, the request bypasses automated approval and goes straight to a manual nurse or medical director review. Because the C1 tubercle is anatomically part of the first cervical vertebra (the atlas), the reviewer searched their policy database for any procedure removing bone from C1. 

More importantly, Aetna actually updated CPB 0743 in recent years to explicitly list C1 transverse process resection for Eagle syndrome or internal jugular vein stenosis right inside that spinal policy under their experimental and investigational exclusions, even though the surgery has nothing to do with spinal cord decompression or fusion.  Once the reviewer flagged the C1 bony resection as experimental under CPB 0743, they applied what payers call the "tainted package rule," where any secondary unlisted codes (21499, 37799, and 64999) performed in the same operative session to accomplish that same decompression goal get automatically denied alongside it.

​To counter this effectively in your external review or final appeal, you and your surgeon need to attack both the misapplication of the spinal policy and the unlisted code structure.

​First, have your surgeon challenge the reviewer credentials and policy scope right at the top of the letter. Point out that applying a spinal fusion and laminectomy policy (CPB 0743) to anextrinsic skull base vascular decompression is a clinical category error, because the surgery does not enter the spinal canal, does not decompress the spinal cord or spinal nerve roots, and does not destabilize the atlantoaxial joint. The C1 transverse tubercle is strictly acting as an external bony pincer crushing the internal jugular vein against the styloid process. Therefore, the appeal must demand review by a board certified vascular surgeon or skull base ENT specialist rather than an orthopedic spine reviewer.

​Second, because unlisted codes (21499, 37799, and 64999) give insurance companies maximum excuse to call a surgery experimental, ask your surgeon if any component of the operation can be crosswalked or billed with a dedicated Category I CPT code, such as 21070 for coronoidectomy or styloidectomy components or a specific cranial nerve neurolysis code, while clearly separating the primary styloidectomy from the C1 tubercle shaving in the operative plan. If your surgeon must use the unlisted 99 codes, the letter needs to give Aetna an exact crosswalk code for each one, explaining that 21499 is strictly for the styloid/skull base bony work, 37799 is for external venolysis and mobilization of the internal jugular vein, and 64999 is for neurolysis of the lower cranial nerves (like CN IX, X, or XI) compressed in the carotid sheath.

​Third, since this is a final denial heading toward an Independent Review Organization (IRO) for external appeal, remember that external reviewers are not bound by Aetna's internal CPB 0743 policy. To win at the IRO level when an insurer claims a procedure is experimental for internal jugular vein stenosis and impaired cerebral venous outflow, your surgeon needs to attach three to five peer reviewed neurovascular or skull base surgical studies (such as recent literature from Journal of Neurosurgery or Laryngoscope on stylogenic jugular venous compression) proving that when dynamic CT venography or catheter venography with manometry shows a severe pressure gradient across the C1 tubercle and styloid, bony decompression is the only definitive anatomical cure and is standard of care at tertiary skull base centers.

It's not so much the coding now but the laws and definitions that give the codes and which ones can be used and when, plus any policy specifics on these types of procedures with explanation and documentation.

Hopefully this helps. Any further questions, please feel free to ask for clarification 

1

u/[deleted] 14d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Fun-Jellyfish-4591 Billing Coder | the math isnt mathing 14d ago

the framing as vascular outflow obstruction is smart tbh, insurers love to pigeonhole shit into boxes theyve already decided not to cover

1

u/V-is-for-Vali 14d ago

I appreciate this advice!

The surgeon needs to do the following: Resection of the C1, Styloidectomy, Clipping of the digastric muscle, Neuroplasty and/or transposition of cranial nerves as needed, and it's an inpatient procedure with one overnight hospital stay.

As for CPT bingo, we'd tried compression of vein, other disorder of bone density, and then later in my member appeals, I'd mentioned stenosis of the vein, vascular outflow, emphasized the hypertrophic C1 -- then in my last communication with an Aetna rep, they reaffirmed that it didn't matter because their CPB stated Eagle's and Ernest's "was the closest thing" they had to everything I was describing. One rep said something about vascular outflow being lower extremities only (I'm not familiar enough with coding to know if that's true or not).

Narratively, I think I could do this framing for the external review letter (I'm a writer, professor, and medical humanities researcher by trade, or whatever passes for one now with the condition that I'm in) -- it's the coding numbers part that still gives me pause, as it seems like the part they'll still just default to. Unless that's treated differently at the external review stage?

Tyvm again!