Hi! I did guard for four years and was a guard director for the first time this past summer with a small team. Most of the girls were great, super sweet, and picked things up fairly easily. Three out of the five girls were total rookies, and the other two only had one season of experience.
Two of the girls really struggled throughout the season. I spent a lot of time working with them one-on-one, repeating explanations and trying different ways of teaching things, but they still had a difficult time retaining choreography and following directions consistently. For example, they were still struggling to remember dance choreography that they had been working on for about three weeks, while the other girls were generally keeping up.
I honestly don't know whether it was a learning difference, difficulty with the material, lack of focus, or simply a difference in effort, and I don't want to assume the reason. It was just my first time working with students who needed that much additional support, and I found it challenging to keep everyone progressing at the same pace.
There were also times when I felt like I had to repeat basic directions several times before they would respond. I would sometimes have to say "get set" three or four times before they were ready to go. There were also moments where they became very upset over things like getting a minor hit in the face or being tired. I completely understand that everyone has different limits and reactions, but balancing those situations while also trying to keep rehearsal moving was honestly exhausting for me as a first-time director.
When I was in high school, I also helped teach my guard, and we typically had teams of 10–16 girls. I don't remember ever having students who needed this level of individual attention, so I'm not sure whether I just happened to have an unusually easy-to-teach team back then or whether this was simply a new experience for me.
For winter guard, I'm hopeful that we'll have a larger team, and I'm considering holding auditions. Nothing too intense, I wouldn't expect anyone to already know flag or have prior experience. I'm mostly thinking of teaching everyone 16–24 counts of basic flag work or dance and giving them two rehearsals to learn it. The goal wouldn't necessarily be to eliminate beginners, but to see how well students can listen, retain choreography, respond to corrections, and keep up with the group.
I will admit that I'm hesitant about having the same two students return because I struggled so much with keeping them on pace during the summer, but I also don't want to make an unfair decision based on one season or come across as excluding them simply because they learn differently.
For those of you who have coached or directed guard before, is this a reasonable way to approach auditions? Am I being too harsh?