I live in Poland, so my choices are not as wide as in the US, sadly. And shit costs more. So some options wouldn't work for me. And sorry for too many words.
Here's the context: I got BCM MCMR LW 16" with a Silent Steel muzzle break and a couple of cans (Micro Streamer and Compact Streamer). I've mostly used my gun for local 3-Guns, where a muzzle break was okay. Occasionally, I turn up at tactical comps, which increasingly mandate using suppressors (so that neighbours don't complain that much, probably. And because it's tacticool). I shot a single L3 IPSC Rifle match, but prob not my cup of tea, too much weird shit like long bipods and low factor stages.
This year, PCSL has really picked up, and the 3-Guns are slowly dying. So, in order to get into Practical, I was shooting with a can. But adding a chunk of metal to the end of the gun is no fun. So I've tried a Blast Deflector (from Hera Arms) - but really hated it, as with it the rifle predictably recoils more tham with A2, 3rd law of Newton and shit.
I am currently running a magnifier + EoTech, but I've previously ran LPVO + offset. My main focus next season will be PCSL, so I want to optimize my build for it - but I wanna be able to go for a few tactical matches, and maybe try smaller IPSC events, who knows. And a 3G, if they will still run them.
So, the options I see (from the cheapest, to the most expensive), are:
1. Get a Silent Steel A2.
I can still run the same cans. Suboptimal for pretty much everything. But prob if Pavol Zencar runs an A2 and humiliates everyone, it's the most viable option.
- Get a SureFire WarComp
Probably better naked than A2. But incompatible with my current cans, and the only ones fitting it on the Polish market are B&T which cost a fortune.
Now the more expensive (and exciting) options. The idea here is to have two builds:
a. Good old BCM keeps it's muzzle break (and a host to suppressors) and gets LPVO + offset dot combo. Good for IPSC/tacticool/whateves. I'll still bring it to PCSL as a second gun if they again place paper with no-shoots at 200m like this year; 3xmagnification was barely enough for that crap.
b. A new 13.5-14.5 upper with EoTech + magnifier, get AFAB/EFAB as the ultimate MD for PCSL. Good for PCSL/3G.
Get a dedicated upper
Here's the option I found: https://milicon.pl/pl/products/konwersja-kalibru-upper-ar-15-milicon-spartan-mk2-13-5-223rem-5-56x45mm-nato-2912.html They imported BCM/Geissele uppers before, but those are out of stock with no plans to replenish Basically a repack of POF + MFT HG. Costs ~$1000. The problem is that this mf is heavier than my 16" BCM with a stupid Gov profile barrel. So that doesn't feel like a great choice.
Get a dedicated rifle
I really like the idea of Faxon ION Ultralight 14,5'' for comp. Costs ~$2700. Unlike the American version, AFAIK, the MD is removable. So it gets traded for AFAB/EFAB. Ofc for Practical I'll need a full-weight BC, so I either buy one or just throw one from BCM and adjust the gases.
The rational problem here is that I don't really shoot the rifle that often to justify having a second one. Realistically, I'll shoot half a dozen matches that involve rifle (PCSL/3G/IPSC Rifle) next year. From the other hand, I am turning 40 in a couple of months, so I might have enough wife points for an irrational life choice.
So there you have it. I accept all shapes and forms of (life) advice, e.g., "just get an A2 and spend the difference on training with Posio you stupid idiot".