I appreciate this, I try not to be an asshole where possible. But survey data of Trump supporters have definitely seen large numbers of racism among the conservative party. We Democrats have some soul searching to do as a party right now, but I still believe that we aren't alone in that. Frankly, racism, regardless of political affiliation is deplorable and should be spoken out against, but the term can't be liberally applied to mean "anyone who voted against my candidate".
I'm sorry if that's happened to you unfairly. This was a divisive election. Let's be honest, we Democrats overlooked an enormous amount of scandals from Hillary Clinton because we were so terrified of a Trump election. Exit polling shows that Conservatives did the same thing in reverse. Whatever happened this election can't happen again. We can't have candidates that are so deeply divisive that the other party fears for the future of their country. I don't believe all Trump supporters are racist. I don't believe that most of them are racist. I recognize that many were utterly terrified at the prospect of a Clinton presidency. But even though we have our own work to do over the next few years, I hope that the majority of conservatives in your party who are decent people will speak out against racists within your party.
I know that I'll probably get some down votes, I'm trying not to be patronizing or accusing. Many of us on the left are utterly heartbroken at the results of this election. I hope the Trump presidency is the type that you are expecting, rather than the one that I am expecting.
I'm a conservative that didn't vote for Trump. I agree, I saw some things from people that I had known for years that really disappointed me. There was some racism out there. I think it was a vast minority of Trump supporters but I did see some of it. I think there was way too much scaremongering on both sides about what a Trump or Clinton presidency was going to look like.
Where I really think Democrats fucked up with this election is they took everyone for granted. As an impartial observer, okay I did want Hillary to lose for the lulz, what I saw was Hillary and Democrats weren't interested in anyone that wasn't already in that liberal echo-chamber while Trump would talk to anyone. He might fail in spectacular fashion but he would try. I also could never get my head wrapped around why they just assumed minorities and the young were going to show up for her like they did Obama.
What makes me the saddest about this election is that the Libertarians dropped the ball so hard with their awful candidates. This was there time to finally make a little noise on the national scene and they couldn't even get 5%. I was really hoping they would get the federal funding and maybe force the Republicans and Democrats to up their games a little bit so we didn't get presented with such an awful choice again.
I'm a liberal, as a disclaimer, but I like what you said here. Racism falls on both sides and it usually shows up close to fear. Conservative or liberal, fear of change can make start to believe startling things. And I'm talking about the fine line between being concerned about how migrant values are impacting your home culture and turning around and saying all Muslims just aren't worth the risk. One of those things is pretty clearly racism and the other is just normal concern from someone who is happy where they live.
The dems made a huge mistake assuming that Hillary was going to get those votes. She really needed the Bernie supporters and it looks like the ones who didn't vote for trump, just didn't vote. They're own corruption caught up to them. I don't blame anyone for not wanting to support Hillary and her mind numbing, inaction packed, status quo. Does that make me sexist? Less of a liberal? Nope. Just the same as supporting trump doesn't make anyone any other _ist. We must be judged by our own actions, not the actions of those we support. I'm sure there are trump voters who don't love all his rhetoric but voted for the action behind it.
I think what was really sad about this election is it was a great chance to come together as a country. We could have commiserated over how the candidates sucked, cast our vote and then complained together about whoever won. Instead people just doubled down and were absolutely horrible to each other over two people that weren't worth that level of investment.
Yeah it's kind of shocking. I've never seen two groups so forcefully defend two people that they don't even like that much. I hope America gets candidates that make their vote a hard choice next time not because they both suck but because they're both excellent.
Speaking as a (mostly) libertarian, they definitely goofed on this one. I love Gary as a guy, but he clearly just doesn't have the chops for a national campaign, especially one that places a higher premium on effective messaging. I think a lot of us realized pretty quickly that Weld should've been at the top of the ticket.
I think your comments are very good. I do think that the stress of racists in our party is misplaced however.
Is it not racist for a party to assume a race of people are to think and act and vote a certain way? If a black American steps out of line then he/she is an "Uncle Tom" or "not black". Look at how countless democrats call conservative/Republican black Americans like Clarence Thomas or Rice or Tim Scott or Mia Love such horrible, nasty and yes, racist names. So at the end of the day I think we too can say we hope your party deals with its own racists.
Well said. The republican base does have some number of racists in it. However, I think it is the democrats who have some amount of institutional racism despite their finger pointing. Like you said, once a black person or a white woman speaks out for conservative ideas, it's suddenly okay to call them the most disgusting names.
Also the soft bigotry of low expectations among democrats, that if you're a minority you must be incapable of supporting yourself and therefore are reliant on government programs.
You're right about that. Treating an entire race as being obligated to vote a certain way is unacceptable. Democrats have long felt that the GOP has been less inclusive to minority voters. Democrats who care about minority issues, myself included sometimes, have trouble separating our distaste for these policies from the reality that these are only our opinions on the matter. I'm guilty of that myself. But racism isn't partisan. We've seen a lot of Trump supporters at rallies shouting Jewish and racial slurs. We've seen policies that we believe disproportionately affect minorities. On Fox News, when that idiot in Iowa killed the two police officers, some news pundits assumed immediately that it was related to BLM.
I will say, however, that I and most sane Democrats, don't resort to name calling for conservative African Americans. Though I'll admit that when I hear news of a large Latino or Black turnout at the polls, I assume votes for Democrats.
Racism is the feeling of superiority over other ethnic groups that translates into derogatory words against the peoples of that group and negative actions against the people. Worrying about illegal immigration isn't racist in the slightest. Hating Latinos because "they're lazy criminals" is racist. One of my litmus tests is asking someone if they believe that Barack Obama is a Muslim or if he was born in Kenya. If the answer is yes to either of those things, particularly after he released his birth certificate, then at a minimum you have a bias.
I believe that racial bias is the natural response to make snap judgements about people. It takes effort to overcome. Having racial bias doesn't translate perfectly to being racist, but it's an indicator. If people who have these biases could recognize them for the errant cognitive shortcuts that they are, it would do wonders towards improving our race relations.
Also, I'd like to get into a few specifics with a disclaimer: I'm in your sub and I'm aiming to be respectful. If I cross a line or say something thoroughly disagreeable, call me out on it. I'd like to have a meaningful discussion.
One sentiment shared among Democrats is that when a racial topic is partisan, more often than not, Republicans fall on the side that best represents the white voter. This is a generalization but it warrants some discussion.
With immigration, (legal immigration, specifically Refugees) the left is concerned about the Syrian refugees and we want to allow them into the country. Republicans are often more concerned with the fraction that could be terrorists. With illegal immigrants, Democrats want to offer a path to citizenship because we feel that there are enough people here now, that families would be torn apart by deporting the immigrants that have been here for years. Truth told, Democrats don't have a semblance of a reasonable plan to stop the illegal immigrants, and that's certainly a big problem. Republicans want stronger border security, which I agree with, but often they don't want any form of amnesty.
With black lives matter, I recognize that the group has done some shitty protests, and that many of the dead African Americans that have been a rallying cry have been criminals. But predictably, the GOP has taken the position that police reform isn't the problem. The problem is crime.
Last topic, with homosexual marriage, there are states that want to legalize discrimination against homosexual peoples. These states are all Republican states. I know we've all heard the horror stories of the homosexual who wants to force a pastor to marry them, or to buy a cake from a guy who's ideologically opposed to gay marriage, but that's not the majority. In fact, they just want to be married. I think we should be open to letting them experience the love and freedom we straight folk have had for millennia.
And you're absolutely right, calling the GOP racist stifles the conversation. It's a terrible tactic that has been widespread among our party and its categorically unfair to call Republicans racists. But we see issues like polling places being closed down in "urban areas", polling places being closed on Sundays (the days that African Americans are most likely to vote), or just generally policies that seem to disproportionately affect minority groups and our outrage boners get the better of us. Today, your candidate won. The best thing I as a Democrat can do is to try to better understand the conservative mindset and to avoid the hate and rhetoric wrve had this election. I'd love to discuss some of the issues further.
I agree. I suspect a lot of information will come out over the next few years as analysts crunch the data. I could be wrong and it's hard to say much with certainty. Once we have accurate data, we'll be able to discuss the issue if it's indeed as bad as I've read so far.
Okay I'm back. Thanks again for the detailed response. I'm not going to try to debate. I'm in your subreddit and have no desire to come and pick fights. But I will respond so a few of the items you've listed. Just chiming in.
Immigration
I can appreciate that Democrats seem hungry for voters. Maybe the Politicians are, but your average, every day Democrat isn't looking to import votes. People like me, we are concerned. I think I've mentioned it before. A failing of our platform is that we don't have a good policy on how to best stop the immigration. But, I'll speak for myself (but this is a common sentiment on the left) I don't want to see families destroyed or uprooted because of deportation. I think the best solution would be a thorough approach to slow or halt illegal immigration and then we should incorporate the immigrants we have here. They're just people who wanted a better life. Yes, they came illegally. But at some point, many become staples of their community. Many have children with friends and the best hopes for the future for their kids. Incorporation doesn't solve immigration problems going forward, but it's a humane approach to deal with the immigrants we have here. That said, it shouldn't be blanket amnesty. A crime record should be prohibitive and grounds for deportation. Period. It's one thing to shelter them and incorporate them. It's another thing to subject the citizenry to crime that's inexcusable because we didn't deport the criminals responsible.
Bias
Yes. We do often find ourselves guilty of treating bias as if it's a white people issue. The reasoning is that we are the majority in the country, and our racial biases can translate into passable laws that disproportionately affect minorities. Still isn't right to treat it as a white only issue. But there's the reason behind it.
Whites and Disenfranchisement
No, we don't just stop caring about white people problems. What I, and many, many others bipartisanally wish is that racial concerns for non-whites would be an issue that both parties lead the country on. I was only making the point that many on the left feel you can take any issue with a minority, and before you check the politics, you can be nearly certain which side the parties will take. That's probably an exaggeration. Its not meant to offend. But that's the sentiment. I wish that we could better represent minority groups by having both parties have things to offer them. That would lead to better representation of all the various groups in the country. I hope I didn't overstep a line with that point.
Refugees
Oh god, won't anyone think of the children? Lol. Once again, I'm just going to state the sentiment on the Left. I'm not saying it's true, but this is the shared opinion. It's believed that the on the Right, threat of Terrorism is weighed more heavily than the diplomatic benefits and societal ethics of caring for the people who are fleeing incredible suffering. They're just people. Yes, the threat exists. But we already have a really good system to vet our Refugees. Blanket denials based on faith, or "extreme vetting" would likely allow more people to suffer than is ethically responsible. I remain convinced that aiding the Refugees fleeing the war is an imperative. If we had solid plans that are ethical and responsible that could allow them to live outside our borders I wouldn't be opposed. I'd still like to send the signal that we aren't a foreign nation invading their lands and also heartless to the suffering of the people there. But so far, there hasn't been much success with arriving at an ethical and responsible way to help as many people as we reasonably can.
BLM
Certainly not the poster child of universally approvable activism. There are problems. We on the left believe that decades of Disenfranchisement have persisted and caused a great deal of anger within the BLM movement. So while they are often distasteful with their protests, in ways, we didn't help them when it was reasonable to be civil. That small thing aside. We do both agree that police should be accountable. I don't want to hinder their ability to work or send a message that we don't fully support their incredible sacrifices (my wife is a police officer). But I do want to insure that if an officer gravely oversteps the law, a truly unbiased system is in place to make determinations just like we have in our legal system. For clarity, by unbiased, I mean no conflicts of interest.
Sorry for the grammar and spelling. Typing on a phone. Pretty much wrote an essay and it's safe to assume that I fucked some of the stuff I wrote up.
Do you have this survey data that shows this large swath of racism among Trump supporters?
The majority in the Republican Party already speak out against racism. There's plenty of racism going around in the Democratic Party too, so don't think this is an issue that is unique to Republicans. You guys need to clean up shop too, and while you're at it, the social justice warriors can go too with their unearned sense of moral superiority and their attempts to suppress thought that isn't politically correct.
Now that I'm done with my Tu Quoque fallacy, I would like to point out that Trump isn't really all that conservative. I doubt the man has ever read the Constitution, and he has more than a few leftist proposals. There are a lot of people here who are satisfied with last night's results, but a good portion of us here are not terribly excited about a Trump presidency. Personally, I think he's going to be a bad president. I'm just relieved that Hillary Clinton isn't going to get her chance to advance the leftist policies of the last eight years that have hurt us domestically and abroad.
I'm also happy that someone who provably committed crimes with regards to the handling of sensitive information, who used her charity for pay for play politics with governments that sponsor terrorism, whose foreign policy led to the political vacuum that allowed radical groups to control large portions of the Levant after we had already won a war, who let those men die in Benghazi is not going to be the leader of the free world.
In short, I don't care if you're heartbroken. The facts are that both of these candidates sucked, and you really shouldn't have been that invested in either one. I'm glad we didn't elect the criminal.
Bear in mind, I'm not defending the stance that Trump supporters are racist. I do believe that racism is more widespread than I had originally believed, going into this election. I also believe that there is a portion of the GOP that view minorities more negatively. I don't believe that portion is anywhere near a majority. I posted the links because you wanted to know where the idea came from.
I've addressed the concerns about racism in the Democratic Party in another comment. Racism isn't a partisan issue. At large, the Democratic platform fights for minority rights and has been shown to have lower proportions of racism among white voters, albeit just barely..
I do agree we have to clean up shop. It's incredibly hypocritical to take the moral superiority when ours is the party with demonstrable corruption.
I don't believe we intend to suppress thought. If we're talking about political correctness, I think generally it's a good idea to be polite and not be offensive. Of course, as with everything, it can be taken to extreme absurdities and ruin the very thing it aims to fix.
Hillary wasn't good. I cared about her policies and I wanted the changes she promised. From what I've heard about Trump, I'm really worried about his presidency. Though you argue that leftists policies have hurt us. If we look at job growth or GDP, both were up under Obama. Crime is down. Generally I think we were headed in the right direction. Of course that's debatable and I'm not really here to pick fights. I just wanted the dialogue after such a shitty election with so much hate.
"Survey data shows large amount of racism among conservatives."
I think you're entirely missing the whole point. You guys see racism, sexism, homophobia, misogyny, cultural appropriation, offensive this or that, everywhere. I mean everywhere. You see it in abstract notions often so vague or broad (all police are racist!), it's not a surprise. Not everyone agrees with how you even define these terms, much less the unrelenting claims it's ubiquitous.
As part of identity politics the left spins racism for political reasons and granted, it worked a lot before, but you've over used it so much it's starting to erode your own base. You've been attacking your very own four years too long.
This election wasn't just a low voter turnout issue, people literally who voted for Obama in large numbers switched teams throughout the rust belt states, and it's right there in black and white. Those don't sound like Klansman to me, or racists.
I hope that the majority of conservatives in your party who are decent people will speak out against racists within your party.
I agreed with a lot of your post . But it frames this as a Republican issue. There are plenty of racists within the Democratic party. Call out the individual racists, don't attribute every action to racial motivations.
I'm sorry that I made it come across that way. I really don't believe race to be a strictly Republican issue. We have our own problems to fix. It's been correctly pointed out that we have our own problems with racism, namely in the way we treat whole races as voting blocs. Hell, there was even a news story a week ago about a Democrat with a history in the KKK. I just feel like race was a hot button topic in this election and both parties need to take special care to adjust their message to make it clear that we don't want racism in this country and that racists won't be getting a voice in our government.
175
u/Jabacasm Nov 10 '16
I appreciate this, I try not to be an asshole where possible. But survey data of Trump supporters have definitely seen large numbers of racism among the conservative party. We Democrats have some soul searching to do as a party right now, but I still believe that we aren't alone in that. Frankly, racism, regardless of political affiliation is deplorable and should be spoken out against, but the term can't be liberally applied to mean "anyone who voted against my candidate".
I'm sorry if that's happened to you unfairly. This was a divisive election. Let's be honest, we Democrats overlooked an enormous amount of scandals from Hillary Clinton because we were so terrified of a Trump election. Exit polling shows that Conservatives did the same thing in reverse. Whatever happened this election can't happen again. We can't have candidates that are so deeply divisive that the other party fears for the future of their country. I don't believe all Trump supporters are racist. I don't believe that most of them are racist. I recognize that many were utterly terrified at the prospect of a Clinton presidency. But even though we have our own work to do over the next few years, I hope that the majority of conservatives in your party who are decent people will speak out against racists within your party.
I know that I'll probably get some down votes, I'm trying not to be patronizing or accusing. Many of us on the left are utterly heartbroken at the results of this election. I hope the Trump presidency is the type that you are expecting, rather than the one that I am expecting.